Served gluten after repeated allergy warnings -- child now sick What happened at Eataly Sherway Gardens was not just poor service, it was a serious and dangerous failure to handle a medical dietary restriction. My two children and I have celiac disease. We clearly told our server this at the beginning and explicitly asked for gluten-free pasta, stressing that it was an allergy. We ordered gluten-free pasta for both children. Another child at the table ordered regular pasta. When the dishes arrived, they all looked identical. That immediately raised concern, so I asked again to confirm which ones were gluten-free. The server appeared unsure and had to check with the kitchen. He returned and assured us that all the pasta dishes were gluten-free. Based on that direct confirmation, my daughter ate almost her entire meal. Only then did another staff member come over to inform us that she had actually been served regular pasta. This is completely unacceptable. This wasn't a simple mix-up--it was: * Failure to properly label or distinguish allergy meals *Failure in communication between kitchen and staff *False reassurance when directly asked to verify an allergy-sensitive dish Now my daughter is sick, vomiting and in significant pain--because of this negligence. This happened over Easter weekend, on her birthday. Yes, the manager comped the meal. That does not undo the physical harm caused or the complete breakdown in basic allergy safety protocols. If you cannot safely handle gluten-free orders for celiac customers, you should not be telling people that you can. This experience was not just disappointing--it was dangerous. I would strongly warn anyone with celiac disease or serious food allergies to avoid this location. read more

Every single item was delicious! We came on a Monday evening and it was about half full in the restaurant. Our server was a little intense but still provided good service. We asked for a salad recommendation and he highly recommend the kale salad. I'm glad we got that. Really delicious with a fine crumb garnish and the perfect amount of dressing (not overly or under dressed). The calamari and zucchini fries so really good, lightly battered. The calamari really tender. The zucchini came with sauce. I think the focaccia was on the house. I don't think they usually do this but it was a slow night so maybe that's why. It was crispy on the outside and so soft on the inside. It was perfect. Paired with a really high quality olive oil and we asked for balsamic vinegar. I would buy it next time because it was so good. Lastly we got the MALTAGLIATI ALL A NORCINA, TAGLIATELLE ALL A BOLOGNESE pastas and the DIAVOL A DOLCE pizza. All were delicious. The TAGLIATELLE ALL A BOLOGNESE was an amazing pasta. The pizza was a white sauce so I saw for marinara sauce on the side and it paired so well. The place itself looked clean and aesthetically pleasing. read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Free focaccia - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

Sad to report this, but we had a group of friends meet us at Eataly for the first time, and I don't think many of them will want to come back. We were there to try Restofest-- the $26 two-course menu. However, on a busy Friday night, they were already out of two things on the very limited menu: the burrata and the mushroom pasta. On top of that, none of the options had any meat. The pizza had a very sparse amount of toppings, and the beet ravioli was bland. What really rubbed us the wrong way, though, was that one of our friends ordered a three-pasta sampler. While the rest of us received our appetizers, she asked the server if she could just have one of the three pastas come to her early while we ate our salads so that we could all have something to eat, but the staff said this was impossible, and that her three dishes had to come simultaneously with our mains. But really, why? After waiting for a very long time after our dinner, we received our desserts, but these were lacklustre as well: the Budino Al Cioccalato was so rich and heavy that none of us could finish it. Honestly, it was obvious to see that they were understaffed-- the service was achingly slow, and the servers looked like they were being pulled in too many directions. Truly, I never ask for this, but I think that given the fact that we'd all ended up with marred experiences and that our food took an incredibly long time, if I were a manager, I would've given customers a complimentary gelato or something-- just a small token to make up for the disappointing food and service. I would definitely go to Eataly again, though; our experiences at the Yorkville location have always been fantastic. Perhaps this was just a bad night. read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Pizza - Restofest option. - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

I've come to Eataly before to get a sandwich or pizza and it's been really good. I finally had the chance to come by and eat in their restaurant with some friends and it was nice. We ordered the Bruschetta ($17) (Toasted Sourdough Bread, Whipped Ricotta, Roasted Butternut Squash, Urbani Black Truffle Honey) to share and it was really good! For my own meal, I ordered the lasagna ($27) as the waiter stated it was the most popular pasta they had. I don't usually order lasagna but I'm happy I did because it was really good! We also ordered the Polpette Della Nonna ($22 - $5.50 per meatball?!) (meatballs) to share, which were just okay. Honestly, the service & food were really good, but it did seem expensive for what we got. I would come back, but only if a friend or colleague really wanted to come. I understand they use fresh ingredients and it's all under a big name brand.. but I could get more from my money elsewhere. read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

