GREAT PIZZA! Found this awesome pizza place by chance on our…read moreway back from hiking. Not too thick, not too thin, crust is perfect, cheese is perfect, friendly staff, ran into someone from 15 years ago and learned "Peppy's" name comes from "Pepe Le Pew" . Tell everyone about this place and the town is cool to visit as well.

Pizza has gone down hill. The amount of toping they put on there pizza has shrunk if you order a…read morepizza that happens to have sausage or ham toping on it you get ver few pieces of either. Got a large all meat not long ago there were 8 pieces of ham on it (JOKE). They have no sign on there door of there cash register that they charge a few for using a credit card and a fee for using your bank card.IT IS THE LAW THAT IF THEY CHARGE A FEW IT MUST BE POSTED ON THERE DOOR AND AT THE CASH REGESTER (look it up). When they sold there Mt Vernon store why in the world would you shut down your Fredericktown store for a week. A good way to loose customers. Past couple week weeks there A/C has been down and by my guess they do not have the money to repair it. Seems it about time for the owner to put Pep's pizza up for sale and get an owner who in there that can bring it back to to what Peppys pizza used to be and what it stood for in Fredericktown Ohio

Very good pizza, friendly staff and clean environment. Order online and join the rewards program…read moreonline and get a free pizza after spending a certain amount. Each time you spend a certain amount it gives helps you work your way towards getting a free pizza. One of the most amazing things about the Howard location is how fast the food is ready. I would say an average is about 10 min. It's also consistently good- meaning the dough is cooked properly and the pizza isn't overcooked. The brownies are good. I'd recommend asking for a light bake on them. Getting maybe 4 or 5 toppings makes for a good pizza! Thanks to the manager for doing a good job, as well as caring about Apple Valley. Thanks to all! :)

Always quick delivery, better dominos than the mount vernon locations. They're great about my dairy…read moreallergy unlike most places who load it with cheese even after I ask them not to

Fantastic pizza and wings. Best in Ohio. Appetizers are wonderful. The desserts are tasty. I…read morelove the cheesecake and funnel cakes. Service is always great. Very accommodating for older folks. Nice atmosphere for any age.

Food is decent but prices are very high. Too expensive to eat there a couple times a month.read more

Food is good, the past five times I have ordered they have said 45 mins for delivery time and it…read morehas always been atleast an hour and 15 mins. Ridiculous.

I have only ordered pizza from here which is good. I like that they have two choices of sauce. You…read morecan get a spicy sauce or regular sauce. Each time I have ordered, I get the spicy sauce, which I really like. Service is OK, nothing outgoing about it.

We dined at Burrata Woodfired today. We were promptly seated and our server was Amy. Amy was very…read moreattentive and reviewed the specials. We ended up ordering the meatball sub and the Vinny for our lunch, and took a Blanco pizza and garlic wings home. Everything was excellent for lunch and the wings smelled awesome on our drive home. Highly recommend and will definitely return! Thanks Amy!

We stopped in this establishment yesterday, August 9th at 3:40 pm to have dinner. We were told the…read morekitchen is now closed down and they cannot serve us. The restaurant did not close until 4pm. If it does not close until 4pm, we should have been served. There was no sign stating that the last meal needed to be served at a certain time before closing. What truly made matters worse is that every chair in the entire restaurant was up on the tables with one table of elderly patrons trying to eat their dinner with that mess! Those poor patrons. This was the nail in the coffin for us. What type of establishment would allow their employees to put up every single chair on top of the tables while patrons were trying to dine?? We were regular customers. We will not give our dollars to an establishment that operates this way. It certainly does not care for their patrons, operating in a manner such as this.

My wife and I tried it for breakfast Saturday morning. It was really good. We will definitely be…read moreback,it was well worth the drive. We need a good breakfast place in knox county. This is at the top of the list. Staff was great,friendly also they have a good store for bake goods and meat and cheese.

Amazing people and amazing food. They have anything you will need to satisfy a craving. This store…read moreis a one stop shop. Whether it be a gift for someone last minute, a meal to be shared with friends, to ice cream and milkshakes to celebrate a game victory, they have everything you could ever want it need!

