Thin, crispy chewy crust, delicious pepperoni and fresh provolone cheese on a square cut pizza,…read moreavailable by the slice, 1/2 tray or full tray. It's perfect just the way it is! Those of us who used to frequent the original Wally's Pizza in Cambridge, Ohio, grew up on this exact style of pizza that stems from the famous DiCarlo's Old Fashion Pizza out of the mid-Ohio Valley. I grew up for my first 11 years of life eating DiCarlo's Pizza out of Wellsburg, W.V. (it was my dad's favorite), then Wally's Pizza from 11 years old to now. I still love me some Wally's Old Fashion Pizza as well! My husband and I were in town for our annual 25th Class Reunion last week and were told by a friend that we've got to run into Byesville to try this pizza. We had saw that they were running a special on their Facebook page, which I highly recommend you follow to keep up with their specials. They were advertising a full tray for $20! So on our way back home to Virginia, we stopped and ordered a full tray. Of course we couldn't wait to eat it; it smelled so fantastic! We sat in the parking lot enjoying a few slices, and continued to pick at it on the way home. I was suddenly thinking that we should have ordered 2 trays, because the entire point of getting a tray was so that we could freeze and reheat some at another time, but we were easily making a dent into this pizza, because it is THAT good! We did manage to get home with at least "some" pizza left, (much less than one might expect from only 2 people), which I took to work for my lunch for a couple of days. This pizza is amazing! It is definitely worth going into small town Byesville for! Although Wally's in Cambridge will still be my favorite, as far as competition goes, Tommy does pizza right! I do like that Tommy's has the thinner, crispier crust like I prefer. Wally's Pizza has been hit or miss lately, when I've stopped in, when I'm in town. They used to stick with the thinner crust as well, but sometimes you get thin, sometimes you get thick...you never know what you're going to get, depending on who's making it. Either way, they're both great! On the other hand, Tommy's didn't throw as much cold cheese on top, like Wally's did the night before for us, and is consistent in doing. I guess I could have requested 'extra cheese', but I get that for free at Wally's. Otherwise, I can definitely say, I'll be back! Love it! Awesome pizza! Keep up the good work guys! UPDATE: My husband and I were back and town and specifically drove 45 minutes out of our way from Marietta to Byesville, JUST to pick up a tray of Tommy's Pizza to take home with us home to Virginia. I like mine super thin and crispy, and Tommy's offers that. This is the second time we have stopped here and both times it's been consistently good. I will say that the 1st time, they didn't cheese it up as much as Wally's does, so this is a tray with pepperoni, mushroom and extra cheese. Requesting extra cheese remedied that, but we had to pay for it when Wally's is complimentary. Also, the woman at the window who had EVIL tattooed on her neck was not friendly at all. She wanted to charge us 50 cents each for a box lid, even though we had just spent $30 on pizza and had made a special trip from Marietta to Byesville, just to get their pizza to take home! She slammed the window in my face, and it was enough to make me not want to return. We aren't local. We were driving and eating on the road, and had to stop at a store for paper plates (I wasn't paying them for a lid out of principle). If I continue to get attitudes like that, I will not return no matter how great it is. But as far as the pizza, it is much better than Wally's and I never thought I'd say that. I have been a fan of Wally's for more than 30 years!

They cook some great quality good tasting food staffs friendly and helpful services are great…read moreambiance is good atmosphere is good their great for community

Read this review! It will be difficult to properly emphasize…read moremy enthusiasm of this review without using curse words to get there... But I will do my best. I ordered a small order of wings (6) and had them mix their fiery hot sauce and roasted garlic to make a garlic hot... Which they did with no problem. I also ordered a medium voodoo pizza, a.k.a." the dumpster". The wings were comically large. I have never seen bigger chicken wings, not whole wings... just monstrous half wings... What would normally be the small kind... But these wings looked like someone went to the poultry Super Bowl and dismembered the winning teams entire offensive line. These wings were literally the size of my fist. And they were super nicely cooked and delicious. I'll include a picture, but my picture won't do them justice. The voodoo pizza was fantastic. It was a little bit on the sweet side, which is not normally my thing... But they nailed it. It's got a mix of a bunch of toppings I won't try to describe, including a drizzle of some kind of a Sweet barbecue sauce on the top... Which again would not normally be my thing at all... But this was fantastic. The young dude working at the counter was exceptionally nice and pleasant even though I rolled in at 10:30 at night. The decor was kind of old style pizza pub-ish, which was just my style. The place is just two or three minutes off the highway, and it was a fantastic stop to have made. I actually got off the exit for a place called Tommy's, which claimed to be open but unfortunately was not... I rechecked yelp, found this place that was open, and it was a great find. I highly recommend coming here if you live in the area or if you happen to be passing by on the highway. Easy five star.

Good pizza sauce is a little sweet and cut into strips makes it a little hard to keep topping onread more

Best kept pizza secret off Interstate 77! Never disappoints! We like to grab a pie as we're driving…read moreby...

Worst pizza we've had in a VERY LONG time, actually I've never given a bad review of this place, I…read moredo however always offer excellent reviews when warranted. Salads lettuce 2eggs and actually not quite any had worse!! $$ 43.00 $$ on worst order ever, not a place we will order again!!! So pass the shop and get a real pizza and salad!!!

