The best New York pizza The antipasto salad yummy yummy We celebrate one of my daughters birthday read more

I used to love Eddie's pizza and used to tell people to go there. However my recent order was rather disappointing. I believe ownership has changed in the recent years. The pizza has changed and is not anywhere close to what it used to be. The quality of pizza was downgraded while the prices went up. I am sad to say I will no longer be recommending to my friends/family until they improve. read more

Eddies Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza (I added Alfredo sauce to the top) - Pizza Near Me - Longwood, Florida

Pizza was good but I expected better from reading the other reviews. The staff were very helpful. X extremely nice. The actual pizza shop is small with limited space. read more

Visited Eddies again to celebrate the hubs birthday and I can't say enough good things about this place. The people are so friendly and welcoming, the service was top notch and the alfredo is the best Alfredo in central Fl. Definitely check this place out if you haven't been! read more

Great food and great service. The sandwiches are amazing. Love the Italian and chicken parm sub. The bread is baked fresh everyday.

The pizza here is AMAZING!! Several reviews said it was authentic NY style pizza. They were not wrong! The cheese was perfect, the crust was the perfect crispness and the sauce, so good! I will be back!! I highly recommend this pizza place!!! read more

My boyfriend took my here for the first time and I love everything about it! The food and the people Everyone was so nice! It was also very clean and smelled absolutely amazing! We had a 16" chicken bacon ranch pizza (I wish I took a picture), the garlic knots, I had a cannoli, and my boyfriend had the tiramisu. Everything was soooo good! Definitely my new favorite place I've also been looking for a good cannoli so when I saw that they had them I was sold lol I actually came back today to get two more cannolis! read more

Eddies Pizza - Cannolis - Pizza Near Me - Longwood, Florida

See all

I've been wanting to try Eddie's based on the reviews and being voted one of the best pizza's in the Orlando area. I ordered a large pepperoni pie and wings on a Friday night. The service over the phone and in person was awesome (hence the two stars). The pizza on the other hand was lackluster and I barely finished a slice. We both agreed it tasted like cardboard and the wings were average. Maybe it was an off night, but with so many other great options in the area, I'll be going somewhere else. read more

Elizabeth at the reception was amazing!!! Loolie made my pizza, OMG. It was made in the authentic and classic brink oven. To die for!!! Well, I want to keep living to be able to eat here again. Hahaha. It's authentic, NYC style. (Yes, I would know, Born and Raised in the Boogie down!) Perfect portion of cheese and sauce. And the dough was toasted to a light mahogany color. Cant make it any more perfect. Thank you both for the experience I had in my mouth. read more

Eddies Pizza - Pizza!!! (Not Pep though). Needed to try their original cheese first. - Pizza Near Me - Longwood, Florida

Eddie's Pizza is your classic American-style Italian quick serve/delivery kind of place. The menu fare is the typical stuff you'd expect - some soups, salads, subs (both hot and cold), pizza, pasta, the strombolis and things like that. But here's the thing with Eddie's - they do all of this stuff really well. As a restaurant, it's really not a sit-and-eat kind of place. It's definitely a spot designed to primarily be take-out. Go in and you'll see. It's the kind of place that uses old cafeteria tables and chairs and uses a lot of the space as storage. So, beautiful it is not. However, the quality of the food and the care that the chefs put into it, is what sets this place apart. Especially considering that it's sort of in this no-mans-land out here on Ronald Reagan Blvd, by the train tracks, somewhere between Longwood and Lake Mary. Add everything up and it's a solid 4 stars. The subs are super good, so my recommendation says start there. read more

Our first time. Friendly staff. Tasty pizza. Toppings were fresh & plentiful. Best around! Complimentary garlic knots were delicious & appreciated. Seamless ordering, delivery, & came when expected. Would definitely return & recommend. read more

This was my first time trying Eddie's and it was a great experience. I was immediately welcomed with friendly smiles and I could tell that they cared about my business as a customer. The food came out fresh and hot and I appreciate that they put a different spin on each item. Although I ordered carry out, there was plenty of seating and the great customer service made it seem like a comfortable environment to sit in. Overall, it was a great experience. I'm glad I got to show this local, down to earth business my support. read more