Not sure what the hype is about this place... Mediocre food at fancy restaurant pricing, but it doesn't feel fancy because it's also a market? This location is also confusing, not sure if the others are as well. If you're coming in from mall side, you'll have to walk in and pass the dining area, to the "front" hostess. For reference, this meal (plus 1 $9 bottle flat water, 1 peroni, 1 coffee) for 2 adults and 1 child was $200. Not worth it, imo. The only saving grace is the kind service and incredible desserts! I would return just for their desserts! We got salads and mains for 2, and kids meal for my little one. The salads we asked for recommendation from our server, and they were just ok. No fault of our server as preferences are subjective. Unfortunately, the mains were just as disappointing. Salads: Insalata di cavolo nero 3.5/5 Another salad with beets, but don't recall the name, 3/5 Lasagna ai funghi: 4/5 Flavour was pretty good but got an edge piece, and much of it was dried (the pasta, not the "crispy" artichoke) and shriveled. Linguine allo scoglio: 2/5 The seafood tasted like they were boiled separately and tossed at the end. There was no fusion of flavours between the pasta and the seafood. I love seafood pasta, and this did not make the cut for me. The kids meal, was a choice of pizza or pasta. We were happy to see the pizzas could be shaped. My little one picked the bunny and chose mushroom add-on. I believe the kids meal was $15 and add-on $3.99. Dessert not included in the kids meal. I wish the drinks option included kid-friendly varieties such as milk, not just sodas. (I believe they were lime and blood orange san pellegrino.) Dessert; the saving grace of our subpar dining experience. They actually make incredible desserts! 6/5! Coppa Gelato al cioccolato: Very strong hazelnut flavour, smooth and creamy, very well done. Amalfi: Incredible lemon cake parfait with the perfect ratio of cake, cream, meringue, and crunchy cookie. The cookie layer was the (figurative) cherry on top! read more

See all

As a first time goer, this is a shopping and dinning restaurant. You can buy lots of Italian products like bottled pasta sauces, pastas, wines and baked items, and then dine in. All in one spot. It's clean. The service is great I got a fantastic server she knew the menu and was really attentive. After placing my order the food did take a while. The drinks are a must. Now to the food. It was just ok. Nothing magical for me. Nothing to brag about. But fresh. read more

See all

I always love all Eataly locations and experiences. The wait time was really long for this location on a weekend evening. But I guess that's normal. We wanted quicker seat so asked to sit at bar. Bar is beautiful; whole venue always is. Food was good- but not the best I've had at this chain - not sure if it's this location, or the way they made it this time, or the selections I chose. The pizza was not as soft-falling-on-my-fingers as I had before. And dessert on special - this house made gelato - way too sweet. Didn't like it. But still overall enjoyed it; atmosphere always so beautiful. read more

See all

This is the second Toronto Eataly location in Sherway Gardens inside the store. Food (4/5) - they have a fairly sizeable menu of food and drink options including pizza pasta appetizers mains etc. Had the Margherita Pizza and it was not bad. Napoli style so soft in the middle and thin crust with a nice bit of burn. San Marzano sauce was nice with just right amount of tang. Service (3/5) - it was definitely on the slower side - a wait for tables so I sat at the bar. Bartender was friendly and took my order fairly quickly. Took a bit to get the pizza though and also the bill. It looked like others were waiting awhile for meals and bills imo. Atmosphere (4.25/5) - it's a good layout with a mix of tables and seats... clean and semi upscale feel. Overall (3.75/5) - it's got potential tbh... service seems to be their weak spot though and dropped my rating for that reason. I would give it another shot though and try out some other items. read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Margherita Pizza - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

November 7/2025: Dinner with the Al. This was a rather disappointing visit to the Eataly at Sherway Gardens Mall. The ambiance was very cafeteria like. Open kitchen concept which made for a very loud & busy restaurant. Our server "John" was a very nice fella but the service level was barely acceptable. He forgot our water. Took forever to place our order and just as long to see the arrival of our table bill. The food itself was expensive & unimpressive. The calamari ($24.00) was small & had little actual calamari. My Peroni beer ($10.00) wasn't as cold as it should have been. My main was shared/split between me & my wife. Both had pizzas, mine was the mushroom ($25.00) & the other was the Diavola ($26.00). Both were just ok but not as great or as well done as they should have been or as I asked for to be done. The highlight of the meal was the Tiramisu ($16.00). It was light, tasty & downright delicious! P.S. The menu font size was WAY too small to be readable. read more

