Service- Food- great vibes in this place! This is a must eat! Lasagna was amazing! they give you enough garlic bread for 10 People lol I have no idea why we have not checked this place out sooner!! read more

I was a little disappointed with my margherita pizza. I come here every year for my birthday so I can eat what I thought was the best margherita pizza in NWA. It didn't seem the same. Basil leaves were diced instead of whole but that shouldn't have affected the taste. Something was just not quite the right. Desserts were amazing!! We tried one of each. Service was impeccable as was the atmosphere. I will return to try their pesto pasta dish next time. read more

Another great meal with this classic Fayetteville establishment. For a great Italian down home meal this place cannot be missed. The pizza, breadsticks and spaghetti and meatballs were all fantastic. The service was also second to none too! Everyone there made sure we ww were all well taken care of. read more

Geraldi's - Spaghetti n Meatballs (made fresh daily) - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

See all

Banging little Italian joint! After a pleasant 10 mile ride on the greenway, I found myself and my near dear friend at this restaurant. I've wanted to go for a while now. Glad we did. Avery was our waitress, and she was great. We got a pesto veggie sammich and the chicken Geraldi, the latter of which was per Avery's suggestion. Wow. Huge sammiches. Enough food to conquer a long bike ride's hunger. You get a whole friggin Caesar Salad on the sammich. Delicious, great value, great atmosphere (heard some Elton John and other artists of note), and great service. We'll be back to dig the Za. 10/10. read more

Geraldi's - Chicken Geraldi and Veggie Pesto - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

I love this place super affordable for the portions. Small seating inside but great takeout pizza was great and salad was super yummy. read more

Geraldi's - Custom pizza ! - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

Geraldi's is delicious. I was recently in NW AR and looking for a non-chain local joint. As usual, Yelp didn't let me down. I found this place, and the reviews were good. Pulling up, the parking lot is tiny, and they were already pretty busy even though it was early on a Friday evening. We had no wait to be seated, and we ordered the fried ravioli and mozz sticks. They came out quickly, and were awesome. For my entree, I had the spicy alfredo with chicken. It had a really nice kick to it, which I enjoyed. If you say something is spicy, bring that heat! Along with our entrees, they brought out what must have been two full loaves of garlic bread. I'm not sure if we looked hungry or what, but There was no way our party of four was going to eat all that. Everything was super delicious and we left stuffed. read more

Love the pizza and Caesar salad. Perfect date night. Parking lot is bad but everything else is good.

A hidden gem. If you don't know about it, you'd miss out. Classic Italian food. We love their all meat pizza which is perfect every visit.

I'm a HUGE foodie and can be a food critic and this place was a 10/10. For flavor, texture, portions size. etc. and the waitress was awesome. We got the Margherita Pizza, added pepperoni, it was the best pizza 10/10. Spinach and Artichoke was THE BEST I've ever had, the chunks of artichoke, paired with spinach and garlic and it's served with the best garlic bread. Can't wait to go back to AR, from AZ. read more

Geraldi's - Spinach Artichoke Dip - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

See all

Excellent food in a cozy atmosphere. If you're looking for a restaurant that isn't a chain, this is your place.

This was a great find on our recent trip to Fayetteville. The spacious restaurant was perfect for a family meal. Our server was so personable offering recommendations and asking about our visit to town. We couldn't decide between the appetizers, so we started with the mozzarella sticks and the spinach artichoke dip. It was accompanied by a very hearty serving of garlic bread. Between everyone at the table, we ordered entrees including salad, pasta and pizza. The large pizza was huge and would serve 4-5 people. Each person really enjoyed their entree, and serving sizes were more than plentiful. We will keep this restaurant in mind for future visits to town. read more

See all

Had dinner here after the holidays and it was busy! Recommend going early. It is not large but so cute. My first time here and it was so good. I had the Mama Geraldi's Garden Salad (half size) and it was huge and had an amazing dressing. They also brought out garlic bread and I ordered some marinara -- beyond good. For my entree I had the small White Pizza and added artichokes; and a side of ranch :) This might be the best pizza I've ever had, and I've had a lot. Also the ranch was soooo good. The servers are very attentive and all seemed so nice. I highly recommend and will be back. read more

Such a fun environment. Gluten free garlic bread is top tier!! The chicken Caesar salad is great too

Good, flavorful pizza. A little small for the price but good ingredients cost money. The service is always great and the food is good

This place has fast become a favorite of our family. Spicy Alfredo (chicken or shrimp), pizza, spinach artichoke dip (appetizer), spaghetti and meatballs - great desserts and great craft, bottled soft drinks - plus the regular food fountain sodas and iced tea. The service is always great and the place is always clean and comfortable! Don't miss it if you like Italian food! read more

See all

Great neighborhood restaurant. good food and lots of it! The lasagna is one of my favorites.

Great food, friendly and relaxed atmosphere. Great service and generous portions. I do wish they offered a different bread choice, but that's minor. read more

The place was packed when we got there so figured we were making a good choice. It's a small place that gives off a cozy, casual, Italian dinner vibe. We really enjoyed the food. We started with the spinach and artichoke dip and it was great. It was nice to know that there was actually spinach in it, because it was green, and not just a plate of cream cheese. We also got an inordinate about if bread with our order so if you are a bread lover- this is the place. The pasta was flight and refreshing. The only thing that could have made it better is if the pasta would have been made fresh. The pizza was delicious- specifically the marinara- which is a very important part of a delicious pizza in my opinion. We finished with a piece of coconut cake and it was perfectly sweet and moist. My only other knock is that it took a loooong time to get our food. We waited 45 min after placing our order before our food came out. Regardless, we would go back. read more

Geraldi's - Spinach and artichoke dip - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

