I've been on a quest and, hands down, can say that Fat Dan's has the best hot dogs in town. I favor the Chicago dog, covered in pickles, onions, relish, tomatoes, peppers, and mustard. It's a messy delight. Pro tip: Once you pick it up, don't sit it down. Just go for it. I love it so much that I can't bring myself to try anything else on the menu. They have a solid selection of rotating beers..should be enough to please most of us. The inside can get a little noisy when it's chock full o Cubs fans or with children running amok. Grab a seat facing the street and it'll be drowned out a bit. read more

Fat Dan's - Chicago Dog - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My review may be a little biased on the high side because whenever I gather with friends to share a meal, I tend to have a more enjoyable experience. Although there is a small parking area reserved for customers behind the restaurant, it does fill up quickly and it is easy to miss if you are in a hurry driving along College. The alley behind the lot can sometimes be blocked by vehicles parked in the way, so I suggest slowing down and keeping your eyes open for the driveway back to the lot. The restaurant has indoor and outdoor seating (including a patio on the back.) The indoor also has garage doors that open to let the fresh air in. It does get loud inside with the music cranked, lots of conversation and the noise of vehicles from College Ave. The six of us shared a table where we could see by the natural light coming in through the front. They have lots of choices for beverages, including many craft beers. Sadly, I ordered an iced tea that had no flavor...I thought it was just water. Almost that clear. Our table ordered a variety of sandwiches and sides. I wanted the Reuben but was a little hesitant when I saw it was house smoked. It was really tasty and I chose it because the Pastrami and Corned beef did not include sauerkraut which I wanted on my sandwich. I made the right choice and was very pleased with the taste. The fries that someone ordered were seasoned and I really enjoyed them. I think the consensus of the group was that they enjoyed what they ordered and other than it being too loud, enjoyed dining at FD. Review #3942 read more

Fat Dan's - 21-7-10 Smoked Reuben with sauerkraut - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

My boyfriend loves this place. He thinks that the wings are the best he has ever had. I thought they were fine. Nice and crispy, I just prefer the sauce on them instead of on the side but again, that's just my preference. I like how they serve everything on the table and no plates. It's a fun idea. It was loud and a little cold sitting by the window, but it does have a bar, so that's to be expected. Overall, it was a good experience. I give the place 4 1/2 stars read more

Food was great 6 in our party. Service was fast the waitress was friendly and It was our first time there and the waitress explained everything. She checked on us a.couple of times which is always nice. We will definitely go back. read more

I've attempted to contact Fat Dan's discretely via the online form on the website as well the Mass Ave Facebook page through messenger; both attempts were timestamped @4:30p on 8/24 & 9/1 @5:30p. My FB messages were marked as read & nearly 1 month later I am sad to say that my feedback and comments were both disregarded. I reached out paraphrased as follows: "Hi there, I visited Fat Dan's in Broad Ripple Friday 8/2/19 & I wanted to share feedback from my visit. I've been looking forward to visit for a over one year now. Closing time was 11p & I called around 10:40 to place a carryout order but the person who answered the phone responded that phone orders stop at 10:30 but as long as I walk in the door by 11 my order can be taken. I arrived around 10:55p and the guy at the counter told me they are getting ready to close. I replied that I just got off the phone and was told that as long as I walked in by 11, my order would be taken; he asked me who it was that I talked to; I wasn't able to answer this as they didn't state their name when answering the phone. He returned to the counter, not too enthused, and began to take my order. $44 and 10 minutes later my order was ready. Tipping for carry-out orders has always been a very debatable topic but considering my "inconvenience" I gave an extra few bucks for my 10 minute visit. I said thank you, grabbed my bags & departed. All he said was "there you go." No smile, no "thank you," no "have a good one." After months of anticipation, I took a bite of a chicken wing as soon as I sat in my car. The flavor was just okay; it resembled more of a BBQ grilled over charcoal vs. smoker cooked. My Wells St. Burger had good beef texture, cooked to the proper temperature & tender however; someone had completely disregarded seasoning the beef. No flavor besides the toppings that came on the burger. The brisket was like eating leather: dry with unpleasant mouthfeel. I spat it out & threw out the rest. The pastrami/corned beef sandwich was just another bust: dry, small, bland & unseasoned. I don't know if it's because I came in right before close or if they had a bad day but my 1st visit to Fat Dan's was truly a huge disappointment, especially since I've been wanting to come here for years. I wouldn't have gone there before close if the guy on the phone had told me otherwise but he said as long as I walk in before close I would be taken care of. But I'd like to know if anything can be done. I basically spent $44 on food that was pretty much inedible. What options do I have ? I have the receipt if needed (Trans #00563338 on 8/2/19 @11:00:25pm /// Total: $44.36). I need someone to get back to me as soon as possible please, thank you." read more

