This place was recommended to us by friends, so we went today and enjoyed it. We loved the modern…read moreatmosphere and the seating was comfortable. The waitress was prompt and our order came out perfectly. I started with a cucumber lemonade (with alcohol) drink and it was yummy as all get out. I'd have loved to have one or three more but didn't want the hangover! I ordered the 8" veggie pizza and minused the peppers. I usually don't order veggie simply due to the amount of liquid that ends up sogging up the crust. I suspected today's would be good and it was! I had enough left over to bring home for a snack during movie night. Hubs had the meat lovers and he enjoyed it and a draft beer. We're not local but we'd come back if we were.

Best Italian sausage sub what i ever ate. Staff was friendly and accommodating. Place always packed…read morewhen I went . Smells great too.

This turned into a two meal takeout order because we got sweets from their case that were too…read moretempting to pass up, and then got sandwiches for lunch. I was a little happier with my blueberry muffin than I was my Cousin Vinny. I wanted so bad for the sandwich to taste like an amazing Muffaletta because of the ingredients, but it didn't blow my mind. Still, it was fine. It was disappointing that they were out of chicken cutlets because several of the sandwiches had that as the critical ingredient. But I would go back to explore the cutlets and their various Italian mains (lasagna, meatballs, etc) if I am ever in Nelsonville again.

Cute little spot in this town. Grabbed some tiramisu. It was pretty good. Quick and fast service…read moreand good selection.

My husband and I housesat for friends in Athens, and they recommended we go to Tavolino for a…read moreweekend dinner. This place functions primarily as a daytime café, but on Fridays and Saturdays, the chef/owner crafts a rotating four-course menu that changes weekly. There is a shared bread or antipasto course for the table, then a choice of soup or salad, two entrees, and two desserts. We went the Friday of Memorial Day weekend. The bread course was a delicious focaccia, light and pillowy and infused with rosemary flavor. When we told our server how much we loved it, she offered us a clamshell with two additional slices to take home. That was such a nice gesture! I had the soup (a cream-based Italian soup with sausage, kale and potatoes), while my husband had the salad with homemade balsamic dressing. Both hit the spot. The dinner options were a choice of pastas. I had the puttanesca, which was bursting with big flavors from the garlic, anchovy and olives. If I had one slight criticism, it would have been that I'd have loved a touch more red pepper -- but I'll freely admit I have a higher spice tolerance than most people. My husband had the "summer fettuccine," which was prepared with bacon, corn and sun-dried tomatoes in a Gorgonzola cream sauce. I didn't taste it because I'm not a fan of the Gorgonzola flavor, but he raved. Both desserts were superb: a strawberry cake and an apple cake that our server informed us was also vegan. We never would have known. It was not dense at all in the way some vegan desserts can be. The server and the chef/owner were both so lovely and welcoming to two non-locals who stumbled in for dinner on a rainy night. It seemed like they knew everyone else there by name, so this is definitely a warm and inviting neighborhood place. The four-course dinner is a steal at $38 per person (plus tax and tip). It's also BYOB. We will surely be back on our next trip to Athens!

We had a private dinner for a social group, and it was amazing! We had the place to ourselves, and…read morewe could speak openly without the normal restaurant distractions of other customers. Food was fabulous! And surprisingly reasonably priced. Service for a group can be challenging with all the discussion, but our server was perfect.

You're in for a treat if Evan happens to be working the bar. Try one of his specials or let him…read moresurprise you. As far as food, the grilled cheese is my go to. It's not only comforting but absolutely delicious.

Quiet and relaxing atmosphere. Service was quick and thorough. Food top notch- hot, affordable, and…read morealways have leftovers for the next day to enjoy.

we were looking to try a new to us local restaurant. it had been on my list for several months…read more we had the ravioli -- beef ravioli, lobster ravioli and mushroom ravioli. all super delicious all made w quality ingredients the owner was our waiter , our cook and talked to us we had the lemon truffle and the chocolate dessert and it was amazing. we would go back for the desserts alone it is CASH only

Over priced asf... cash only and they had no atm working and portions were tiny it was almost…read morelaughable for 30$+ owner was nice but very pushy. food was alright but not worth 30$ + for a tiny portion. We could almost not believe how little the portion was for the price and how it was cash only and had to drive to the nearest gas station for cash. Absolute disaster of a dinner

The food has always been delicious and the staff is very friendly and good at what they do. I don't…read morethink theres ever been a time that ive left there unhappy.

Stopped in while headed home for the holidays. Greeted by a nice staff and an excessive amount of…read moreChristmas decorations. Esp. for days ahead of Thanksgiving. But it looked nice. Family ordered a variety of meals. The Trio of Italy with fettuccini Alfredo, chicken parmesian, and lasagna. Ziti rosa, Ziti marinara and a big pepperoni pizza. The dipping bread came out with marinara. It was ok. The salads weren't that exciting either and the blue cheese dressing was truly not great. The potato soup was better but also not remarkable. The mains came quickly and followed suit. Most things weren't bad they just seemed like a knockoff Olive Garden - and that's not exactly great either. The exceptions were the lasagna and chicken parmesan. The lasagna just wasn't good at all and the chicken was overdone and dry. I found the pizza decent, but the rest of the family was less impressed. Our oldest said it reminded her of high school pizza and others reported it was bland. We didn't complain but someone was kind enough to provide a complimentary cheesecake with the sauces. One who sampled it didn't find it to be that wonderful either.

Loved the environment, great Italian made pizza! My wife, kids, and I loved it! We will be back…read moreagain!

The restaurant is very nicely decorated and looks clean and neat. That's about where the positives…read moreend. The salad was just way too much shredded lettuce and we weren't asked what kind of dressing we wanted, the waitress just brought some vinaigrette. The waitress kept telling us she had heart issues and that's why she's slow. Then she disappeared for awhile and when she reappeared, she told us she passed out in the kitchen. We got a cheese pizza, an Italian sausage hoagie with peppers, and fettuccini alfredo. The cheese pizza had almost no sauce and tasted like the Italian seasoning they sprinkled all over it and nothing else. The Italian sausage hoagie was a joke. Little tasteless gray balls of sausage and it was so sweet it tasted like they just poured sugar all over it instead of Parmesan. My kid liked the alfredo, but I didn't like the price for how much he got. Then at the end the waitress charged us for stuff we didn't order and the check just has numbers on it so without the menu in front of you it's hard to figure out where the error occurred. We were disappointed after a few locals said this place was good. **update: checked my checking account and discovered the waitress added a $15 tip on top of the incorrect charge without authorization. Contacted bank to dispute the charges

Our dinner this evening was awesome. Environment is perfect…read more Server (Audrey) is attentive and is one of the best. She went above and beyond!!

Great server and good food, but sloooow kitchen…read more Yes, we were a group of 18. Drinks and salads come promptly. Food took another 90 minutes.

My wife and I stumbled upon OMHI on the way back to Columbus after a day trip to Pittsburgh. What a…read morefind! The interior of the restaurant is modeled after the interior of the oldest pub in London, the Prospect of Whitby. Trust me, you'll be amazed. On to the food. I had the lasagna, which is served in a bowl to accommodate a pool of delicious tomato sauce. The lasagna was wonderful, full of String cheese and crushed meatballs. My wife has the vodka pasta, which was likewise delicious Ice cream desserts use a locally made ice cream and we're incredible, as was the creme brulee. This place is definitely worth a drive from Columbus. We'll be back!

Very good service. A wide selection to choose from and Very cozy feeling…read more The food was great.