My normal go to bagel place was randomly closed while I was visiting in town so I was super bummed. My friend found this place so we decided to try it and man am I glad we did. They had lots of bagels to choose from - regular and "fancy" ones too. I am pretty basic so I got a sesame seed bagel. They also have lots of options of what kind of sandwich you want. I got an egg and cheese and a hash-brown side. We also got coffees. I was bummed about the other place I like because they always have some kind of fun flavor coffee until I saw this selection!!! Holy moley - so many flavor choices! I got the Yankee Doodle flavor which is basically hazelnut and cinnamon. Yum!!! Our bagels were ready pretty quickly - we grabbed a seat and dug in. It was Delicious. The bagel was nice and toasted on the outside and so soft on the inside! read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

See all

I had a jalepeño cheddar BEC and my partner had a SEC on an everything bagel- both were really solid. Would definitely come again to try more kinds of bagels. Service was nice and quick. The place was alot more spacious inside than I thought. read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Bacon, egg, and cheese on a Jalapeño cheddar bagel. - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

Absolutely the best bagels around. I'm from Waterbury and I love Ami's Bagels on East Main Street but Fancy Bagels has Ami's beat hands down. I will drive to Southington even though Ami's is closer. My only complaint is that service can be slow when Fancy Bagels is busy. I wish that one person would just work the register and one or more people would deal with customers orders. This is a common problem for other reviewers also. Overall, the upside far outweighs any downside. Just be prepared to wait a bit when they are busy. The bagels are worth the wait. read more

Delicious bagels! Always busy unless we get there right when they open but worth the wait! Good bfast sandwiches too

Amazing breakfast sandwich, egg and cheese on am asiago bagel, banana nut coffee. Always busy but great service read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

If you want a good breakfast sandwich then Fancy Bagels got it! They have varieties type of bagels from savory to sweet. My current addiction is the sweet cinnamon bagel toasted with cream cheese. I try to hit the spot every Sunday. The line can get long but the service is quick. There is a sit down area if you need eat and go do your next errand. The lady in the front and staff is always friendly and nice. She always try to remember her returning customers name which is sweet. I also love that they participate in the "Plate it Forward" for people in need. read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Sweet Cinnamon Bagel with cream cheese. - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

Fast service and great variety! Where else in the world can you get this much food for such a low price!! Amazing!! You will be a hero if you grab these for the office. read more

Excellent local place to grab a quick breakfast bite or lunch! They have bagels, bagel sandwiches, wraps, coffee, and more. There is casual seating available, first come first serve. The food was ready very quickly and tasted delicious! Very reasonable pricing too. read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Bagel egg and cheese - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

Such a delicious sandwich!!! I got the fancy French dip sandwich and it was bomb!!! The bagel was awesome! Very busy on a Saturday afternoon but still plenty of seating available! Definitely coming here again! read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Fancy French Dip Sandwich with a poppy bagel - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

See all

Last Sunday, my 9 year old son and I drove 20 minutes to the Southington Fancy Bagel. The food we received was very good and I can see why people I know are big fans of Fancy. We arrived around 10 a.m. and it was very busy. Service was friendly, but I'm sure it's challenging to provide optimal service when it's that busy. I ordered a bagel sandwich for myself, a plain bagel with cream cheese and French Fries for my son, a 1/2 dozen assorted bagels and two containers of cream cheese. One person initially took my order, and then a different person rung our order. I didn't notice until after we left, but we did not get our cream cheese containers. In retrospect, I don't believe that we were charged for the cream cheese because the cost was lower than I expected. I assume there was some miscommunication between the first person and the cashier. My toasted sesame bagel sandwich with bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado and mayo was delicious. The bagel had good texture and worked well for a sandwich. The sesame seeds were on point. The bacon was ample and peak crispy. The other toppings all worked well too. I mean it's basically a BLT with avocado, so what's not to love. The menu indicated that the sandwich I ordered also came with turkey, but there was no turkey on the sandwich. The sandwich was terrific without the turkey, but that was a service miss. Later that day, I had a Fancy Everything Bagel and some cream cheese from a different place. I believe Cafe Busy Bean serves Fancy Bagels, so I've previously had a Fancy Everything Bagel. When I ate at Cafe Busy Bean, I described it as the most everything Everything Bagel ever. Still holds true. It was very good. The food that we received from Fancy was very good and in the 4.5 to 5 Star range, but I've got to deduct a point for the service misses. So I ended up at 3.5 to 4 Stars. read more

See all

Friendly staff, great bagels, fast service, coffee was also really good! Restaurant is clean. read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Everything bagel - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

I'm not very picky when it comes to most things, but when it comes to bagels and men? Different story. I had heard great things about Fancy Bagels by a few friends, but I don't take my bagel game lightly, so it took me a while to get here. When I finally did, I was so mad I hadn't sooner! The bagels are delicious. They are freshly made ( and you can taste it) and there are great options for flavors of both bagels and cream cheese. I LOVE the French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese, or the everything bagel with scallion. Honestly - you can't go wrong. OH and if chicks are your preference - the egg bagel sandwiches are definitely worth it. read more

Great spot, super fresh and hot always and tons of variety. Employees always friendly.

