From the looks of the older pictures, it has moved into Meijer Capital City Market. Small stall, with limited options. I would try and preorder if possible, or order and then shop as it was quite slow. Decent bagels, though and seating available to eat them there. read more

The bagel sandwich ingredients are amazing! The employees were polite. And Meijer is always clean.

Ordered a bacon egg and cheese, driest, flattest bagel I've ever paid for. Other sandwich had the wrong kind of cream cheese on it. Service wasn't great, guy was a bit rude. Save your money and just make it at home, it'll taste better too read more

Yummy bagels ordered via DoorDash, I ordered the night before so they would be delivered to my hotel room right when waking up. Ordered the Cosa Nostra salmon and the Godfather which were both very delicious. One came hot and the other came cold just how I ordered them. Next time I will order in their restaurant when it isn't so cold outside. LOL read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - Cosa Nostra salmon - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

See all

The Goodfella sandwich from Good Fellas Bagel Deli in Lansing, MI. I'm usually not a breakfast person but this was pretty dang good. Sausage, egg, hatch chile, Havarti cheese, and avocado cream cheese on a bagel. Definitely fills you up and cures any hangover or hangry person . If you're in the area check em out! #eatlikejed #goodfellasbageldeli #goodfellasandwich #mieats #goodeats #instafood #foodie #latergram #bagel #breakfast read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

See all

They can't seem to open on time. I've been twice now around 7:30am and nobody is there. The barista at the coffee stand next to this place confirms it's a regular occurrence. I don't need much from a breakfast bagel shop, but I do need them to be open when they say they're gonna open. The New Daily Bagel is nearby and maintains consistent hours -- I'd recommend skipping Goodfella's for a place that won't waste your time. read more

If you're confused about where exactly this is located, it's inside the Capital City Market. I was hungry after working an overnight shift and this was the first place that came up when I looked up bagel on Yelp. When it comes to bagels I have pretty high expectations since I think NY/NJ bagels are the best. I got the bada bing sandwich (chorizo, egg, bacon, tomato, avocado) on a jalepeño bagel which honestly was pretty good. The chorizo definitely is what made the sandwich really good. The bagel itself was average. Overall, I think if you're looking for a good bagel sandwich this place will certainly satisfy you! read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - Bada bing sandwich on a jalapeño bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

See all

I'm pretty bummed because I've read great things about this place. But sadly I didn't feel it was worth the time. We ordered 3 bagel sandwiches and a vanilla latte on our way to Lansing, about 40 minutes in advance (scheduled order said ready by 10:30). Unfortunately, once we arrived at 10:15 we had to wait an additional hour for the order to be ready. This happens at popular places I just wish we would have known and would have ordered farther in advance! If it was an exceptional bagel, then it's worth waiting! But sadly it was very mediocre and honestly would recommend going to a Brueggers bagels or Panera for your bagel fix because you'll get the same time thing but not have to wait an hour. To top it off, the coffee I ordered was just a can, which I can buy at Trader Joe's. Feedback for restaurant: Put the expected wait time on the website when people are ordering in advance! Also, please don't use styrofoam because it's bad for the environment. If you wrap the sandwich well, you don't need the extra container (I saw everyone just instantly trash their styrofoam box as they were eating) read more

See all

About as good as the sushi next door. It's garbage, that's overpriced likely nothing made in house.

Only reason I went here is because my normal bagel place is closed this week to let their entire staff off for the 4th holiday, which I'm fine about. I wanted a dozen bagels and some cream cheese. Simple right? As this is in the grocery store, my expectations were a bit low, so I asked - "Are the bagels baked here? Not from your other location in East Lansing?" I was told yes. They may very well be baked there, but when I got my dozen bagels .... THEY WERE COLD. AS IF THEY WERE TAKEN OUT OF THE REFRIGERATOR. I went at 730am. When they opened. The *only* way they could be cold is if they were baked YESTERDAY. I DIDN'T GO TO A BAGEL PLACE TO GET A DOZEN BAGELS FOR YOU TO TO GIVE ME COLD LEFTOVER BAGELS FROM YESTERDAY. if I wanted refrigerated bagels, I would have walked literally 6 aisles over and paid 1/4 of what I did for the same amount of bagels. Do not get your bagels here. Period. Waste of money. read more

