I stopped for quick bite for a slice. They so our slices of pizza during 11 and 2 PM. I believe…read more. two of the last slices of pepperoni he still had.. I gotta say the sauce is very flavorful crust is fantastic and I can't say anything better. Next time I come around I hope to get a fresh slice. Kudos to the owner for their pizza and it reminds me of New York pizza.

Another great pizza from Long Branch. The side salads would be entree salads at most restaurants…read morethese days. Really appreciated that LB was open New Year's Eve. Keep up the good work. Jim M.

As we walked up to the patio, the smell of wood burning, party lights, and people laughing greeted…read moreus. The setting is so cozy you feel right at home even though you are social distancing. The pesto pizza was exactly what i imaged- it did not disappoint and the cold Octoberfest beer was cold and delicious. The band was an added bonus and further eased us into feeling we were all neighbors enjoying the evening together. This is a true gem and makes the drive to this little village worthwhile.

Saw a lot of burnt pizzas coming from kitchen And a lot of…read morebugs on patio Too many to sit outside So moved to bar Still waiting on food They had 3 people working Well at least they were there Won't be back Fixing my diner at home now

Fantastic pizza and wings. Best in Ohio. Appetizers are wonderful. The desserts are tasty. I…read morelove the cheesecake and funnel cakes. Service is always great. Very accommodating for older folks. Nice atmosphere for any age.

OH Pizza & Prime has a lot of potential, but our recent visit was a mixed bag…read more The interior is beautiful--modern, comfortable, and definitely gives the impression of a place you'd want to linger. The wait staff was fine, nothing over the top but polite and attentive enough. The big issue of the night was the pizza. It took about 45 minutes to come out, which was surprising given the restaurant wasn't very busy. Unfortunately, when it finally arrived, the center was undercooked and raw--a real disappointment. Management was very understanding and offered to make another, but with the time already invested we couldn't wait around for a second attempt. On the positive side, the appetizers were really good, and the wings were spot-on--crispy, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. That alone makes me want to give them another chance. Overall, not the best first impression, but I'll chalk it up to an off night. I'll be back to try again, hoping the pizza comes out as good as the rest of the menu.

This is our second time coming here and both times the food was ON POINT!…read more Garlic knots have become our regular starter and for main course we do our pizzas. This time I had the Italian sub which was delicious! All the flavors were spot on and the bread remained crunchy with the dressing! My husband had the meat lovers pizza this time. He wanted to add hot honey and Dori (our server) recommended we try a garlic honey drizzle they have (I could be wrong on the name) -- BEST DECISION! Hands down best pizza in town! Check them out TODAY!

Yes sir!!! Ingredients are fresh, staff and owner are awesome! Pizza is on point!! Best pizza in…read moreSunbury!!!

We love Highland Pizza! We are steady customers and usually buy the same thing over and over. A…read moreHighland Sub and Taco salad. We are never disappointed at the care and quality of our purchase. The owner and workers there all friendly and polite!

Hi. I was there for the first time on Monday 6/15/2026 at 1:52 p.m. I paid $4 for 2 scoops. My…read morereceipt reflects that. "K" is listed as the server. I have my copy of the receipt containing transaction details. I DROVE BACK TO TIP IN CASH. I did NOT tip $5 on the card for FOUR DOLLARS worth of Ice Cream. So WHY did Ii receive a text from my card at 11:15 p.m. on 6/16/26 stating that "Your transaction at Highland Pizza & Ice C has been updated from $4 to include tip. Your new total is $9." NOOOOO. I WILL DRIVE ALL THE WAY BACK UP THERE TO ADDRESS THIS. THIS IS THEFT. I will also be writing reviews warning others that this happens. AND I ACTUALLY CAME BACK WITH A FREND ON 6/16/2026 Zach was the server and he was training another young gentleman.