There pizza terrible I moved from a large state never and live in a small town still and have eaten…read morelocal owner's pizza company never have I eaten some cheaply made pizza's we had to peel off the toppings and eat it and throw the rest away never again bad experience

These are some honest hard workers that makes great food so you don't have to good atmosphere…read morestaffs friendly very helpful their great for community's

They have great selection fresh great tasting food atmosphere is great ambiance is great services…read moreare good for customers staffs friendly helpful their great for community

This is a little old-school drive-in, and since it was right on my route and no one is dining in…read morenowadays, it seemed a good choice. And it turned out to be a great one. Ice cream, burgers, hot dogs, etc. I had hoped for home-made root beer, but no; also for a restroom, but no. Still, a snack seemed like a good idea, and the staff were super friendly, so I got an Orrburger (cheese/lettuce/tom/mayo/ketchup/pickles.) And saw corn nuggets, which I never pass up, so, yes, please. Made to order, but still up fast, I took the bag to my car. I wasn't super hungry, but man, that aroma made my car smell so good I started salivating. The burger is what a Big Mac wishes it was: two perfectly cooked patties, good bun, good toppings, all the flavors and textures working together perfectly. Bigger than a Big Mac, and tastier, and cheaper. The corn nuggets were piping hot and also tasty, and though the one thing I like at McD's is their fries, I still prefer corn. For $8 I had a good lunch (I already had a pop.) There are tables outside, and in summer this is probably the place to be for ice cream. Nothing fancy here, just good food. It's not too far off 77 so the next time I am down this way I will swing by.

Seeing other reviews for this dominoes and it's one star for a reason. I tried it many different…read moretimes, giving it the benefit of the doubt but this time was just beyond ridiculous. They got people in there that just don't care how the food is. This pizza was suppose to be a handmade pan, it's clear that it's just regular hand tossed as well as the fact that it's burnt. Took one bite and threw it in the trash, it was like chewing leather.

I ordered pizza this morning when I got there I found out I only had $100 bill I could understand…read morethem saying they didn't have change and I would have to go to the gas station and break the $100 bill that wouldn't have been a problem but when the boy told me that his female manager said that I would have to leave a tip in order for them to break the $100 bill I looked at him and told him to tell her to stick the pizza where the sun does not shine I could not imagine treating your customers like this I'm not done with this I will get a hold of corporate tomorrow morning and inform them about the Byesville store I have been a Domino's customer for over 50 years and I am done with Domino's the bitch needs fired and I will do everything I can to make sure this happens

Great stop with easy on/off Rt 70. We visited as Harvest Host stopover and had a great time…read more The Tavern/Vineyard has an amazing multi-tiered deck that overlooks the town and valley. Multiple tables and high-tops are around. The setting exudes calmness and relaxation. The staff is very friendly and welcoming. The food was delicious! They have a nice selection of local craft beers and tasty pitchers of sangria! The brick over pizza was amazing! I wish we'd ordered one to go for the next day. Portions are large and served promptly. One item on their "sampler platter" was hushpuppies. All of the member in the group agreed these were some of the bests we'd eaten. Highly recommend!

This place was AMAZING! You have to stop. We had great service. The bartender was very…read moreinformative and helpful with our selection. My wife got one of their alcohol slushes. I got one of their brews that was 10/10. The view was phenomenal overlooking the town. We just enjoyed sitting in a chair and talking and enjoying the view and weather and the tranquility. This place is definitely worth the stop. The drinks were amazing and the pizza was 10/10. You MUST stop and check this place out .

This piece of places is pretty good but their customer service it's not the best some people by not…read morelike the food, but I do so that that's why I'm giving it 3 stars some stuff could've been approved

the dipping sauce I got tonight was bad. it had a terrible pungent odor to it with liquid coming…read moreout the lid and bubbling . it had to of gone bad over a day ago. I'm so glad I spelled it before using it.

they are so rude? and not welcoming they are very rude to each other. Definitely not a friendly…read moreplace. its just a bunch of brats. the only ones who was actually nice was the girl with long braids she was so kind and sweet she made my ice cream so well, and she was so friendly

Great milkshakes and ice cream. Probably the second best in the area. The food isn't crazy good but…read morethe ice cream is definitely where they shine

As I pulled into my hotel across the street, I saw The Forum and wondered how it was. In a sea of…read morechain restaurants, I was glad to see there was one that wasn't familiar to me. And, as I was checking in, the hotel desk clerk recommended to me. I ordered the steak salad. It was so good & so unusual. Fresh spring mixed lettuce, cucumber, lots of cheese, a healthy portion of steak, mandarin oranges and, to top it off, nice, big onion rings. The service was good as well. This seems to be a local favorite; lots of groups and families, and some people who were also waiting were talking about how everything they get is good. Definitely worth a stop!

Off the I-70, and checked into the Quality Inn overlooking Cambridge, OH, Terrie at the front desk…read morementioned that if she were off right now, she'd be down the hill at the Forum enjoying Greek food. Well I was sold. And man, The Forum Restaurant delivered. I enjoyed the flaming cheese saganaki, white wine and lemon haddock, and a matching pinot grigio for fun! My favorite was how everyone around me too enjoyed their food, and when I came back for dinner later in the day - my fellow diners were acting like it was their dinner table. I think that was the vibe Terrie had mentioned, and the reason why I would direct any and all to The Forum Restaurant!