Relentlessly hard, hot hike with very rough trail terrain, overrated views, and little shade.
I'm not sure why so many people give this trail such positive reviews. I thought it was the very least desirable hike I've ever done in the Tucson area, and I've been here 45 years. I've hiked many other similar trails in the Santa Catalinas, including Pima Canyon, Ventana Canyon, Esperero, Bear Canyon. I've also hiked Mica, the back way up Rincon Peak, Agua Caliente, Picacho, Chiricahua Peak, the Superstitions, Mt Wrightson, Wasson Peak, etc. Heck, I've hiked the entire John Muir Trail! Every one of them had a nice mix of steep and level, ups and downs. They all had significant stretches of well beaten down soil or sandy trails that made for reasonably easy walking, at least at times. But Finger Rock Trail to Mt Kimball is a really harsh, unpleasant trail. 90% of the time you're clammoring over boulders or dealing with loose, slippery rock. I can't count how many times you have to stop and step up or down at least a height of 2-3 feet to get up or down over a big rock in the trail. Over the whole distance, there are only about two short portions that were comfortable to hike on. Everything else (aside from the lowest entry portion) was relentlessly uphill, dry, and rocky, and this also made it tricky on the descent.
I didn't see a drop of surface water and very little wildlife.
I'm a good, experienced hiker and in good shape. I usually pass lots of other hikers on trails, and almost never get passed. I also have ridden 100+ miles in El Tour de Tucson multiple times, I play basketball, etc. Point is, I'm in good shape and experienced. Not a novice and not in bad hiking shape. It took me 4 hours up (with lots of short pauses to let my heart rate slow back down from the pounding, and to wipe the ample sweat from my head) and 3 hours back down, watching my steps so I didn't break an ankle or fall. Grabbing a few downed sticks as poles helped with balance on the descent, especially for all those slippery, big steps down over boulders.
Look, I believe commenters when they say they have done it much faster, and I commend them. But I found this hike to be the least enjoyable I've ever done in Southern Arizona. Period. A 10-mile round trip hike would normally take me more like 4-5 hours, not 7. This trail sucks, in slope and trail condition. There are lots of shin daggers and an upper section with many thorn bushes.
To make matters worse, the trail markings and signage are awful. I probably built 5 new cairns in various spots to help future hikers. At the junction with the Pima Canyon trail up on the ridge, there is zero indication of which trail to take to Mt Kimball, for anyone without a map. And no distances at all. Then at the top, there is no indication of a summit, and poor views. I could not find where the trail continues to Pima Canyon at all. There was one spot where you could look out over Oro Valley and another facing Mt. Lemmon, and Biosphere II in the distance. No view back toward Tucson or the Rincons from the top of Mt. Kimball. At least none that I saw.
The only highlight was seeing thousands of ladybugs all over the logs and tree trunks at the peak. And I enjoyed having the trail 100% to myself all the way down to the parking lot.
Much lower, there's a hairpin turn with a short, unmarked spur trail to an overlook with the best view of the hike. But it is not labeled with any signage either.
It was an unusually hot day for early October, but I took tons of water and ate along the way. That's not why it was a crappy experience.
I was not impressed by the views compared with many other area hikes. Yes, there were a few spots with great views, but that was limited.
After reading all the positive reviews, I find myself questioning whether I've turned into a wimp in my old (49) age or if people are just trying to put on an aire of bravado by saying how much they love this hike. Maybe some didn't do the whole thing, or they did it in cooler weather, or are just in better hiking shape.
I thought it was awful. read more