My new favorite candy store in Brooklyn. I spent a recent afternoon in Bushwick and I happily stumbled into Eugene J. Candy Co. It's more than an amazing store with an incredible selection of candy, It's charming, friendly and has a magical quality. Eugene is so friendly, ready to help with a smile and made me feel welcome. It was so hard to choose, I wanted everything. Eugene's has his very own candy creations (now my mouth is watering). "Freaks" are Eugene's version of Nerd's but so much better! He makes them in several flavors, and they are amazing! Who knew I would like chocolate covered cornflakes? I am a chocolate lover but I would never have thought of this combo. They are melt in your mouth while, being crispy at the same time. There is a large selection of gummies in so many varieties and flavors. I felt like I went back in time with many childhood candies that I haven't seen in years. I didn't know that candy waxed lips, fangs and mustaches still existed. I totally had to buy my dad Mary Jane's, such a classic candy. I most definitely will be back. Thank you Eugene! read more

The Freaks (Eugene's homemade version of Nerds) are a must try. The citrus flavors (grapefruit, orange, lemon, and lime) are flavored with essential oils and the grapefruit ones taste like a super packed version of my favorite grapefruit gummies. They're bigger and crunchier than the original Nerds, honestly better in every way. After my first trip, I was back within the week for more. For chocolate lovers, there are a plethora of chocolate covered candies and cereals. My go to are the matcha white chocolate covered Frosted Flakes. read more

Very cute candy store! There are a lot of unusual candies and chocolates here. Sadly when I visited the proprietor's own candies were sold out, but he pointed me in the direction of some other chocolate covered goodies that I'd never seen before (like chocolate covered gushers!). You can mix and match, and pay by the pound. The price was very reasonable and I enjoyed my treats. Looking forward to returning to hopefully get some of the sweets Eugene makes. read more

Wow. Just wow. I'm stunned. My husband and I moved to the neighborhood in November and it took us until last weekend to actually go. And wow we're we blown away. We opted to shy away from anything that we could get anywhere else and the guy at the register was super helpful. He had great advice and even let us try a few things. Turns out he's the owner of the store. This guy is DEDICATED and his candy is incredible. He was telling us about how he gets up at 3 am to make candy and the whole thing is kind of just his show. And his candy is just awesome and creative and inventive. His attention to detail is impeccable - this shell is just the right amount of crunchy, the triple dipped malt balls are beautifully thick, each color of freaks has its own unique flavor that really comes through and OH MY GOD THE GUMMIES. Best gummies I've ever had. They're literally perfect. Anyway thanks Eugene. Your store is fantastic, your candy is spectacular, and I can't wait to come back. read more

Eugene J. Candy Co. - Freaks and SuperFreaks! - Candy Stores Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The most delightful place in all of Bushwick. Candy made in house by the store owner, Eugene, who is a remarkably kind person. If you haven't been, go! Get some freaks! read more

Found this place while craving candy and was AMAZED by the reviews. Had to take a pilgrimage with 5 good friends and we were all equally impressed. The candy is DELICIOUS and the decor triggered that magic nostalgic feeling that I'm always hunting for. What a selection! Try the freaks (Eugene's homemade and superior nerds). How lucky were we to also find Eugene himself behind the counter-- humble, kind, and clearly a Willy Wonka in his own right. Oh trust...I'll be back. read more

Eugene may or may not be the reason I've gained 10 pounds in the past month, but no regrets. This is one of my favorite local shops in Bushwick, and I always stop by if I'm in the area. Eugene's has so many different candy types, from old nostalgic packaged candy to pick n mix to novelty candy. The owner (Eugene) makes a lot of his own candy, like 'Freaks' (sort of like a supersized Nerd) to chocolate covered Cheerios. I always tend to go for the pick n mix selections, as I'm obsessed with gummies and they have varieties of candy I've only ever seen in Sweden before. There are also so many candies from my childhood that you can't find in other stores, as well as a bunch of fun novelty candies (including a huge Harry Potter section). At the register, you can also choose from fancy chocolates or giant rice krispie treats (the s'mores one is amazing). I can never control myself in here, but I can't keep away! read more

I came here to return a package because they do Happy Returns here. I didn't expect it to be a cute local candy store. I chatted with the owner and he is a very nice person with a very interesting story. Since young, his hobby was making candy and now he has created his own business doing just that. I would definitely give his stuff a shot. I can't resist gummies and I ended up walking out with a bag full of them. He has a bunch of varieties with different flavors. There's a bunchhh of other stuff but I was so focused on the gummies because I have a problem lmao. This is definitely a local store I want to support whenever I'm in the area! read more

