Friendly staff. Nostalgic setting…read more Delicious food. Butternut squash soup was very tasty, as was the roasted vegetables sandwich. Giant French toast was delicious, too.

My husband and I stayed at the White Gull Inn and ate at the restaurant three times, twice for…read morebreakfast and once for dinner. The food was great for dinner. I loved the dinner rolls. Breakfast was hit or miss depending on what you ordered. The eggs in my eggs benedict were overdone, which was a bummer. Prices are high, but that is expected of Door County. The Inn itself could really use an update. It's stuck in the 90s, and not in a charming way. Everyone who worked there was nice. I think we'd return to have dinner, but I wouldn't stay here again (despite the really good cookies you get).

We selected this restaurant based on the reviews and menu and were not in any way disappointment…read more Everything we ate was excellent. Started with the cheese plate and very much enjoyed the selection. I wish they would have provided more bread or crackers but that is because I'm a carb lover. Additionally, we had to clarify what one of the items on the cheese plate was because it tasted like alcohol to my husband. Looked like olives or cherries. It was indeed a type of cherry and had alcohol. I was grateful we had asked before trying myself at 8 months pregnant. My husband got the pressed 1/2 chicken and we both loved it. It had an incredible depth of flavor, great seasoning. I got the braised short ribs and enjoyed these as well. However, I wished they had been served with mashed potatoes instead of what I believe were grits. We ended our meal with the flourless chocolate cake which was the perfect cherry on top. Caramel spoons with popped amaranth on top were served with our check. Nice touch! Cozy atmosphere, nice fire crackling and friendly servers. What more can we ask for?

The ideal brunch spot in Fish Creek. My fiancé and I had the prosciutto eggs Benedict and it was…read moremouthwatering. The hollandaise was perfectly prepared. Sitting on the sun porch, sipping coffee, cherry juice and mimosas was an idyllic way to spend the first official day of spring.

Our stay at Main Street Motel in Fish Creek was wonderful. I had booked a room online, or so I…read morethought. I didn't get any confirmation. I started to get worried. Note to self: next time don't wait a week to find out whether it was confirmed or not. I finally called and talked to Sharon about not receiving confirmation. And sure enough, there was nothing booked under my name. Sharon went above and beyond to try to accommodate us. And she was amazing. The Customer Service you will find during your stay here is exemplary. From the immaculate rooms, to the staff that you will encounter. We would absolutely stay here again. Actually, we can't wait to book our next stay. ( I've never seen a cleaner bathroom in all of my stays anywhere) Located at the very end of Main Street, it is a quiet, peaceful, picturesque location. Once we parked our car and checked into the motel, whenever we wanted to explore the town, we left our car and walked. Fish Creek is an incredibly walkable town. Especially Main Street. So close to everything. It's just our favorite place in the world. So, if you are thinking of visiting Fish Creek and want a lovely clean, comfortable stay, I can't recommend Main Street Motel enough.

Lovely staff, incredible location, couldn't have been more clean. Smiling housekeepers, helpful…read morefront desk. Grounds are beautiful and private. Great private parking. Beds are a bit hard, pillows a bit flat, could use better toilet paper. But would most definitely book again!

My husband and I had a fantastic time staying at Thorpe House for a long weekend; it was both fun…read moreand relaxing. The decor throughout the house is gorgeous and every room is very unique, so there's a nice variety to pick from all of the photos when booking online. We had the Jessie and it was such a treat having both a fireplace and jacuzzi in the room! The staff were lovely and fun to chat with, as well as hear more home history. The food was fresh and delicious-there was no doubt about who was making it because it was done in the same room. The Inn is right in the bustle of town so its easy to walk for shopping, different restaurants, going to the water (etc) but you never hear any noise inside of our room. Thorpe House is reasonably priced if you're celebrating something like we were. It was like stepping back in time but nothing felt dated. They fill up really quickly so get a room booked as soon as you know when your trip is! We will absolutely come back the next time we're in the area!

Our stay at Thorp House Inn & Cottages was nothing short of miserable. The room was freezing…read morebecause the bathroom heater didn't work in the middle of winter, which made the entire space uncomfortable from the moment we arrived. The jacuzzi tub -- one of the reasons we booked -- was filthy, clearly not cleaned properly before our stay. We also paid for a horse‑drawn carriage ride, which was canceled due to weather. That part was understandable. What wasn't understandable was the complete lack of communication about the replacement trolley ride being one‑way only. We were dropped off and left to walk back to the B&B in bitter cold temperatures with no warning. Breakfast was another disappointment. What was served tasted reheated and stale, like it had been sitting around far too long. And the truffles we ordered -- which should have been a special touch -- were stored in the laundry room and all tasted like detergent. For the price and reputation, we expected a warm, welcoming, and well‑run experience. Instead, we left cold, frustrated, and extremely let down. We won't be returning.

Could not cancel a reservation due to illness, refused to refund our deposit,…read more Poor ownership

Our first time to Door County was in 2023. We stayed in Egg Harbor which we really liked - but…read morethought Fish Creek would be an even better location the next time we returned. This trip in 2024 we picked Homestead Suites and couldn't be happier. The place is spotless! We had a fireplace (although it was too warm out to use) and great place on the first floor. We used the outdoor pool daily and also their bike locker room. I brought my Trek bike and did a daily ride in Peninsula State Park - which is right next door. This was also only a 10 minute walk to downtown Fish Creek. We'll be back!

