Their flavors always look unique on line so we finally stopped in. Quite surprised how spacious the inside was with lots of seating. Friendly staff. Cheesecake was good. A little denser than I personally prefer. We tried the red velvet. My rating rationale +1 Service +1 Food~Taste/flavor/quality +1 Presentation +1 Atmosphere/vibe +1 Value read more

See all

The perfect sweet ending to our Martinsburg day trip! They had about eight different flavors the day we visited. We tried peanut butter, sugar cookie, and coconut cream. The coconut cream was the winner. The shop itself is spacious with ample seating and a very large interior, making it great for families or groups. A must visit if you're in town! read more

See all

I Came in to get a birthday treat for a friend of mine and the daily selection was wonderful- so hard to choose from. I selected the chocolate peanut butter cheesecake. I had forgotten to bring candles on my road trip and they graciously gave me a sparkler candle to put on his birthday cake. read more

Everything Cheesecake - a living room with couches and tables - Bakeries Near Me - Martinsburg, West Virginia

Excellent variety of flavors. Peanut buttercup is awesome. Always fresh! Service is good too.

I tried the reeses and cinnamon toast crunch. the cheesecake was not dense and thick, it was thin. The reese's flavor is very bland. not enough chocolate or peanut butter. The cinnamon toast crunch was better flavor wise. still too thin and I could tell there is either sour cream in the mix or some weird whipped cream cheese. I love cheesecake and make plain and chocolate. So I know cheesecake. The price for a whole cheesecake is also crazy high. $40 to 60 for a cheesecake is too high. Shouldn't cost more than $20 or $25. I know the cost of materials and how long they take. read more

I drove a hour and 45 mins one way to check this place out. I've been following them on Social Media for a long time & Cheesecake is my favorite. First of all the service is great but I have to give 3 stars because I didn't enjoy all of the cheesecakes. I brought 4 slices.. the peach cobbler was my favorite but it was missing half of it. The Cinnamon Toast Crunch was pretty good but the cereal ontop had gotten soggy, same thing with the lucky charms so I wouldn't recommend eating the toppings. The lucky charms was suppose to have cookie dough in it but only had a piece the size of a quarter. The brownie batter was my least favorite because of the texture, the filling wasn't like a cheesecake but more like a pudding. read more

See all

Great local spot offering exceptional cheesecake at an affordable price. We stopped in after hearing about this place from a local and were presently surprised with how welcoming and spacious the interior was. They offer a limited but ever changing selection of well made cheesecakes ranging from candy flavors like Twix to fruit inspired choices like creamsicle and standard NY style cheesecake. They also offer a loyalty card for repeat customers. Their cheesecakes are delicious and flavorful I definitely recommend checking this place out. read more

See all

This cheesecake soooo damn good like what they put in this, they have a unique cheesecake and the new york cheesecake bussin its soo good 10/10 definitely coming back read more

Everything Cheesecake - a variety of cheesecakes on display - Bakeries Near Me - Martinsburg, West Virginia

This has been the best cheesecake I have ever had in my life. Ive traveled a good bit so I was pleasantly surprised to find this in Martinsburg. The salted caramel and reeses are super flavorful and decadant but the specialty flavors never dissapoint. My all time favorite is the cookies and cream but the cinnamon toast crunch and chocolate chip cannoli were delicious as well. read more

The shop is super cute! Very homey with the cheesecake fabulously on display. My husband and I purchased a slice of each of the three flavors that were left as we came in just before closing. Salted caramel, original NY style and orange creamsicle. My absolute favorite was the salted caramel. It was the perfect consistency and a very complimentary flavor to the cheesecake. I am very particular about my cheesecake crust. If it isn't right I will leave it behind and simply eat the filling. This place got it right!!! Praise the Lord!!! I devoured every crumb. read more

I was gifted a piece of peanut butter fudge white chocolate cheesecake. It was the best piece of cheesecake ive ever eaten. Flat out. I don't think I need to elaborate anymore. I think the only way it'll get better is if I go to the actual store myself and bask in cheesecake heaven. read more

Everything Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Martinsburg, West Virginia

The best cheesecake I ever had by far. It's only hard to just have one slice. I love love love the Oreo Cheesecake. I never had any slice from here that I did not just love. This is the type of cheesecake people are happy to wait hours for, happy to get there half an hour before open for. It's the type of cheesecake, you wait in the cold for, wait in the rain for. It's the type of cheesecake you dance while eating. It's the type of cheesecake you just eat it in the car because you can't wait 10 minutes to get home. It's the type of cheesecake you may want to eat by yourself because it's so good you may embarrass yourself. Just remember to breathe when you eat. With her all success she gives so much to the community. She gives Easter baskets during Easter weekend, and free food sometimes regardless of purchase. I love Deanna and admire her work. Also check her out on Lansing State Journal's 6 people to watch for in the Greater Lansing Area. Thank you for amazing cheesecake and your generosity. You're an inspiration. read more