See all

Eataly Ristorante's menu focuses on Italian classics with an extensive array of appetizers, pasta, pizza, and main dishes. The cavolo nero salad ($17) uses a base of Tuscan kale that's mixed with shaved Brussel sprouts for crunch. While I would have liked a bit more of the pecorino dressing on the leaves, at least it was well incorporated and went nicely with the golden raisins. The addition of crushed garlic breadcrumbs added texture that augments an otherwise common kale salad. I was glad to see their tagliatelle alla Bolognese ($29) was heavy on the meat and light on tomato. It was just disappointingly tasteless. Having had the same dish at their Yorkville location, Sherway's portion size was smaller and stingy on the sauce. The Prosciutto e rucoloa pizza ($28) incorporated too much mozzarella. I know what you're thinking: can there ever be too much cheese?! Yes, if starts to congeal into a globe than there's too much cheese. The timing of when the arugula was added to the pizza also was poorly chosen, causing the leaves to be bound into the mozzarella. And even though there wasn't too much tomato sauce, somehow the crust was still soft and soggy at the centre. Something also seemed off about the Prosciutto... it didn't taste fresh. Don't get me wrong, it was likely fine as I had no stomach issues after the meal, but there was a slight odour or taste that just didn't resemble the typical 18-month cured ham. With the glowing review our waitress gave the tiramisu di Eataly ($15), I was excited for the dessert as it incorporates a special mascarpone cream not found at the bakery version. And I'll admit, as the cream is poured tableside, and the plastic barrier is removed so it oozes over the cake, there's a showmanship to the presentation... whether it really added that much to the cake? I can't tell. Firstly, the tiramisu was extremely sweet - possibly because of the additional crème sauce - and lacked espresso flavours. The lady fingers hardly seemed "soaked" in espresso as noted on the menu. Still, it wasn't a terrible dessert. I liked the cake to crème ratio. If only they decreased the sugar and increased the caffeine. I'm not a fan of chocolate, especially not chocolate pudding, but must admit that if I did like that dessert Eataly's budino al cioccolato ($12) would be wonderful. Thick, creamy, and rich the budino satisfies like a truffle by the spoonful. The layer of crumbled Devil's food cake on the bottom was great for texture and they should consider incorporating more of it. And the sticky chocolate glaze on top not only helped with presentation but gave a fudgy swirl to the dessert. Alas, it was cloyingly sweet so that a teaspoon was all I could handle. Eataly contains tons of tables so you wouldn't think it'd be difficult to score a spot for a weekday lunch. Yet, with only two hostesses expect a wait just to be shown to an empty table. The time to placing an order and getting our food improves, but when it comes to paying trying to find someone is like hunting for Waldo. read more

See all

So we visited Eataly on a Saturday evening, after making online reservations , we were there 25 mins early and of course being Saturday night it was super busy and if know it, so should the restaurant management. But they were running behind ( like even after reservations, tables were not available, and there was a queue of people at the reservation desk) really? What is the point of online reservations then? My husband requested a couple of times as we had a 5 year old and 4 months old to get a table on time, luckily the server considered it and provided us a table after non much of a delay. Service: again there was such a rush , seriously serving was affected adversely as well. We kept chasing our server, we weren't served until one hour after we sat down, the server was so unavailable, that we couldn't ask him questions/recommendations about food, and couldn't even order my drink. He never came back . And anyways everything was spoiled as my 4 months by 1.5 hours by the table got fussy, and we didn't have any clam dining experience. Good news I didn't order my drink. Lol. Food was A-okay, i mean the mushroom ragu ( was dry) fancy word for just mixd mushroom on the oiled pasta. We had to wait to get pepper, no cheese , that too after asking . Butternut squash ravioli was good. We ordered 2 sides with our 3 prefix menus, the beet tartuffo was great but polenta fries were too dry, no sauce or dip. Again seriously??? Now Burrata, which last time served with ratatouille ( not sure Italian name of it) was good. This time served with burned zucchini chips and a hint of pesto was way to blend. Butternut squash and ricotta bruschetta were decent. But they are good for date as well as family. They have nice dining areas depending on what kind of party you are read more

