I truly LOVE this place! Being from NYC I grew up eating really really good pizza. I had been craving it for a long while. So excited that I refound this pizza joint. It used to be owned by 2 NY brothers. They owned the place for over 30 years. They sold it and one brother, Angelo stayed on to train Sam how to bake. Well both Angelo as a teacher and Sam as a student did GREAT! The pizza is truly one of the best in South Florida. Sam's daughter has been our waitress and she is sweet, kind and attentive. The ambiance is cosy and comfortable. Prices are reasonable and you definitely will not be disappointed. Give them a try! read more

Awesome place owner greeted me came out like wow that was old fashion places don't do that anymore that showed me how good the food was gunna be and then i took the first bite and wow just wow best by pizza in Florida ! The place was spotless clean and that shows me what i need it gave my food more enjoyable. The ambiance was just so great how well kept and decorated it was read more

Firefly Italian Restaurant - Clean tables, great smells - Italian Near Me - Cooper City, Florida

I've been wanting to try their pizza and finally got the chance. We ordered the XL Margherita Pizza, a Personal Pizza - Cheese and Dozen Garlic Rolls. There was a little wait beyond the time we were quoted but they explained that the pizzaiolo started making a large pizza when he realized we ordered XL and had to remake it. There was a party of 3 and a solo diner dining in with a couple of people walking in for take out orders. While I was waiting, the party of 3 each got a small plate of garlic rolls and a small salad which looked appetizing. Our order was completed and was brought out to us with an apology for the delay. It smelled so good in the car on the way home! The XL Margherita Pizza box was so large, I had to tilt it a little just to get it in the front seat of my car. In hindsight I should have put it in the back of my SUV. When I opened the box at home, the cheese had run a little to one side. No fault of the restaurant. The crust on the Margherita Pizza was amazing! You could see the layers when you bit into it. It was very crispy. The garlic rolls were garlicky (in a good way) but a little dry. I'm not sure if they can make them saucy but will ask the next time we place an order. My husband had some of the Personal Pizza which, by the way, was almost the size of a small pizza! He said it was also very good. I'm glad we tried this and will definitely be ordering from here again. read more

See all

We have 5 dishes and everything we're all absolutely delicious! Definitely going back again! Service was wonderful, manager was very helpful! Ambiance was peaceful! This is my new favorite Italian restaurant! read more

Firefly Italian Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Cooper City, Florida

This place was such a pleasant surprise! Hands down, one of the best Italian spots I've visited locally. We ended up at Firefly when our usual Italian restaurant was closed, and it did not disappoint. From the moment we walked in, the staff was so friendly and welcoming, and we loved being able to pick our own table. The atmosphere is cozy and has that authentic homestyle Italian feel. We had the lasagna and chicken marsala, both of which were amazing. The meals came with freshly baked bread (crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside with delicious garlic butter) and a choice of soup or salad -- the minestrone was packed with flavor! You can really taste that everything is made from scratch, and the portions are generous. If you're craving classic Italian food that's comforting and delicious, definitely give Firefly a try. HIGHLY RECOMMEND ! read more

Firefly Italian Restaurant - Chicken Marsala - Italian Near Me - Cooper City, Florida

See all

Excellent real Italian food Take out is great portions are family size No frills fantastic food Everything is homemade so don't come in ravenous. You have to wait a while, but it's worth it. read more

I did a takeout order, the wings are great! The server was very nice and it was an overall nice experience.

Service was great , the food came out pretty quick maybe because it was Saturday afternoon and not too busy. Will definitely come back. read more

See all

Stopped in on Mother's Day, as I had eaten here before the new ownership & always loved their pizza. I had since moved out of state but my mom is still in town and told me she's been since new ownership & remains a place she recommends. Prices are fair & the pizza is still yummy; we got a large pie half pepperoni half cheese. The customer service was great, the young gentleman that waited on our table was polite, and I think he is the owner, seemed pleasant when taking away our plates & bringing boxes out. Even the clients that I observed coming in to either dine in or pick up were super pleasant; I was like am I still in Florida LOL! read more

Their food is amazing. Have ordered multiple times and every single dish has been great.