Excellent Bagels -Went this past Sunday 11:00 very busy place. They should be like Neils Donuts, with 8-10 girls at the counter. People ordering Breakfast Bagels getting drinks coffee and playing with their kids! Im just there for Dozen Bagels to go not watch some parents let their kids try to make up their minds on what to order. Don't get me wrong staff is fine but customers don't seem to care there is dozens of people behind them waiting . I will be back but if long line, im going home empty. Wish they had a line for take out just for loose bagels not for ordering coffee and breakfast bagels read more

Run, don't walk to Fancy Bagels! These are the best bagels & bagel sandwiches we've hands down ever had. The bagels are delicious and light yet when toasted a delightful crisp! The line moved decently fast, if you can-call ahead for pick up as there is a separate line when you come in to pick up! The staff was super friendly for a busy Sunday morning and there is plenty of seating to stay and enjoy! We can't wait to come back and try out more if their specialities. Pro tip; on your breakfast sandwich add a crispy hash brown-you won't regret it! read more

See all

The bagels are worth the line, and the sandwiches are fantastic. Def need to be specific on toasting - if not specific, they come very lightly toasted, but that's just about any bagel shop. Always crowded, always loud and noisy- but the staff so a great job at handling the crowds. read more

Arriving at Fancy Bagels late morning the first thing I noticed was they had a huge selection of bagels. While deciding on my choice of bagels, there was an employee restocking freshly baked bagels. Other bagel places that I have been to late morning, you can have a hard time finding any selection at all. We tried two flavors that we never had before sweet cinnamon (which was amazing), and double cheddar. Plus a old favorite cinnamon raisin.Their bagels are simply delicious. We will definitely be returning. read more

See all

It's the best bagels in the area! May not be as good as New York, but top notch for CT!

Went to this place for breakfast and it was pretty good. We ordered two bacon egg and cheese bagels . I got mine on the cinnamon sugar bagel and it was tasty. I will say that the everything bagel was a little too salty for my liking, so I'd skip that flavor. It could've been a bit cheesier but other than that I would go back again. The service was pretty fast even though there was a line! The ambiance was great, a very family friendly establishment. I loved all the decorations on the wall. read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Cinnamon Bagel - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

See all

Freshest bagels I've every tasted! Amazing variety in bagels and stuff to put on 'em! : )!!

A Southington staple! This was our first time at Fancy Bagels after our friend recommended it while we were in the area. A low key joint in a kind of run down plaza with some surprisingly great tasting bagels. Don't let the look decieve you! The hubs got a sausage, egg, and cheese on an asiago bagel and I went with something different. Someone recommend a sweet and salty combo that changed my life....blueberry cream cheese + bacon on cinnamon raisin bagel. *mind blown* I will never have any other bagel combo again! And their cinnamon raisin bagel was A+ During COVID there wasn't a long line on a Saturday morning and they also offer call ahead ordering for easy pickup. Great grab & go breakfast spot when you're in a pinch. read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - blueberry cream cheese + bacon on a cinnamon raisin bagel with a sausage egg and cheese - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

COVID-19 era: More like casual but yummy bagels. Most were gone by 11 am with no jalapeño or blueberry left, but plain and raisin were good substitutes. The store is a bit piecemeal right now because social distancing and the dining area being closed, but part of the dining room is now a coffee area where they pour and prepare. I imagine it's typically a self-serve coffee in non-pandemic times. Our barista (not that we had fancy drink, but I'll call her that) even inquired if they got the color right. If you don't feel like waiting, call ahead--part of the piecemeal is Fancy Bagels has a pick up counter dedicated to phone orders. The local flavor here is fun with a gallery of concert photos on display and bagel flavor paintings. read more

Hands down the best bagels in the area. I have tried many different places but Fancy Bagels gets my vote as #1. Had a talk with the owner one day. Super nice guy. Really cares about delivering a quality product. read more

No skimping here! A poppy seed bagel is covered in poppy seeds--both sides! Same with all the other bagels I have sampled. These bagels have a texture and crunchiness that just surpasses all others. I lived in N.Y. city and tasted bagels from so many places of which none impressed me. This place does. read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Poppy seed, onion, and asiago cheese bagels - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