This is a great spot to grab a burger and have a beer, or watch a game if you are into that. It's the opposite of fancy, as you might guess from the name, but the food was all high quality. I went all out (had skipped lunch) and had the Dan's Fat Brother burger which was too big to fit in my mouth even after smashing it down. The fries and tots are top-notch. I highly suggest sharing an order of Dirty Tots, they stayed crispy even with the delicious cheese and hot sauce slathered atop. read more

I love Fat Dan's Deli! I always get the pressed Cubano. It is the best Cuban sandwich I've had. The atmosphere is great and a good place to have a quick lunch. I do wish they'd get on DoorDash, because I'd eat there more often if they were. read more

The go to place for meat! Fat Dans will always be my favorite place to go when craving delicious food. The dirty tots are out of this world, I love the spice of them. The smoked pork is amazing! I've always had wonderful service and food! The burgers are massive and you can't really go wrong with what you chose. Plenty of selection for even the pickiest eaters. read more

Love the expansion. I guess it had been a while since we were in last. I was ready for a huge basket of tots and an ugly corn dog. Basket of tots was not nearly as big and my corn dog wasn't ugly. All still tasted good and had friendly service, but don't skimp on the tots. read more

Honestly, the worst Fat Dan's location. Terrible vibes for certain demographics. Don't call to ask about their kitchen hours in Broad Ripple if it's past 5pm on a Friday. They'll hang up on you if they're "too busy". It's usually not very clean at this location and the bartenders' attitudes have much to be desired. Servers are hit or miss. Be ready for flies and gnats in the warmer months. Just overall not a very welcoming location. Go to Hank's instead. read more

Really like this place. Good service, delicious food, and good prices. Definitely not the place to go if you like health food and clean bathrooms. Besides that, all positives. read more

Love the food here! Patio space to bring your pup companion. Lots of parking near by. Great food, great staff read more

Fat Dan's - Chillin under the table - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Always liked this place. Never had a bad meal here. Some of the best wings in Naptown. I would recommend this spot no question.

A coworker of mine has been raving about the wings here, so I couldn't wait to try them. After a 5K and plenty of wine at the finish line (hey it was a wine themed run!) we were starving and headed to Fat Dan's. I got the dry rubbed wings, so so good! They were seasoned well and had great flavor, and so tender and yummy. They served them with two sauces, one sweet bbq and the other a hot sauce. I preferred the sweet as the dry rub already gave the wings a spicy kick. I got a small order of tots on the side, a nice change from fries and they were crispy and good also. I've heard that they do "dirty tots" where they add mountains of other delicious things on top so that may be a future order! My friend got the pulled pork sandwich and it was very good also. With open air seating and the draft list filled with local favorites, this is about to be a regular spot in my rotation! read more

See all

Ohhhh my goodness! Wow! I don't know why I didn't visit sooner. This Chicago vibe restaurant is needed in every city for those who need a taste of the cities finest comfort food. The Italian beef rivals that of portillos and Zel's from northwest Indiana. Honestly it's better than both of them. The spiciness of the au jus that is soaked into the meat is ah-mazing! Ugh my mouth is watering just thinking about it. I cannot wait to come back for another bite. read more

