Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fire and Slice Pizza

    3.9 (45 reviews)
    Closed 7:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Fire and Slice Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Fire and Slice Pizza

    Recommended Reviews - Fire and Slice Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Slice of pizza

    Not the same Fire and Slice! I have been a customer at all 3 locations in Eureka, but I must say the quality now 08/29/24 is more miss than hit these days. The Hit: The mango habanero bone-in wings are great, just enough heat and sweetness to win over the most staunch wing connoisseur. The house salad with fresh veggies and wonderfully pickled beets were a treat for the eyes and pallette. The mozzarella sticks well are mozzarella sticks. They were perfectly cooked, crunchy and unbroken with the ooze of the cheese. The Miss: The cheese pizza with red sauce is usually a solid hit for the traditional pizza lovers. Usually the pizzas are cooked a bit light, but that is something for a dicernable connoisseur to fret over and easily fixed at home with 10 extra minutes in the oven. However I degress, it was requested to cook this pizza a bit extra, but it arrived and appeared near undone. The cheese texture is HORRIBLE, no matter how long it was reheated, the cheese never seemed to melt, and had a very bitter/sour taste. The cheese bread cheese was overall better but the over-saturation of garlic and garlic salt rendered the cheese bread bitter, horribly salty and unappealing. The red dipping sauce usually offsets the saltiness and bitterness however, the sauce appears to have been downgraded as well. The red dipping sauce tasted as if it were just poured out of a can and served. The tomato and bitterness shown through the red sauce as well. One last minor miss which hurt the otherwise spectacular wings was the ranch dipping sauce or lack there of! This may seem like a minor quip for many, but the offset texture of ranch against spicy, sweet crunchy wings is a thing of beauty, but to run out after 4 wings is a bit much. It is not an over indulgence on my part over a half serving of ranch in the cup, literally half, which woefully denies the complexity of tastes too their full virtue. So 2 stars, this order feels as though Fire and Slices standards have fallen a bit to far for today's competition and price points. Attached is a picture of the pizza after it was cooked a bit longer, even extra and you can see the cheese problem I spoke about in the review. UPDATE: The manager has informed us of a temporary distribution issue they are currently experiencing. Today's pizza was made with a substitute cheese from the distribution center due to the center running out if their regular cheese. We have been credited with a pizza gift card which will replace the cheese knockoff. The manager was very pleasent and we will try the pizza again in 2 weeks. Updated from 2 star to 3 stars for making transaction change.

    We ordered a regular cheese pizza from them and this is what we got.

    We ordered a cheese pizza from them. Keep in mind...20 dollars for a pizza now and you would think they would make it worth it. The cheese was clumpy and not melted at all. We put it on a pan to warm it up in the oven. Overall very disappointed.

    Cheese pizza

    The food is awesome. It's worth coming and checking out. The price was very reasonable. I can't wait to come back again.

    Chicken Outback
    Heidi M.

    The outdoor seating is so much fun! My family loved the games they have to play while we waited for our food. The crust on their cheesy bread and pizza was nice and soft and had great flavor! We also tried the wings and the chicken was nice and Tender, but the breading was a bit thick.

    Supreme pizza

    See all

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    We had the supreme pizza and wings... very impressed with this little pizza joint, it was better than expected!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Really good, fresh flavorful pizza. Gorgeous salads. Friendly service. Good prices. Love this place!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Fire and Slice Pizza

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Blackstar Brewery - Bavarian Pretzel

    Blackstar Brewery

    4.1(235 reviews)
    47.4 mi
    $$

    Some of the best food in the valley. Jeremiah Johnson beer is no joke. I love the shift back to the…read morename Blackstar for us locals. My favorite is the Vanilla Porter. I also enjoy most anything else. You can not go wrong on their beer. Solid choices. I would say Blackstar has one of the best if not best burgers in the valley. The pizza sandwiches when they have them are excellent. My kids love the pizza and I do too. The chicken sandwich is also a solid hit. You will go up the line to order or use the QR code at the table to order. Some things come out sooner than others but the runner do a good job of getting what you need. The second floor is a great spot to hang especially in the summer the mid level tap bar is open. The best is the top floor and deck. It's a hidden gem.

    Lunch at Blackstar Brewery in Whitefish, MT. Let me just cut to the chase. Lunch was excellent!…read more It's a modern brew pub with a big menu. It has three levels, 1st and 2nd floors with a roof top. You pick a table and order from the bar giving them your table number or or from the table using a QR code. We each ordered a beer. I chose the Hazy Pale Ale and was happy with my choice. Then we ordered a Bavarian Pretzel for the table and it was OUTSTANDING! We each ordered the Cowboy Chicken Sandwich and it was excellent. The sandwich comes with char-grilled chicken breast, southern coleslaw, tangy BBQ sauce, pickled red onion, ob a potato bun. It was excellent. Blackstar is a fun venue with a wide variety of menu items. The food was excellent and the prices what you'd expect.

    Photos
    Blackstar Brewery - Big screen

    Big screen

    Blackstar Brewery - Smash burger

    Smash burger

    Blackstar Brewery - Mexican Lager beer

    See all

    Mexican Lager beer

    Fire and Slice Pizza - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...