See all

The quality of the food is good, however, the portions are small compared to what I expected. We ordered a pasta and the branzino to share. Both were good however not anything spectacular. I've had Bronzino for the same price at other restaurants and it was double the size. Service was also slow, as they seem to be very busy and hard to flag down. We had to grab our own menus and more water ourselves. A serviceable meal. read more

See all

I came here on a Wednesday evening without a reservation but was seated immediately. The staff was friendly and helped me decide what food options to get. I went for the dinner for two option where you can choose two items on the list for a set price. I chose their ravioli and sourdough bread from that menu, and ordered a pizza from their regular menu. The pizza was good (4/5), it was very similar to classic italian pizza. It was indeed a bit spicy, which I liked since I got the diavola pizza. It was difficult to rip off the slices because the pizza wasn't cut fully through the dough, so ripping the slices got a little messy. The sourdough bread was really good (5/5)! It was topped with sour cream, eggplant, onions, and tomato sauce. The bread slice was thick, so it soaked up the flavors from the sauce nicely and the bread was really soft and bouncy. The ravioli was good, but it wasn't my favorite dish (3.5/5). I would have appreciated more sauce and more salt, maybe parmesan cheese on top? Inside the ravioli was spinach cottage cheese, and it was topped off with pistacchio. I though the ravioli was under cooked a bit, as it was hard and a bit dry. The ambience of Eataly is very nice, intimate and you can see the kitchen staff working which feels inclusive. Overall, I'd recommend trying this place out and I'd definitely come back! read more

I can't speak for everything on offer at this place, but the tiramisu croissant is top notch. It's over $7, but still. read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - The tiramisu - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

Smooth and delicious gelato! There are different pastries, Italian delicacies to try, including a pizza restaurant inside. We tried three scoops of gelato - Pistachio is a must try! Hazelnut and passion fruit are also very good! If you're looking for an Italian fix, you need to stop by Eataly. Quite busy on a weekend so expect to wait a little if you don't have a restaurant reservation. Otherwise it's a great spot to pick up some Italian ingredients. read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

I've been here twice already and I enjoyed both times. I like that it's a store but then there's also a restaurant. Our server was lovely, very attentive and knowledgeable. I ordered a non alcoholic drink and it was good but it was a bit sweet for my liking. I also ordered the zucca pasta and it was good however, I wish the plate had more pasta and I wish it was a sauce (red or white) instead of just butter and sage. The ice cream was delicious and a great portion size, definitely a highlight. read more

See all

Went here for Eatalfest. Food is great! Service is amazing. Clearly as the event was full with tables inside the restaurant and outside. read more

We've been to Eataly a few times since it opened and I can't say I've ever had my socks knocked off. The food isn't bad, exactly, but given the price point of many of these items, I would hope the dishes would be more than just decent. On a recent visit, we decided to share a breakfast croissant called the Cornetto Uovo e Pancetta. It contained a frittata, cheese, and bacon. In theory, it should've been delicious. However, it was served to us completely cold in the middle. The egg was clammy and the bacon was chewy. It was an odd choice that transformed it into something you'd get at a gas station. Very disappointing. Far better was the cannelloni, which was freshly piped with a pistachio filling. The shell was nice and crispy, and that filling was sweet but not cloyingly so. The pistachio flavor was a big winner, too. I feel like the problems at Eataly stem from poor training to the various employees. If they'd just try a little harder, this would be a fantastic culinary destination at Sherway. read more

