If you want the best experience buying a car, go see Leo at this location. He's a great resource…read moreand knows a ton about all the cars. He's not a typical salesman, we didn't feel that unpleasant pressure like we've experienced at all the other dealerships. Just a super nice guy, knows a ton, and did everything he could to advocate for us to get a car we love. The rest of the crew was great to work with as well, all very nice and enjoyed working with them. If you're turned off by how other dealerships work, give Leo a shot, it was a genuinely pleasant experience..

I usually don't write reviews and this dealership is horrendous. All the bad reviews deserve a…read moreplace and I've gotten multiple recalls here and all nightmares experiences. But I will say Cameron helped me out on my vehicle that needed a gas tank replacement and he was amazing timely kind compassionate, and lovely. That's why I'm writing this review because the one star of this whole establishment is Cameron! So glad for him.

Unfortunately, the worst car shopping experience I have ever had due to customer service. To make a…read morelong & drawn out story short, I've bullet pointed the prominent contributions to my experience: Ordered a Mazda CX-30 to be shipped from Texas. January 15: Spoke with German, who said the vehicle was flagged for repair before shipping (later stated it was a title transfer issue). January 16: Informed reservation would expire the next day; told to schedule an appointment immediately. January 17: Asked about "express pick-up" before seeing or test driving the vehicle (declined). Met Aaron, who became primary salesperson. Test drove vehicle; decided to return Monday to finalize decision. Had to reschedule Monday appointment; Aaron said Saturday would be fine. January 20: Received message that vehicle hold was at 6 of 7 days and an appointment must be scheduled immediately to avoid losing reservation. Scheduled Saturday, 1/24/26 at 3 PM; received confirmation text. January 21 (6:29 PM): Cristiona (Sales Manager) stated appointment was scheduled in error and vehicle would be released unless customer came in that evening. Expressed frustration about lack of clarity regarding 7-day hold policy. Felt pressured to provide documentation to create buyer's order before second appointment. Declined to move forward without planned visit. Saturday Appointment: Noticed full tank showing only "170 miles until empty." Low key fob battery warning. Requested battery replacement and service check for gas gauge. Aaron agreed to replace batteries. Aaron and Cristiona refused service check on gas gauge; stated vehicle would self-adjust and referenced 10-day return policy. Felt pressured to complete purchase. Asked to leave vehicle on lot until partner could pick it up; felt unheard as Cristiona repeatedly focused on reservation expiring. Aaron commented, "I could never do her job," after interaction. Waited for finance processing while Aaron assisted other customers. Completed purchase; vehicle left on lot for later pickup. Vehicle Pickup: Full tank now read "160 miles until empty." Approximately 9 miles into drive home, "Engine Oil Level Low" warning appeared. Researched warning; advised to stop vehicle immediately due to potential low oil pressure. Upon parking at home: oil warning, tire pressure light, and low key fob battery warning all active. Contacted Dean (Sales Manager). Arranged for vehicle to be towed next morning. Service findings: Oil filter and drain plug seal leaking (required replacement). Battery disconnected and instrument cluster reset to correct gas gauge. All tires underinflated. Key fob batteries needed replacement. Frustrated because gas gauge and key battery issues were raised before purchase but not addressed. Requested dealership keep vehicle; planned to return it within return window. Attempted to contact Aaron regarding title assistance; message left on read. January 31: Called twice requesting Aaron; told messages would be relayed. No return call that evening or following business day. February 2: Returned to dealership to complete return agreement. Assisted by Casey. Casey acknowledged experience was not typical but stated he may have responded similarly regarding gas gauge concern. Aaron approached, asked what was wrong. Expressed dissatisfaction and lack of follow-up. Aaron stated he was busy until 9:30 PM Saturday; did not acknowledge lack of Monday follow-up. Observed unprofessional behavior (frustrated gestures, walked back to his desk and frustratingly pushed a chair, walked out of the office for 10 minutes). Overall experience included: Confusion and pressure regarding reservation/hold policy. Dismissal of mechanical concerns prior to purchase. Multiple preventable mechanical issues immediately after purchase. Lack of communication and follow-up from sales staff. Unprofessional conduct from management and sales representative. Result: Returned vehicle and lost trust in dealership due to poor communication, pressure tactics, unresolved mechanical concerns, and lack of accountability.

Went here to look at cars, spent an hour on the lot narrowing down what we wanted to test drive, so…read morethen we went in to ask about a test drive. The guy at the desk put our name in and told us no one was ahead and it would be 5-10 minute wait. We left after 30 minutes of no one coming to assist us. I've had much better customer service at small, local lots.

These people basically can take your car. Someone (stranger) can call them up, and say "Hey, you…read morewant to buy my car?" The recycle towing people, including peddle, do not require a title, or keys. Just someone's word . I have had not one, but two cars stolen from auto recycling places. No one called me to verify. Someone I don't even know, called auto recycling, told them the car belonged to (insert name here) . Auto recyclers paid this random stranger and straight up stole my fucking car. This can't possibly be legal. I still have both titles and the names of the people who lied , saying the vehicle belonged to them. So I will be taking it to court. However , Colorado recycling towing, should not be taking vehicles without some sort of verification. I could run up and down the street selling random cars , getting paid to sell someone else's vehicles . Apparently it's not illegal . It keeps happening to me. These places need to be put out of business. Either that or have tougher verification standards . Wtf!! Stop stealing cars assholes !!

All Heads Up! i had…read morea 1967 implala convertible stored at RMS storage. Agreed to $300 on phone, (that isn't even the value of the hood). When half wit shows up doesn't know anything about what he is buying, then offers $200, I start to walk away and counter at $250 he takes it. Issue is they said $300 on phone after I shared pic. Dont trust these people. They are bogus buyers. They got a deal at $300 and still thought it necessary to rip off the seller. Bogus Buyers! Why I sold (RMS storage) is another rip off story.

