This was my first time dining in at Flippers. I've been to this plaza so many times over the years and never tried them. Nancy won a coupon for a free large two topping pizza, valued at $25. We stopped in on a somewhat slow Sunday evening and were promptly greeted by our server, Milah. Milah was super friendly and attentive. We ordered a pepperoni and mushroom pizza and antipasto salad to share ($13.50). Our salad was out in about 10 minutes and 10 to 15 minutes later our pizza arrived. The antipasto salad could have been a little bit bigger but it was enough to share during this meal. Our pizza had great flavor and the sauce was delicious; however, it was a bit greasy and the bottom was burnt in some spots (oven maybe too hot) but ultimately tasted very good so not a major upset. The restaurant was clean and organized and so were the restrooms. The two young ladies working in the dining area were cleaning and keeping things in tip top shape. It's good to see staff cleaning up when there's downtime, most places everyone is on their phone; great job Flippers staff. All in all, we had a delicious meal and great service so we will be back. read more

See all

My first time here. I won a coupon for a free large pizza. I had it in my wallet for a while and we finally made it here! We ordered a pepperoni and mushroom large Pizza. Eight slices. Came out fresh and hot. Some people say it might be greasy but it was a lot of cheese and a lot of pepperoni on it and I thought it was delicious.! We also ordered an antipasta and shared it. The salad was also good and the dressing was tasty. Our server was Nilah she very good and attended to our every need. There wasn't very many people here on a Sunday evening so we may have gotten special service but I enjoyed the dinner and will come back again. The restaurant is clean and nice. November 2025. read more

See all

I won't be ordering from here again tbh wings 17.50 for 8pc for soggy wings. Pizza was not cooked all the way. The salad for the price I could have got salad for a whole week and salad was trash. They have turned into a commercial pizza restaurant ! read more

See all

Update! Thank you, "Z" for another wonderful experience. Food was still on par and I hope you guys never get rid of Show Pigeon! read more

See all

Just ordered flippers for takeout. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza & an order of buffalo wings. The pizza was great ! Really tasty. Love the sauce, and the crust was good too (good balance between crunchy & fluffy). I took off one star because while their wings were tasty, they certainly were not "hot" or buffalo wings at all. Tasted like they were just plain oven roasted. Service was good, friendly & accurate with wait time for pick up. Location is right in downtown lake Mary, so parking isn't bad either. read more

Flippers Pizzeria was the pizza of choice for a Friday dinner. Is this the best pizza I have ever had? No, but it is a good choice to change things up. My husband and I ordered pizzas and Asiago Pepperoni Rolls. We ordered Hawaiian and pepperoni sausage pizza. Both pizzas were good. The Asiago Pepperoni Rolls are amazing! Those are our favorites. They also have salads and sandwiches in the menu which I haven't try yet. Our order was ready to pick up when we got there. Service was great too. This location is in downtown Lake Mary, and it has outdoor seating. Parking is easy to find around the park or in front of the restaurant. read more

See all

This is my favorite pizza place, my family has gotten here many times. My usual is the Pizza Margarita, I can eat a whole pie of that by myself, the crust is beautifully charred, the tomato is flavorful, and the cheese brings it all together. I can't say much about the ambience or service since my family primarily orders from this place, but I can say the inside of the place is very cozy. This place deserves more stars than what it has! read more

Still my Favorite Pizza spot. Flippers Pizzeria in Lake Mary, Florida. My favorite the Deluxe Pizza with a Greek Salad. The Service is always great there and this being a busy Friday nothing changes. The service is great along with the ambience to match. Not to mention the Lake Mary Plaza is a nice place to eat on a Friday evening and Flippers Pizza is my favorite. Please put them #1 on your places to eat. read more

Poor organization. No order among the staff or management. Gave me a 25 minute wait, said they called, never did, and wasted waiting an hour watching two entire families skip over me. read more

Flippers has truly blown me away, the customer service was absolutely incomparable!! They helped make my work end of year party such a success, everyone knows: Good food = Happy People! Thank you Flippers for some absolutely delicious pizza and even better customer service!! read more

Great location with good parking. The staff is friendly and the pizza is super good. I highly recommend them. The establishment is very clean. read more

First, they were delayed in having our pizza ready. It took 45 minutes. It was nice and hot when we got it. There was plenty of cheese on it but needs parmesan in addition. However, the pizza was a flavor disappointment. The sauce needs salt, oregano, and garlic. The crust was good and chewy. read more

