I visited her tonight with a friend and my mom. Overall I'd give it four and a half stars. Outside it doesn't look like a lot, but once inside it's a very nice cafe and well kept. It was very clean. It's small, so be prepared for a wait during peak times. It seems 6:30 is when it fills up. The staff was friendly and helpful. They have a good variety and something for everyone. The spinach dip was excellent. The bread was toasty but soft. It was a nice portion to split between three people. For dinner my mom and I had the rueben, and my friend the steak sandwich. The rueben was a bit messy but very good. The roasted red potatoes were. My only complaint was the fries were over seasoned. My friends steak sandwich was very good. He said the meat was cooked perfectly, and a nice portion. We split the raspberry cake. It was huge. It could have been a bit more moist, but the flavor was great. It was $12, so be prepared for that. Overall if we are in the area we would visit again. read more

See all

Stopped by the Evergreen for a late lunch and was pleasantly surprised! The atmosphere was great, the service was superb and the food was fantastic. 3 stars for the Evergreen Eatery; we will definitely be returning!! We started with an appetizer that hit the spot--light and crispy chicken rolls with a spicy dipping sauce was the perfect way to start our meal. From there, I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich, which was cooked well, and flavored nicely! Nothing extremely unique but it tasted fresh, and the sriracha aioli adding the perfect zing read more

Evergreen Eatery - Southwest Chicken Rolls - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

See all

Passing through Rochester and needed a place to eat so we turned to Yelp for help. Evergreen was an awesome experience from our waitress to our food. If ever in Rochester this MUST be your go to restaurant. One thing to note however: this is not a cheap chain restaurant. You pay for what you get! Thank you Evergreen for a great evening dinner! read more

See all

A good breakfast stop today. 15.00 breakfast. Ham was delicious and added raspberries to the pancakes read more

Evergreen Eatery - Shrimp Bruschetta Omelet - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

See all

Always good food and service. Southwest egg rolls and any dessert are must haves. I wish they would not had reduced the menu, though.

Talk about hidden gems ! This place is the holy grail !!! I stopped in on my way home from South Haven Michigan . The place was packed, but didn't have a long wait . I had their Mushroom and eggs Benedict and a half order Biscuits and gravy. I have never been more satifyed lol you can ask my wife . You also have to try their pancakes! If you are near here you gotta stop in ! read more

We live in Logansport and wanted something different so we started driving to Rochester. Got on Yelp and found Evergreen Eatery had 5 stars so we wanted to try. Oh my goodness!!!! From the staff to the dessert and everything in between was EXCELLENT!! Everything is made there and it showed! We will definitely be going back. Thanks Shelly for being a great waitress! See you soon read more

See all

We are from Michigan, so this was our first time at Evergreen. I would highly recommend it. Service was excellent, the food was fabulous, especially loved the fried chicken. Only wish they served rolls or bread sticks with the entrees. The iced tea was spot on! A good 4.5. read more

We really enjoyed our evening at Evergreen. We started with southwest egg rolls and bruschetta. They were really good and then I had the ribeye and my wife had the walleye and those were excellent. One of our friends had the pork chops and those might have been the taste winner of the evening! We had 4 different desserts and all where wonderful but the bread pudding was the best I ever had! It was so much like my grandma's maybe even better! (Sorry Grandma ) Drinks were really good and our waitress (Virg) was excellent!! We will return. read more

Evergreen Eatery - Southwest egg rolls & Bruschetta. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

I've been a steady customer since the new Evergreen opened. Never a less than perfect meal. Service is always attentive without becoming annoying. Perfect balance. The customers are generally happy to be there so the vibe is nice. You should try breakfast there. It's a pleasant surprise. I never feel overcharged and so I'll be back every chance I get. read more

Everything was delicious! Starting with the appetizers and dtinks, ending with the desserts and after dinner coffee. Virginia was the best waitress ever! Great, great restaurant. Can't wait to come back, going to try breakfast next time! read more

Evergreen Eatery - Chocolate cake, bread pudding with rum sauce, peach crisp with ice cream and carrot cake. Bread pudding was the BEST! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

We had great service, and wonderful food! Everything was hot, and freshly prepared. Inside of the restaurant is really nice as well. Loved the fresh flowers on our table. read more

I am a big fan of their breakfast menu! Each dish is so well presented and very tasty. I tried a couple of their different breakfast plates over the years and have always been impressed with the quality of the ingredients. A great place to get a unique dish in the small town of Rochester. The wait times tend to be long, and I would definitely recommend getting a reservation. read more

Evergreen Eatery - Biscuits and Gravy with French Toast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

See all

Holy moly!!! We were on our way from South Bend back to Indy - we decided to take the detour to this restaurant as there are zero breakfast places on 31 (except McDonald's ). We are so very glad we did. I had the country breakfast. Eggs, bacon and pancakes. The pancakes taste like marshmallows. Kids split the biscuits and gravy. It was perfect - and after they tasted my pancakes I made some trades. Husband got the ham Benedict and love it. We also had a mimosa (you get the split bottle to make your own) and ultimate coffee. All the food as on point, fresh and delicious. Service was above average and they were busy on this Sunday morning. This place is well worth a pit stop from 31. read more

First impression, clean and nice staff. Food...we had their homemade Mac and cheese and burger. Both were delicious. We liked our artichoke mushroom appetizer. Cheesecake was yummy. Simple environment but worth going again to try all their other items. Glad this place is in town on the main drag and easy parking. read more

This morning's breakfast service and food were excellent. Very good coffee. Recommended.

