I rented the same unit from J&S Management for seven years. On the whole, they were okay -- I mean,…read moremost landlords are shady crooks, so we're grading on a curve here. If I could've I would've given 2.5 stars. A few experiences of note that may help you decide if these are the particular shady folks you want to go with:
1) The worst experience I had here was undoubtedly when my fridge broke. They sent out one of the brothers, I believe Steve, to check it out. It was leaking like mad and wasn't staying cold. He cleaned out the filter and said that should fix it. It didn't, and I spent the next FIVE DAYS calling and emailing trying to get them to come fix it. I called the regular and emergency maintenance numbers. Nothing. It leaked tons of liquid everywhere and all my food in the fridge and freezer went bad. Finally they got back to me, didn't apologize for not returning my calls or emails for nearly a week, and never responded to my request that they compensate me for all the food waste because they wouldn't do their jobs.
2) I second all the complaints that they're impossible to get ahold of. Don't respond to emails or calls until days later. Generally just a hassle to get in touch.
3) I also had a few occasions in which they stated they were coming by for an inspection and didn't show. Once, I delayed a road trip because Greg (office manager) was supposed to come do an inspection of the water heater and never showed up. When I called him to see where he was, he acted surprised and like he didn't even remember scheduling the appointment. Overall, they just seem pretty disorganized.
4) Security deposit stuff. Oof. Honestly, I didn't expect them to give me anything because, you know, landlords. I did get about 1/3 of it back, but saw that they had charged me $200 to replace the carpet. That carpet, to begin with, was maybe worth a buck and a quarter -- the absolute cheapest, crappiest carpeting on planet earth. It went downhill FAST once we moved in, it was such abysmal quality. Before re-signing our lease for the second year, we asked if they could replace it, and got an email back saying that it should last 5-10 years. Never asked them to replace it again. Then they charged us for it when we moved out, even when I showed them the email stating they would replace it after 5-10 years (again, lived there for seven). Did I have dogs who probably made it messier than if I hadn't had pets? Sure. Was it in the best shape when I left? No, because it was absolute crap carpet and even though I shampooed it at least four times a year for the duration of my tenancy, it was still crap carpet. Maybe the charge was justified -- you can come to your own conclusions.
5) The timing of asking you to re-sign is BONKERS. My lease started in July, and I'd get an email saying I needed to re-sign by December in, like, October. Thankfully, they always let me extend the deadline until February or March because I was on the academic job market and never knew if I'd be staying in the area until spring. But yeah, I don't get it, and none of my friends ever had to re-sign so quickly. Annoying and unnecessarily stressful, IMO.
6) Good things: Jeff, the maintenance guy, is 10/10 awesome. Nice dude, competent, on the tenant's side. I think Greg is a nice guy as well and enjoyed talking to him.
So overall... Meh? Like, you could probably do worse, but they're not good? I mean, I stayed there for seven years, mostly because it was fine enough and pretty affordable and I hate moving more than anything in the world. To me, this seems like your standard middling to poor landlord stuff. Besides the fridge incident, nothing too shocking or awful happened. Just mediocre quality all around, seemingly pretty disorganized, and hard to get ahold of. But, in my experience, livable. Hope this is helpful!