Hi. I was there for the first time on Monday 6/15/2026 at 1:52 p.m. I paid $4 for 2 scoops. My…read morereceipt reflects that. "K" is listed as the server. I have my copy of the receipt containing transaction details. I DROVE BACK TO TIP IN CASH. I did NOT tip $5 on the card for FOUR DOLLARS worth of Ice Cream. So WHY did Ii receive a text from my card at 11:15 p.m. on 6/16/26 stating that "Your transaction at Highland Pizza & Ice C has been updated from $4 to include tip. Your new total is $9." NOOOOO. I WILL DRIVE ALL THE WAY BACK UP THERE TO ADDRESS THIS. THIS IS THEFT. I will also be writing reviews warning others that this happens. AND I ACTUALLY CAME BACK WITH A FREND ON 6/16/2026 Zach was the server and he was training another young gentleman.

I JUST HAD BY FAR THE WORST EXPERIENCE EVER…read more Called an hour ago to put in 3 pizzas and wings. We sat out there 40 minutes after paying. They come out with 2 pizzas. I asked where the 3rd one is and also both the other ones were not the correct size. I clearly stated I wanted 3 pizzas over the phone and my order was read back. When the problem was not resolved, I ask to speak to manager which is KEN. He did NOT resolve the issue and also laughed on the phone stating he couldn't fix the issue because it was not their fault they didn't get it right. He said he could charge me for a large and small that would make up for the medium incorrect and also the missing pizza. I work in management and I have never experienced such a rude manager. Ken literally laughed and said he had to get back to cooking and hung up. Now we are left to go find pizza somewhere else while hosting a pre k graduation at home. Way to ruin the day.

First time I stopped and will be the last time I stop. I will say when I got my food the smell was…read moregreat I was excited to dig into it. When I got home and started to eat the first bite of my foldover it was100% let down. The best way I can put it is simple. I have two dogs and I left my plate with the dripping from the foldover on my coffee table and my dogs never touched the plate to clean it off. So if you don't trust my review you can trust " Mans best friend "

ordered food for my family and the delivery driver decided he was going to try and steal a tackle…read morebox from my garage that has about 200 dollars worth of tackle in it I addressed it with the driver and he then cussed me my father and my mother out and threatened to fight us After that he left then probably about 5 minutes later tubbys called and he was on the line cussing us out and the manger was in the background cussing us out VERY UNPROFESSIONAL I wouldn't recommend ordering ANYTHING from this place!

From the outside you cannot tell this place is amazing - amazing food and amazing customer service…read more Our waitress was Mallory and she made us feel right at home. I was already excited to see my friend that I haven't seen for over 20 years and having Mallory as our waitress made it even more memorable. I even had my dog with me and she made sure that the chicken she brought out was prepared properly by going in the second time and grilling it herself which I really appreciated. She talked with us like we were her friends too and also took a lot of pictures for us as well. The food was good too. For a small salad they gave me a massive salad. They served my friend her Kahuna pizza, which she said tasted good and they gave us complimentary cheesy bread with marinara sauce to start our meal off with. Thank you for making us feel at home.

It's a rather small restaurant, but the overall experience was awesome! Service was spectacular…read more Friendly and attentive. The Eddie bread appetizer was unexpected and tasty. Bar menu was very limited. Pretty much just beer, but the amber ale I had was very nice. I had the pepperoni lovers and it was great. The cheese was extra chewy and the crust was clearly handmade. Loved it! Usually don't get dessert, but the gelato was good. Overall the place was a really nice surprise.

I tried a calzone and hot bbq wings. The calzone comes with sausage, pepperoni and cheese. I added…read morehot capicola ham. A nice size dish of warm marinara is included. The calzone was excellent. The hot bbq wings were equally delicious. I would order from here again in a heartbeat.

The delivery guy was nice. I had to re-bake the pizza, it was not done all the way. Then my first…read moreslice of pizza I found a hair.