See all

Amazing Food, had the homemade Garlic Knots and Stromboli. Food was amazing. Service was excellent. Can't wait to go back and try the rest of the menu. Been too many pizzerias in New York City and across the country, this place by far has the best Stromboli I've ever had. Thank you for the reviews that I read on here , it was the reason we stopped in to eat. read more

Was there last night! What a wonderful pizza joint! I live in lake nona and when I come see my mother on Friday nights I like to come to Eddies the pizza is perfect! And for my mom she likes gluten free and it's delicious. Thanks for always making our family's bellies full and happy read more

Hello The Pizza is excellent. Everything is fresh. The owner Lulia & her son Adrian are great. The waitress Elizabeth I think that is her name is very nice. They take great pride in their food & service. So, if you can you will enjoy the food & support a family owned buissnes read more

Stopped in to Eddie's by way of seeing other positive reviews on Yelp. Did not disappoint. The garlic knots were some of the best I've had and the pizza is on point. Great cheese, sauce, and the crust was perfect. Will be back! read more

See all

I have had many pies in te past.This pie i give a low rating.it dad a spicy sauce also pie was not hot must have been precooked,could not eat went to the trash read more

Their pizza is so flavorful, you can tell they use the best ingredients. I absolutely love the crispy crust on their slices(NO FLOP) perfection!!!! If you're looking for some tasty pizza and a hidden gem in Longwood, check them out. The staff there are so friendly and accommodating as well. Never a bad experience at Eddie's read more

Super impressed they make their own ricotta cheese. The crust is delicious. Can't say enough great things about this place. We really enjoyed it. read more

Eddies Pizza - Bianca Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Longwood, Florida

Fabulous pizza. No, really! FABULOUS PIZZA!!!!(screaming so that the folks in back can hear this too). Thin crust, but not too thin, crispy on the bottom but not crunchy, holds its shape when you lift the slice, cheese not too salty (I don't wake up the next morning all puffy in the face from it), toppings are spread evenly, the sauce is not intense...light...like nonna's passata di pomodoro. So, it's not original Italian-style pizza, but if you want Italian, go to Italy {shrug}, but Eddie's is what good NY-style pizza was once upon a time ('cause let's face it, it ain't what it used to be). Every time I'm in the neighbourhood I swing by and get a slice. Last time I got a whole pie all for myself... I wanted to eat it next day too... oh and it tastes awesome cold too. I'm not paid to endorse Eddie's, I just really like pizza, and I know good pizza when I taste it. OK...all this talk of pizza, now I'm hungry for Eddie's pizza again. read more

Pizza is phenomenal! Bruschetta pizza had the perfect amount of toppings with a thin, crisp crust. Staff was friendly and helpful. Great cozy place for comfort and great food. read more

Best pizza in Longwood try to eat here every time we get pizza and it's consistently good. I usually get a half pepperoni and mushroom half cheese and it's consistently good and delicious. The owner is super nice and very grateful for your business. They have many other things on the menu that people say are very good, although I haven't tried them yet. read more

It's been so long since I patronized this place that Eddie ain't crazy * no more, but he's still cooking! He and his wife and two kids, whom you often see in the restaurant, have been a fixture for many-a-year on 427, a hard-working family that only takes one day off a week. I'm glad to see that they have survived the Covid death-grip that's tragically caught a lot of other small businesses. But seeing very little business even on a Saturday night (with no sign of his Porsche Cayenne parked out front) might mean that he is barely hanging on. So I promised myself I'll cook less often after this most recent visit. And on this visit, we just wanted a pizza. We ordered the 16" Philly Cheese steak, which I'd never ordered before here or anywhere. And BTW, unless you're allergic to left-over pizza reheated the next day in the oven, ALWAYS order the largest size available, or at least do the math first. In our case, vs. the 12", it was 75% bigger but only 25% more expensive. The pizza was a little, well, strange. When I got it home 5 minutes later, I noticed a ton of grease seeping to the bottom of the box. Not sure if it's from the cheese or something else. So, when it's TOO greasy like that, I don't care for it as much. As well, a Philly Cheese Steak pizza is about as 'good' and idea as BBQ Chicken pizza. I like PCS, and I like BBQ Chick, just not in a pizza! So, it's not Eddie's fault, as the pie was well made with great ingredients (fresh juicy mushroom and red bell pepper in addition to the onions and steak). So next time, I'll do the meat-lover thing, probably; and if that doesn't work out either, I'll just have to settle for his delicious lasagna! But if you're in the area, go and support this small business, will ya? * The establishment now goes simply by "Eddie's Pizza", losing both the 'Crazy' and 'Grill'. However, Yelp has been slow to catch on - I've alerted them to this new identity, but to date, they have yet to make the change. This is perhaps not inappropriate. Eddie hasn't even changed his FB page identity! read more