Got my first car from here in June 2025 and I got a nearly brand new vehicle with a warranty that…read moregets me where I need to go with confidence, Being a new owner of a vehicle is nerve wracking and these guys set me up for success thanks to everyone here and Isaiah sales man

Drove 45 minutes for scheduled appointment to do a test drive on vehicle. Spent 15 minutes…read morechecking out the body of the car, the engine, etc. Attempted to start the car, and the battery was dead!!! Complete waist of my morning. I would not recommend this dealership.

Tito would not honor his original price and kept decreasing the price when negotiating his already…read morelow offer. Would not recommend

Called him up he paid what he promised. They even go there in 30 mins. Top notch customer serviceread more

This is a great company to work with if you are trying to get rid of a car quickly. From start to…read morefinish Eddy not only showed up on time to tow my car but he was able to give me cash in hand right then and there without any delay. Eddy was friendly and the transaction was smooth. Thanks again Eddy.

From the owner: We buy junk carsread more

I've been a loyal customer of Mike Shaw Subaru for several years and have purchased four vehicles…read morehere. The team has consistently provided excellent service and has always treated my family with respect and care. Most recently, I brought my son in to purchase his first Subaru WRX. John Vang assisted us from start to finish, and his patience, kindness, and knowledge made the experience smooth and enjoyable. It's rare to find a dealership that stays this consistent over the years. We truly appreciate the team at Mike Shaw Subaru and we will be purchasing more vehicles there in the future.

BEST AROIND I LOVE THIS LOCATION!!! i've been going here for years now and never had any issues…read more They run three oil change deals sometimes where it's $160 for three oil changes OMG, what a good deal. The staff has always been nice to me. They have a nice waiting room with coffee for you. I love it. Thank you, Subaru. You rock.

Very impressed with the level of service, prompt communication, and a fair price…read more I had tried CoPart, Wheelzy, a few others that supposedly buy wrecked cars and I tried on facebook marketplace, etc... just trying to cut my losses on this totaled vehicle. Went through a frustrating runaround with lowball prices and poor communication until I found this company and I am glad I did. Prompt communication. Very easy to work with. He committed to meet me to tow the vehicle and he followed through as promised. Certainly not fun to have a totaled car to deal with but this part was easy

Super friendly and quick service! Ivan was very professional and got my husbands eyesore old car…read moretowed from our parking garage! They provided me with the best price out of all the companies I called. They are definitely who you want to use!

Terrell was such a helpful and kind man to work with! My husband and I finally had to say goodbye…read moreto our 1994 Subaru Legacy and I was amazed at how quickly and efficiently Terrell came and took care of everything. Highly recommended. Great person to work with.

Quick appointments and good communication. Helped make sure I had my plates and my possessions out…read moreas well. Overall good experience.

I had a great experience at O'Meara Ford, and I especially want to shout out Kaelan, my service…read moreadvisor. Kaelan was incredibly patient and helpful from start to finish. He walked me through all the logistics of my car repair, kept me informed throughout the entire process, and was very communicative, which made a stressful situation feel much more manageable. I really appreciated how transparent and responsive he was. I actually chose to drive about 30 minutes out of my way to come here after having ongoing issues with a closer dealership, and I'm really glad I did. The difference in service was noticeable, and it was absolutely worth the extra drive to feel confident my car was being handled properly. While there were a few additional services I couldn't take care of at the time, I definitely plan to come back in the future. For now, I'm just grateful to have my car back, running well, and to have had such a smooth experience overall. They also offer a shuttle, which is a great option if you need to get somewhere nearby while your car is being serviced. Highly recommend if you're looking for reliable service and good communication.

13 Days of Excuses, Incompetence, and a Dangerous Safety Hazard…read more ​This dealership has been around since 1913, but they operate with the incompetence of a business that opened yesterday. We purchased a truck on April 1st and were given five different "firm" pickup dates (the 4th, 7th, 8th, 10th, and 13th). ​The Endless Excuses: Over the 13 days it took to get our vehicle, we were given every excuse in the book: a safety inspection, needing a spare tire, a new headlight, "the machines are broken," and not having enough staff. The lack of communication was the most insulting part. When we finally confronted our salesman about the silence, we were essentially told that because it was his "day off," he saw no reason to respond to an upset client who had already handed over a $6,000 down payment. ​The Staff: ​Scott Rockefeller (Sales): Avoid at all costs. He is unprofessional, immature, and eventually resorted to name-calling when we asked for updates. He has no answers and pushes every failure onto management. ​Nathan Johnston (GSM): A total ghost. We were told we needed to talk to him, yet he was never "available" and his contact info was guarded like a secret. ​James Houtz (Internet Sales): Told us "everyone in the dealership" heard about our situation, yet no one reached out to resolve it. He gave us a firm 11:00 AM deadline for April 13th and then went silent. ​The Bright Spots: Nicholas Trujillo (Quick Lane) and Eissa Hizhley were the only professionals there. Nicholas found the finance team after they disappeared on us and made sure our daughters had drinks and snacks. Eissa stepped in to help when everyone else failed, despite it not being his job. ​The "Safety" Failure: We were told the 13-day delay was for a "safety check." After waiting an additional 3 hours for a final detail on the 13th, we got the truck home only to find a loose razor blade on the truck bed cover where our young children were playing. To claim you are doing "safety checks" for two weeks and then leave a razor blade in a vehicle is negligent and dangerous. ​ We had every dealership sticker stripped off the truck because I refuse to promote a business this careless. They claim to use CarMax as an example of "what not to do," but they are currently the gold standard for how to lose a customer's trust and respect