See all

I reserved a table for 3 for my girlfriend's birthday party at the restaurant for last night. We arrived on time and were lead to our table. The first impression we got that the disco music was blaring from the speaker directly over the table. It was so loud that one could not talk comfortably. I mentioned this to the person in charge, who appeared not very pleased with my complaint, but he lowered tha volume somewhat. My girlfriend and her daughter ordered from the Prix-fixe menu- Antipasto - Burrata and Bruschetta Zucca. I was not very impressed with that menu and opted to order a Insalata Cesare and Salmone Alla Piastra. The waiter, an older gentlemen was very nice and helpful. I had a decaf americano while waiting for the food. It was very good! Then, the first dish arrived- Burratta. What I have a hard time understanding is how do you serve each individual separately and let two others sit and wait for their food? Very unprofessional!!! But, that is what happened. After another 10 minutes or so another dish arrived. It was supposed to be Bruschetta for my girlfriend, but is was not. She was served a Mozzarella in Carrozza. I mentioned it to the waiter, who profusely apologized and suggested that we c an have the dish delivered for free and he will get another, correct one shortly. My Caesar salad arrived and it was a huge disappointment. Whole leaves of lettuce with a dressing that lacked any acidity or flavour and just a dusting of toasted bread on top, their version of croutons I was told. At a $17 price I expected a lot more. The main courses all arrived at different times, a testament of either luck of care or inefficiency of the kitchen. The waiter mentioned that one of the reasons was that they had several kitchens. One would think that good organization and coordination would help a lot. The Ravioly was not too bad. Apparently Burratta as well. My dish, - Salmone Alla Piastra priced at $35 was a total disaster. The salmon was overdone and the dish was too acidic. Some of the lettuce edges were wilted and spoiled, they should have never served it like this. Poor judgement on the part of the chef? I think not. The entire experience showed me that the restaurant was all about appearance and a hight price tag and not quality. Now, I may be a bit more demanding as a customer being a chef myself. However, some of the mistakes, to me, are unforgivable for a restaurant that advertises itself as a serving high end cuisine. All in all a very disappointing dining experience which was not the large price tag. I will not be set my foot there again! read more

I've been here twice. On both occasions the food was AMAZING but service is a little disappointing. Getting sat was never an issue but the time it took to be acknowledged by a server whether it be to take our order, table touch, or bring the bill, was a little frustrating. The first time my family and I dined in, the food came out 5-10 minutes apart from each other so by the time everyone got their food, some were cold/sauce became matted. My most recent visit I came on my own, it took 20 minutes for someone to finally take my order despite only two other small parties sitting in the same area. The girl who took my order walked by and saw me multiple times before I overheard the busboy point at me and say to her "She's been sitting there for a while did even you get to her yet?". Once my order was taken the food came out shortly after, I wasn't offered parmesan cheese until I had already finished a portion of my plate. I feel like my experience could've been better, maybe I just came in on an off day both times? Now the food on the other hand, is literally SO GOOD, you can taste the time and care put into each dish. On my first visit I got beef short rib (usually what I gravitate towards at higher end places when available) and I remember it being one of the best short ribs I've ever eaten, along with the truffle mash. I got a bite of my brother's lasagna as well and we both loved it. My most recent visit I ordered their gnocchi in mushroom and sausage ragu and was genuinely debating on ordering seconds because it was that good. The portion to price ratio for the items I've tried I feel to be pretty fair. I remember being full without desert or drinks on both occasions but the flavors are what tempts you to order more. Aside from their hot food, just walking around the market is so fun, they've got a large variety of cool imported food items, both dry and fresh, it's easy to spend quite a bit of time exploring everything. I also bought some fresh braised beef ravioli to take home, which I later threw together with some browned butter, anchovies, parsley, and onions, and it was delicious. I'll definitely be back, Eataly is beautiful and such a fun experience, I just hope the service improves in the future. read more

See all

What's with all the hype about this place? The dishes are so pricey, small portions, and the noodles were cold! Cold! I'm not sure if it's because it's new and they're still having some growing pains, but the best thing about my experience was that I was with my best friend! We had the margarita pizza to share and then she ordered the seafood pasta while I had the Bolognese. The waiter was super nice though and the seating area is fun! But likely won't return. read more

See all

Very disappointed as I'm a huge fan of Eataly! This is the most average location and food. The Caesar salad was poor and dressing tasteless. Ordered the chicken Milanese with roasted potatoes which was good. My wife ordered the rigatoni pasta which came out cold and we needed to send back. We had to ask for cutlery after our appetizers. The waiter was nice but all in all the service was average. read more

Ask for Consuelo! This place was phenomenal. Consuelo was our waitress and took excellent care of us, even provided excellent recommendations and went into further details describing the meals that are prepared here! This was my first time, and I can absolutely say I'll be back again. From the fresh foods to the excellent ambience, I would absolutely recommend this place for a nice dinner and a cozy atmosphere! read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Affogato, Tiramisu in back - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