Decided to try a new place on Superbowl Sunday. Was further than my usual place but reviews persuaded me. The food was actually good but unfortunately, the first time experience was a bit aggravating. I placed an online order for 6:15 pick up 70mins in advance. Arrived at 6:13 to store with several customers waiting on their orders. I was told order was not ready and they were behind. Watched as another customer placed an order and was told 40min wait. Heard worker explain the reason for delays on online orders was that their POS Toast does not notify them of the order until 10min prior to pick up time and that they cannot control the wait time displayed online. Didn't really like hearing that "excuse" as it sounded more like user error. Finally, received my order at 6:57. While waiting, the same guy at the front asked me what order I was waiting on twice, so I didn't feel confident he knew what he was doing or if they even had my order. After like 30 minutes, a manager (perhaps) noticed I've been there for a while and started looking into it. Me and another woman were literally the last two orders. He apologized for the wait and offered us a can of soda each. Would have rathered my food on time but acknowledged and appreciated the gesture. As for the food, we got a pepperoni and a white pizza. It was not as thin as I expected for a NY style pie but baked well. The white has a lot of ricotta (?). Mixed feelings about the blobs because they were kind of bland but also balanced out the grease. Pricing was decent. Would be willing to go back at a a later date to give it another go if I was in the neighborhood. read more

We stopped here after our cruise as we were staying in the area and after visiting the flamingo refuge nearby we needed something to eat. The establishment is rather small but has a lot to offer with great customer service and excellent pizza. We ordered the chicken bacon ranch pizza, my wife, kids, and myself all agreed it may have been one of our favorite pizza experiences on this vacation. Highly recommend their food! read more

Great service and phenomenal food! We had the chicken Alfredo, spaghetti bolognese and cheese and pepperoni pizza. Best pizza in Cooper City and the garlic knots were perfect. It's our new Italian spot! read more

Friendly service and great pizza! Plenty of parking since it's located in a shopping plaza. Will be back to try one if their Italian Entrees read more

The food is delicious. The service is friendly and the ambiance is cozy. Had the chicken parm and it was cheesy goodness. Don't change a thing!! read more

Excellent restaurant in Cooper City. Came based on a Facebook post and let me tell you it was great. The meal portions are huge, the garlic rolls are delicious, the house salad yumm and the Chicken Parmigiana, Eggplant Parmigiana and Eggplant Rotellini were are delicious. A must try. Can't wait to try their subs soon read more

See all

The best! Looking at locally owned mom and pop places and picked this one based on great reviews. We ordered the medium chicken bacon ranch well done. I'm not kidding this pizza was a melting pot in your mouth. It reminded me of my favorite, richest, loaded Alfredo. We are from Wisconsin- home of Cheese. Best freshest pizza ever!! And our server was amazing too!! read more

Firefly Italian Restaurant - Chicken bacon ranch. Meatiest tastiest cheeziest pizza ever!!! - Italian Near Me - Cooper City, Florida

Amazing food and nice service ! The restaurant is clean and I loved their chicken tandoori pizza. It is different pizza than the usual but I enjoyed it! Their cheese and pepperoni are also good quality so I will be coming back! read more

Firefly Italian Restaurant - Chicken M Tandoori Chicken Pizza - Italian Near Me - Cooper City, Florida

More than a year ago, we found this"new " pizzeria. They make pizza the way I like pizza. Thick crust, thick cheese. I drive twenty minutes past three local pizzerias to get to this one. read more

Food was fresh. The portions were big and the staff was super friendly. I recommend to get the chicken parm!

Great food, great selections great portions, great service, nice atmosphere and superb NY pizza best anywhere. One of my favorites! My wife loves it too! read more

We are so happy to have picked this spot for dinner tonight. My son really wanted spaghetti so I started to look at Italian spots near our house. We noticed Firefly opened recently and decided to give it a try. Everything was delicious!!!! My son loved the spaghetti so much. He asked me to bring him 100 more times. We also tried the meatballs... outstanding flavor!!! My husband ordered the chicken wings, a slice of cheese pizza and Alfredo pasta. I tried a bit of it all as well. Everything had amazing taste. We were all so happy with our experience. Plus delicious red wine. Highly recommend adding this to your Italian dinner rotations!! Thanks for a great dinner, friendly service, and we will be back! read more

Firefly Italian Restaurant - Minestrone Soup! Delicious and very savory!! - Italian Near Me - Cooper City, Florida

See all

Excellent food and excellent service been there quite a few times always left happy the pizza is phenomenal and when reheated at home is super crispy highly recommend read more

