Diving with Garden Isle Divers is a fantastic experience - to quote Eric, the dive master and one of the two owners, "Best in Show". He and his partner Carrie take such good care of their dive groups, and its easy to see that they are passionate about what they do. One of the running themes of our dives when I joined was that what is considered "best" is going to vary, based on personal tastes in various categories. That rang true to me (hence the following review will be arranged as such), with the caveat that I've never had a bad day if I'm able to scuba. :)
Dive Group Size: When I joined them on 8/16, it was as a solo diver with ~100+ dives under my belt, renting all my equipment, with my last dive ~1 year ago. We met on at the Port Allen docks, where their boat was moored, and I found out that it would just be 3 of us diving. The website had indicated the max dive groups were capped at 6; this enables Eric and Carrie to customize the dive experience to the people on board. The other two people diving with me were a couple whose last dives were 15 years ago -- clearly a disparate experience, but not something that phased Eric at all. He was extremely thoughtful and thorough about doing a quick refresher overview for them, as well as walking us through all of the equipment on the boat to make sure we were comfortable with their kit (more on that later).
Equipment: I mentioned that I rented all of my equipment. Historically I bring (at least) my own boots, wet suit (if needed), fins, mask, snorkel, and "emergency stuff" (sausage, whistle, etc). This trip I decided not to, and instead rolled the dice on using Garden Isle's kit. It was a great decision. The masks were well maintained, and not overly scuffed. The fins were boot-fins, as opposed to slide ons, so no blisters. The BCDs were integrated with weight pouches as opposed to having to deal with weight-belts/lead (and bruised hip bones). The octopus/regulators were dialed in such that they had very easy airflow (no sucking/extra effort needed), and were color coded so that you didn't run the risk of accidentally using someone else's kit. Very pleased with all of it.
Dive Sites: This is one of the categories that I think Garden Isle Divers really sings. We dove two locations on my trip - Poke Bowl and Hale O Honu (Turtle House) - and both were absolutely teeming with life. Naturally, you can't guarantee what you're going to see on ANY dive, but man, Eric has eagle eyes and we saw so many incredible things. At Poke Bowl, we started with several (large) green turtles. We also saw three different varieties of nudibranch, two different kinds of eel, a rare variety of puffer (guinea fowl), angelfish, frog fish, Hawaiian sergeants, and the others saw dolphin (I was distracted by other stuff). It was 47' max depth and I got 62 minutes of bottom time. Heaven!
You'd think that couldn't be topped, but we meandered over to Hale O Honu (Turtle House), which felt like it was 5 minutes from Poke Bowl (who knows... we were all chatting... it was a fast ride). Once again, there were several green turtle waiting to greet us. Then, we descended an started wandering around, we saw more nudibranch, frog fish, an octopus, two eagle rays, barracuda, coronet fish, loads of beautiful cowries, Hawaiian sand dollars, lion fish, and a striped sea snake-eel that was out hunting (and spooked the heck out of two stouts just trying to live their best lives). This dive was 62' max depth and I got 65 minutes of dive time.
Intangibles: Okay, I know this is getting long, but there needed to be another category to catch all the random thoughts that didn't fit anyplace else. First, Eric is an encyclopedia of fish, coral, invertebrate, and geological knowledge. That's awesome for nerds like me who want to learn while they dive. He carries a write-on board so that he can give details underwater, not just the perfunctory hand signals (which of course are also used). So if you like that sort of dive experience, he kicks it up to the next level. Second, Carrie, is a treasure. She makes the boat ride smooth/comfortable as the captain but she ALSO runs around getting everything set up and broken down for the dive, down to helping put on your fins so you don't have to bend over. Like, that's next level luxury as far as I'm concerned.
All told, considering the above, it's a best in show dive experience, and one that I'm looking forward to returning to. I told my husband about my diving experience today, and he actually said he might like to come back with me (instead of golfing... and he LOVES golf). Guess this means its already time to plan our 2023 trip to Kauai. Thanks for everything, Eric & Carrie!!! read more