See all

Literally the best cheesecake I've ever had! Wonderful service, great price, and always a variety of options. Better get there quick if you see a special type that you want--it sells quick! The PB cup and the Cinnamon Toast Crunch of my favs, but I do always love the special holiday offerings too! read more

You won't be able to find a sweeter place than this. Haha, get it? SWEETER? Seriously though. We stopped in for pepperoni rolls but they were completely sold out. Not to worry--the incredibly friendly staff made sure that we were taken care of. We left with flavorful, rich, and decadent TRIPLE CHOCOLATE. Yum. Yum. Yum. Next time we're back in town, we'll be in! Wish we lived closer to a cute independent shop with such smiling faces and delicious richness. Definitely a treat! read more

Got the salted caramel and the Cinnamon Toast Crunch and both were delicious. Definitely coming back. read more

Everything Cheesecake - Cinnamon Toast Crunch and Salted Caramel - Bakeries Near Me - Martinsburg, West Virginia

We are from out of town and we travel a lot and when we do, we like to try out the local restaurant and sweet treat places, I've eaten a lot of cheesecakes and I'm originally from New York so I know cheesecake while the actual location was sooo cute, I loved the tables we got ours to go but I definitely took notice of the place however the cheesecake was disappointing we got the pb cup and the consistency was off I'm not sure if it was just mixed to much but it was like a paste cheesecake has a type of texture and this just wasn't it, I hope it was just overly mixed that time. read more

This place is so adorable and quaint. Plenty of seating. Lots of open spaces. The employee I encountered was delightful and helpful. There were plenty of cheesecake options and a couple of scones. Cheesecake flavors included : ny style, sugar cookie, chocolate peanut butter, salted caramel and one or two more I can't remember. I had the sugar cookie. It was cool because it has a cookie dough crust as the bottom. But it was hard to get a bit of cheesecake and crust since they were different densities. The cheesecake was delicious however it was a very small piece of like$5. I would of wanted to pay more for a bigger piece. Personally. But I'd totally return. Delicious! read more

Came here on a whim just out exploring new eats. Sadly we came at the end of the day so we didn't have as much to choose from. The cheesecakes we got were very good and perfect Black Dog Coffee to compliment it. The place is warm, fun and inviting. Come out here with your girls on a girls night or on a sweet dessert date. read more

See all

Like cheesecake? Then...you're going to LOVE this place! Not only is the cheesecake the best that you will find; but, the service and attention to the customer is OUTSTANDING! Multiple flavors are available daily. Most flavors vary from day to day; but, Reese's Peanut Butter and New York Style are daily standards. There is a rewards card that is punched with every slice of cheesecake purchased. After ten punches, FREE cheesecake! You can buy it by the slice or whole. You can even mix the flavors to make the "whole". They also have scones (limited supply) and some really good coffee from Black Dog. read more

See all

Absolutely the best cheesecake I ever had! It was my first time here and I had the salted caramel cheesecake. OMG! It was so delicious. Creamy, tasty, rich, sweet, delectable, smooth, yum, yum, yum!! I didn't think I would finish the whole slice because I normally cannot eat that much cheesecake due to its richness. But this time I did! I had to control myself not to have another slice. Everything Cheesecake will now be my place to go for cheesecake and I highly, highly recommend it. If you have not had the opportunity of going there, it is a must!! You will not regret it. read more

Better stay away from this place so the rest of us can have more of what we want! Other than making your own cheesecake at home from scratch, this is the best New York style cheesecake around. Again, stay away from my cheesecake stash! read more

A hidden gem! Their cheesecake is amazing and we love their rotating flavors. This year for my birthday, I had a cheesecake "cake" from here and it was the best. You can't go wrong with any of the flavors here but the hot fudge sundae and double crust are our absolute favorites. read more

Everything Cheesecake - Assorted cheesecake slices - Bakeries Near Me - Martinsburg, West Virginia

Every time I go there it's closed . They were closed at 1o'clock today .they were supposed to be open till six !!! Not happy !!

Oh my gosh! This place has the best cheesecake I have ever eaten. I am not exaggerating. And they have amazing flavors. The staff is pleasant and helpful. read more

Situated in downtown Martinsburg, Everything Cheesecake has yummy cheesecake and dare I say - the BEST pepperoni rolls in this area. I stopped by today and picked up two slices of Cookies N Cream cheesecake. Upon entering, the decor was simply adorable and cozy. It was so modern, bright, and full of color. It was also very clean. The selection of cheesecakes was pretty diverse. I saw Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, Key Lime, Orange Cream, Salted Caramel, Cookies N Cream, and Original NY Style. As I browsed, I noticed their huge freshly baked pepperoni rolls. The owner noticed my interest and gave me one for free!! How sweet. It was absolutely delicious. Each slice of cheesecake was $5.50. Honestly, the price was fair considering the huge slices that I received. I was also given a reward card for a free slice on my 11th visit. I plan to come back again soon and try all the other flavors! read more

Everything Cheesecake - Cheesecake makes me happy! - Bakeries Near Me - Martinsburg, West Virginia