This spot, formerly known as Alfredo's, has a charm all its own once you walk through the door. The staff were extremely friendly as well. They still boast the same pizza from Alfredo's, but I personally feel the crust wasn't quite right (maybe a tad too thick). Their prices are also still reminiscent of Alfredo's, as they offer an 18" pizza at $18, and several family meal deals. They offered me a homemade watermelon mint refresher sample, which was delicious. I just love the interior overhaul this place received under new ownership - it could be a great little date night spot now. read more

See all

Definitely not a New York pizza. I was served my food with no drink. I literally had to ask for water. So no good food and then bad service too ‍ read more

Great little pizza place. Good tasting pizza. Mark was a great server and all the staff was very friendly. Recommend to pizza lovers.

Excellent food and service. Been here a few times. Chicken parm sub is fantastic. Eggplant Rollatini. Garlic rolls included and side salad with all entrees. read more

Firefly Italian Restaurant - Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Cooper City, Florida

See all

Wow. What a hidden gem. The pizza was phenomenal! Our server was Issie. She was so warm and personable. Made us feel right at home. We will be back. Great place! read more

We had great service and the lasagna, pepperoni pizza and garlic knots were delicious. We will definitely be back. read more

Great date night dinner! The service was excellent, the pastas were delicious and big portions, and the tiramisu was homemade and literal icing on the cake :) read more

The pizza is AMAZING. The family combo is such a great value, my husband and I get it and have leftovers for later. It's hard to get decent pasta that isn't drowning in grease but Firefly delivers Also the service is top notch! They have the sweetest lady who served us and the guy was so attentive, they both did a fantastic job in providing excellent service. My husband and I were in Italian restaurants for over 10 years so we can be a little critical sometimes, but I have zero complaints for firefly. read more

I ordered the Alfredo's 5 topping pizza with a thin crust for pick up. When I went inside the pizza was not finished and after paying the owner brought the pizza out to the car. The owner said I will enjoy the pizza and I absolutely did. I have picked up 3 pizzas here before and they were all great. I will be returning to try some additional items. read more

Firefly Italian Restaurant - 5 item slice of pizza - Italian Near Me - Cooper City, Florida

See all

Firefly is a hidden gem in Cooper City at the South end of the Walmart Plaza on Griffin and Flamingo road. We had minestrone soup, excellent flavor and spices with chunky veggies. The garlic rolls were soft and fresh. We tried chicken wing appetizer 1/2 with Buffalo and Firefly Sweet Chili sauce . Excellent! Then a meat lasagne and eggplant rigatoni for the main course. Both incredibly tasty fresh ingredients! We took 1/2 home. Can't wait to have later! In addition, Alfredo , the former owner of Alfredo's is there part time to continue preparing many other excellent chef dishes! read more

Best italian food in Cooper City. Big portions, reasonable prices. Best garlic rolls.

The pizza is really good and the staff is top of the line. Nice little corner spot and away from any hectic shoppers.

Amazing pizza. Great service. Super clean and nice ambiance too. The location is perfect for me too.

We're from out of town and was looking for pizza close to where we were staying, we saw they had good reviews and ordered online. The pizza was delivered in a timely manner and was really good. read more

FOOD - not many photos but i was delighted that everything i tried garlic knots pepperoni pizza and chicken parm were AMAZING literally hit the spot for some good italian american food SERVICE - service was amazing everyone was very attentive and nice the pricing for everything was very reasonable!!!! your able to get a good rounded meal for under 20 dollars per person and the portions are amazing! ** wish i was able to attach a good photo but we cleared all of our plates read more

The best NY slice for 5 miles around, and that includes Steve's and Joe's. Try the lunch special, you will not be disappointed.

The waitress didn't understand the orders. We had to each say what we wanted multiple times before she understood. The food that was served while we were there was not very good. The pasta fagioli was very spicy. There was no broth. It was mostly overcooked pasta and some red sauce. My family ate some of what they ordered but had to wait because each meal came out with about 5 minutes between them. They were not happy with their meals since they had no taste and only ate a little of each one. There was 4 of us and the there were only 6 other patrons, but for some reason it took an hour for my chicken parm sub to be made. I ended up taking it to go. Tried it when I got home and there were only 2 very small pieces of chicken with a bunch of sauce that made the bread soggy. Tried a couple of bites and then threw it out since it was not good. Will not be going back there read more