While staying in a local hotel we stopped here as it was the only restaurant with seating nearby. Our expectations were low, but it was decent! The only seating is the patio which was extremely cute. The pizza had a thin, crispy crust, making 4 pieces per person do-able. The servers were very friendly and brought the pizzas out to us on the patio. We walked around town after, which has historic buildings. This place was affordable and good! The special was $8.95 for 4 slices and a drink. read more

See all

Drifting away from what Wally pizza was. Disappointed with my last couple orders. Not sure if new mgmt or not. Thinking the drive to the original store might be in the future and hope for the best. read more

Great subs and amazing pizza!! Snuggled in a small town it's the perfect small town venue!! Warm and welcoming!!

They are honest hard workers that make honest living they make great pizza staff is very friendly and helpful their great for community's

Endured bad service for some mid pizza. Creno's right down the road. Just go there instead.

Went to pick my order up, I assumed it would be ready so I was standing by the door when this old man behind the counter told me to go wait outside because it makes them nervous that I was standing there watching them, I was waiting on my order and opening the door for the gentleman in front of me, I had no idea my order wasn't ready because no one said it would be a few more minutes!! Love the pizza but will never go back due to the old man being so rude!!! read more

Very nice staff and a great big sub. A very convenient way to get a dinner sub. Perfect.

TL;DR: Close to freeway, clean, cheap, friendly, solid pizza. Nice place that isn't too far off the freeway (about 1.5 miles) if you are driving through and looking from somewhere to eat that isn't a chain. You can get pizza by the slices by request, took about ten minutes, but wasn't too bad (could have called ahead). The staff members were very friendly and the everything looked clean and orderly. We ordered six slices of pizza and a can of pop, and it was less than $9, so you can't beat that. The pizza was good, I've had better, but solid nonetheless. Would recommend. read more

See all

Italian Sub, no dressing, extra Mayo, extra banana peppers, lightly toasted. You're welcome.

I don't want to be mean, but I'd pick any chain over Wally's. I really don't see what the draw is. Is it just the cheapest option? Do you need to feed a lot of people? It's so plain, it's like you went to the store and picked up a pizza kit for your kids. Dull crust that's thin, even crispy in the middle. Yet, thicker and bready toward the edge. There's no complexity to the sauce. There's so much cheese, there's even extra floating around the box that didn't make it onto the pie. And two whole carefully placed pepperonis per slice. Maybe if you're eight years old, but I can't see an adult ordering this for themselves. read more

Call in to order delivery, won't take order have to use "online". Can't get internet so call back to explain...nope, online orders only. Called competitor, order placed, arrived and was delicious. Got a new place to order from now. Spent over $40 at the place down the road, hope Wally's enjoys the profit from ZERO. What happened? Wally's been my place for years, was happy they opened a place in New Concord, very disappointed lately. read more

Great pizza friendly ppl clean place!!!!!!!! We will be back for some great tasty pizza

Wallys has one of the best pizza subs I have ever had! I did not enjoy the blt sub as much, the bacon was cold when I got my order. For the most part they have amazing service but I would call ahead if you are ordering on Thursday Friday or Saturday! They are closed on Sunday's! But they tend to get very busy. The pizza is decent not my favorite but good!! read more

Ordered one piece of pizza, they gave me two. Legends. Taste delicious. All you need to know.

I am proud to say that i truly enjoyed my first experience eating WALLY'S delicious pizza. I had the spicy grilled chicken pizza with bacon, lots of delicious cheese, and hot sauce. The crust was very crispy and like a bakery style .... so awesome tasting If you have a taste for something spicy this is a wonderful choice. I highly recommend WALLY'S Pizza. read more

Wally's Pizza - a man giving a thumbs up - Pizza Near Me - New Concord, Ohio

So I live 1.3 miles from this place. Me and my family order pizza( subs, salads) 2-3 times a week, the app NEVER WORKS.. sometimes u can call and get delivery... sometimes u can't... depends on who's working... soo A) fix the app. ) b) be consistent (I'm willing to prepay for delivery) c) order from Crenos.... (They always deliver) mike needs to step in on this one and say we are losing money not accepting delivery over the phone if they are willing to prepay... also for you drivers, I tip $10+ for going 1 mile down the road... I love Wally's pizza... it's awesome... just can't get it to my house because of their issues! When I'm home, I'm home! I don't feel like leaving again!!! read more

So this is my first experience with Wallys and the pizza is delicious. Huge yummy kids hubs and I all liked it.

Just called the place for a delivery and the host on the phone answered laughing. He then apologized for laughing then I proceeded to ask to place an order and he continued to laugh. I got to placing my order and he was laughing at something more important than taking an order. I told him I will just call somewhere else since he was too busy laughing. Creno's took my order pleasantly. read more

Amazing food, great owner & employees, so accommodating and helpful. We were visiting the university and needed to feed a large group on the road. Called ahead, gave us a great deal for a large order of sub's. We didn't have the pizza but it looked delicious. Owner even followed up and made sure we were satisfied with our order. Next time we are in town we will definitely eat at Wally's. read more

I grew up with Wally's and we love it! They're so friendly, and our pizza is usually perfect. We don't get it often as we live far away, but when we are in town we order! read more

I dislike their pizza, it is very plain and the way they make it disgusts me. It always gives me the runs and to be honest their employees and terrible. Terrible people, terrible food, and most of all terrible ownership. read more