GJP has a long ever growing list of Italian & other Cuisine! Everything I've tried so far has been very tasty! Their portions are generous. I usually have enough for 2 meals! Their prices are great for your budget! The Owner Larry M is a Philanthropist for The Oswego County Area! It's Dine in (Nice atmosphere) or Take Out! read more

Not the best Pizza in my opinion. I came in around 6PM, there wasn't many pizza slices left which is understandable. I got 2 slices, chicken wings and garlic knots. Pizza was dry. One of my garlic knots was not cooked completely. The flavor on all 3 dishes seemed alright. Staff are friendly. There are many tables to dine in. read more

See all

The young lady who helped us order also made our food and she was very helpful! She was clear when communicating our order wait time and was accommodating when I was using a coupon. When waiting for my order I noticed that the tables and seating weren't completely wiped down which was slightly off-putting. But the space was a good size for what it was and parking was no problem due to the pizza shop being apart of the collection of businesses here. The pricing is also not bad in comparison to some of the other local pizza places. Overall the experience wasn't bad. But, the pizza and wings were kind of chewy. read more

See all

I know Vinnie and Mozzi, i worked at a Gino and Joe's. I ordered from the Oswego location, food was half an hour late. Fried mushrooms were mush inside, and discolored from bad oil. Garlic knots were dry, and flavorless. Wings were dry, but otherwise okay. Way overpriced and not the quality i would expect from GJP . read more

In town for baseball tourney, this place was recommended by locals at grocery store. The dill pickle pizza was pretty good. Kids loved the sheet pizza but it was heavy on cheese and soggy. Wings were greasy too. Some people in the group loved both the wings and pizza? To each their own. read more

GJP Italian Eatery - Dill Pickle Pizza - Italian Near Me - Oswego, New York

I got take out pizza and 6 wings. I ordered a 14" with sausage and spinach. I was in the area for work and didnt feel like going to a restaurant. So, it took 20-25 minutes and I ran to the local grocery store for a 6 pack. Came back and pizza and wings were ready. Everything was piping hot. Went back to the hotel and enjoyed a cold beer and some wings. Wings weren't as hot, flavor wise, as I expected, but they were definitely good. Wings included ranch dressing. Pizza was next, I ate two slices and enjoyed them. Later on as I proceeded to drink more I got the munchies and finished the rest of the pizza. Oh goodness, the rest of the pizza.....I should have ordered the 10" as I thought I am just a pig. read more

I paid $98 for for two 14" pizzas, 18 wings and an antipasto salad. The online ordering system told me everything would be ready for pick up at 6:00 pm. I waited inside until 6:20 pm for the order to be ready. The wings and salad were fine but both pizzas were cold, paper thin, and lacked enough toppings to justify the $9 upcharge. read more

Normally when I think of GJP I think pizza, but their diverse menu makes it much more than that. There are many different pasta dishes all of which are quite good. I won't try to mislead anyone by suggesting this is a 5 star fine dining Italian restaurant but they don't represent themselves as that. This is a pizza shop with sandwiches and wings along with some very decent Italian dishes. Absolutely worth giving it a try. read more

This is my go to place for ordering out. This food is fresh, tasty and plentiful. I ordered at the last minute food for a family that had a sudden loss. GJP didn't just 'whip up' some food they prepared some delicious family favorites for 15 at a moments notice and it wasn't sheet pizza. I was able to pick it up in 30 minutes and the family asked me how I cooked such good food so fast. My comment was. I called GJP. Thank you for your compassion, attention to customer service and your quality meals. read more

That will be a nooo for me, I simply asked for a little extra sauce on my pasta well I got the whole pot it was just way to much I could not even eat it so based on this I will not try the pizza read more

Just had the best chicken bacon ranch pizza I've ever had! Love this place and the people!

