The good: the burgers are excellent. There's a good selection of menu items that aren't super common. The meh: they are frequently out of different menu items. The fries are meh. Many of the sundaes are just vanilla ice cream with different flavored syrups drizzled on top. The bad: the service is atrocious. Easily the worst in town. Your order will take 30 minutes to come out, minimum, even if you just order one meal, even if you're the only one there. If there are other people there, you'll be there for so long that, congratulations, you live there now. Calling ahead is an option, but they only answer the phone about 25% of the time. And calling multiple times in a row will not help. Overall definitely worth going to if you have the time to wait, and definitely one of the best restaurants in town. read more

Hyper local spot. Various hunting & wild game photos on the wall, ambiance maxing. Seriously good burger & ice cream.

Hands down the best burger in Susanville. But you better be ready to wait because it takes a long time for them to make your food, like 20 to 25 minutes, easily. read more

What a little gem! This unassuming Di er has it all. Nice menu with something for everyone. Big burgers for a really reasonable price. They don't skimp on anything. We ordered a kids soft serve and we split it between two adults, it was huge! Classic diner favs, very affordable ;) read more

I just left the frosty mill for the first time Has the " world burger" 1/2 lb. Meat and cheese with all the right stuff Onion rings and a coke.. I have traveled the world quite a bit and this is by far the best hamburger/union rings I have ever had I could barely finish what was there I was stuffed this is definitely on a to-do list read more

Me and my fiance love the milkshakes here, and the workers are very nice. I see alot of people travel through for a quick bite.

I would not have found this place without the recommendation of a friend and so glad that I found a great little burger joint in a town that I pass through frequently. My friend and I were discussing the pros & cons of the burger joints in town and what stuck out to me is this place had comfort food and ice cream. Now you can get burgers here of various toppings but the name of the place is Frosty Mill. Super kid friendly, family friendly and of course any age friendly. My World Burger was great, it was so much that I would opt for the smaller serving next time. Checking out the menu did indeed express a lot of fried foods that I would be interested in. The service was fast, very helpful in shake flavors and offerings. Described the burger types and of course they make everything fresh. I essentially enjoyed the fantastic value of the milkshake but next time I may opt for the large cone that they turn upside down into a large cup and the kids love it. Inside was clean throughout but it's a small restaurant, seating about 25 people. Some outside seating as well. read more

See all

We were passing through and most of the reviews said the food was great! I'm still waiting on my food, but this is what I've observed. Multiple people in and out with no cleaning of tables. I asked several times for a towel, as I'd clean it but was told to hold on. My husband asked and cleaned our table. Unfortunately, that was worse! The towel smelled of really old, soured water. This left the table smelling like that. My one kid moved to another, yep....dirty table because of the smell. The food was really good. So, I'd recommend ordering to go. Just makes me wonder how clean they are in the back. Granted, there were only two people working and they were super busy. read more

Frosty Mill - Chicken strips - Burgers Near Me - Susanville, California

Yes there's a wait but it's all real food so it takes time! Friendly service and the food is great we had burgers fries and ice cream it was great. Cute burger joint! read more

Incredibly slow preparation of food. Waiting 40 minutes for 2 burgers and onion rings.

This place puts all the other fast food places to shame. Better quality and it's cheaper.

We showed up with a party of 8 at 7:35 pm tonight and the girls working said they closed at 7:30 but they closed at 8:00. Lied And refused our business so we left and they missed out on our business... not a Merry Christmas. Thumbs down. read more

Just passing through, My husband and I both got the world burger with cheese, they really hit the spot. Burger had great flavor and fresh produce. 10/10 read more

