Every blue moon, I go in search of cookies online from companies that deliver nationwide. It's not that we don't have good cookies here in Virginia, but great are few and far between. I specifically recall having about ten different companies open on my browser simultaneously. I was removing them one by one and Fat T's was the last one open. I had just about given up hope and found myself on the verge of settling for a cookie I'd ordered before from another company. After viewing the selections (and the backstory of Fat T's), I figured I'd give it a try. Most of the cookie selections fall right in line with what I'd typically order so I was optimistic. From placement of the order to arrival at my door took about six days which is more than acceptable. I ordered a nine-cookie variety pack. I'm about six cookies down and they are phenomenal. I have yet to find one that I wouldn't enjoy more of. Fat T's will definitely be my go-to cookie for myself and my family moving forward when we look to indulge. You all at Fat T's deserve to be incredibly proud of the quality of your product. Cheers! read more

Fat T's cookies are the best. They will be missed. Four the Love of Chocolate & Here we go Brownies are my favotites

Yummy! Delicious! These cookies are so BIG you will want to split one with another person. Fat T's cookies come in a variety of flavors, and there are seasonal ones too. The kiosk at Northside Marketplace has both cookies and brownies. In addition to this location, there is a website where cookies can be ordered. Local Acme Fresh Market locations also carry Fat T's cookies. Now, back to the cookies.......amazing! These cookies are stuffed with goodness. Very unique! Worth it! read more

See all

I have been following along on social media and was so excited to try these cookies. They are hyped up quite a bit and fell flat for me. I bought 6 different cookies and a brownie and each was just okay. The brownie was likely the best as it had the most and best flavor. The cookies and brownies are a good size, but I expect more from a cookie that costs $3 and a brownie that costs $6. read more

See all

I took my husband on a wild goose chase to find this teeny little wire stand in the market district. I wasn't even going to buy one.. because I thought if they looked like what they tasted like (none of them had expiration dates.... so I have no idea how long they've been tossed around in this basket... and by the looks of the stand.. it's been a while before anyone gave it love).. it was going to be a disappointment.. but how could Yelp be that far off.. so for $3 we did it. Dry, crumbly and lacking anything to rave about. Just don't do it... there are so many more places to get a good cookie or treat around here.. this goes down as something we are going to laugh about for a while. read more

Fat T's Cookies - Driest Cookie in the history of ever - Bakeries Near Me - Akron, Ohio

Not worth the hype. Though I am a chocolate snob-the choco chip cookie looked good-tasted ok. I feel like maybe a low quality chocolate was used. I had one cookie years ago that had Oreo in it. I don't recall it being anything special. Same with this time. Probably will skip our purchasing in the future. read more

I've only bought Fat T's Cookies from The Northside Market a couple of times. I buy them on Friday on my way home from work just after 4:30pm a couple hours after they have restocked their baskets. This is a review of those cookies. I've bought the following cookies: pumpkin, chocolate with peanut butter chips, chocolate chips, Cookie Monster, and Cinnamon Bun chocolate chip. The Pumpkin cookie was so soft and like eating pumpkin pie--delicious. All the cookies had the following characteristics. They were delicious. I don't know how to describe delicious but it was delicious. Quality ingredients. Nothing inferior. I would describe them as small batch cookies from a small business owner. Nothing fancy or large scale that sacrifices quality. All of them were fat! Lol. All were fresh and moist. Some folks have described them as gooey but I don't think I had that experience with the cookies I got. They weren't hockey pucks but they weren't gooey like Insomnia cookie. Insomnia cookies are gooey. These were soft in the center and the further you got from the center the harder it got. They didn't crunch or crumble too much. I could eat them in my car and not worry too much about crumbles. Warning: you should probably just eat one in a 12 hour period. Lol. They have so much sugar etc., especially the Cookie Monster because it's essential one cookie inside another, that it made my stomach sick when I ate two cookies. read more

~ will update review as I consume more cookies ~ Thank you Instagram for introducing me to these beauties! I bought the Cookie Monster, #MooseHouse, Four the Love of Chocolate, Chocolate Peanut Butter, and the OG. Normally wouldn't splurge so greatly, but there was a really good sale that basically gave me free shipping. I heard these freeze well, so I'm testing that out! 1. Cookie Monster: a winter special item, containing milk chocolate and a cookie dough center. I was so surprised at how chewy & soft it was since it looked kinda hard! I also microwaved half of it for ~20 seconds and would definitely recommend that for anyone who loves gooey, warm deliciousness. My only critique is that it was a bit sweet (I couldn't finish a whole cookie in one sitting), but I think that's a personal thing because I always prefer dark/slightly bitter chocolate to milk or white chocolate. 2. #MooseHouse: Whoa. I should've bought more of these because it is peanut butter goodness! It is a chocolate dough cookie, filled with a PB cup and topped with fudge drizzle. If you like peanut butter cups (the only form of milk chocolate I love) and soft cookies, look no further. I couldn't rate it anything less than 5 stars cause I think owner is super cute too lol read more

Fat T's Cookies - Cookie Monster (cut in half) - Bakeries Near Me - Akron, Ohio

See all

I really enjoy getting these cookies when they come to my hometown. They freeze well and even a short blip in the microwave makes them extra gooey and fun to eat. I highly recommend not eating the entire cookie (or brownie when they're available!) at once since they're so big. Plus you can enjoy them longer. He is really accessible online/through social media to answer questions, provide ingredient information and offer deals pretty frequently. Support local business and give these cookies a try. read more

See all

Absolutely LOVE Fat T's Cookies, they are delicious and well made cookies that are made with real ingredients (not just random chemicals!). I have sent 5+ boxes of cookies to friends across the United States and they now are all huge fans of the Fat T cookies! I especially love the seasonal flavors and whenever the owner does fun cookie related polls to interact with their followers online. 12/10 would recommend these cookies - get them as gifts or for yourself (you're always deserving of cookies!) read more