Great local eatery. Highly recommend. Service was great, food spectacular and restaurant had a lot of charm for a small town restaurant (and very clean!). We'll be back! read more

Terrible customer service! Long wait for lunch. Almost 1.5 hours. Charged for a bad beer and told that I was charged since they couldn't pour it back into the tap. Greasy fries. No one checked to see how our food was. Terrible customer service and long wait. Food is just ok. Go somewhere else! read more

I had an excellent experience at this eatery. My date and I had the spinach dip and it was so good! I love that they have so many specials and everything is cooked to perfection! Great little addition to Rochester, IN! read more

Love this little place in Rochester! This was the perfect place for a girls day out lunch with my grandmother while I was in from out of town! She's still raving about their crab asparagus soup! Evergreen was running lunch with one server! She did an excellent job & kept up with the busy lunch rush so well! Our server Kerriea (spelling is prob wrong) was so kind & patient with my disabled & deaf grandmother! She patiently took our order & had great recommendations! The Caesar salad was amazing! With big chunks of shaved Parmesan & a really great Caesar dressing! My grandmother loved her shrimp & also liked the option of just getting it plain with salt & pepper! I had a few sips of her crab asparagus soup & it was really lovely! I really enjoyed the salmon BLT! The salmon was cooked perfectly! In a world of supply shortages, staffing shortages & local restaurant closures, it's nice to have a meal that makes your forget about that! read more

I found this place thanks to Yelp reviews on our way from Indy to Northern Indiana. I'm so glad we stopped here. It's the cutest restaurant and the food was delicious. We went at lunch time but I really wanted to try their breakfast menu so we'll be making the 75 minute drive eat breakfast there soon. read more

Evergreen Eatery - Spinach dip - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

See all

Wonderful food and great staff Get there early if you want Sunday Brunch as it stops when someone wants lunch read more

The food was so delicious, be ready if you order cake it is a massive slice. For a small town venue I was very satisfied with the menu sophistication. My fish was a shrimp/scallop pasta in a vodka sauce and it was a great dish!! read more

Rochester has needed a spot like the Evergreen. The interior is exposed brick wall with John Lennon and Marilyn Monroe among other pop art spotting the walls. It was Mother's Day, and the staff was very accommodating at getting our table of 7 in before their closing time. Our server was friendly and helpful. Our whole table enjoyed all of our food. We had salads, chicken Alfredo, filet medallions, and perch as well as cake and crisp for dessert. They have some nice kids meals at a reasonable price. I was pleased to see their wine list included the standards as well as some sweets from some Indiana wineries. We will look forward to trying more of the menu on our next visit. read more

See all

Driving home to Indy from Lake Michigan, looking for something different.. this place had good reviews and 4.5 stars! And I know why!!! It was very good, from the service, cleanliness, and all the delicious food! It was a perfect pit stop! With all covid stuff happening this restaurant was doing everything to ensure there was social distancing with tables 6feet apart, employees were all masked and someone was going around wiping not only the top of the table down but the chairs and backs of the chairs too! It started with the host telling us our table of 3 it would be a 10 minute wait.. no big deal! It was 11:50am and breakfast ended at noon. So she made sure to ask if we were getting breakfast or if we wanted to wait and get lunch. We wanted breakfast! We were sat, ordered some coffee! They gave creamer and sugar packets. (I do prefer the little cups of creamer so I can add vanilla flavor and I know how much creamer is being added) The server asked if my baby needed milk or anything to drink, which I thought was nice because at most places they don't even acknowledge the baby! We ordered ham Benedict with hashbrowns on the side! Shrimp and bruschetta omelette and I added avocado on top with an English muffin and raspberry jam! I loved the shrimp and bruschetta omelette! HIGHLY RECOMMEND ORDERING IT! Lots of REALLY GOOD AND FRESH food for such a reasonable price and GREAT staff! read more

Evergreen Eatery - Shrimp and bruschetta omelet with avocado and an English muffin - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

See all

Nice atmosphere and decor and big windows are nice. Great service friendly wait staff and awesome food!