We came here after the park. We ordered the kids by the slices pizza which was perfect and good. We…read morealso got cheese bread and nightmare on pep street. The pizza had a crusty bottom and we enjoyed a lot. The service was very friendly. You order up at the front and they bring the food to you. They also had a bunch of pinball games that were fun. 1$ per play if you're bringing kids

Absolutely incredible! I tried the Stromboli and it was cooked to absolute perfection--perfect…read morecrust, generous fillings, and amazing flavor. On top of the stellar food, the horror-themed decor and pinball machines make for such a fun, unique atmosphere. Highly recommend checking this spot out!

I ordered an Italian sub and it was delicious. I love when they are oven heated/toasted. The pizza…read morelooked delicious and the smell in there while waiting for my order was killing me.

1/5 Stars - Complete waste of $70. The people leaving good…read morereviews must have zero taste buds. The pizza is totally flavorless, tasting like plain, cheap bread with the lowest-quality ingredients. To make it worse, I paid extra for sauce and didn't even get it. The Stromboli and Bosco sticks sucked, too--completely dry and bland. I love pizza, but I couldn't even finish this. A total $70 waste of money. Never again.

Never been in, we always order for delivery. I WILL say, the delivery is always quicker than the…read moretime they give on the phone, which is always a nice surpirse! Ordering via phone is quick and easy! The delivery staff, which is usually a younger guy with long black/dark hair, is SO friendly! The food always arrives quick, hot and fresh! The food is always SUPER good and delivered as ordered!!! We've ordered from here several times and each time the food is delicious! Great portions! Decent and fair prices!!! Love that they have a punch card!!! I know some ppl don't care about that stuff but it's just a fun little incentive that I DO enjoy and will take advantage of! I WOULD recommend!!! A+++++

Great vegan food available here with great service from a veteran owned restaurant. Prices were…read morereasonable and the food was delicious.

Out of towner looking for a sit down pizza restaurant and we found good one…read more We ordered a medium pepperoni, a mini BBQ chicken, side of ranch and two drinks. Both pizza's were cooked well with some crisp on the edges which is heavenly. I was surprised on how big the restaurant was and the service was really good. Everyone had a responsibility and seemed to work flawlessly. Go Blue!

We ordered a couple of pizzas for carry out while camping nearby…read more The pizzas were hot and fresh. Just out of the oven when we came to pick them up. We ordered a veggie pizza and a supreme meat pizza. Toppings were extremely generous on both pizzas. Garlic bread with cheese was delicious. A great place for lunch or dinner when visiting Hocking Hills.

This pizza place is incredible! This is top 5 best pizza I have ever had and I have eaten a lot of…read morepizza! I got the Colossal Italian and the Primo Pepperoni. The Colossal Italian had very fresh and delicious sausage on it, especially the spicy sausage! The Primo Pepperoni had old world pepperoni and lots of cheese! The sauce is incredible here because it is a nice balanced sauce that is savory but also has a hint of sweetness to it. The fresh garlic and basil really adds something amazing! The crust is not crust you will toss aside either! The staff was very helpful and courteous in explaining the toppings to me and accommodating not putting spicy sausage on the entire pizza because my wife can't eat spicy food. The restaurant had a cool ambience and feel to it. Overall, this is a must stop for any pizza lover and if you live distance away....its worth the drive! Don't miss this pizza gem in Amish country! Incredible!

First time trying this place. It was on a Saturday afternoon. I'm guessing it was considered busy…read more We ordered a small pizza for $17. My wife also ordered a chicken sandwich. We said water for our drink and they wanted to charge for water so we decided against that. We dined in. My wife's chicken sandwich came out pretty quickly. About 40 minutes later my pizza was delivered to our table. The noise of the place was terrible. The steel chairs on the hard floors echoed throughout the dining area. The pizza was delicious! Definitely one of the best pizza pies I've had. Little soggy in the center but overall it was great! My wife liked the chicken sandwich but the dressing was a little heavy, which made it a little too salty for her taste. We're excited to try different items next time! Pros: Food was great. Cons: WAIT TIME Noise Price