This is the cutest candy shop in Brooklyn. It's so creatively decorated, you could spend hours just looking at everything. They have sooo many options, and LOTS of old school candy. Super nostalgic. If you decide to go any month of the year, go in October!! They go all out for Halloween! read more

Although small, this store has a mighty selection. Today I was just browsing but had to try some Halloween gummies. Picked out some gummie eyeballs and brains, thinking they would be basic gummies. I was so wrong! They're delicious and fresh! And to my surprise, they're even mushy on the inside like eyeballs and brains! Wow Thanks for a surprising experience today! read more

Having a candy store is so old school and at the same time has grown so rare. Think about it, how often do you encounter a dedicated candy store? Furthermore, how often is it independently owned? Yeah, there's a fair amount of gimmicky ones, chains that one can see in many cities, but this one is unique. They have a lot of candy that I have never heard of, I usually pick up at least one item that I've never had before, just to ensure I am experiencing as much as possible. There's also various candies one can bag and pay by weight, all high quality. The owner makes his own stuff, too. There are, are I say, artisanal Nerds-esque candies called "Freaks." There is even a variation that has Kava in it, which is a root that is very calming when ingested. There are some fancy chocolates next to the register as well, salted dark chocolates with peanut butter in them, peanut butter cups, crackers dipped in chocolate, etc. All delicious (I know, I've checked). Ironically it's a small store, so while there's a fair variety of candy, being overwhelmed should be no concern. It's kind of the perfect scenario. You should go and check it out for yourself. :) read more

The Most Creative Candies in New York! There's too many good things to say about Eugene and his fantastic store! How many sweet shops can you say actually make their own creations? I stumbled upon this store while on a random visit to Bushwick and it honestly made my day. Most candy stores in NYC - great as they are - typically are resellers. While Eugene J. does have a wide selection of sweets that are from other producers, there's still a lot of care and attention to what is offered and the curation of sugary treats is excellent.  But the stuff he makes? Oh man. "Freaks," which are his supersized take on Nerds, are amazing. Each one has a different flavor and they last really long (if you don't give in to the temptation to just bite into them). And the chocolate covered corn flakes have this great crispy texture like nothing I've had before.  You have to get the chocolate covered cheerios, too - they have this delicate outer candy coating reminiscent of an M&M, but they look like mini dinosaur eggs or some sort of holiday delight. It's hit after hit in his store and I loved everything I picked up during my first time there. My only regret is I didn't buy more.  And as many other reviewers already mentioned, Eugene himself is a real pleasure to be around. He's super friendly and open, gave me lots of fantastic recommendations when I asked for them (but left me alone to make my mind up), and was an excellent conversationalist.  Simply put, Eugene J. Candy Co. is exactly the kind of place that makes New York such a great city to live in. A hidden gem with an owner who is passionate about his craft, whose workmanship and dedication to quality really shows in the product and speaks for itself. read more

See all

I recently moved to Brooklyn and thought it was lacking in candy stores. After googling candy stores in Brooklyn, I knew I had to check this place out. I was very impressed when I wandered in to Eugene J. Candy co. They have all the necessities plus Halloween themed candy I hadn't seen anywhere else! I got everything I was looking for; nerds rope, laffy taffy, smartie candy necklaces and bracelets, sour punch straws, candy by weight, and they even have Rice Krispies treats from the crispery. The guy working at the counter was very kind and knowledgeable about the candy. He made recommendations that were very helpful. Definitely recommend this place to anyone who loves candy! read more

When i think about reviews, i think about how completely a place a place exists in its own definition. This is how i can comfortably give Eugene J's the same rating that I feel for Gramercy Tavern. Eugene J's haunted candy store is completely and charmingly its own world. The candies, the decor & the friendly, expert staff are all top-notch. The scoop-able treats are always fresh & feature enough variety to be exciting, yet not too much of a selection that could be overwhelming. Eugene J makes a few of its own candies which are stupendous for lovers of multi-textured sweets. Hunks of cereal nestle inside smooth chocolate and wear a fashionable candy crunch coating in seasonal colors. The same craftsmanship shows up in the "Freaks," an in-house Nerds-like satisfying tart chew. I come here when i want to indulge or when I'm picking up unique edible novelty gifts. A neighborhood treasure! read more

Whimsical, amazing, delicious! A walk back through childhood. This spot has any and all of your candy needs- plus some! read more

See all

Super cute place and nice owner. Lots of options and some really brings back memories. I thought the Pet Ray Gummy was adorable although my friend wasn't a fan. Eugene, the owner makes his own candy (floral) and it's great. He sells CBD gummies (help with sleep, stress relief, anxiety, etc.) I'd definitely have to come back for some candies on one of my cheat day read more