I wasn't really hungry, just needed to use the facilities, IYKWIM, but after reading the reviews, I had to stop by for a chocolate malt and fries. Not a fan of ketchup, but I do like extra salt. Several salt packets were in the bag with the fries! I used them all, lol! I never go small on the malt, and usually pay between $8-10 bucks for a large at these small burger spots. But both the "Super" 32 ounce malt and large fries were only $11. There was a large group ahead of me, but I received my order in less than 10 minutes. These thick cut fries can be tough to cook thoroughly, but they did. Delicious! The malt is super alright - super chocolately. I'm not tasting much malt. But I like a lot of malt. The restroom was small but clean, with a newer looking pull down paper towel dispenser and push to dispense soap dispenser. I'll stop by again on my next visit to Susanville. W read more

See all

I've been visiting Eagle Lake to camp nearly every summer since my childhood, yet somehow it took me being nearly 40 to find this place. Frosty Mill is everything I expected it to be. Drab interior bordering on dilapidated. Believe me when I say no frills aesthetic. But you don't come here for the ambience...you come for the food. Highly recommend the soft serve. As most have noted, portions are outrageous and leave me wanting to be a child again. If you're looking for a greasy spoon burgers and shakes spot that's different from your standard fast-food chain fare, consider this a place worth stopping. read more

Well, the flies outnumber the customers though a busy place. Dirty but could be due to the age of the place. Just passing thru and Recommended by locals but I don't know why. Good burger/ fresh bun , potato wedges. Machine made shakes. read more

Honestly it was filthy, no soap in the bathrooms, showed up 20 minutes before closing and they would not sell any food. Probably for the best. The employees were decent, building just dirty. read more

Waited 35 minutes for a grilled ham and cheese sandwich, chicken sandwich, and one order of fries. The restaurant was dirty and full of flies. Decided to eat our food in the car with doirs open no fly problem. The restroom was disgusting. The food and ice-cream prices are reasonable but sodas are astronomical. No adult manager on duty. 3 high school aged girls. read more

Great food.... That being said, hours are unacceptable. They stop serving food at random hours throughout the week. Clearly this place does not want to make money. read more

This was the worst food I have experienced in a long time. The food was flavorless, and expensive in addition to the long wait we experienced (over 25min for 2 burgers). We ordered 2 burgers, 1 order of fries, 1 diet drink and 1 shake (the shake was runny at best and had an odd aftertaste), and our bill was almost $50! This is a place that offers no services except cooking your food which was poorly cooked - but the thing that topped this terrible experience is the poor customer service. The girl that took our order was rude at best and almost borderline angry with us when we asked a question. I would avoid this place and go down to the lumberjack, get your moneys worth and edible food. read more

great food, amazing ice cream. I come here probably too often. I can't wait until next time

The shake I got was amazing wish I had grabbed some food to maybe next time I swing through

Small little hole in the wall Favorite spot in Susanville Always stop when we come visit Great burgers and even more awesome milk shakes Definitely recommend read more

Great little local favorite! Amazing prices. Will definitely be going back there anytime we are in Susanville.

Great food as always....been going there for years. BUT, it's become a filthy rundown mess of disrepair. Seems like it wouldn't take too much to clean up the filth on the booths, walls, doors, floors, highchairs....fix the doors, replace that nasty faucet in the women's room. (What happened there?) If the whole place is that dirty how sanitary is the food service area? read more

You will wait. If you have the force with you or some kind of patience it will pay off. This is not for people who want fast fast food. This is for home town quality food. If you want good food you will wait. The average wait time is around 20 mins. This place is busy. I don't mind waiting around 20 mins for quality food. The cook is working to deliver quality food. Patience is needed for quality food. This is a local food place. A true throw back that will always be busy because the food is good. If you want 1 min food don't come here. If you want an experience and quality food this is a must try. Small town at its finest. read more

Frosty Mill - Fish and chips.  malt vinegar and the tartar sauce wow so good - Burgers Near Me - Susanville, California

See all

This little gem along Hwy139 In California had the best tasting burgers. Seasoned perfectly, soft warm buns, fresh tomatoes , lettuce, onions with their best special sauce. This reminded us of our past. Where you always received hand pressed burgers(not that processed meat) . Service was quick and friendly too. read more

Great place to eat. Takes longer to get your food but that's because the make it fresh.so be patent.

