Outstanding. Everything was on point. A must try, but don't act like an American. We noticed…read moreseveral tables of Americans who were rude in my estimation...the attitude...with one women making awful faces because she felt her steak had grizzle when the waiter asked why she did not finish. It was not grizzle...it was fat...delicious fat...your in Italy eating the best beef....I could not believe how classless she was. I am American so I feel I can judge just a bit here. A must try is the steak with leek sauce and the pasta with beef sauce...fantastic and of course the wine pairings were exceptional...I asked the waiter to pair for me and it did not disappoint. If I could give more stars I would!

Great rooftop bar. The food was not fancy, but it was very tasty. Drinks were good and people were…read morefriendly. Good service. Great view of Florence.

5 stars for service and ambiance. 4 stars for food. We were in town for the day and looking for a…read morelunch spot. Many restaurants were booked or told us that there'd be a long wait. This restaurant was full outside, but we were told a table would be available in 10 minutes. Another couple arrived and tried to take our table, but staff informed them we were next. Our server spoke English well and was professional and helpful. The house wine was good. The pear/cheese souffle didn't have much of a pear flavor, but it was cheesy and delicious. The pork with pistachio pesto was also delicious and came with tasty rice, but seemed a little overcooked. My partner enjoyed the grilled shrimp salad. I thought it was a little fishy. Note: they claimed their credit card machine was down and we had to pay in cash. FYI there just happens to be an ATM next to the seating atea.

We had such a great time at this restaurant that we ate here twice. My husband had the steak both…read moretimes because it was so good and inexpensive. My favorite dish was the gnocchi with shrimp and artichoke. The wait staff was very friendly and fun. All together a great experience.

Ristorante Cacciatore is off the main square - on Villa Roma. Excellent meal and service.read more

I thought I should provide a review, to balance off the otherwise glowing reviews presently posted…read more We had an Ok dinner, but it was not exceptional, and this is not a restaurant to seek out, unless our experience was atypical. The quality of ingredients was probably the best feature, though still less than remarkable. The cooking was the low point, with the meat platter Main being a real disappointment: overcooked, almost flavourless game, chicken and pork. The service was good, while ambience is again, nothing special. I don't like being a Debbie Downer in amongst the mostly rave reviews, but I feel compelled to comment, for a more balanced consideration.

We enjoyed our dinner so much that we returned the next night. We had the steak with a bottle of…read moreSangiovese, the first wine on the menu. It was perfect. The ambiance is beautiful. The first night we sat inside to enjoy the air conditioning, and the second night we sat outside. It felt more special and unique inside. The Syrah that we ordered the second night was disappointing. It upset both our stomachs and gave us headaches, we could not enjoy the food. I drink red wine all the time and rarely does it give me a headache. That's why I am giving four stars instead of five.

Always our first meal when arriving in Cortona. always have pasta with truffles. always have house…read morewine. what can I say? if it ain't broke, don't fix it!

Great restaurant! The food is divine and the wine list is fantastic. The waitstaff is very friendly…read moreand helpful. We loved the setting, just perfect. Definitely will go back when we return to Cortona! Do not miss this gem!

Good service and nice wine recommendation. 6 adults traveling together, 4 ordered the ravioli dish…read morethat came recommended. While they were pleased with that recommendation, they were not overwhelmed by their choice. However, the 'trio of soups' did get rave reviews. My wife had the chef's special (steak with foie gras and truffles) and she was very pleased. I also ordered steak and I really liked my choice. In the end, our time at Osteria del Teatro (the meal, the service, the ambience) warrants a 4-star rating.

First night's dinner in Cortona. This is our top pick in this wonderful town. Ravioli with butter…read moreand sage. Carpaccio. Sausage. Spinach. All delicious. And of course house wine. Again notice the tablecloth... paper but looks and feels like cloth. This was also our choice for dinner our last night. Ribolito, orange fennel salad, crostini with Gorgonzola and walnuts, crostini with prosciutto and anchovies, and wine. Perfect! Enzo and Sara are lovely hosts and take great pride in treating their guests like family. I recommend reservations as they get very busy. We eat early which is why there are empty tables.