This is THE spot for bagels in southington! If you go on the weekend, call ahead if you can because it can get a bit busy but it's worth the wait! The bagels here are always fresh and sandwiches made to order. If you like sweet bagels, don't sleep on the cinnamon sugar bagels here, paired with the walnut raisin cream cheese is a dream! Some of my other favorites are the Asiago and you can never go wrong with an everything bagel. They have a great variety of bagel flavors as well as cream cheese flavors, and the staff is always so friendly and kind, definitely give them a try! read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - a variety of bagels - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

Came here for a quick stop, they were super fast even without preordering. All the bagels are displayed behind the counter when you walk in so you can see your delicious choices. I went with the egg bagel toasted with sausage, egg whites, and American cheese. Came to about $5.50, was ready in about 3 minutes, and was piping hot! It was delicious and I can't wait to try another option next time. Looks like they are only open until 2pm and also offer lunch options. The Turkey on a bagel with lettuce, tomato, and onion looked real good. Stop by for breakfast or lunch and I'm sure you won't be disappointed. There is plenty of sitting room in the dining area as well. They also have a variety of coffee. As I was walking out I saw they had a chocolate peanut butter coffee! Next time! read more

This place is popular for a reason!! It's a little annoying trying to get through on the phones to place an order but once you do, it's worth the wait!! The breakfast sandwiches are so good!! Just a heads up though, the bacon is VERY salty but that's no issue for me, love Fancy! read more

I love love love this location. I recently moved from NY and was so excited to have a bagel place so close to my job. This location is super efficient- they take the orders, they make the orders, you get your order. It's simple. They have hash browns, which the Farmington location doesn't. The people in this location are friendly. The bagels are great. My order has never been wrong- although sometimes they don't label when you have multiple orders so if I'm ordering with multiple people, we have to open them all to distribute them- which isn't a big deal. I usually call in my order so I can grab it quickly on my way to work. They always do a great job. The prices have recently gone up but it's definitely worth it for a great breakfast. My coworkers and I only wish they were open later (they close at 2pm) because if we don't get an early lunch break, we miss out. But that's on us, not them! Keep doing everything you're doing, Fancy Bagels Southington! We love you!!! (The Farmington location is inconsistent and we've given up on them unfortunately after multiple chances.) read more

Have been buying bagels at Fancy Bagels in Farmington 15-20 years and they are the best. Also get breakfast sandwiches and some lunch sandwiches. Every thing is good including the service. Highly recommend you won't be disappointed. read more

Fantastic bagel shop with speedy service! I can't believe I just found out they are in the plaza right off Queen St. The place is really big inside and full of cool memorabilia on the walls . The coffee flavors are plentiful as well as the bagel selection. I found myself ordering a egg bagel toasted with steak, egg and cheese on it . Delicious isn't the word!!! It was light and crisp with good ingredients inside. I will definitely order that again. I took home a sugar and cinnamon bagel and a French toast flavor. I have to come back to try their coffee. The speed of my sandwich order was spot on they even have a side to wait for your orders ,so the process is quick especially on busy days or lunch hours. Definitely try them out !!!!! read more

See all

The food is awesome, definitely my favorite place for bagels. The service, not so much. I usually come in between 12 - 2 and somehow most of the time they are out of bagels. They are out of bagels because they give them to customers in order to close earlier. I know this because they've given me a free bag of bagels because they were "getting rid of them." I think this is extremely distasteful considering, your shift is nowhere near over and you could simply give them to a food shelter. I called the other day to order by phone at 12 (they closed at 2) and the women giggled and said they ran out of bagels. I'm so disappointed with the staff here, I understand they're all young girls but they're not even nice either. They're usually standing around chatting and ignoring you when you come up to order. Food is outstanding but only in the mornings I guess. read more

Best bagels in the area love that they support the local community and hire school kids on the weekends.

With the pandemic, I'd prefer an app to order but I called ahead and had a very nice BEC prepared. The everything bagel still has a bit too much garlic for my tastes but the sandwich itself is still solid. The place has adapted for the pandemic with coffee filled by staff and good distancing too. Overall, much better than its unassuming appearance might indicate. read more

From time to time, we will buy three or four dozen and freeze them, we don't know when we need more until we open the freezer and they are gone and then go buy more. What is funny is the lady that works there, when I buy 3 dozen bagels, she says "Can you call the night before and let us know when you are going to need this many?" I would if I could, sorry but I can't. read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - 12:30pm Saturday almost totally out of bagels - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

Been enjoying bagels from here for years and was happy to find that they are as delicious as I remember. Sweet cinnamon has always been my favorite, so picked up a half dozen of those and a dozen and a half of others and put them in the freezer to enjoy later! read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Sweet cinnamon - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