See all

Had a large family dinner (14 people) at Geraldi's to celebrate our son turning 21. The restaurant was amazing to accommodate our group and make the dinner special. The food was good as always. And the price point can't be beat. read more

Stop scrolling! You just found a gem! Geraldi is some of the best Italian food I have had in my life. The spicy shrimp Alfredo was so good and just the right spice. They give a ton of garlic bread with your meal and we dipped it in their fantastic pesto sauce. The sizes are grand. My wife got the chick parm sub Alfredo sauce and she loved it!! The service was kind and courteous. The restaurant is small but it feels like a hidden gem when you step inside. We will be back! read more

See all

Geraldi's is a must when you're looking for the best Italian food. From the service to the menu choices it's the real deal. Pizzas were amazing and we loved the crispy crust. read more

So good! We ate here twice while we were in town. The Lagana was some of the best I've had. The stuffed mushrooms and cesar salad were also delicious. My wife has to eat gluten-free and she enjoyed the GF pizza very much. Great atmosphere and customer service too! We will be back! read more

Geraldi's - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

See all

Good pizza! Long wait but probably just because its game day and they had 80 pizzas to make for to-go orders. Pretty solid pizza, but greasy I will say. Not much reason to take away stars just took so long to get our pizza and the bill. read more

Geraldi's - Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

Geraldi's is a local Italian restaurant in Fayetteville. The food was tasty, and prices were reasonable. The service was excellent, and the waitresses told my high school-aged son all about the University. I recommend this restaurant over the chains in the area the pizza was good. We were there in the middle of the afternoon and had the place to ourselves. read more

See all

Incredible! Everything about this place was great: atmosphere, service, and the food. Our server was extremely friendly and helpful. The garlic bread literally melted in my mouth and all of the food was excellent. The sauces were especially good. Highly recommend this place and we will be back! read more

Geraldi's - Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

The food was delicious! We had the stuffed mushrooms (creamy and delicious filling) the spicy shrimp pasta and the basil pesto pasta. All were very fresh and delicious. The service was wonderful, atmosphere was very pleasant and being Valentines Day, they were packed, but everything came out quick, hot, and delicious! I'll definitely be back and I definitely recommend! Also...the garlic bread is delicious! read more

Geraldi's - Stuffed mushrooms and delicious garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Fayetteville, Arkansas

See all

Great little hole in the wall Italian seat a few mins away from Razorback field. Good service fantastic Italian food. Sweet tangy red sauce. Fresh vegetables and cheeses for the caprese salad. We will be coming back every time the LSU Tigers come to town for Baseball or football. Geaux Tigers!! read more

Stopped in for lunch. Great food! We had pasta, caprese salad, and the Italian dip. Excellent food! Great service and the to go drink was appreciated! read more

We ordered delivery. Meal was fantastic! Had fettuccine Alfredo with chicken. Chicken was cooked perfect and the sauce had a nice consistency (not too thick). We also got a Caesar salad which had nice greens in it, and a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was delicious and we were big fans of the crust. My favorite part of the meal was the spinach artichoke dip. I loved that they served garlic bread with and they were generous with the amount of bread. We will definitely order again and will try to make it to the restaurant one of these days. read more

Pesto pasta was excellent! Great place to eat and a good ambiance. Service was quick and thorough. Parking was a bit of a pain, first time to the area and the lot is very small. Circled around a bit waiting for a spot to open. Wasn't aware of any other spaces in the nearby streets. Definitely will go back if our daughter ends up going to school at U of Ark! read more

The food was really good! We were seated quickly and got our order taken. A couple of large groups came in behind us. Our server then seemed to forget about us. Our food didn't come out until after the group's food. We sat there for a while waiting. Our cups were empty. I would be willing to go back. read more

See all

Best service I have ever experienced. So incredibly helpful and kind. Best pizza I have ever had.... What a TREAT!!! Mayzee was spectacular! She put the "mayz" in AMAZING! So delightful and made the experience so much better! Also amazing atmosphere. read more

Food was great, service even better. We had pesto and pizza. A nice off the beaten path kind of place.

The best restaurant in the universe. A few words for you: Chicken fettuccine Alfredo read more

I wasn't sure because it's off the beaten path, but we wanted Italian food and it didn't disappoint. I had the Spicy Shrimp Alfredo. It was delicious, and the portion was great. The whole family enjoyed it. read more

Came from out of town and was amazed by the food and excellent service. A fun atmosphere just tops it off. Would definitely recommend!!

The ambiance is like being in a little cafe on a back street in Italy. The servers are friendly and helpful, the salads are always fresh and the Calzones are the reason that I come back every week. read more

Pizza is great as always. Service is prompt. The ambiance is what I would call a college student cheap date night place. The only problem with dining here is the parking situation. Get there early! read more

Five stars for past experiences. I have a personal gripe with this place right now. The pizza was the best in town. It was the closest thing to New York pizza around. Now someone decided to change the pepperoni to cup pepperoni. They took something that was perfect and decided to ruin it. Something I learned working in restaurants in my earlier years; people eat with their eyes first. When they put that pizza in front of me I was transported back to my childhood when we used to make Tony's frozen pizzas, they had the cup pepperoni, and were god awful. A truly disappointing pizza, I couldn't enjoy it at all. I also got a huge grease stain on my khaki shorts. Why? Because cup pepperoni holds pools of grease, and when a pepperoni fell off the pizza it splashed grease all over me. Major disappointment. This place was one of my favorites in town. I won't be back until I hear they've switched back. But, every time before that the pizza has been stunning, perfect. Also the best garlic bread in town. read more

My daughter was so excited for a gluten free pasta option. She loved it & said she'll be back.