I was craving a lox bagel sandwich and came across Goodfella's Bagels on Yelp. Placed a Grubhub order for a Cosa Nostra on an everything bagel and the house fries and was on my way. When I arrived they were pretty busy, but my food came out hot and smelled delicious! The bagel was a little over cooked but it all tasted delicious! The house fries were awesome, love the chipotle aioli dipping sauce, it brought some heat. Definitely going back to try the other bagel sandwiches! read more

See all

Drove 40 minutes to go here and they weren't open almost an hour after they were supposed to be. Checked the times twice. Waste of time and disappointing experience. Sounds like it's a regular occurance. read more

Ever since they relocated into the grocery store, they're seemingly inept. They don't toast the bagels, they say 20 mins on a simple order and take an hour, they don't man their cash register..... just all together worse than at their previous location read more

One star, for many reasons. The bagels sandwiches are subpar at best. The bagels themselves are dry, dense and stale, every single time. More importantly, the last few times I've stopped in there, the owner, Adrian, has had a serious attitude problem. You can sense his ego from a mile away. I also witnessed him treating one of his employees poorly, which is extremely disappointing. I used to really love this place, so it's a bummer. Do better. read more

Amazing service. The bada bing sandwich IS TO DIE FOR. Best breakfast sandwich I've ever had. I got the Parmesan bagel for the sandwich and it was so good. The hash brown was also amazing, better than McDonald's. LOVE THIS PLACE. read more

This place is AWESOME! Delicious menu with an option for everyone (including vegetarian bagel sandwich with black bean patty) and they are affordable and fast. Tried the Beca Blanco today and definitely coming back soon for more! read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - Great menu with lots of options - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

This is the spot for all your breakfast needs. I love this place and am so happy I stumbled upon it one Sunday since it was one of the few places open! This is a newer business but they work as if they've been doing this for years, I'm never shocked with how long the wait is because everyone is going here with good reason to! I call in my order of the Bada Bing sandwich and "house fries" (they just added to their menu) which are cheesy, bacon covered potatoes with a side chipotle aioli.. my mouth is watering just thinking about it again. read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - Bada Bing on plain bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

Excellent bagel sandwiches with fresh tasty toppings. Give this place a try! I recommend The Godfather. read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

Bagel shop with a cool theme. Delicious and fresh! Friendly and efficient staff. Everything was made to order with the great ingredients sourced from Michigan so supporting local is something they do. The bagels were soft and not too chewy. Everything was cooked to perfection. Tons of flavor. Definitely will go back when I'm in town again. read more

See all

I'm walking around Lansing with a hole in my gut and I stumbled upon another hole-in-wall joint. I'm thinking wadda ya got to lose, eh? It's a good thing I did, because even though the sammishes they make have a hole in the middle, they plugged the hole in my gut. Custom made for me and quite tasty too. I'll be back. PS: Don't forget to try the fries, assuming they don't run out before you get there! Yum read more

Great service, as well as high quality food and coffee. Highly recommend! I got The Godfather. read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - The Godfather - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

Terrible inside vulgarity on TV, slow service. Bacon was burned and the bagel was sub par I would give this a negative star read more

Very friendly staff and yummy bagels! Located in downtown Lansing, very convenient location! read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - Best bagel spot in Lansing! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

Went there for the first time today. Best sandwich I've had in awhile. Get there! Hitman bagel was insane good. read more

I'm really surprised this isn't on Yelp yet! We've been searching for a good bagel place since moving to Lansing a year ago. This place checks a lot of the boxes. Chewy bagels, fun sandwiches, and unique cream cheese flavors. Definitely recommended! Only complaints are that they aren't open on Sundays and they have limited selections. Also, their online menu leaves out some info (like what all their cream cheese flavors are), and they don't have iced coffee. I'm sure they'll get there! read more

See all

I absolutely love this place! My bagels are always so good and the Belgian waffles are to die for. But also the customer service is always amazing! Highly recommend read more