Fat Dan's - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

French fries just come out in the middle of the table on butcher paper. If you love copious amount of fries you will enjoy this place. Food is good. It's greasy food, no salads and tea cakes here, so prepare your insides for some wonderful grease and flavor. I've had corn dogs but recently had the classic Chicago dog, all was tasty. A friend gets the Cuban Sammy and raves about it. Lots of TVs and large beer selection. We've come here to watch Bears games (we are transplants from Northwest Illinois). Fun place to meet friends and have a few drinks! read more

Fat Dan's - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

iLife this Chicago style bar. Delicious hot dogs, hamburgers and wings! The only down side is they don't serve Ranch...because apparently people in Chicago don't eat ranch. Their bathrooms are also pretty unfortunate so hopefully you won't need to use them while there! read more

This Bloomington location has not been open long, and a co-worker said it's awesome, so we decided to we wanted to try something new last night and popped in. NOT disappointed. Great staff. Great service. AMAZING food. I'm not even kidding....their Brisket puts others to shame. It doesn't even need sauce. HOWEVER, it's great with sauce too. Bun or no bun, it's really awesome. Their buns are even super tasty. The whole experience was yummy. We will be back! read more

See all

They finally changed the menus so they are legible! No more black print on a dark gray back ground! Have enjoyed most items, inside hint, when ordering the beer fries, have it changed to tator tots ! read more

See all

What a great, little friendly place!! I had the Italian beef which was delicious! With plenty of peppers & cheese! My husband ordered the BLT & it was the biggest and best BLT Ever!! Definitely give this place a try...it's priced right, friendly staff & huge beer menu!! Can't wait to go back!' read more

Fat dans is one of our favorite places to go in Mass Ave. it's not directly on Mass, so it's more laid back and less busy (typically). Everything on the menu is insanely good (but fattening, obviously). You have to get the wings when you go. Their half/half tots and fries are good too, plus any sandwich on the menu. They're pretty cool about putting games on that you wanna watch too, which is what sold us because we're Detroit fans. Service is always good and super chill, if you need something, just ask. Their happy hour from 4-6 and after 9 is amazing: half of burgers and wings. read more

This is definitely a cravings spot because I'm pretty sure nothing on the menu would be considered healthy. I like the late hours and take-out options. Menu is pretty straightforward with plenty of choices for most people to find something they will like. Portions of fries are HUGE! Service is friendly. Interior is pretty basic. Overall, nothing bad, but nothing too exciting. Fat Dan's is exactly as advertised, but just not something I have the need to go to that often. read more

Fat Dan's - Fat burger with side of fries - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Fatty melt, fatty melt, oh how I love thee!! Is it awkward ordering your sandwich, knowing the word fat is in it? Yes. Did I end up caring? No. It does come with a relish/ketchup/mayo mix which I ordered on the side because I do like the my burgers with the sautéed onions to stand alone on flavor and this one sure did! We ordered the large fries and tots combo which was plenty for four people to share. I definitely thought the tots were better than the fries and I'm a fry girl all the way so that says a lot! It looked like they had beer and wine, but I didn't ask if they had cocktails. My husband and my friend's husband both ordered Zombie Dust and they were happy to say the least. Loved the vibe and how our food came out on huge pieces of wax paper. My husband wants to go back to try the smoked meatloaf so I'm sure we will make another stop in! read more

Wow. I am impressed. Food is plentiful and delicious. The signature Dirty Tots are a recommended appetizer for any group size and if the group is bigger than 3, get two orders. Otherwise, everyone will be counting tots! Very sweet delivery service. All food transported on disposable paper. No plates! I like it because plates are just a geography consumer and I can't eat them. I don't eat the paper but it doesn't take up my space either. read more