See all

Oh my goodness!! If you haven't been there, as soon as they're open again you need to go!! I tried the Cinnamon Toast Crunch cheesecake the last time I was there. It was one of the best pieces of cheesecake I have ever eaten, and that includes the ones that I've made! Staff is always polite and efficient. Looking forward to a return visit soon! read more

I haven't had a cheese cake from here that I didn't like. The workers are super nice & very helpful. Great place

I have known the owner Theresa for several years for several years. She is incredible and the most sweetest woman you will ever care to meet. The cheesecake compares to none other and comes second to none! There cheesecake is made with only the freshest ingredients, and each bite is pure bliss! I highly recommend Everything Cheesecake to everyone wanting to taste their own little slice of Heaven. read more

I heard about this place from my boss, and I was told it was amazingly good. I heard it was supposed to be the richest tasting cheesecake around, and I was not lied to! The service was wonderful; my friend and I were greeted at the door, showed how their ordering works, told about flavours, and even offered a punch card for further visits. The cheesecake was just as nice! Peanut butter cup with a lovely drizzle of chocolate. I will be back again to try that cinnamon toast crunch cake people keep talking about! read more

Exceptional. This family-owned business makes "off the Chart's" good cheesecake! I just ate Cinnamon Toast Crunch, my wife had Turtle, and son had Reese's Peanutbutter Cup. The service is ALWAYS with a smile. So hospitable. There is something really special about this place. Fabulous, in all aspects of business ownership and operation, is in the DNA of the Owner's and Employees. Try the place. It is kinda tucked away in Martinsburg WV, but a great little place to bring your loved one for dessert and coffee (Black Dog Coffee). DEFINITELY TRY THIS PLACE. SIX-STARS!!! read more

As soon as you walk in you are welcomed by the owner, she is so sweet and friendly! She has a large variety of cheesecake, and the coffee is delicious! The decor is absolutely perfect! I have found my go to place for a yummy treat!! read more

Everything Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Martinsburg, West Virginia

I thought I had tasted some really good cheesecake in the states until I had the pleasure of visiting this place and its very delicious offerings. I had a piece of the salted caramel, NY style and turtle cheesecake, it was so soft and creamy. Some cheesecakes can be a bit hard and compact but this one had the perfect consistency. I would certainly give 5 stars if the establishment had sugar free/low carb option. Will be nice to Satisfy that sweet craving without the guilt, an espresso machine would also be excellent, and coke ZERO. The place is very clean, friendly staff, always busy but the tables are always empty. I believe that the thing of this place is to buy and take home! The reward card for a free slice is a plus +++ read more

My friends and I are visiting Martinsburg for Veterans Days weekend and found this gem! The cheesecakes are AMAZING. We had one of every flavor available so we pretty much tried everything and nothing disappointed. My friend said she'd drive back from DC for another slice read more

I am not a cheesecake fan - that is to say, I really hate plain cheesecake. You gotta load it up with all kinds of goodies for me to enjoy it, and this place does just that. From key lime to fruity pebbles to my favorite Reese's... they have really great cheesecake and have made me a minor convert. It is pretty pricey, though, so it's a rare treat. Also, typically friendly staff and a punch card available for a free slice. I know they are "everything cheesecake", but I really, really wish they would add just two easy sandwiches and a soup or something to their menu at lunchtime. They are surrounded by hundreds of government employees, many of which work at their desks through lunch and order out, and it would be super awesome to just pop next door to grab a sandwich, some soup, and a slice of cheesecake. I'd much rather spend my money there than fast food or Sheetz or something. read more

Everything Cheesecake is literally THE BEST cheesecake you'll ever taste! Definitely worth the trip to enjoy a slice or two of heaven! Great for parties and special social events. Teresa & her husband are the sweetest people ever! Please support this small business!! read more

The cheesecake is fantastic! Cute little space. If you go during peak times be prepared to park elsewhere (municipal buildings nearby) and walk over. Menu changes daily. read more

Overpriced.. dense cake with thin slices.. poor excuse for NY style .. the server was kind

Well, I really hate to break the chain of 5 stars, and didn't find any reason not to, so here's our additional 5 star review of this amazing place. My wife and I were scrambling to find a very last minute birthday cake and checked Yelp and found this place. It's funny that we've lived in the area for over 10 years and still find hidden gems like this place. My wife went to see what they had and came back with a full cheesecake (mixed flavor). It was awesome. Of course it had the seasonal pumpkin, but also others that were amazing. I personally like one of the large chain cheesecake restaurants, but always placed it below a family friend who makes amazing cheesecakes, well, this has place best them both. My wife said the place was really nice and the person who waited on her was very pleasant and was a huge help in picking out the cake. The cake was very smooth and flavorful and loved the appearance. If you haven't tried it, you're missing out. Our full cake was around $50, but much better than the large chain and better flavor. Supporting local businesses is always up there with us as well. Enjoy, you won't regret it. read more

i keep hearing insane things about this place And i live 40min away! someday i hope to try their cameral cheesecake. read more

The pecan pie cheesecake is to die for!!! Love the quaint atmosphere inside the shop. It's quite cozy. It would be a great place for a small work or family get together. read more