AMAZING little bagel shop! Freshly made by some super nice guys. Will definitely be going back to try out other bagel combos! read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - Lox - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

See all

As someone who frequents East Lansing I am disappointed in myself for not finding this place sooner. The BEC sandwich on everything bagel was DIVINE. And the side being a single waffle that they give in tin foil along with your sandwich... absolutely genius. Great way to end the meal. Will be ordering from here every time I'm there now! read more

Easily the best bagels in Lansing. Big Apple Bagels? Super solid. Bruegger's? Great. But neither nor any other comes close to Goodfella's. Their sandwiches are some of the best I've had, and I wish I could go every day. Take the time and check them out, it's so worth it. read more

The bagel sandwich was delicious. Be sure to either order ahead or get their right when they open. We did wait quite a long time, which wouldn't be a big deal normally but it happened to be raining. It was worth the wait to try it though! Will be back. read more

Delicious & Fresh!! We will be back! I had the Lucky and my husband had the Bada Bing both on Jalapeno Bagels. Yummy!

Haven't had a bad Goodfella's bagel sandwich yet, and love that they're using compostable To-Go containers! read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - a planter - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

Warning! Eating a Goodfellas Bagel (I had a Hitman) will distract your co-workers during meetings. So much so that the meeting stops and they want to know where it came from lol. All jokes aside...consistently great food and great customer service. Goodfellas are good fellas! read more

I've been eager to try Goodfella's Bagels for a while and finally got a chance today. I ordered through the online Door-dash platform and it was a pretty smooth process with just one minor hiccup. I indicated on the Door-dash platform that I'd like them to contact me if an item I ordered was out of stock rather than automatically choosing a substitute, but instead I got an email telling me the sandwich I ordered was out of stock but it was replaced with the same sandwich (?), which was confusing. I immediately called the shop to get clarification and their customer service was excellent. The gentleman I spoke with was able to explain that the bagel type I selected was out of stock and helped me to select a different kind. I had the Sonny sandwich on an everything bagel and it may have been the best bagel sandwich I have ever had. I loved that the flavors all complimented one another and I was especially pleased with the quality of the ingredients. The spinach was fresh, the bagel was fresh, and the sausage wasn't at all greasy. I couldn't really see or taste the brown sugar in the cream cheese, but it did have a subtle sweetness to it which I liked. The egg wasn't runny, but it could have been because it was sitting a while before I picked it up. (It was ready well before the estimated wait time on Door-dash) I'm looking forward to trying the lox bagel next time and definitely recommend checking this spot out! read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - Sonny - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

See all

Great little bagel spot in downtown Lansing. It's located in a former, old school men's clothing store. Great selection of various bagel sandwiches and innovative. The gentleman who served me was super. I highly recommend it. read more

A welcoming little joint right on the corner. The food was fantastic. I had the Bada Bing, and it brought the Bada Boom.

Hidden gem in the Lansing area. These bagels were absolutely phenomenal. I was nervous about the Sonny having brown sugar cream cheese but the flavors went together so well, don't be scared of it. These bagel sandwiches were amazing and definitely recommend. read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - The Hitman - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan

See all

Placed my order before 9 on grub hub. Apparently they don't check it when they come in it's 9:44 and there's 4 people working there making other peoples orders while they wait and tells me they're just now going to make it. Supposed to be done 9:15-9:35. Shouldn't have tipped. Hour late. Don't even get a bag to carry it in. read more

I am staying at the hotel in downtown East Lansing and went to grab a bagel and lox sandwich. The inside of this place is pretty unimpressive. And the bagel was pretty bad. I expected a place that has bagels in its name to have baskets of fresh bagels. There were none visible and the bagel I had was rubbery and tasted as if it came from Krogers. Bruegger's on Grand River is far better, and if you go to Detroit, you can get a first-rate bagel from New York Bagel or Jersey Bagels. Even the real Goodfella's would give the bagel a thumbs down. Poor excuse for a bagel. read more

That capo is slamming.... all were fire and had good presentation. Going back for more in the near future. Want to try everything on the menu. read more

GoodFellas Bagel Deli - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Lansing, Michigan