Flippers Pizza - Sausage Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

A couple months ago, I went to lake Mary for dinner... I'm glad I chose Flippers! the pizza was BRILLIANT! Hands down, best pizza ever. words cant explain how good It was. I got the broccoli too and it was delicious! I would definitely recommend to anyone! Kat and Z were so kind too. They had nice lighting and a nice aesthetic! Now, I go like every week! LOVE this place. read more

I went to Flippers yesterday 2-14-26 and I was pleasantly surprised. Prices were great and our pizzas tasted so good, our server Rachel did a really great job making sure that we had all that we needed. I will be coming back for sure read more

this isn't even abt the food the pizza is okay kinda mid the breadsticks are good tho but if u wanna work here do not work here they send ppl home early and tell them to not come in for their shift like how does that make any sense. be professional and considerate of people that you hire or just don't hire them at all... read more

been coming here for awhile, first time coming In around 10pm, service was just rude, sarcastic tone, usually the service is amazing but this time was just embarrassing and so few toppings than usual, guess he was mad I ordered so late. read more

We ordered delivery for an event and could not have been more impressed with the customer service, efficient delivery, and delicious food! Highly recommend this location! read more

The meat pizza, wings were great. But the BACON cinnamon rolls were outstanding! Definitely will be a return customer.

Came when it was empty on a Thursday for spirit night for our school. Unfortunately they were severely understaffed and had no idea what was going on regarding the spirit night. We ordered 4 Mypies and after we placed our order, it was like 50 people walked in and the poor staff- who truly tried their best with what was given to them- were completely overwhelmed. It did take however 30 minutes to get our food and because we were there so early I didn't think it should have taken that long. People who came in after us were getting food before us. Because it was so packed our server didn't have chances to come to us and check in or get us our check, our boxes, our silverware, or food so a lot of that was up to me to go grab those things. With 4 hungry kiddos, it just wasn't a pleasant experience. On a lighter note, I ordered the Pig and Pesto MyPie with Cauliflower crust, and I loved it! The taste was perfect. The cauliflower crust is crunchy, which I happen to like. Think of a thick cracker with toppings. I enjoyed it. read more

Flippers Pizza - Pig and pesto mypie on cauliflower crust - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

The establishment consistently delivers pizzas of exceptional taste. Furthermore, the presence of a location in Lake Mary is a welcome convenience. The staff demonstrates a friendly demeanor, and the service provided is of a high standard. Additionally, their salads are delectable. I have never had an unsatisfactory dining experience at Flippers. On October 9, 2021, I visited the Metro Orlando location and received outstanding service from Jaron. The pizza was of exceptional quality. I encourage the establishment to maintain its high standards of service and culinary offerings. We anticipate returning in the near future. Update: June 5, 2024 My spouse and I revisited the Flippers establishment situated on Grant Street in Orlando and were once again met with exceptional service. Eric Hernandez crafted one of the most delectable pizzas I have ever had the pleasure of consuming. When visiting the Flippers Pizza establishment on Grant Street in Orlando, I highly recommend requesting Eric to prepare your pizza. You will not be disappointed! Furthermore, the establishment exudes a welcoming ambiance and maintains a commendable level of cleanliness. read more

Placed a large order for a graduation party and was very impressed. Pizzas were made exactly as ordered and were delicious. Order was ready on time as promised. Staff was very helpful at pick up. Will definitely be ordering from them again soon especially for large get togethers. read more

The pizza rolls are very good would recommend them . Not too much dough . Pizza crust was crisp OK I will get peppers and peppers, baby girl baby girl. read more

When I ate there recently, I had a great experience. The food tasted amazing like usual and it really felt like the team took their time making the food with love. I definitely felt welcomed in and read more

I'm a delivery driver for Uber Eats and DoorDash. I picked up an order here and it wasn't quite ready, but the staff treated me like royalty and gave me a free drink. After smelling the restaurant, I had to go back and have their food for myself. read more

Flippers Pizza - The restaurant and the sign outside - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

Heading from home on the road and stumbled across this place. The young lady is ver sweet and rather inexperienced but she's trying. The beer is cold which was a bonus for me at the moment. The pizza does take awhile but it's due to it being brick oven so understand. The ingredients were fresh and pizza cooked well. For me and my husband, we were hungry and the pizza was good, but just not a stand out with us. I was kinda torn on three to four stars, but being what seems to be a local business that is trying, we will give it four stars. I would recommend a try but understand there is a wait due to the cooking process. read more

Flippers Pizza - Order counter - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

See all

The staff was so friendly and the food was delicious. The inside was very clean and inviting. Definitely recommend.

