I've been a customer since Nicks opened and never had a complaint until tonight. My wife ordered…read moreour dinner as usual, tonight we ordered chicken Quesadilla and a fried chicken salad. I drove 15 mins. to pick it up another 15 mins. to get home. When I opened the Quesadilla it was not what we ordered. I drove 15 more mins to return it and find out what they gave me was. the boy at the counter said I don't know but a girl came out of the back and told me it was a Taco Quesadilla I said I we ordered a Chicken Quesadilla the little girl said I'll make you a new one. When she brought it out she said here you go have a nice evening. She didn't even offer a refund and acted like it was my fault they made the wrong order. Needless to say we will no longer be doing business at Nick's again. Sorry Sandy and Dave but your employees reflect management.

Used to be the best pizza in licking county. They changed their recipe I guess. It's the same as…read morethe one in Saint Louisville now

Amazing food! Friendly service!! The owner came out to chat with us dining in after a softball…read moregame. The pizza, subs, salads, parmesean bites are all fantastic! Highly recommend dining in!

Great pizza wings and the salads are awesome they're huge worth the price ! Great service and if…read moreyou dine in there's a cozy comfortable dining room .The people are very friendly ,can't get much customer service anymore but this place is an exception !

I have only ordered pizza from here which is good. I like that they have two choices of sauce. You…read morecan get a spicy sauce or regular sauce. Each time I have ordered, I get the spicy sauce, which I really like. Service is OK, nothing outgoing about it.

Great owner and super good pizza and wings!! The new ownership has stepped it up and the pizza is…read moreeven better

Amazing great food Have had it since the eighties and it is…read morestill by far the best. Even some of the same staff from the 90s are there

Villa is a Johnstown staple, no question. It has a fantastic cracker crust that doesn't disappoint…read more It's hard to find one like it. However, accuracy and service are lacking. I've been eating here since I was a small child and I can genuinely think of only a handful times they have actually got our order correct. We're not particularly difficult orderers either. The most complex thing we ask for if a plain Italian sub. But our food is consistently wrong and if you say anything about it the owners are super rude. Our visits are few and far between these days.

We ordered online, which I would say was the best online ordering experience I've ever had. The…read moredetail that went into their website, you can edit everything so well and customize your order down to a T! They thought of everything. They are very busy, so pick up was like an hour and 20 after we replaced and then we still had to wait 20 minutes when we got there. But it was very much worth it and I would just plan for the wait. The French fries were bomb. Good fries, cooked well, great toppings and well distributed so you didn't get a bunch of naked fries. The cheese was good, not some crappy cheese sauce. It was like shredded. The pizza was delicious. It was a thicker crust and it had great flavor. Even the smaller pizzas you could split in 2 so you can try 2 different specialty pizzas. We got half Romeo (but switched out the sauce for white olive oil sauce) and half right primo pepperoni. The Primo was the bomb. The red sauce was so good, pepperoni cups were plentiful. The Romeo was different since it was a seasonal, had pistachios on it so had to try it. I thought it was good but didn't compare to the Primo. Also ordered garlic parm boneless wings that would be a problem if we lived here. The tiramisu was good, but I'm a connoisseur so I'm a little more picky. I thought it needed more espresso flavor like a wet layer at the bottom. I would 100% come back here. Great take out to go back to the Airbnb!

Best pizza I have ever had..and I have had a lot of pizza! If you are in the area this is…read moredefinitely a must eat!

Out of towner looking for a sit down pizza restaurant and we found good one…read more We ordered a medium pepperoni, a mini BBQ chicken, side of ranch and two drinks. Both pizza's were cooked well with some crisp on the edges which is heavenly. I was surprised on how big the restaurant was and the service was really good. Everyone had a responsibility and seemed to work flawlessly. Go Blue!

We ordered a couple of pizzas for carry out while camping nearby…read more The pizzas were hot and fresh. Just out of the oven when we came to pick them up. We ordered a veggie pizza and a supreme meat pizza. Toppings were extremely generous on both pizzas. Garlic bread with cheese was delicious. A great place for lunch or dinner when visiting Hocking Hills.

The pizza is outstanding. Couple that with fast, friendly service at fair prices and you have a…read moreSunbury area jewel

Staff members are awesome- great tavern pizza - get the charred pepperoni pizza. Nice outdoor…read morepatio, restaurant is clean and organized.

Decent pizza. The only pizza that doesn't leave bad after taste in my mouth. Feels like It was…read moremade with fresh ingredients. They still use wax paper protecting the pizza from touching the cardboard box which is an important matter for my tastebud.

Friday evening and not wanting to cook. We ordered pizza, a personal Sicilian and a Stromboli…read more Everything tasted great. The Sicilian was like a deep dish compared to the regular pizza. The Stromboli was Awesome love the crust with the sauce good combo together.

Soooo good. 5/5 and we are definitely going back. We ordered takeout, and the thick pizza had the…read moreperfect crisp. Highly recommend. We also tried the cookies, and they reminded me a lot of Lion's Cub cookies - thick, soft, and loaded with chocolate chips (especially the chocolate chip one). Takeout was fast, everything stayed hot, and the person working was really nice. Adding a photo of the inside because the place is fun and has a great vibe.

Crumb uncooked. They claimed they would replace it, but when I called for my replacement pizza…read morethey blocked my number and never made good in their promise to replace it. Not worth the price and the worst customer service I have ever experienced.

We absolutely love there garlic bread we do pizza night at least 2 x a month and come from Ashland…read morejust to get pizza

A great small town pizza place with great recipe and fresh ingredients. I enjoyed my pepperoni and…read moremushroom pie.