We ate in the restaurant but the pastries and sandwiches looked good too! The pizza was nicely cooked and the service was quick. I was surprised by how busy they were and would recommend having reservations of you're planning to go. Luckily we got a table (as long as we were done within 1.5h). They have a good selection of pastas, pizzas and a brunch menu too. May need to try the tiramisu pancakes next time :) read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Margherita - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Food amazing, visiting from SC , thank you for service , great ambiance. Sad to leave read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Fungi pizza, pistachio croissant, absolutely fantastic delicious, and latte - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

The mushroom pasta was good, prepared al dente. I recall the pastas at their downtown location to be tastier and more flavourful. overall it was a nice meal. The service was spotty on Saturday brunch when it wasn't overly busy. My friend ordered a coffee with her meal but it didn't come til she was almost done her eggs Benny. Turns out, first they didn't put the order through and then the machine was backed up. They were slow to take our orders too at the beginning, we had to look around a few times to flag the server down. read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Mushroom papperadelle - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

This location is smaller than Toronto's flagship location in downtown (on Bloor). There is more limited selection of products and ready-to-eat foods (less varieties of pizza, salads, desserts, and other food available), and there is only 1 restaurant on site (La Pizza & La Pasta)... whereas in the downtown location, they also have a seafood-themed restaurant. The self check-out machines don't work very well, i.e. having to input produce item one by one instead of being weighted or being able to input the quantity (cumbersome if you're getting a lot of items at once). There are no cashiers around to help with using the self check-out machines. Out of all the grocery stores I've been to with self check-out option, Eataly has the worst system. The touchscreen function also does not work half the time, and is not very responsive (need to press on the button on the screen very hard before getting it to work). The layout of the store is somewhat messy and confusing. Almost all of the grocery store products (except for the high-end imported items), produce, and grab-and-go meals are overpriced... which is typical of a luxury gourmet grocery store. The quality of the products and food that they do offer is pretty good though, which is reflected by the price (e.g. their pizzas are much better than the typical run-of-the-mill fast food or typical grocery store pizza). There are very limited tables for eating. The few round tables that they have available are very small. There are additional seatings in front of the store, but they're almost always full. read more

See all

The Cracker Barrel of Eatalys is what I said to a friend. I hadn't done much reading on the newest location prior to going opening weekend. Having been to Eatalys on Bloor St and in Las Vegas I knew there would be differences but didn't imagine this. Being opening weekend it was extremely busy, not unnavigable. You can enter from the mall (not the small side entrance in the mall entrance) or from the front doors facing the parking lot. As per the typical market there are fresh fruits, vegetables, various foods. At this location you'll find the cheese monger counter, bread and Gelato all packed in tightly bordering the market. Along the other wall is the pasta area with tight seating leading into a large dining area for the La Pizza and La Pasta restaurant and an oval bar. I think the dining area outsizes the market a bit based upon watching people most people walked in expecting more market or counters. Between Bloor and Sherway Gardens, if I'm making the trip from Buffalo I plan to stick to Bloor. read more

See all

Yes. Nice food. Good quality for many things. However some bad oils used so you have to pay attention to what you are buying but overall, very good. read more

I didn't know what I was getting into here. But, the second I looked around it all started to make sense. This is the type of place where you can sit down at a table and order off of a menu, or walk around and pick up a few things and eat from any of their self-serve tables at the front (after picking up a disposable fork at the checkout). Or, it's just a grocery store. You can use it however you want. I came here for the creamy Tiramisu, not the cakey one, but the one that is available in the refrigerated aisle. It was $20 after tax, and was a decent size to feed two. And it was pretty good. It definitely had the coffee flavor, but like so many things in the city it's losing the alcoholic flavor. It was pretty tasty, but not something that I would never need again at that price. And that's why this place is four stars instead of five. Yeah it's at sherway gardens, which means the average income probably isn't concerned about the prices on anything here. But that's not me. There is one thing that stood out though, and it was the pizza. Everyone was eating the pizza, and it looked fantastic, and if I hadn't already had three meals today before noon I probably would have had a slice. Now, just for frame of reference that slice was $10. Or you could get the whole pizza for $60, but it's pretty big pizza. The cheese and mushroom pizza was the one that everybody seemed to be eating, and it's the one that stood out to me as well. But man, wouldn't it be great if you could just pay $60 and get a mixed 10 slice Pizza that let you sample them all? That would be an afternoon that I would remember forever! I'll be back, but not so often, because my wallet can only afford so much. But if that's not a concern for you, why not eat here everyday? Except probably for the fact that it's not great for your health. But who has time to think about such things! read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Eataly itself (the store) has amazing, fun products you can't get anywhere else. We dined at the restaurant and it was very expensive. The food and service were good, not great. I would go back occasionally but it's not a ton of the list favorite. read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