This is the best food I've ever had in my entire life. When I die, I will be thinking of this meal…read more 5 stars is not enough. God has blessed the family that cooks the food here!

WOW! If you want to feel warm and welcomed then you must go visit Emma, at Bar 500. Her…read morerestaurant is in the heart of downtown Cortona and offers inside and outside seating. Her restaurant is quaint, charming, and cozy. Emma will treat you like one of her family. My wife and I found her one night while she was closing and asked if we could get dessert and coffee to go. She could have said "no" very easily but instead welcomed us and prepared two hot coffees with cookies and a tart to go. We liked her so much, we made reservations for dinner the next night before we walked out. OBTW, the coffee and desserts were fresh and tasty. Our dinner and service the next evening was great. Emma and her associate do everything. They seat you, hand out the menu, take your order, cook and serve you the food, and then bus the tables. All along the way, you get to talk with Emma. My wife and I had salads to begin our meal and then pasta dishes with ragu. Our meals were cooked fresh, served hot, and the portions were generous. If you looked around, all of her customers were laughing, smiling, and enjoying themselves. The prices were very reasonable considering her location. Emma has quite a selection of tasty and fresh desserts, especially the cookies with the chocolate strip. There are plenty of options in Cortona but if you want to feel like you are entering into someone's home, go visit Emma. You will not be disappointed. Don't forget to make that reservation because you will need it!

The breakfast here is delicious. The eggs are cooked perfectly and comes with cappuccino and orange…read morejuice. The eggs were our favorite in town. My husband also enjoyed the pancakes.

Pizza was amazing, server was welcoming and attentive and wanted our business. Dined outdoors which…read morewas perfect on a beautiful Tuscan evening.

Pizza was the best we have had in Italy. Good service, outdoor area that was very comfortable for…read moredinner at 9:30 pm. One of our group ordered a burger and gave it a thumbs up. Funny name - good food that was reasonably priced.

It was the perfect place for my slightly homesick grandchildren. Everything they wanted with a…read moredistinctly Cortona flair.

Best burger and fries combo my wife and I have ever had!!! We've eaten at many burger places in our…read morehome area of Seattle but have never had a place where both the burger and fries were the very best. The funny thing is that we wanted Italian food but all of those places were closed and our only good option was this place. Although we really enjoyed the Italian cuisine in Cortona, we're so glad we found this place. The server was very accommodating to my wife's soy allergy and made sure it wasn't in any of the food, especially the mayo as it often is. This place makes their own tasty mayo. Most burger places have either a great hamburger and okay fries or great fries and an okay burger. But it's very rare to find the perfect combo like here. We know it sounds crazy but if you're an American and accustomed to good burgers, give this place a try. You might be surprised that it's the best you've ever had! PS - to top off a great trip to Cortona, I got to meet and get a picture taken with Jovanotti, my favorite Italian singer!!!

With so many Michelin star choices in Cortona we chose this as our last meal in Cortona. You walk…read moreinto an old cozy intimate space and are greeted by all the smiling servers. My husband and I got the chefs menu. Each dish was delicious. Pasta, meat, and veggies; we got it all. The platings were big and not what I expected from usual Michelin places! Two big servings of fresh pasta! By the meat plate I was actually too full to finish. The pistachio drizzle over panna cotta was one of the best desserts we had in our whole Italy trip. Never had it before and it was a perfect ending. Great staff. Our kids had plenty of choices of food as well. Staff very patient with them. Amazing last dinner

Fantastico!!! Everything was delicious. We were walking through the beautiful streets of Cortona…read morewhen we came across La Bucaccia. Once we saw they had Michelin star we had to check them out. The restaurant itself is not that big but the flavor of the food sure is. Cozy, romantic atmosphere. Perfect for a gals night out or couples. I wish we would had more time to dine there again. I highly recommend dinning here if staying in Cortona. We had the handmade raviolis, rosemary fries, pork, steak and tiramisu. The fries were so delicious we ordered a second batch. The steak and pork were cooked perfectly- both juicy not dry and packed with flavor. I loved how we were treated. Service was top notch . Loved the attention of detail throughout the dinner- the way the food was presented, to the nice dinner napkins and how we were offered grappa after dinner. Pictures do not do it justice.