Very good got the seafood bisque and langostino pasta. Both were very good and iwl be back for more. read more

See all

We passed this place on the way to an antiquing adventure and decided it would be our lunch spot. The decor is clean and cute---a little modern, a little rustic, but warm and inviting. My husband and I both opted for salads. My spinach bacon salad was delicious. The egg was initially left off, but I notified the waitress and she brought some promptly. No harm done! It's rare I'm sad when I get to the bottom of a salad, but I sure was today. My husband liked his Cobb salad, but I'm preeeetty sure it couldn't have been as good as mine. We shared a piece of the six-layer chocolate cake for dessert. Honestly, six people could have shared this six-layer cake! It was HUGE! See the picture. Really, it was crazy. We cut it in half before we started and STILL shared a bigger-than-average slice of cake. It was rich and delicious, and the saved slice will be enjoyed again later! read more

Evergreen Eatery - So. Much. Cake. Really good, but plan on sharing it and still taking lots home! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

We had a great dinner, the service was top notch. The food was fresh & delicious. We highly recommend Evergreen. read more

Stopped on our way south from Michigan. Very surprised how good the food was! We had lunch. Ruben had real corned beef and husband loved his burger. Had a bowl of the daily soup which was very tasty too. Nice surroundings and largest, cleanest restrooms I've been in for a long time read more

My wife and I took her cousin and his son there on the way from Bloomington to South Bend. I was looking for a place that served fresh, local, and as organic as possible and certainly Evergreen fit that bill. The food was very tasty, very well prepared, and for what you get, a very good deal. The local organic Amish green beans were exquisitely prepared, tender but still with a little bite to them, and still green, not an over-cooked olive drab. They were finished with a drizzle of a very ordinary olive oil and could have benefited from a light dusting of parmaseano reggiano or some fleur de sel. The rosemary potatoes were done perfectly and finished with a golden toastiness. I had the marinated skirt steak sandwich with grilled onions and red peppers, Olga had the ahi tuna (just rare on the inside--perfect!), Alexey had the grilled tenderloin and Nikita had the rueben--his first. Virginia was our server. It was filling and delicious, the perfect amount of food, and the total was just shy of $50. It did seem to take a tad long for the food to be served, but for the quality it was worth it. I imagine the proprietors are walking a tight line between elevating the palate of the community and serving really good food. Stepping up the condiments would be a good, inexpensive way to elevate their game. They are provisioned by Sysco, so I was skeptical of the table salt, and they could use a better ketchup and mayonnaise like Sir Kensington's, instead of the bulk industrial mayo and Heinz ketchup. We would definitely go 2 hours out of our way to dine there again, and are very enthusiastic about Evergreen. read more

A little Expensive sides for sandwiches -condiments extra charge for each, small portions

My wife and I enjoyed our 2020 Valentines Day dinner at the Evergreen Eatery. It was our first visit, and was on a busy date night. We had reservations, and were immediately seated. The service was excellent, the meal was good, as was the dessert. The only negative was the incorrect mood lighting. The dining room is incredibly well lit by hanging fixtures and recessed spotlights. It was brighter than my office at work. Really detracted from what is supposed to be a romantic night out. Otherwise it was all around excellent. Will definitely eat there again. read more

We had my bridal shower at Evergreen this weekend and had a great time! The staff at the restaurant were very nice, attentive and ensured we had everything we needed. They accommodated several requests we had to make it special and the food was great! The bruschetta and southwest rolls were yummy and very flavorful. Would highly recommend Evergreen for events and special occasions.. we'll be back! read more

Evergreen Eatery - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

See all

My Mom and I stopped here for lunch as we were traveling from Indianapolis to South Bend. What a delicious lunch (Ruben and Grilled Tenderloin). Fantastic food and Virginia (manager) provided awesome service. Highly recommend, you will not be disappointed!! read more

I am so happy to see such a fine restaurant like this crop up in Rochester. It has really brightened up Main Street. The environment inside is clean and modern. It is my understanding that they even have live music from time to time. I had the 4 oz steak sandwich. It wasn't just a slab of meat on a bun. They cooked the steak perfectly and sliced it into bite-sized pieces onto a toasted baguette. On top they added an asiago ranch which paired perfectly with the rest of the sandwich. Will definitely eat here again! read more

Great service, very charming environment. Food was served hot and fresh. If your in the area stop in and treat yourself.

Stopped by for dinner while traveling. The service was attentive, food was very good and the atmosphere was inviting. The hostess provided the kids with coloring books and games to play. Family friendly but could come as a couple and be happy! read more

This place is fantastic! We were driving from a Norte dame game and had dinner. The restaurant is funky and warm. The food was delicious. We had fish, steak and shrimp. The service was equally as good. Ruth the owner came and told us about the food and turns out her son and I Had a common connection. It was great to meet you and good luck with your business. Matthew Smith Vancouver BC read more

Wonderful service and tasty food! We stopped on a trip to Southern Michigan and had such a nice server (Allison). Great for adults and our toddler loved it too. Recommend the six-layer cake! read more