I had the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie and it was mediocre. Not bad, but I've tasted better ones. I do like that you Can purchase singles cookies (at Acme). It does have giant peanut butter chips in them and it's a thick cookie. But other than that, I'll keep looking for a better tasting one. read more

Not only have I enjoyed Fat T's Cookies myself, but I have enjoyed sharing them with friends! I recently placed an order, and it shipped so fast, and the cookies made it to their destination in amazing condition! I messaged the owner to ask a few questions before ordering, and got very helpful responses extremely fast. Fat T's was wonderful to work with, and really helped to bring a smile to a good friends face from afar! I'll be ordering again, and highly recommend that others to do the same!! read more

See all

Very average cookies. Hard to find location, it way off in a back corner. No one at shop. Very little selection day we were there.

I love these cookies. Been ordering through a friend since 2019. My kids love the Cookie Monster ones when we can get them. I'm in California and wish I was closer, because UPS seems to think the box is a soccer ball and I got a bunch of little cookies instead of one big one. They are still always top notch cookies in my opinion. read more

Stopped at their booth at the 720 market and I have to say, maybe next time they should put samples out! Paid upwards of $16.00 for a sample pack of cookies and they were NOT GOOD. Description says they are "chewy" mine were DRY, not sure if they were just made so far in advance or what but myself, husband and the kids were dissappointed, my son who is an absolute sweets lover threw his away after two bites. Probably my fault for buying so many without trying first, but lesson learned. I will say the people working the booth were really nice, I wanted to love these cookies but they definitely fell short, especially for the price. read more

Definitely the best cookies in the world. Take my word for it. Never thought a cookie that was already a 10/10 could get any better? Warm it up. You won't regret it. read more

These are the absolute best cookies I've ever purchased anywhere. I've been sending them to family and friends since i discovered them. You will not be sorry you purchased these cookies and they are BIG. DELICIOUS!! I'm sending 2 more orders this weekend to more friends and i can't wait until they try them. 10++++ read more

These cookies are so delicious that I wish they could be mailed to my house weekly! I learned about this business when a coworker mailed me a sampler 6 pack when I had a baby a few months back. Since then, I have been ordering cookies to have shipped to various friends on their birthdays as my way of celebrating them in COVID times. I have also done another order for myself! All cookies are chewy, moist and packed with flavor. My favorite would have to be the Cinn City, which was a cinnamon swirled chocolate chip cookie with thick, creamy icing. I look forward to ordering more cookies for my friends, family and as a treat for myself! read more

I have tried ALL of the desserts you see floating around Instagram. Most of them are just crazy concoctions made to get attention or likes, and they all end up tasting like overly sweet artificial garbage...But not Fat T's!! To say I have an addiction is an understatement. The simplicity of these cookies is what makes it stand out the most. Real ingredients that deliver on flavor, texture, and overall belly happiness. Thank you Fat T for creating this gift to the world. read more

Just when you think you have found your favorite Fat T's cookie then BAM you try another one...this time it was the Snickerdoodle. Two giant soft snickerdoodles with some cinnamon buttercream holding them together. The flavor, the softness, it was pure perfection!! I have had many different types of Fat T's cookies and not one has yet to disappoint. read more

Customer service is PHENOMINAL. Easy to work for. They really went above and beyond to help me with some special arrangements I needed for my pickup. Great company even better cookies!!!! Strongly recommend the monthly subscription. read more

The cookies are easy to order and easy to pick up if you don't want to deal with potential shipping delays (caused by the current state of the USPS). We ordered them to include in a party favor bag and they were a big hit. read more

I found them via the gram, couldn't get them because I wasn't gonna order a box and be disappointed, ended up finding them at a desert show and not necessarily fell in love but I am a monthly subscriber and if I run out I get them at a local shop they sell at. The cinn city and moose heads are the big hitters, cannot go wrong. The OG is not as good as my moms but i would eat that every day for the rest of my life. Put them in the oven and heat that cookie up and it's perfect. read more

Fat T makes a phat cookie. Recommend a try. It's a little hard to find in the marketplace, but if you do, give it a try.

First time trying fat t's and I'm impressed! The texture is firm yet soft, the cookies seem to melt in your mouth. I would say they have great flavor but it's not 100% to die for flavor. I'd definitely pick up a few cookies again but I wouldn't go out of my way for them. If you like your cookies on the dryer/harder side you'll be satisfied but don't think these will be super chewy! read more

Always the best. I look forward to seeing them at markets and business nearby. Would recommend

Delicious every time. Try the OG and cookies favorite cookie. Amazing. Definitely try if you haven't!! read more

Fat T's Cookies - The OG Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Akron, Ohio

I lived in New York City and tried all of those amazing cookie places you see on Instagram (chip,levain,duchess,schmackeries) and fat t's can go toe to toe with them any day. I suggest ordering them for pickup to make sure you get the flavors you want as stock is limited or follow on ig and look out for their restock posts. read more

These are the BEST cookies I've ever had, and I consider myself a complete foodie. We bought 2 cookies at a street market event last week and we were craving them ever since. Bought more today & Now I'm completely hooked. You'll be seeing me/us regularly! I personally like them warmed for 20 seconds in the microwave. Mmmmm! My mouth is watering now as I type this! read more

A. M. AAAAAZING. These cookies are easily the best ever!! You cannot go wrong with any choices. Monthly specials are to die for so snag them quick! I get them constantly when at home & get them shipped to me at grad school. Fat T truly loves The Land & cookies and it's an epic combo!! Take however many you think you need and multiply it by 5! You won't regret it!!! read more