Five star pizza is definitely not five stars. (A two at best.) I bought a large pizza( that only had 10 slices and it wasn't even big) and some wings and the total was 65 dollars! So I was expecting a good meal. The pizza wasn't appealing to the eye and wasn't very appetizing to eat. I would not recommend you to come here. read more

Loved this place hot fresh pizza. Awesome cheesecakes!!! Would recommend. Will come back here. read more

Definitely lives up to its name! 5 stars! Always enjoy coming here while in town for Magic Week.

Great pizza, subs, even the homemade new York style cheese cake. GOOD SERVICE & small quiet dining area.

Best pizza in colon. fast food, and it's delicious every time. very quick to arrive and nice people working there. ive never been inside so i dont know about the ambiance. all i know is its a great place to go for pizza night. read more

Saying it's the best pizza in town doesn't really do it justice (as it's the only pizza in town), but here's a better indication of the quality: we're from Chicago and drive the three hours to eat here. They have all kinds of fun twists on regular pies; my favorite for years has been the taco pizza, but this time I took a more traditional route and honestly their plain cheese or pepperoni just can't be beat. They also have salads and sandwiches to choose from, and several different desserts. Their customer service is awesome, and the employees are so kind. Highly, *highly* recommend this place, and we'll definitely be back! read more

Five Star Pizza - Taco pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Colon, Michigan

Good service, Good food, Good atmosphere, I never had a bad experience here!! I have only been to the Colon 5 Star Pizza.

We are here (all 14 of us) on one of the lakes for our summer va-ca. Arrived last night and didn't want to cook so we ordered. Polite staff, good value for what we paid, good pizza. BBQ, pepperoni, cheese, and breadsticks. Loved them all and they heated up very well for lunch today. read more

Good pizza for the price, nice service, and would definitely eat it again when in the area!

By far the best pizza in town! Whenever we are in the area we always visit with friends and have a great meal at Five Star Pizza. The staff is always helpful and friendly. Not only is the pizza amazing but the salads and sandwiches add to the variety available ... there's something for everyone in the family! With so many other options for lunch and dinner, we always go straight to Five Star! read more

Five Star Pizza - a man standing on top of a yellow car - Pizza Near Me - Colon, Michigan

I recently purchased a home in Colon and tried five star pizza for the very first time last weekend. Pizza was great, service was friendly. Will definitely order from them again! read more

We got a medium pizza at Five Star Pizza while vacationing in Colon. The pizza was reasonably priced and sized for what it cost. It was hot, flavorful, and not too greasy. Overall a great stop to get a bite. read more

If you have to get pizza from here make sure you ask them to put cheese on it. Ordered a large Ultra (basically everything) and the dessert pizza and two slices of cheesecake. Over $50. Get it home and there's no cheese on the pizza. All the toppings basically rolled off when you try to pick up an over cooked crust. The dessert pizza was fair. Mostly crust with very little icing and it also pooled in the middle. The local brand cheesecakes were very good. They do freeze them so it's not entirely fresh. But that was the best part of the meal. Staff was friendly. Hoping this was just an oversight. read more

If you enjoy a pool of grease and all of the toppings falling off your pizza then this is the spot! Terrible pizza and over priced.

Field Dispatch - Camp Colon - 2010 When people "from outside The Company" think of "us," they may know about "The Farm" as a tough training place, but those "outsiders" never think that we, too, need some R&R - aside from the "covers" that give us Ann Arbor in the sweltering summer and Marrakesh as "a rug dealer" (hard to believe, but that cover is still in the top 5!! What would Professor Dai think . . . ) Anyway, Camp Colon does exist, and the place is populated by ex "us" people who know a thing or two about a thing or two! Carl at Five Star is one such person. The place fits so totally into the "town," that even seasoned "professionals" think it is JUST a pizza place. Well, the truth is that it is one of the BEST pizza places in the world - at least on the 5 continents that I have "done business" on - and your cover is NEVER jeopardized. In fact, Carl (not his REAL name, but the name his "retirement cover" guys at The Farm gave him) is about the most affable and friendly owner operators you could ever meet. NO ONE would believe the "work" he did in Yemen or with "The pip squeak" in North K -- all past, best not to ask. The pizza is remarkable. The subs are filling, even the "half subs" (I chuckle when I think about how Carl came up with that name -- just suffice it to say that The Hunt for Red October has more than a whiff of meatballs or mozzarella to it . . . !) I am not sure about the bread. I WAS sure that the "Formula 18" was NOT to be taken off The Farm, but the subs and crust that Carl serves up has all the sensual joy that "Miss Betty" used to pack into her "special treats" for the Libyans, the K. Rouge, and those "bread mavens" who led their own people into ruin. Obviously, the "extra ingredient" is NOT there in Camp Colon, but the craving you will have to have MORE of these sub rolls and crust is just like "Miss Betty" planned it! All the taste of heaven . . . without "Momma's little extra . . .!" The pizzas are what pizza should be and so rarely are. Plenty of toppings that are fresh and tasty, crust that is -- like I said, All the taste of heaven -- and a price that will cause confusion. How can he remain in business with all this value he provides at the "reasonable to the point of head scratching" prices? Well, as we all who had trained at The Farm and who took "Doc Adam's" course in financial affairs know, there are investments and there are "investments." In any case, Carl has the latter as his prices serve to save the rest of us enough to make our own "investments." Word to the wise, visit the Tip Jar for the women who help Carl -- They MAY be interns, and we do NOT want to disappoint interns in our business, do we?? So, there will be another Dispatch from Camp Colon on another eatery not owned by "a retired one of us," but this Dispatch has but one purpose. If you want the best pizza or sub at the best price -- take a detour and go to Colon. Ask for Carl, tell him you know Paul from GR, and you will be convinced that we "take care of our own." Paul C read more

If i could this pizza a 1 star review i would. I drove 17 hours from NYC to try this 5 star pizza. I've had a homeless man defecate on the worst pizza in NY and it was still better than this Bread Bowl Grease Soup. 0/10 will not return read more

I'm not trying to be funny by giving Five Star Pizza Five Stars, but I have been eating their pizza for about 30 years now, which is most of my life, and its pretty delicious. I like mine extra crispy and they will pull it out of the oven to show you and ask if its how you want it, and if its not, then they will toss it back in for you. The staff was very pleasant, as I went twice in the past week. They were polite over and phone and in person. The place has definitely got an old feel and look as the building is very, very old. Hard wood floors and lots of old pictures and such. They have freshly baked cakes too, so, five stars for Five Star! read more

Simply the best pizza in town period! Always good and have never had a bad one there! Ask them about the "hidden room."

Great pizza place!!! The food tastes great as always and I'm always wanting more! The people that work there can be a little cranky at times, and rude. But I believe that the pizza is what we go there for, the taste of it always pulls us back! read more

Super yummy pizza at 5 Star. Have not had a bad pizza, yet from them. Carl is very accommodating, especially during magic week when he stays open almost 24 hours a day!! Great prices, too! I have not tried their dessert pizzas, but they do look yummy! read more

The pizza use to be really consistently good! These days you don't know what exactly gonna get. You could either get a perfectly cooked pizza that's very tasty, or a pizza that's under done and doughy that the toppings wont stay on when you lift up the pieces. They also do a poor job at cutting them I always have to get out Tue pizza cutter. Although I would say it's still the best pizza in town read more

Great for the price. Ultra special without bacon or ground beef was perfecto

Some of the best pizza around here! My family loves to get pizza at Five Star and the customer service is always wonderful. So happy that they are so close! read more