I bought an LP but but didn't look inside the jacket and when I got home there was no record…read moreinside! They were very nice and offered store credit but I spent less than the gas it will take me to get there and back!

I've made a few trips to this thrift store and have to say it is a gem! Prices are very reasonable…read moreand merchandise is always nicely presented. I am growing tired of the "chain" aspect of some of the larger resale shops and the willy-nilly way they price donations. The staff here is helpful and happy to have you as a customer. The clerk who checked me out was more than happy to tell me about about Heritage House & the mission behind the store. I found a few gems @ Second Thought, and i'm sure you will too!

Always find what I needs there at a terrific price . Better quality than that what has come a big…read morebox charitable drop off center.

Like any low end thrift store expect there to be a smell and dust/lint. This one had plenty of room…read moreto maneuver around, was well organized had a good amount of inventory. From other reviews people mentioned the staff being bad, maybe I caught the staff on a good day but they greeted me at the door and was very friendly. Some notes- - A majority of the clothing range around $3-$5 - Clothes with original retail tags ranged from $11-$16

Prices were very reasonable. Very neat and well arranged. A whole section just for christmas…read more Lots of vintage clothes.

We recently stumbled on the Main Street Thrift Store while out having some fun when at our nearby…read moreOrleans County camp property. This store is located near downtown Albion, just across the street from the public library. It is in the same building as the laundromat, so can be easily overlooked--but don't overlook it, as there are some great deals here! We were so fortunate to on a whim stop by on their dollar clothes sale day. Every clothes item in the store was just a dollar each, WHOA! :-O It isn't a huge thrift store, but we still found some great finds! The clothes are organized very well by item type/size, making it easy to peruse everything in a reasonable time. In addition to apparel, there are all of the other typical thrift store sections, including accessories, shoes, books, housewares, toys, games, dishes, bedding/curtains, artwork, decor, etc., and some furniture. I was particularly impressed with the dishes and china area. If I had less self-constraint and more room, some lovely new-to-me-china pieces would have definitely come home with me, hahaha. Overall, the regular prices here are very reasonable. Of course if you hit it on a dollar-deal-day, that is a phenomenal steal. But clothes regular prices were about $2 - $4 or $5 a piece. We live in the Buffalo burbs, and the thrift stores I frequent closer to home have regular prices about double that these days. So when we are in town at our camp, or maybe even just for a country drive to Albion on the off season, Main Street Thrift Store is well worth the adventure. Great deals, good assortment, tidy and well organized, and friendly staff--stop in to find some new-to-you treasures soon! :-)

This consignment store is a must-visit! The atmosphere is fantastic, with tons of individual…read moresellers offering unique finds. The staff is super friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend it for a fun day trip!

We finally made it to this shop! I think that it is technically two shops: A estate sale shop and a…read morecollection of small consignment booths. Hubbo was excited to stop by due to it having old comics. I love old furniture and dishes. There were lots of each. Also, IDK what satellite radio they were using but it was bumping! Rather than sitting out in the car while hubbo finished ransacking the back-issues, I sat in a rustic table demo and rocked out!

Always find good stuff and the books are a can't beat price. Sometimes a little bit dirty.read more

This is my regular stop anytime I come to Batavia. It's not the cleanest store but the prices are…read moregood. It's possible to find many useful items and not break your own personal bank.

I moved to Alden in April of 2025 and somehow I have managed to become a regular at Under One Roof…read morein what can only be described as record-breaking time. Honestly, I think I'm in there more than anywhere else in town... okay, maybe second only to the coffee shop -- but still. Priorities. Recently one of the girls who works there asked, "Were you in here recently?" My response: "Yes... but you're going to have to be more specific." At this point I'm basically on a first-name basis with the clearance rack. This place is truly a magical hybrid of boutique, consignment shop, and small-town treasure hunt. They have clothes for kids, teens, and adults -- some new, some consignment -- and the consignment pieces are so pristine you'd swear the previous owner bought them, lovingly removed the tags, whispered affirmations over them, and then never wore them once. And it doesn't stop at clothing. Oh no. There's furniture, small appliances, baby items, exercise gear, bedding, health and beauty goodies (from really good brands, too). You name it, they probably have it. And if they don't today... check back next week, because the inventory changes constantly. One of my favorite things is how active they are on Facebook -- posting new arrivals, sale alerts, and little contests so you can plan your visit like a highly strategic shopping mission. If you live in or anywhere near Alden and you haven't been here yet, I don't know what you're doing with your life -- but I gently and lovingly suggest you redirect yourself to Under One Roof immediately. I'll probably see you there. I'll be the one pretending I'm "just browsing."

consigning for a couple years, no problems. This January, I dropped two new winter coats with them…read moreand some other household items. This week I called to retrieve only the new winter coats and they tell me there is no balance on my account - and they do not have them. They further went on to state, they had nothing "tagged" for me since last December.... you literally cannot randomly drop off items, you need an appointment which I had January 26, 2026! The owner had her manager call me, who I had spoke to about these coats twice. Since they take your items and you get no ticket, ...they win! Bad business practice. Whoever took these coats has some nice winter wear.

The place to go for large quality furniture items. I got a large 6 person wood dinning tables and…read morechairs for $150, a 6 person cheap plastic and metal wire dinning set from Amazon cost the same price and definitely won't last as long. Christmas items are almost always 50% off so check that out for some cheap decor. The staff has always been kind, friendly, and helpful, especially when helping to load furniture into my truck. I almost never leave empty handed.

Best thrift store in the entire greater Rochester area. Always fresh options. Great prices. Lots of…read moregems to be found. Very friendly.