I love the ambience at Eataly, and the dining experience was enjoyable though there's some things to be improved. First off, the focaccia bread appetizer is excellent. Served hot, with olive oil to dip in (used it all and they brought more!), it is to die for. Ordered two of the linguine sea food dishes (mussels, clams, shrimp), with marinara sauce. It was a bit bland, and not the greatest portion, at least for me where I eat a decent size. Wouldn't recommend and price is a bit higher compared to what you'd expect to get. Rounding it off with a tiramisu dessert, this was beyond excellent and tasty. The server peels off the edge of the tiramisu when he brings it, and the extra cream on top boils down like a lava cake. If you were just going for this, it'd be more worth it than going for the whole meal. Otherwise for the store, they sell some great options of Italian pastas (from Italy and also handmade), olive oil, cheeses, chocolates, pizza slices (for on the go eating) and more. This is what I think I'll more stick to overall for my visits to Eataly. read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Tiramisu - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

This was my second visit, almost 5 months after my first. I made a reservation by phone the day before but called on the day of to add one more person. They claimed they didn't have my reservation and tried to make me take a different time. After insisting I needed the agreed time from the day before she agreed and I had the text confirmation from both days. When I arrived, they said I had 2 reservations?!?!so I told her to cancel the old one. Our server was friendly and chatty but getting water or plates cleared was slow. The food came very fast. The fam had the best salad and bruschetta to start. Hubby ordered a negroni that never arrived. The fam had the cheese wheel pasta, margherita pizza and steak and enjoyed it. I had come to try the gf pizza as they didn't have it on my first visit. The crust was light and fluffy and tasty. Problem is they would not accommodate making a vegan pizza with requested toppings. They said I had to choose an existing pizza on the menu and omit the cheese and meat. They would not add anything extra. So my pizza had tomatoes, mushrooms, a few olives and artichokes. It was bland but the spicy oil was very nice. They do not have any non dairy milk so we skipped coffees and ended up buying tiramisu from the takeout (way cheaper). read more

See all

Just thought that I'd update my review after a couple of visits of grabbing a dessert/coffee and dining in at La Pizza e La Pasta. When I asked about the difference between the 2 "restaurants", the blonde hostess had a bit of an attitude, like I was bothering her. She could've been friendlier. So that didn't make the best impression aside from her IG filter looks. Il Pastaio (exterior restaurant) serves fresh pasta dishes, from different regions in Italy, while La Pizza e La Pasta (enclosed restaurant) will serve SOME fresh pastas, but also has dry pastas, and more variety. Kinda pricey at ~$20-30/ea pizza/pasta especially considering the size, protein dishes are more expensive. If you're compare the price of the to-go bottles/cans from Indie Alehouse, it's quite a markup! Menu w/ pricing is online, so you can check it out before heading over. Portion sizes are just enough for share between 2ppl, no leftovers unless you eat like a bird. I ordered the Margherita Pizza and the Cacio e Pepe pasta, both were cooked well and GOOD. I thoroughly enjoyed both dishes! Actual service was pleasant, waitresses came around just enough. Definitely MORE enjoyable when you visit at an off-hour when it isn't as busy! read more

See all

Excellent pasta dishes. I enjoyed eating here. Venue is spacious and pleasing. Highly recommended.

Second Toronto location (downtown was first location). Great addition to Sherway; lost Nordstrom recently... so, a big new addition adds a lot. Great food and drink options (espresso!!). Super busy opening day. More visits to follow. read more

Eataly - Sherway Gardens - Exterior - Grocery Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Food is good but the service is not great. The server was overwhelmed on the weekend.

Fantastic menu selection, grocery option and wine. Good service. Enjoyed our experience

Went for the fixed price menu It was absolutely delicious had the salad and a veggie ravioli dish with lemon The service was amazing Will recommend to anyone read more

The service was fantastic (thanks Consuelo!). The food was above average, however, the portions (meat and fish plates) were on the smaller side and the price was pretty high for what we received. read more