Really terrible service. We won't be back again. Server forgot to ring up half our order and just left us sitting there.

The staff was very friendly and the pizza w/wings combo was amazing!! I ate there with a friend and the location was very clean. I would recommend for sure. read more

The pizza was good, better than the "fast food" pizza places but not amazing. The salad was excellent! Fresh and plentiful and just delicious! The garlic knots were very good, my son could not get enough. The best part is the location, you can eat outdoors and walk through the park afterwards. We had a very nice relaxing time and a very good meal with friends! read more

Stopped in for a late night pizza and it was everything a late night pizza experience should be. Great customer service, excellent food, relaxing outdoor seating. Special shout out to Johnny for being a great server! read more

Best pizza in Lake Mary. Sat outside tonight with our dog and enjoyed a great dinner of pizza, salad and wine all perfect. The whole staff was super and efficient. Took excellent care of us. Will be back and recommend it to our friends. Thanks read more

Greasy food, service had to ask for cutlery for each person each time she came back to the table with a salad for each person separately, bathroom was dirty and had to ask for toilet paper which they got frustrated about. Will not waste my money there again!!! The place was loud like a bar but no alcohol better spots to get quality pizza and service. read more

My first flippers experience. The sauce and cheese wasn't bad flavor. The pizza crust was ehh. Its conveniently located right by the Lake Mary farmers market so we were surprised to be the only people in there at 1130am. By the time 1230pm rolled around, every open table was taken. The gluten free mypie was very badly seasoned aka not seasoned. But not many places offer gluten free pizza so it was nice to have the option out. The girl behind the counter was on her phone most of the time and needed my wife to repeat the order 3 times- we only got 3 items. read more

See all

After not so great in person service we decided to try take out since when we ate inside it took an hour to get our food.... At 6:47 pm we put in an order with a process time of 25 minutes. At 7:05 we were called and told they were out of salad so we had it removed leaving one pizza and a calzone. At 7:20 we got to the store and were told it had yet to be started because the ticket wasn't printed out, even though the "tracker" stated the kitchen had it. So both in person and delivery were horrible and will be the last time we will order from this company. read more

This pizza was seriously the best I've had in a long time! We had the Bianca! So delish! The restaurant was clean and the pizza came quick! Good thing because there were four hangry women. Michael was such a delight, you can tell he loves his job read more

Had another tasty triple pepperoni pizza with my little family at Flippers! Thanks to Divine and all the staff for keeping their cool during a power outage and for some great service! read more

The roasted broccoli is to die for!! Omg I cannot explain the deliciousness of it all. Sam was the best server ever! Love her! Highly recommend you won't be disappointed. Be careful sitting outside though ants everywhere. read more

Yummy high quality brick oven pizza! Crust has the perfect soft to crispy ratio, the sauce is seasoned perfectly, and cheese and toppings are the highest quality. I tried a Caesar salad as well with free upgrade to their organic greens. Really really fresh. I will be back. read more

I would offer Zero stars but it's not an option!! We decided to try it again over the weekend, after a previously poor experience. It started with online ordering system, which kept loosing my order and prompting me to start over. I finally got to the end, scheduled a pick up time and paid. I was given a confirmation number, yet when we arrived there, the order was not paid for and it became clear they had no idea what was going on. We paid again, knowing I could reconcile with my bank if double charged. Once home, which was 5 minutes away, we found cold pizza that was missing ingredients and toppings. Overly salty and just poor quality. Here's where it gets interesting. I called in to chat with a manager and when I finished telling him what happened and that based on our two experiences, it was doubtful we would be coming back, his response was, "oh well." He was annoyed, rude and could care less about our experience or trying to make it right. If that's the "manager" and they set the tone, no wonder they have terrible service and issues executing a basic pizza order. If corporate looks at these reviews, roll out some training to this location ASAP! My first time there, I sat in a booth waiting for my pizza only to watch staff members ignoring guests, talking to each other loudly about personal stuff and leaving tables dirty. Not good !! read more

I really liked the pizza, the waitress was kind and food was on perfect time. I will come back! read more