As always I looked up the best spot for lunch while in Susanville, Calif. I always look up the best French fries. It's super important for me to get the properly cut steak fries. Shoe string fries are not my faves. Frosty mill was the spot for me. I asked a couple of people where they recommended for lunch and we were told gristly mills and that the mozzarella sticks were a must. Feisty mills is about 1/2 a mile from the Main Street in town (that's what it's called). It's a little spot doesn't catch attention. As soon as you walk in there's the menu on the wall. The prices are very very reasonable. We ordered two burgers, two fries and an order of mozzarella sticks and it was a total of $21. Not bad. The fries were bomb...just fried to perfection. Let's not mention those Mozzarella sticks...the hype is real. They are super crunchy and pair well with their ranch. The cheeseburger was smaller than most burgers out there but super filling. We could not leave frosty mills without trying their ice cream cones. Super yummmyyyy. I will definitely be back. My only complain are the bees inside the restaurant. There were about 5 bees wondering inside by the windows. Seems like there might be a bee hive nearby and they got stuck inside. Super scary. That should definitely be looked at. read more

Frosty Mill - Front of restaurant - Burgers Near Me - Susanville, California

See all

We love going to Frosty Mill! The staff are always so sweet. The food is always hot and juicy!

I had the World burger with cheese and onion rings both were very good. Located just about a 1/2 mile off the Main Street (highway 36) WELL WORTH the short drive off of Main Street if you want a very good hamburger. It takes about 15 to 20 minutes for your food but the burgers are hand patted and made to order. read more

Wonderful food! My family and I stopped by for the first time and had burgers and shakes and loved them! The staff are very helpful and nice! We will be back! read more

Frosty Mill - Cheese burger and onion rings - Burgers Near Me - Susanville, California

This place is in the middle of a neighborhood, but don't be fooled it is the best burgers, fries, and shakes in town for a great price. Great service, might take a while but it's definitely worth the wait. read more

Frosty Mill - Belly buster with fries and medium cherry shake. HEAVEN. - Burgers Near Me - Susanville, California

I gave 3 stars because of the time it took to get our food. We ordered a cheese burger and fries to share. It took about 40 minutes to get our food. If you have time, it's worth it, the food was really good. read more

It was ok for an old fashioned hamburger joint. Now, the frosty was very tasty as I got the half & half. Fries were okay and the cheeseburger was a cheeseburger, nothing to write home about. Not sure of the service as my mom ordered our food. Seemed like it took a while for them to make our order but, who knows. Overall, it was okay. Ads read more

Not great. I ordered a peanut butter shake, extra thick. It was not extra thick, it wasn't even regular thick! It was thin and runny. Also, they use soft serve. I have had soft serve shakes at tons of other places, and they are good. For whatever reason, here, the soft serve seemed like it had separated and was icy and slightly watery. I had heard that the food here was not great, but they do a good job on anything ice cream related. Apparently, they don't do a good job on either. Will not be back. read more

Oh my goodness, the best hangover burger in the world!!! Basic cheeseburger and fries so mouthwatering delicious do not miss the opportunity if you are craving a burger, fry's or a banana split go here!!! read more

The restroom now has a key and ruler attached as the key chain to open the bathrooms that are located inside. When you're done with the key it is returned back to the counter where the food is placed for pick-up. This is highly unsanitary and needs to be addressed asap by the owner. A bathroom key should never be placed anywhere near customers food. read more

Delicious food and great staff! I can see why this place is popular. If you're in a hurry, call ahead and order - they make all food fresh. The cheeseburger was exactly what I wanted it to be. read more

We got a hamburger and fries are both awful cold Take my advice go to McDonald's it be better Burger King any place, at least they have health standards refers stopped at the casino the trailer try to have that face stinks incisor restaurant don't go there and read more