My favorite subs--the bread is unique--tasty and a bit chewy. Plenty of meat on my favorite turkey with lettuce, onion tomato, Mayo and roasted red peppers. The pizzas and other items are good too. Nice dine in area. read more

Overall food was tasty. I was a little surprised bu the size of the pizza (although I ordered small) for the price it was smaller than I imagined. Also the salad left me wanting something more. Clam strips were good. Would order again. read more

See all

We've eaten in and ordered take out, and never been disappointed. However, I do wish the garbage plate came with authentic Texas hot meat sauce rather than a tomato-based Italian meat sauce. But since I grew up in Rochester, home of the legendary garbage plate, I guess I'm a bit of a garbage plate snob. Whoa, is that any oxymoron?!?! GJP Pizza is among the best available in Oswego, not too thin, and not too thick, but rather just like Goldilocks. I always ask for our wings to be crispy with extra sauce, and they have gotten it right every single time. I've tried a few of their Italian dishes and they're all pretty good, but I haven't tried their subs yet. read more

GJP Italian Eatery - Your classic pizza and wings backed by Roadkill's own Stubby Bob, another classic itself! - Italian Near Me - Oswego, New York

Damn I feel easy and cheap today. Given several 5 stars on Yelp reviews on this day and that doesn't happen. But I digress. I went to this place 3 days in a row. After working 12 hrs, ya dont have it in you to cook. So? Went for pizza slices and they were fantastic, many choices, damn that thin crust NY style folds in 1/2 nicely in ur hand! Fresh toppings. Yum yum yum! Service was good, they seem to actually care about you in here. We ate outside every day since we worked inside. They came outside the restaurant to check on us??!! And its a seat yourself. The desserts are to die for. Five star! Do stop here! No. On 2nd thought , dont stop here cause it will mean better choices for me! Heh,heh, heh. read more

New York is a hotbed for good pizza. Normally, Oswego doesn't necessarily provide the same quality slice that you'd get in New York City. However, this place bucks that trend. This is the rare opportunity to get an awesome slice of pizza in a college town and for a fair price. I consider it one of the few hidden gems in Oswego. While they have plenty of things on the menu wr come for thr pizza. And what we usually do is order several different slices so we can try different flavors. You'll want to do the same. I think your biggest challenge is going to be deciding which slice you want to eat because when you look through the glass so much of it looks appealing that deciding on one or two slices can be a chore. Which lights you choose is entirely up to you, but plan on being impressed that there is a place in Oswego that belongs on your must eat list. In fact, this pizza place would survive even if it was in New York City and that's saying a lot. read more

Fairly didsapointed with my expereince here. I'll give this place another chance because what I ordered may not be their specialty, but I all around didn't love this place. It's nice enough inside and the location is good, but I ordered a cheeseburger sub, and it took them about 30 minutes to make, which is weird considering the Oswego Sub Shop has them ready in less than 5 minutes. Well, it turns out, all that time was put towards burning the meat and making the bread rock hard. Also, who puts tomato sauce on a cheeseburger sub? It's not like It's chicken parm or anything. I really didn't like the sub, and the service wasn't great. Again, I'm willing to give this place another chance, but $15... not worth it for this experience. read more

Good pizza, and I'm a pizza snob from NYC. I had a small pizza with mushrooms and was happy but the small is pretty small so don't plan on leftovers read more

Overpriced. Flat soda. I paid $7.39 for 2 slices of cheese pizza and a flat fountain soda that doesn't come with refills. Way too expensive in my opinion. Pizza was just ok. Nothing great read more

Oily overpriced and the young ladies at the counter are extremely rude! Better off going to Bridge!!

I come up to this Oswego location because I think they have the best quality pizza in the area. I am not usually a fan of New York style pizza I love thick crust but GJP in Oswego has changed me. Worth the trip. read more

See all

Worst customer service ever and the food is just mediocre. Used to be good...skip this place and order from Bridge Street instead.

I tried this place for the first time yesterday. It's very convenient for those looking for Italian on the east side. However it is much more of a pizza/sub shop than anything. I ordered the stuffed shells which were good (comes with 5). The side salad was absolutely awful. Just lettuce, onions, and two slices of tomato but one tomato was rotted. The Italian dressing was probably the worst dressing I've ever had. Also came with a garlic knot which was good but super greasy. My brother had a chicken spiedie sub which he described as "good!" read more

I have ordered twice from this place, both ordering garlic parm wings. The wings were good, very oily, but pretty good. Should be a creamier option, but we'll see what happens there. The deliver for the first time ordering was decent, the second time however was way too long. I ordered at 7:19pm and had an estimate of between 8:23-33pm. The order didn't arrive until almost 9:50. That needs to be fixed. Hopefully it will! read more

Very friendly phone service, affordable prices however NO one was wearing a mask or gloves... Something that I don't think is acceptable or even within restaurant guidelines/standards right now.. especially the mask! I thought my caught off guard face would have sent the message but masks remained off... saw a review 2 months ago saying the same thing but figured it wouldn't still be relevant.. read more

Awesome place with wonderful staff and amazing food. From the subs, to the pasta, to the pizza GJP is delicious.

