This place is seriously to die for! Everything is SO delicious & always fresh! You can taste the…read morecare they provide when selecting their ingredients! Everyone is super helpful & friendly every single time we go! They have take great care of their little shop both inside & out, making you feel welcome & trusting the quality & integrity of their business!

Love their sundaes. We will likely work our way through each sundae on the list as the summer goes…read moreby.

Durbin magic freeze has been one of my favorite ice cream spot for years. They have so many…read moredifferent options for ice cream, milkshakes, slushies, frozen yogurt, and more. They also have ice cream cakes, which is very good for parties of course, but the reason I drive all the way from Cuyahoga Falls is because of their low prices and 100% in love with their toasted coconut ice cream flavor. The lines can get pretty long in the summertime, which is understandable, but the staff is friendly and the ice cream is delicious

Always good Been going there for 29+ years…read moreMy favorite ice cream in the area. They always have weekly specials and sell Christmas Trees

We stopped in to get the Egg Nog and ended up getting 4oz 4 flavor flight…read more What a great idea, ice cream flight. Farmhouse, waffely good, cheery cheese cake and mocha Carmel chip. We liked Farmhouse the best, but they are all very good ice cream. Staff is very nice, and we're so happy to get to visit the store, since we have only had their egg nog purchased at other retail outlets.

Was visiting Ohio and Amish country so on way back to Cleveland daughter recommend we stop here for…read moresome ice cream and milk! Place is great wish we lived here to keep enjoying that chocolate milk

Delicious food, friendly staff, place was very clean and tables/chairs/counter stools all very…read moreclean and in great shape. It was a pleasure to dine there.

What a terrific surprise…read more.. I drove from muncie indiana to pick up some auto parts at j.And j I had no idea how big Marshallville was but I assumed I could find a meal. I realize when I walked in that the place was hopping at the lunch hour, found a stool at the counter, given a menu by Brenna.. Chicken fried steak, eggs and really good sourdough toast. It was perfect exactly what I needed after a five hour drive. I don't think I'll be coming back to pick up any more auto parts... I wish the Gigi experience could happen closer to my home. Thank you.. I really enjoyed your restaurant and the excellence food/service.

Amazing. My niece's…read morecollege roommate works at this location and so we drove 45 minutes on a frigid day to order ice cream at a walk up only window and now I'm about 11 hours and 45 minutes away from this ice cream place and I'm thinking about a roadtrip. Ask about all the flavors. Whatever you like, they probably have an even better version of it.

I'm sure it's delicious but the line was too long on a Sunday night for us to stop!! And my mouth…read morewas watering for homemade ice cream...

Thee best soft serve ice cream anywhere near here. Worth the 15 minute drive once a week during…read moreseason. But tonight I went with Oreo and Reese flurry. Overloaded in every bite top to bottom. Couldn't be made better!

You pay $9.25 for a monster milkshake just to find out that they only fill it 3/4 such a scam you…read morecan get a 5 gallon tub of ice cream and a gallon of milk for about $7.50-$8.50

If you are an ice cream fan, but haven't been to Waylon's then you need to add this place to the…read moretop of your to do list. Can't believe they were open on the 4th! What a treat after a paddle at Nimisila Reservoir. I live about 35 minutes from them, but might make the trip back just for the ice cream. Waylon's must know how to hire pleasant staff. Saw another review complimenting staff demeanor and it was true today as well. The young lady was so pleasant. Can't wait to work my way through the huge buckeye brownie that I brought home for tomorrow. It's huge, so hopefully the boys will help. The store is in a strip mall, so it's fairly unassuming. But it's bright, clean and fun inside. Best wishes to this business!

This was the BEST ice cream cake I ever had. Blows DQ outta the water. I ordered online and picked…read moreup at Brecksville Hallmark. My order was confirmed and upon pickup they said to let the cake sit out 45 minutes (I wouldn't do that again though bc the cake was melting) I'd just take it out right when ready to serve next time bc it was very sloppy cutting the melting cake, but it was so so good. My husband and kids loved it. It tasted like real ice cream and tasted like authentic food not fake. Grant it I did not read the ingredients. I'd choose this again next.

I had lots of time to kill before a Yelp event 5 minutes away, saw this ice cream shop in the…read moremiddle of nowhere on the drive over, and immediately did a U-turn to check it out. Even though I did NOT need ice cream today, I was intrigued by their pumpkin soft serve seasonal option and ordered a small for $3.25. It was pretty good but not amazing. If I wasn't about to enjoy a heavy Yelp sponsored dinner at a brewery nearby, I would have tried one of the more enticing fall themed ice cream flavors like deep dish apple pie or even their version of a blizzard. Prices are slightly high but there are a couple things listed that are under 3 bucks. There's also an option for drive thru although I ordered my treat at the walk up windows.

Got the pumpkin custard. It was delicious, more vanilla than pumpkin. I like how the pumpkin…read moreflavor isn't overwhelming. Staff was nice and efficient. I like how their outdoor seating area has a gate to slow you down and look for traffic from the drive thru.

Went for Bfast with some others and tried the German Skillet which is really like an omelette with…read moreKielbasa mixed in w the hash browns. It was good although the skin of the kielbasa was almost like paper because it was not breaking down. I had to take care of that subtly with my napkin. But flavor was very good and our waitress was super despite being very busy.

This place was awesome! Server was super sweet, accommodating and helpful. He convinced me to get…read morethe patty melt. It did not disappoint! Delicious! I added fries and cole slaw which were great, too. I don't eat ice cream but they are famous for it and had pages of options. The atmosphere is very quaint and homestyle. It was tucked away in a tiny plaza but packed at lunch so must not be a secret!

Went here last night about 30 mins to close! The team working was fantastic! I have been to Handels…read moregrowing up my whole life but my first time at this one. Having an inside space especially in the colder months is amazing! They have screens that show you visually what each icecream looks like and I think it adds to the experience. Icecream is always delicious. I've been getting the same flavor since I can remember which is chocolaholic chunk. I am dye free now and would love to see them move to dye free icecream so more can enjoy all the flavors!

Awesome new location for Handel's Ice Cream! We are so excited that they opened this location. Lots…read moreof great, creative flavors, and very generous with the portions too! The whole family loves this place!