Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fancy Sandy’s

    4.5 (4 reviews)
    Open 8:15 am - 3:00 pm

    Fancy Sandy’s Photos

    FANCY SANDY’S ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Fancy Sandy’s

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Sean L.

    Sean L.

    Thank you Kaitlin! We are so glad you enjoyed your sandwich.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Megan S.
    115
    67
    7

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    It's a very convenient location. Warm and tasty, I'll keep coming back. Thanks so much!

    Business owner information

    Photo of Sean L.

    Sean L.

    Thank you Janet! We look forward to serving you again soon.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Fancy Sandy’s

    You might also consider

    Little Hats Italian Market

    Little Hats Italian Market

    4.6(313 reviews)
    0.1 miGermantown
    $$

    Another Germantown staple. I ordered the Spicy Italian sandwich -- the sandwich is HUGE and…read morehonestly big enough to share. It has the perfect kick without being overpowering. They have a bar, I got the limoncello spritz, which was exactly what I wanted in the 82-degree Nashville weather. The service is quick, from the time we ordered - we got the sandwich just few mins. They have a big patio area, a great spot to sit outside, relax, and people watch. Parking can be limited, but they do have a few dedicated spots and a free street parking if you get lucky. Otherwise, there's a paid parking across the street.

    Adorable Italian market with homemade pasta and gluten free focaccia! They have a few different…read morelocations around time, and I appreciated that the Germantown one had so much parking! I got the bolognese after debating between a few different menu items. I loved how creamy it was--the pasta was definitely on the Al dente side which is usually not my preference, but it did really work with the soft melted cheese and chewy meat! We also tried the gluten free focaccia. My friend thought it was a bit crumbly, but I really liked it because it was on the undercooked side and therefore a lot softer than I was expecting. The ordering process itself is counterside, and you get a number that is called out on a loudspeaker when it's ready! There's a ton of seating inside and outside.

    Photos
    Little Hats Italian Market - Counter

    Counter

    Little Hats Italian Market - Pico meatballs and Goat cheese strawberry salad

    Pico meatballs and Goat cheese strawberry salad

    Little Hats Italian Market - Strawberry  goat cheese and d see lemons salad

    See all

    Strawberry goat cheese and d see lemons salad

    Turkey and the Wolf Ice House - Tomato sandwich special

    Turkey and the Wolf Ice House

    4.7(58 reviews)
    1.2 mi
    $$

    I rarely order salads at restaurants because I make amazing salads at home but this restaurant…read moreabsolutely delivered. The cabbage salad was well dressed, well seasoned, and the homemade pork rinds added so much in terms of flavor and texture. Best salad I have ordered out all year. My husband has the wedge and the dressing was fresh and had real fresh herbs. Love a bright flavor paired with heavy meats. 10/10!

    I genuinely cannot believe it's taken me so long to try Turkey and the Wolf, given that it's a…read morefive-star establishment by even my pickiest of friends. This casual sandwich shop is the Nashville outpost of an original New Orleans Michelin Bib Gourmand-recognized spot. And it truly delivers. The menu is tight but emphasizes indulgent, tasty burgers, po'boys, and a variety of sandwiches and sides. The vibe is ideal for the warmer months, as it's primarily outdoors (with a covered patio on part of the eatery.) I've come twice now: first for a pop-up they did for Lunar New Year and again a few weeks later just to grab lunch. Parking is pretty easy to find on the street but be forewarned at peak lunch time on the weekends or for special pop-ups, whichthere can be a long line to order. I've had the burger and fries here and it's excellent but can't wait to come back and try the daily special po'boy or the collard green melt so many of my friends have raved about. They really understand the perfect mathematical ratio between sauciness, crispness of the breading, and overall flavor to just make really incredible sandwiches. Service is friendly and very fast. You order at a counter and then your food is brought to you. They have my favorite local seltzer, Maypop, or you could opt for a drink from their full bar. They host a lot of special pop-ups in collaboration with other chefs or just other cool people (Tyler Childers did a sandwich with them last summer.) When I came for their Lunar New Year pop-up with Chef Christine Lau, the line was around the block but they dealt with everyone efficiently, there were still plenty of tables for sitting, and the food (we ordered everything on the menu that day) was truly unreal delicious. Menu prices are pretty reasonable, about $14-15 for a sandwich and then sides would add up on top of that. Believe the hype for this spot - it's absolutely a worth it.

    Photos
    Turkey and the Wolf Ice House
    Turkey and the Wolf Ice House - Fluffernutter ice cream sandwich

    Fluffernutter ice cream sandwich

    Turkey and the Wolf Ice House - The Tomato

    See all

    The Tomato

    Fatbelly Pretzel

    Fatbelly Pretzel

    4.8(119 reviews)
    2.4 miEastwood
    $$

    After coming here for the first time in my 4 years in Nashville, I can say that the KDUB sandwich…read moreis one of my favorites in the city! I love the avocado and ruffles added as a welcomed addition to a classic turkey club type of sub. Add in that it is all on a fresh Dutch roll and it is a chefs kiss! Proper levels of savory and tangy with all the toppings that make this sandwich what it is and texturally complex. The staff was busy but attentive and patient with everyone even during the Saturday lunch rush. The owners are front and center working with all the staff at the counter and in the kitchen prepping all the food and adding to the hospitality and small business feel that makes you enjoy spending your time and money at a place like this. It is a nice touch that they have a dip come with any pretzel ordered. The pepperoni stuffed pretzel was solid heated up, but for me was lacking the option of a marinara type sauce to dip it in. The everything bagel is properly seasoned the way I like it not sparing a bit of open space on the surface and fully covered in seasoning. These pretzels are unique in shape and have you wanting to come back and try all the different varieties, both regular and special unique danish and dessert pretzel infusions. I will definitely be back to try other sandwiches and desserts!

    I think this might be the most incredible sandwich I have ever had and I am a bit of a sandwich…read moresnob. This sandwich was what I always wanted Al'Anitico Vinaio to be but never was, and could never dream of being. The inside is your typical deli counter/sandwich shop setup. Nothing fancy and not trying to be. The "Hamma Mia" was on the most perfect focaccia I have ever had on a sandwich. Extremely fresh and fluffy, they said it takes 3 days to make! The artichoke cream and homemade motz are two of the freshest ingredients again, that I think I have had. Flabbergasted is honestly the only word I have for how good this place was. Will definitely be my go to local sando place from now on. Cant wait to try their other offerings. Staff was super helpful and made a recommendation based on "if you had to pick 1." Go try them out!

    Photos
    Fatbelly Pretzel - Don't forget to use the "pick up here" window (:

    Don't forget to use the "pick up here" window (:

    Fatbelly Pretzel
    Fatbelly Pretzel - The Store!

    See all

    The Store!

    Fancy Sandy’s - sandwiches - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...