Eddies Pizza - Not 'crazy' after all these years... it's just "Eddie's Pizza" now. - Pizza Near Me - Longwood, Florida

See all

I'm not typically one to complain...but...ordered $60 worth of food and was really disappointed. Garlic cheese bread cold and worse than that raw garlic taste. Who in the heck likes raw garlic taste? Stromboli Regular...looked amazing...taste filled with very little cheese and way way to much onions and green peppers. Supreme pizza...same issues very little cheese and way to much onions and peppers! It's a shame because we liked the crust and the sauce This was our first time ordering not sure we will order again. read more

Our group had a wonderful night with delicious food (best pizza I've had in a long time!) and the best hosts ever! Thank you soooo much - we will be back and with more friends! read more

See all

Reasonable price. Solid football pizza. On line ordering could use some charity to reflect the menu. Overall I would order again.

Amazing food Amazing people Been years since I've been here and can't wait to get my food today. read more

Eddie is no longer crazy, just Eddie's Pizza. Extra points for being family owned and operated. The portions are large and the prices small. They'll generally make what you want and the way you want it. read more

See all

Tried Eddies Pizza for the first time today based on Yelp reviews - we'll be back for sure! As described by many, pizza had tasty crunchy bottom crust, delicious toppings (I had small Bianca - friend had slice of Italian sausage). We received an order of 4 garlic knots which were absolutely delicious!! Small salad split perfectly between 2 people. Friendly, wonderful service. We'll be back SOON, don't hesitate to try them! read more

I'm so glad we found this gem on the way back to the airport. The staff was great, very friendly. Ordered the Stromboli it was delicious, spaghetti and meatball were also great. Our server took the time to wrap my leftovers in foil and bag so I could take it to the airport. Will definitely be making this a go-to when in town. read more

Eddies Pizza - Small Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Longwood, Florida

Everything they make is delicious. The owners are also very nice and have excellent customer service.

Family owned Great guy and pizza Amazing service This is why you choose Eddies over all else!! Makes it special and personal for everyone Brooklyn style pizza right here in longwood They make everything from scratch! From meatballs to bread! read more

See all

This place is GREAT! So happy I finally found a place in the area that has excellent NY style Pizza. The wings are excellent too.

Amazing Pizza and friendly owners! They always give us extr garlic knots and the pizza is always hot and tasty. They do not skim on the topping either! Thank you read more

Eddies Pizza - Pineapple Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Longwood, Florida

See all

I've eaten here when it was the original owner and now had my first pie under the new owners. I actually prefer a thinner crust and I really liked my pie. I'm 100% coming back. read more

EXCEPTIONAL food and OUTSTANDING service! Antipasto salad was fresh and their BIANCA pizza was DELICIOUS!!! I highly recommend Eddie's Pizza 10/10! read more

The pizza was absolutely amazing! The ricotta was so fresh and delicious. I am also going to note that this was for takeout and we were running behind, and they were absolutely wonderful. He gave us ideas and tips on how to heat up the pizza when we brought it home and it was, just delicious! We will definitely be back to try out more pizza! read more

High quality ingredients make great food. Service is always amazing and I appreciate how fast they remembered me after I'd come in a couple times. read more

Picked up two pies for family pizza night. This place knows how to do NY style! Will be back for more!

Pizza was good. Cannoli were filled - not hollow in the middle . Will definitely be back!