Craving authentic Colombian cuisine, my party of three decided to visit El Peñol in East Boston around 2 PM. Despite the mid-afternoon timing, the restaurant was bustling. A group of four was ahead of us, and shortly after, a group of six and another group of three arrived. The waitress seemed to know members of both the group of six and the other group of three, greeting them personally.
After seating the group of four, she proceeded to seat the second group of three. When we inquired about this, she explained that she had noted that group arriving first, followed by the group of six, and then our party. I respectfully clarified that we had arrived after the group of four and before the group of six. She acknowledged this and assured us we'd be seated next, which is all we wanted.
Eventually, we noticed her conversing with her acquaintances, with some pointing in our direction. It appeared she asked them to move to accommodate us, which we neither expected nor desired, but we were seated promptly. This led to a bit of an awkward meal with the man on the other group of three mean-mugging us the entire meal.
Once seated, the experience was seamless. Another waitress took our order, providing friendly and attentive service. The coffee was rich and delicious, a testament to Colombia's renowned coffee culture. I highly recommend trying it.
We ordered the Bandeja El Peñol, an enhanced version of the traditional Bandeja Paisa. The bandeja includes rice, beans, steak, chicharron, fried egg, plantain. The bandeja Peñol also includes chorizo. Based on the menu, it seems like the bandeja was supposed to include an arepa too, which we didn't get, but it was too much food anyway. The portions were generous, and the flavors transported me back to my time visiting Colombia.
The chicharron is probably the best I've had in Boston. The chorizo was so tasty and the steak was so tender. As I mentioned earlier, our waitress was so attentive and she offered us salsas which we appreciated. The red salsa was perfect with the steak adding a bit of acidity from the lime and some heat. We enjoyed a fantastic meal and I can't think of a better restaurant for Colombian food.
Given the excellent service and delectable food, I highly recommend El Peñol. However, I encourage them to improve their seating system to avoid confusion. Perhaps taking names for each party would help. While it felt like we might have been de-prioritized in favor of regulars, I'll consider it an honest mistake and give them the benefit of the doubt. read more