I'm in love with this place! I've gone for the past three weekends and I can't wait to try the…read moreentire menu board. The people that work there are very impressive, they don't write down anything, but they remember everything perfectly! I've tried the chicken Parmesan wedge, the chicken cutlet wedge with mozzarella and peppers, egg, and cheese on a roll, and my favorite, the patty melt. All of them were delicious, perfectly executed, really tasty. I forgot to take pictures, but I will next time! These guys are really hard-working and create sandwiches that are masterpieces! Can't wait to try another.

This review has been a long time coming. I've been going to Anthony's Deli for years and they…read morenever disappoint. Excellent sandwiches and HUGE. One Italian combo on a wedge, hero, sub, whatever you want to call it will last you easily two days. That pretty much goes for any of their other sandwiches. Their double cheeseburger is excellent and so are their breakfast sandwiches. The prices are also very reasonable like 1990's prices. Anthony's will always be my go to deli.

Amazing sandwich shop. Authentic and fresh ingredients. Probably the best or one of the best…read moreItalian sandwich shops in the area. Ordered a few different types for my office holiday party and each one was solid. I was particularly impressed with the quality of meats and the bread. A very tasty Italian sandwich for sure. The prices were super reasonable i felt, especially considering the level of food. Everyone inside was very friendly and helpful.

Great place to get great food. Highly recommended to everyone who appreciates quality food.read more

A true staple to the Mamaroneck community. I've had all great experiences here. Hidden gem!read more

When I was in the deli I was the only customer. It took 15 minutes to make my food as the only…read morecustomer. The food was so bad I think I was food poisoned, it's been 3 days and I'm sick. I don't know if it was a joke. The workers didn't speak English, and they were yelling at me saying five more minutes. when we were paying the worker described the restaurant as ghetto. Overall, never come to this restaurant, it's the worst of all time.

Sage is my go to deli when I'm in Mamaroneck…read more I like their wedges. And I like the York peppermint patty they add to the bag. I tend to order the Veggie Weggie. It's a wedge with cheese (I order provolone), artichokes, roasted peppers and lettuce, tomato & onion. I'm not a vegetarian, but I really like this sandwich. Beyond that, I mostly get meatball wedges or turkey. Someday I need to ask if they can make a Balboa.

Yesterday (12/08/22), I was on my way home from work and hubby called me up to ask me to bring home…read moresomething for him to eat. I should have just gone to the place in our area that we know but I happened to see this deli when I was stopped at the light out front Theres 15 minute parking our front so I quickly found a spot and went in. They look led pretty clean. The salads in the case did not look that fresh but I don't ever get stuff like that unless I know there's a good turnaround. The guy who took my odder was nice. Initially, I ordered a hot Italian for my son. I saw it on one of the pic from the deli's Yelp page. I should have paid attention to when the picture was posted. The guy said that he could toast the bread but would have to microwave the cold cuts. That was a hard pass and that should have been my first inkling to get out of there. I just told him no to the microwave but yes, toast the hero bread. I also asked for him to put out chipotle mayo on the sandwich. Hubby's sandwich was simple: honey turkey, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and regular mayo on a hero. Not hot. I came straight home and both of my guys ate their sandos. I wasn't feeling a sandwich so I did not order anything. Thank goodness. Fast-forward to last night. Hubby was sick all night until the following day (today). We think it might have been the mayonnaise or the lettuce, which would make sense because my son was fine. He had not lettuce on his sandwich and had a different mayo. It definitely could not have been anything else that he ate because he did not eat anything else that day that was out of the ordinary. I was not sure about ordering food from this deli and I should have listened to my gut but because I saw a good amount of people come in and I odder food, I figured that they might have improved. Never again. If the deli see this review, please check your fridge temps, expiration dates and produce for contamination.

The best. So intuitive. So chill. Patrons need to know this craft takes a little time…read more Super high quality ingredients and expertly prepared.

I was ramen to this place by a friend and co-worker. I wish I knew this place existed sooner! I had…read morethe Chicken Vodka Parm on a Garlic Bread Hero. It was delicious! The staff is friendly and helpful. The place is roomy and clean. If you're in the area you have to try it. I came back the next day to try another one of their sandwiches and to pick one up for my son.

Always a great place for deli sandwiches and much much more. Super nice and place is clean as…read morealways. Owners are great. This place is a must!

Amicis has really good sandwiches from breakfast to lunch, the food is always fresh. The staff is…read morefriendly and the place is clean. They are also good if you're having a party with their catering menu. I highly recommend this place.

Decent food, decent service, very convenient location with outdoor seating during the warmer months.read more

Great service, friendly staff! Coffee is always hot & fresh, sandwiches cooked to order and are…read moredelicious!

I made a mistake, I ordered their version of an Italian comb. Okay well mistake no not really. They…read moreshould put a warning label that reads "only order if you are really really hungry"! Now I did not order the hero, I just ordered on a roll! This thing is huge, it came with its own zip code....okay maybe a bit of an exaggeration but the sandwich was a good size . The combination of meats was also real tasty, the dressing okay oil and vinegar was a good balance as well. The staff behind the counter really know their staff and their customers. Not being a regular there kind of made me jealous of those that are. This could have been a 5 star if the line moved a little quicker. When you have limited time to grab lunch and eat it becomes problematic. Of course it was after the fact that someone informed me I could have ordered on line and just ran in to get it. This place has the right atmosphere for a neighborhood deli.

Very, very busy deli. Go to sandwich is the Grilled Mexican. Highly recommend texting in your…read moreorder or else the line can be long with high school kids.

If I could give Joe more than 5 stars I would! The food was ordered in advance and we went for…read morepickup. Joe was so sweet helping put all the foods in the back of the car. We ordered big ziti, chicken wings, green salad, meatballs, turkey, and roast beef wedges, chocolate chip and oatmeal cookies, French Rolls and sourdough bread. A feast! Everything was absolutely delicious. My favorite were the wings and big ziti. Yum, food coma! Street parking.

Friendly and welcoming when I walked I. The door. They were ready promptly take my order but I was…read moretrying to make up my mind.they had plenty of drink selections. I finally choose the roast beef sandwich and it was really big. I ate one half on day tried to eat the other half the next but only was able to eat 1/2. No shortage in size or how fulling their sandwiches are.