The burgers and Chicago specialties are very good. Great Chicago dogs and Italian beef sandwiches. But for me, I gotta have the smoked wings. They are awesome. With an Old Style beer is best! read more

I love Fat Dan's & its location! Their fresh cut fries are to die for (they rank up there with Kuma's). However, their Cubano was a bit of a let down & it was dry. Still a neighborhood favorite. read more

Fat Dan's - Pressed Cubano - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Okay okay let me just oh WOW!!! I have been looking for this taste since I moved to Indy!!! Great good food and atmosphere. I give 300 stars!!! They know how to respect Chicago's name!!! read more

Cubs and Bears fans, come here!!!! While the Italian beef is the best south of Crown Point, the hamburgers go nose to nose with any in Indy. No mixed drinks, but they serve Old Style on draft and have house wines. There are other beers too, you bougie Northsider! Only thing green is the relish on the hot dogs, you can get a salad next door or across the street. read more

It was my 56th Birthday and wanted to try something different. We looked in the Indianapolis Monthly Magazine for the restaurants in the back and saw that Fat Dan's Deli was what we wanted to try. Easy to get to in SoBro! We live in Greenfield and want to try something new each month. Francine was our Bartender and she was so patient with us since we had tons of questions. She let us try some of the craft beers we had not heard of(love that some from Wyoming). I ordered the East Coast Submarine (Al Capone) Style(hot) and hand cut french fries, my husband had the special trio of sliders, brisket, pulled pork and italian beef! I tried the brisket and I would say the best I have had!! The French fries are do die for! Thank you Francine. We will return! read more

The wings here are always pretty large and really well cooked. The burgers they have are unreal. I go to here on the regular for some consistently great food! read more

This place is unreal. I had to buy a whole new wardrobe because I've gained so much weight from eating here a couple times a month the past 2 1/2 years. Officially wearing size 36-38 waist pants now and I do not regret it. Top items: dirty tots, wings, meatloaf, patty melt and Griffins cubby. read more

Fat Dan's - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I think I am Fat Dan. I had wings, fries, sides of blue cheese and beer cheese. I'm Danny. I am Fat Dan. Except I don't own a successful business. Fat Poor Dan. I was in Broad Ripple and been meaning to stop into Fat Dans. It was NOT what I expected. I expected quick service. It's sit down. I went in with basketball shorts and a rain coat. Don't get me wrong, it's a dive, but I didn't know what to do since I was alone. Fat Poor Lonely Dan. I ordered the wings and fries as previously mentioned per the recommendation from the server. The fries were extremely crispy, almost to the point of burnt. I loved it. The beer cheese was not super flavorful so I would leave it be next time. The wings. Hello naughty naughty wings. They outside was coated in dry rub while the inside was so juicy, fall off the bone tender, smoked meat. It was fantastic. Hands down - best wings in Indy. I will dream about that wing. If I can figure out where the smoker is, hell have no fury like I will go for those wings. Fatter Poor Lonely Dan. Parking is a pain, but unrelated. Dan can only control so many things, ya know? read more

Fat Dan's - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

So we had an opportunity to visit Fat Dan's. There was a lot of anticipation to try this local favorite. Upon entry (for a first timer) I was slightly confused as to if I'm seated or if I seat myself. We just decided to go ahead and find a seat. The hospitality wasn't great. When someone finally did recognize, it was with lackluster enthusiasm. That's fine...whatever, I came for the food. My hubby and I decided to have their wings and their duck fat fries. Service wasn't long actually; we got our food in good time. There was a lot of food for just the two dishes we ordered. The wings were good; very flavorful and I loved the smokey taste they had. The fries were a little disappointing. I thought they would be more flavorful than what they were. So all in all, it was alright, nothing spectacular. read more

Would eat here again and again! Great drinks, service and food at all locations I've been to. :) No ranch though. Don't even bring it up. Lol read more