Prior to being gluten-free, I used to stop at Fancy Bagels at least twice a week. That all came to a stop 7 months ago when I learned of my allergy to gluten. I was looking up gluten free bagel spots and came across a review for Fancy Bagels. I stopped here on a busy weekday morning. The staff are very friendly and made sure to clarify my gluten allergy as I had wanted to get lox cream cheese. (The only cream cheese which does not have potential cross contamination is plain). The bagel is smaller than a regular one but has a good consistency. I actually like the slightly crispy bottom and dense inside. Next time I'll have to ask them what ingredients they use. If you find out, let me know. I definitely recommend this place if you're looking for a gf bagel that's tasty and affordable. My only gripe is I wish the bagels were bigger. read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Gluten free bagel list. They keep these bagels separate and ask if you have an allergy. Pleasantly surprised with this list. - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

See all

Great bacon, egg and cheese. Real eggs cooked to order with crispy bacon and whatever cheese you want. Bagels are soft with a great little outside crunch. You can tell it's a family run business with a lot of heart in it. read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Bacon egg and cheese on an Asiago bagel. - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut

Longtime fancy fan, best bagels and sandwiches you can find in the area. That said, have you recently changed the bacon? Must fattier and greasier than the past. Noticed the past few times, I would rather pay $1.00 more and continue to have your crispy delicious bacon of the past. Thanks! read more

First thing I was shocked about was that the shop was bigger than I expected. When I walked up to the counter, you're greeted with a hand written sign that says "don't be rude, don't use your phone when you order" or something like that. I mean, I get it. But also...don't be rude with that sign? I don't know, came off relatively weird to me. There are so many bagels behind the counter which really does allow you to take a look at what flavors they have. I got a pumpernickel with low-fat cream cheese. For a toasted bagel with cream cheese, it was an annoyingly long wait. Pumpernickel almost just tasted like a plain bagel...it's definitely missing something. The cream cheese was great! A little less than $4 for this bagel, so it's okay. I think I'd maybe come back to try another flavor, but I wouldn't go out of my way. read more

Let me start off this review by saying that I have been going to Fancy Bagels my entire life. I have great memories from childhood all the way until now. They have amazing bagels, fantastic service and have been a landmark in our town for years. This is truly one of my favorite places to eat/get breakfast and it pains me to give them a bad review but I must do it because unfortunately they gave me the worst bagel I have ever had in my life. Let me break down what went wrong, I asked for a "onion bagel toasted and buttered with bacon please". They got the order right. The execution was terrible. For a relatively simplistic order it took around 10 mins to get my bagel. It was not that busy at the time I went. I was there around 1pm with about two other customers and most of the bagel selection gone. I'm not complaining about waiting a long time for my food. I don't mind waiting at all. The reason I'm complaining about the time is because it is tied in with executing a good bagel. Unfortunately I think fancy's system is flawed. When you order a "toasted and buttered" bagel at fancy the person at the counter will take your order and then put the bagel in the toaster. Then go back to the front counter to take orders. The cooks in the back (busy working on the griddle) are now in charge of finishing that bagel by buttering it. Sometimes the bagel finishes toasting and then sits for a while becoming cold before the cook can get to buttering it. This two man system sometimes makes for flawed execution. When the bagel is cold the butter is not only harder to spread but also does not melt and that to me is a travesty. To counterattack this problem fancy bagel uses a whipped spreadable butter that is very tasty but easy to put to much of. That is exactly what happened to my unfortunate bagel here. It sat way too long so none of the butter melted and the cook put a three-inch-thick slab of whipped butter on the bagel. I tried to scrape it off and salvage my breakfast but the sea of butter was too much and I had to scrap the meal. In my life I have been to fancy bagel at all times throughout the day. When it is busiest in the morning, to when it was dead right before closing and every time in between. I have never experienced this poor of execution before. I hate to say this because I love fancy and the owner so much. But this type of cold bagel, cold unmelted butter thing has happened to me before recently. This was just the most butter I ever received on a single bagel, making it inedible. Don't even get me started on cooks who only butter one half of the bagel either. Which seemed to have happened here as well (look at the dry top slide of the bagel pictured). This poor execution never happened before fancy expanded into Franks. Everyone use to be in the kitchen so close that they were unable to let bagels cool down. Everything was fresh and flying out of the kitchen. Now that they have more space, and the toasting of the bagel and the application of the spread is a two person job standards seem to have fallen to the wayside. I am super happy fancy is expanding and doing well. But I don't want that expansion in expense of a well executed bagel. The best bagel is hot off the toaster with both sides adequately buttered, warm enough for the butter to melt. That is what a fancy bagel is. That is what I grew up on. That is what it MEANS to be a fancy bagel. Not this monstrosity. I really hope this improves. I want what's best for you fancy. I love you so much. I hope this tough love is enough to wake you up. P.S. I will say something amazing about fancy, the people are amazing. Front counter ace "Jackie" and her crew are some of the most amazing people I ever met. I love them so much. They make fancy worth it every time. Love you Jackie! read more

Fancy Bagels - Southington - Onion Bagel toasted and buttered with bacon. - Burgers Near Me - Southington, Connecticut