See all

You know those moments when you really like something you've purchased and you keep looking at it over and over again because it gives you this odd satisfaction? That was me the evening I came home with my bag of candies from this cute but formidable shop. Most of the candies I chose were handmade by Eugene and my god, they were delicious. My favorite was the chocolate covered Cinnamon Toast Crunch. Looking forward to returning and trying one of those giant, decadent looking rice crispy treats near the register. read more

I love going to Eugene Js! When in Bushwick be sure to go there and enjoy very fresh gourmet candy treats. During Coronavirus I see that it is possible to call in your order and I think that is a great idea. Then while walking on Wilson Ave, pick up your order. It will brighten your day! I recommend the snow caps, peanut butter cups, mint dark chocolates, milk chocolate covered pretzel pieces, black licorice. Those are my current favorites! read more

A wonderland of whimsy. Eugene keeps every nook & cranny stocked with delicious and surprising treats. The off-kilter shelves are bursting with nostalgic childhood candies, literary sweets, and specialties from around the globe. Not to mention the fresh chocolates & decadent rice Krispies treats. It is a joyful place & I hope it sticks around forever. read more

"I want the world. I want the whole world. I want to lock it all up in my pocket. It's my bar of chocolate. Give it to me now." -Veruca Salt Chocolate, candy, and sweets can bring the inner Veruca Salt out in many of us! My sweet tooth has been building up more and more over the years. Luckily the only golden ticket needed to get into this small candy kingdom is an MTA pass. Eugene J Candy Co is a great little addition to the NE part of Bushwick. Located in a small shop on Wilson that used to house the great pins and patches crew known as Scumbags and Superstars (now in the LES). Hopefully their great neighborhood mojo has been passed on. I mean nothing goes better with Monster Movie greats like some sweet or sour candy and this place is a perfect stop on your way to a double feature at Syndicated Bar & Theater down the street! Although the store is rather small, it packs a punch, a sour patch punch! You can get not only your classic old school candies and holiday needs like peeps for easter but also many gourmet offerings. With options like Ladybug Truffles, Sea Salt Caramels. Speciality chocolates, featuring classic brands like Double Stuff Oreos and Ritz PB Sandwiches and original takes on mints and peanut butter cups. The proprietor seems knowledgeable, young, creative and very friendly and helpful. Theres something great and innocently childlike about going into a candy shop and picking out a sweet for the day. Eugene J Candy Co is helping to keep that ability alive. read more

See all

Eugene, who this place is named after, makes his own candy and owns this establishment. Super super cool vibes inside this candy store, we came and it was decorated for Halloween which I loved! He has chocolate behind glass container and a wild assortment of global candies. Tons of gummy offerings available here as well! read more

It's like a candy museum! This is the best candy shop I've ever been too. Eugene has the most unique and interesting candy and I love going there for treats for myself and gifts for friends. He even makes his own Kava flavored nerds, he has old school flavored candy wax lips, and kits to make your own candy (Japanese Ramen and sushi kits, make your own gum, and create your own candy popsicles). I like supporting this local business and the owner is really passionate about his shop and it's a special place. read more

Eugene J. Candy Co. - My candy from Eugene's :) - Candy Stores Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I LOVE this place!!! It's an absolute gem! A truly unique shop with tons of candy, old and new. I am a candy nut and you'll be able to get your hands on all the classics as well as things you've never seen before. Eugene is super friendly and he even makes his own nerds that he calls Freaks. I highly suggest buying them. No doubt the best candy shop in all of NYC and definitely the best one I've ever been to. read more

This is the best candy store in NYC. Halloween themed anything is amazing and this place exemplifies it via selection, decor and even lighting! The shop owner is a great dude who is super nice and helpful and makes coming here even more of a pleasure! read more

I absolutely adore Eugene's candy store. I've been there a couple times and it really is like walking into a real life Willy Wonka Factory! Every time I've been there Eugene J. has been behind the counter. He's a lovely, friendly guy and always has good suggestions if you're indecisive when given too many choices. I certainly am and really enjoyed his guidance. He always has new candies, some that he imports and some that he makes himself. It's always interesting. The candy is definitely more expensive than if you had bought bagged candy at the supermarket, but its totally worth it. You walk into the store and feel like a kid again. It's too much fun! read more

See all

Eugene presides over this magical sweet emporium like a Bushwick Willie Wonka! There is every candy you could ever want and many memories from your childhood. And Eugene is kind and fun. read more

Eugene J is the Willy Wonka of Bushwick. Charming, iconic, Halloween 365 and right next to a smoke store, Eugene J's collection of candies are tastefully curated, and gave the locals sweet relief in the time of pandemic read more

Super cute candy store! Loved the selection of stuff they had, and the decorations were very nice.