I would've posted pictures, but I completely forgot to take them once my sandwich was given to me. The perfume of meat and spice that wafted my way was enough to make my mouth instantly start watering and my brain stop working. Then when I was able to compose myself enough to take a bite, it was almost like the deli scene from "When Harry Met Sally". I would like to think that I was able to control myself slightly better, but I make no guarantees. SO GOOD! I would absolutely recommend the hot pastrami and corned beef sandwich to anyone. read more

This place has some of the best freaking burgers ever!! Seriously, so worth the price! Me and my mom have had them deliver several times and I swear I almost see stars when I bite into one of them. They're so messy but divine! It's as if the gods of grilling have bestowed upon Fat Dan's the secret to the most amazing burger. If you have not had Fat Dan's, you need to try it! I guarantee it will be worth it. read more

Just when you think their Reuben sandwich couldn't get any better....oh it can. It twas' the night after Winterfest and my stomach was in some serious food desperation. It was eager to soak up the cornucopia of beer I just consumed. The smell of smoked meat lingered in the air, I knew this was going to be a fabulous meal. Our server recommended the Beef Brisket Reuben (*not found on the menu) and I obliged. Hot damn this sandwich was legit. The brisket was flavorful, tender, juicy and balanced perfectly with the kraut, swiss and relish. As most delicious sandwiches should, the juices dripped down my chin. Fat Dan should surely invest in some bibs as his meats are not only some of the juiciest around but they bring on tears of joy. A bib would make a great accessory and catch all. In summery -- whatever you do just order this sandwich, you will be happy that you did. **For extra precaution bring your own bib for juices and tears. read more

Small selection of draft beer here, but they're decent brews. The wines are kept sitting on the counter, so I wouldn't plan on having wine with your fries. Instead of wine, have the cheese sauce. It's from a can...just like you remember from high school football games. Drink it up. If you eat here, you MUST get the fries. They're freshly cut and oh-so-good. If you're not into being a messy eater, you would do well to steer clear here. Food is served on paper. If there are two of you all your food will be on the same giant sheet of white paper and plopped down between you. I had a sandwich with pulled pork, ham, and provolone. It was massive. And tasty. It was not on the menu but they were happy to make it for me :) Yay! He had an Italian Beef, wet. It was reeeeaaaally good. I'll get that next time. The bartender was friendly, none of the other customers were being obnoxious. Best of all, we didn't have to wait "at least 45 minutes" like we would've at Twenty Tap next door...for NOT hand-cut fries. We'll definitely be back! read more

Fat Dan's - Not on menu: pork, jam, provolone. "Cuban-esque" - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Oh. My. Gosh. We came in on a whim after Twenty Tap had a long wait. We walked right in and sat ourselves, it was pretty empty. When the waitress handed us old paper menus with sandwiches I was skeptical. We almost left. Instead we ordered a beer, I can't remember what it was because they were all types I hadn't heard of before, but it was good! The waitress was helpful in picking one bases on our tastes. Then we made the best choice of the night and got their wings. The wings have a dry rub and are smoked for 3 hours. The meat literally fell off the bone. The seasoning was awesome and I didn't even need the sauces. My boyfriend liked the blue cheese with the wings. It was $10 for 12 which was a good amount to split. You don't find wings like this many places! It definitely makes me want to go back and try their other smoked meats. This place was definitely a surprise but I am glad I didn't leave! I would go back! read more

Fat Dan's - Sorry, they were too good to pause for a photo! The meat fell off the bones! - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I am talking specifically about the College Ave location; not the Carmel location. This place isn't bad if you're looking for Chicagoland favorites. Their burgers are decent, too. A little spendy for lunch, and it would be great if you could get a reasonable amount of fries with your burger for maybe a buck instead of a bushel of tots for an extra $4. In Covid times, chips with your sandwich means a sealed snack bag of plain potato chips like you can buy at Costco. If you have a craving for a hot dog with sport peppers, tomato, relish, and celery salt (no ketchup!), stop here. read more