Stopped on way through Oswego for work. Not one employee had a mask on during this covid pandemic also no one wearing gloves. Made my way to subway right next door. read more

My favorite pizza in Oz. I'm a NYC girl and extremely picky about my pizza. The sauce and cheese are on point. Sometimes it could be little soggy, leaving you with limpy crust, still super tasty though. read more

GJP Italian Eatery - Eggplant parmigiana pizza with extra ricotta ...no words...love you pizza. - Italian Near Me - Oswego, New York

Went into GJP to check out the new expanded dining area. The food was great and the large new dining area is perfect to bring a family for dinner. read more

Delicious food, great quality, wonderful service...if you're looking for the best Italian food around, look no further than GJP!!

The ice cold pizza and the soggy wings that I asked for extra extra crispy was not the issue. I called to let them know about my concern with the order. The manager Alexis didn't even take the complaint but told the employee to tell me that I should have asked for sauce on the side if I wanted extra crispy. Pretty much telling me that it is my fault, with NO APOLOGY OFFERED. They could have recommended that when I placed the order. I also get wings this way at least once a week never have an issue. And I firmly believe placing the blame on the customer is not how you do business. I requested the manager get on the phone. I tried to coach her a little on how the manager should take a complaint and they should not place blame on the customer. She then offered me a $5 credit which I didn't need since I don't live around here. She simply could have apologized and asked what she could do to make it better. I would agree with some of the other Yelp reviews that this was a RUDE experience. COVID or not we can still treat people right even when we let them down. read more

I like their pizza and their canolis. Though the atmosphere was a bit cramped with all the people getting pizza and dining in. The service was alright, but gave the vibe we shouldn't stay all too long. I enjoy a sir down place where I can take in my surroundings and have a conversation with my boyfriend or friends. If you enjoy sitting for a while, gjps is not the place. read more

Probably one of my favorite places to eat in the Oswego area. My fav is cheesesteak sub. Amazing food!! Yummy.

My husband ordered pizza from this pizza shop. He was told it would be 45 mins to an hour. It showed up 2 hrs later. He called multiple times to check in the order,kept being told it was on the way. And told they wouldn't do anything to compensate him. The total cane to $28, he paid the driver $20. The driver told GJP that we refused to pay anything. So they were calling the police on us. The whole situation is infuriating. I have never dealt with such poor costumer service before. I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone. Btw, the food was cold by time it made it. It's sad to see how poorly companies handle their costumers nowadays. read more

This is very good food. At very good prices. I'm enjoying chicken parm which came w a lovely dinner salad, garlic roll and ziti and sauce. The sauce is definitely homemade. The chicken is NOT a chicken patty but a pounded chicken breast, breaded and fried. Very tasty. Plenty of sauce for everything. All for 10.99 read more

Great pizza and more than healthy portions for a reasonable price. The meat lasagna fed me 4x and I can eat.

Love the wings! Crispy, flavorful and so delish! Best we have found in this area. Pizza is great too! Prices are very reasonable.

Often referred to by the local Italian community as Larry *Millerino*, Proprietor Larry Miller has upped the stakes at the former GJP in Oswego by using premium ingredients for starters. With his years of experience making pizza's at various establishments an applying his college education to the business, customers enjoy an assortment of classic and creative specialty pizzas as well as fresh and never frozen chicken wings. As a customer who has had pizza made by Larry at other places, this is his best ever. The menu expands beyond just great pizza and wings, as there is a wide variety of classic Italian dinner entrees and recently added Gyro's. Being a family independent restaurant, Miller and his wife have created an atmosphere at GJP that revolves around customer service and satisfaction.. **Highly Recommended**. read more

First time in Oswego I ordered from GJP, and it was the best pizza I ever had. I highly recommend them!

We often order from here and we love it, but tonight was TERRIBLE. I ordered a pizza and loaded fries at 5:28p and the woman said it would take about 45 mins to an hour, which was fine. There was a knock at the door at 5:43p and I was surprised it was the delivery. I spent nearly $30 for an old cheese pizza they sprinkled some bacon on and reheated and some old loaded fries. Husband called to complain and he was told they make everything fresh so they apologize that we didn't like the food and that was it. NEVER AGAIN! read more