I love Eugenes!! This is a must go to place when I'm in the area. Great customer service and knowledge on some very delicious sweets. My mother loves the truffles Eugene has to offer and my son loves his mini mario/pokemon section. Eugene also has a great selection of sour candies, cool throwback sweets and an endless variety of gummies. I've been hooked since he first opened and continue to do business with him. Come in check out what he has to offed. You won't regret it!!! read more

The staff here was so friendly and accommodating. It's a good deal, especially for the bulk bins, and the selection is impressive for the size of the store. The next time I'm craving sugar, this will be the first place I go. I highly recommend it, they have a handful of specialty items I didn't even know I wanted. read more

Eugene is very kind and extremely knowledgeable about the merchandise. My boyfriend visit at least once a week for the amazing strawberry marshmallows and rice krispie squares. You are doing a great service to the community Eugene, haha! read more

OMG!!! The triple chocolate malt balls are TO-DIE-FOR!!! This is a great little candy shop tucked in a Bushwick street. The attendant was friendly and courteous, and the selection was wide. Our family left the shop very happy read more

Love this little Bushwick gem! Eugene is a master craftsman of candy himself (those marshmallow bars are otherworldly). Beyond his own goods, step inside to peruse a wide variety of classic, new and interesting bulk candy (gummy sours please!) along with plenty of packaged items. I promise that you'll find something for yourself and if you are feeling generous, a number of gifts for friends. He's also got some neat/cute/crafty pins and non-candy items. Step inside this mini wonka land and leave a better person. read more

Eugene's is a neighborhood staple for Bushwick. There's so many great selections, especially the ones Eugene makes. Try the chocolate covered corn flakes, the chocolate covered Cheerios and his famous Freaks (better version of nerds). You won't be disappointed you went! read more

I'm not going to lie, when I first found out a CANDY SHOP was opening in my neighborhood, I judged it harshly. Until I went in one night to see what it was all about. First off, Eugene is probably the sweetest store owner you'll ever meet in all of north Brooklyn, I felt like he cared about what sort of candy shopping experience I'd leave his store with. We got to talking a little, and he makes some himself (chemistry background). Second, this place has every candy from your childhood, and some. All the old school brands and packaging you thought were extinct live at this store. But they also have bomb baked goods like a giant brick of marshmallows rice krispies treat covered in chocolate. This place is magical. Go spend your money there. read more

Words cannot describe the tenderness and appreciation I have for Eugene J. Candy Co. Eugene is always there for me- he is the one constant in my life, and I am so grateful for that. His store is phenomenal, and it has all kinds of candy you could ever want. I was in a search for junior mints a few weeks ago, and I went to every grocery/corner store from Maria Hernandez to Eugene's, and Eugene was the only place that has Junior Mints! And he is open so late, perfect for when you get home from work 3 hours later than planned and need a quarter pound of gummy's. Eugene, thank you for all you do. You do not know how much you mean to me, and everyone else you serve. Thank you :) read more

I have been on yelp for the last 5 years and never once did I ever review a place, except for this one, so you know this place has got to be good. This store is Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory meets Nightmare Before Christmas. Eugene is always friendly and is always playing some wonderful music on the stores system. You got all kinds of pick and weight em candy/chocolate choices. Classic candies from the 90's and beyond, candy inspired by pop culture fads of today ( Duff 'Beer' cans, Ricky and Morty gummies) as well as candies and chocolates that Eugene makes himself. Whenever I am in the area I make sure I make a pit spot, and you should as well. read more

This place filled me with wonder that I haven't felt since I went to the penny candy shop my grandmothers friends owned. What a blast of fresh retail air. Eugene is lovely and so is his well curated collection of candy. It makes me feel great visiting local establishments owned and operated by someone who truly cares about their business. Get the freaks and the chocolate gummy bears! read more

Eugene is the nicest and most patient owner/operator in retail. The candy is pricey which is why I can't give a five star review. But the customer service is exceptional. Can I give 4.5? My only complaint is EVERYTIME I go in, he tries to give me the cashew clusters when he KNOWS I only order the peanut butter cups!!!! AARRGH!! Such a small problem to have. We love this place. LOVE! read more

I've never found a candy store with a wider selection or a nicer owner! Go to Eugene's for all of your throwback candy needs, as well as chocolate covered Oreos, chocolate covered ritz crackers, and my new favorite, peanut butter caramel corn. read more