Julie's Cafe is simply excellent! Great food, service, & ambiance!…read more I chose the "Texas Eggs" and it was simply delicious, an absolute not miss! So much flavor! :-) The $0.50 upcharge for the sour dough toast was well worth it. I would have liked to have tried the cinnamon roll but no more room, what a lovely dessert it would have been! The coffee was plentiful & tasty. All in all a lovely experience from start to finish! Thank you, Team Julie! :-) Thank you, Patrick Shaughnessy Chicago, IL

I feel like for where you are and what you need at the moment, this is a quick fix. It just didn't…read morequite hit the spot for a good brunch meal- the hash was more on the greasy end, the Belgian waffle just reminded me of the ones you get at the hotels you make yourself, and the French toast wasn't evenly cooked through. The sourdough bread was maybe the part of the meal that was most worth it. Unfortunately, missed the mark for brunch. Plenty of parking though.

This place was a miss for us. Similar review to what Gail H. wrote…read more The place was very tiny, and had I known the motel rooms were this small, I would have chosen another room or booked elsewhere. The pictures posted online consist of just three of them, and I didn't get a feel for how small the place really was from those photos. The shower was so small it was frustrating to use. I'm not a big guy by any means, tall or wide. We didn't have any issues with the noise from screen doors or similar, likely because of when we were actually there and it was not super busy. It's nice to get a parking space that's pretty much guaranteed for your stay, and there are plenty of nice places to walk in the area. From their pictures, it would appear that their other areas are bigger. Personally, I wouldn't stay in a motel room here again. When we were on our last day and preparing to leave, room service took all of the clean sheets and towels and placed them on the dirty outside chair for over an hour. In my book, it's not acceptable at all. Having the expectation of clean sheets going on a bed without them sitting outside on a dirty chair beforehand seems obvious.

This hotel is very clean and updated. Location is perfect…read more The problem is the screen doors slamming at 5/6 am. The staff does a great job keeping things clean, but they do it super early and if you want to sleep past 6/7 am it's not going to happen. Pool was very nice and ice machine worked great. They just need to be a little quieter. Put some stoppers on the screen doors.

The most relaxing place to stay in Door County, on aptly named Relax lane. Wonderful grounds for…read morenature walks. But best of all, it's dog-friendly so Sammy can enjoy it, too. And the cows at the farm next door enjoying seeing her. Very nice earth cabins with outdoor fire pit and indoor fireplace. Very convenient location to the rest of Door County.

What a great boutique hotel right in downtown Fish Creek across the street from the quaint beach…read moreand park access. The owners couldn't be any more welcoming and accommodating, clean, fresh towels and the mattress was a dream. Strong WiFi connection throughout the property was a life saver. Can't recommend this hotel enough!

If you want to be in the thick of main street this place is for you. The owners are very…read moreaccommodating and very nice people, my few complaint on the room were that there is no coffee maker in the room but they do serve coffee in the lobby I believe from 7-11. I'm an early riser so I brought my own coffee maker. Second no microwave to heat up all those wonderful left overs from going out to eat, but again the owners of the hotel said just bring your food over to the office and they would heat it up for you. For the price of this Motel I expect these items in my room.

Spent 3 nights in a king size room (unit 21) at the Settlement Courtyard Inn in June 2025. Great…read morelocation right outside of Fish Creek. Checking in was quick and easy which was lovely. They gave me a key with a huge wooden keychain so it would be hard to lose the key. Made it hard to walk around with. Later on after I was getting settled I went back down to the desk to ask 2 simple questions and the person at the desk didn't know the answers to my questions which was a little weird. Maybe a new staff member for the summer. The room had that quaint, countryside feel. It does have a musky scent when you first walk into the room. Once you're in there for a couple of mins you don't notice it anymore. Everything was very clean with the exception of the tub in the bathroom that had some hairs left behind by the former guest and some microscopic bugs by the sink. It was great having a full fridge and microwave which I used both. No stove or oven so keep that in mind. The temp in the room was great and can be changed whenever you want. The bathroom has small vials of shampoo, conditioner, lotion and bath/body gel - keep that in mind cause I'm always used to hotels having a huge refillable container of all those products. The TV is a regular tv with local and national channels. No logging into different streaming platforms if that's your thing. The Pool - spent a little amount of time there. The temp of the heated pool was great. Towels are available at the pool. The recliners aren't the most comfortable for a position to read but I made do. Breakfast - I went to the little nook in the morning for breakfast but only got a coffee and hard boiled eggs once. They had cereal, and some other items. I'm not much of a breakfast person. Parking - lots of parking. You'll register your car with the front desk. The only comment on this is that they need desperately to redo the lines in the parking lot cause it was hard to tell if they were specific spaces at all. Location - I think the location is perfect to hop down to Fish Creek or another neighboring bay city. It was central to everything I felt and Fish Creek ended up being one of my fav places to hang out and walk around. So many shops and restaurants.

This place is old, outdated and way too far from town. When we first drive up it' was a…read moredisappointment. A few shops just lingering there, only pie shop seems to have any business. Rooms are dirty.