This is the best game / nerd shop ever. The service is amazing and the owners are super friendly…read moreand make you feel welcome! The selection and prices are amazing. There is so much variety !! Everything is perfect and everyone should support this company over corporate!! I'd highly recommend for anyone interested in going, you will not be disappointed

This is our favorite retro gaming shop anywhere we've traveled. The staff is super helpful,…read moreknowledgeable, fun, and friendly. They have a wide selection and they update their social media frequently with new items. If they don't have something, they can either get it or tell you where you can find it. The one time we had a problem with an item, they immediately made it right with a smile and without any hesitation. We try to visit at least twice a month. It's about a 30 minute ride each way for us, but absolutely worth the trip. On the rare trip that we don't buy anything, we still have a fun time. If you're a retro gamer, this will become quickly one of your favorite stores.

Whether you are a collector of sports cards/memorabilia; someone shopping for a sports fan in the…read morefamily; or simply searching for something unique for yourself that you can't seem to find anywhere else, this is where you should go! I enjoy looking at cards/memorabilia the old fashion way where I can hold and view the actual item I'm purchasing rather then going online and hoping for the best. That is one of the many reasons I am a frequent visitor here. It has a vast variety of unique sports cards/memorabilia no matter what sport, team, or player you are a fan of. Even more outstanding then the selection to choose from is the friendly service you will receive from the owner. John has gone out of his way numerous times for me in helping me find what I was looking for, or answering questions I had. He is more then fair on his prices and very trust worthy, so you never have to second guess whether you are getting a fair deal on what you are buying or selling. With the strong online presence of sports memorabilia, there are not many places like this that exist anymore. This only demonstrates what a outstanding job he does running a very successful and fun establishment.

From the owner: We carry a wide range of video games, systems, and accessories along with sport and non-sport…read morecards, collecting supplies, autographs, and sports memorabilia from your favorite teams. We are western New York's only authorized Beckett Grading Submission center and JSA authorized dealer. We offer appraisals on one item or whole collections. We buy, sell, and trade so bring in your old unwanted items.

DO NOT ALLOW THEM TO RESURFACE YOUR DISCS FOR FREE, here is my story of what happened to me. I took…read morein 2 discs to get resurfaced on 3/12/18 at 3:55 pm by Jay who I'm assuming is one of the owners. Along with buying 2 items I had the discs of resident evil 4 and scarface for ps2 get resurfaced. The scarface game was working and I wanted it to be resurfaced so the scratches on it wouldnt get any worse, the resident evil 4 disc stopped working at a certain point in the game. After getting the discs resurfaced i waited 2 days before trying them as to keep them from melting as i know that they need time to cool after the resurfacing. The resident evil 4 discs still hasn't gotten better but that isn't my issue, the scarface disc right after he finished resurfacing it, now had multiple burn/melt marks which he told me would fix themselves within a few days. It is now 3/23 and they are still present. The scarface disc does not get past the first loading screen as it did before i brought it in. Today I brought this disc into his store and told him it was completely broken and he responded with "Well I didn't charge you for it so what do you want me to do" the entire time he said this he looked at me and smiled which gave me the impression that he has done this before and uses the fact that he gave it to you for free as protection from being held accountable for destroying my disc. This is speculation on my part. Since he is not bound by any in store policy for destroying my disc this is just a story of a private citizen trusting another private citizen to do what they asked the other to do, and instead destroying the first citizens property, and hiding behind the fact that they did it for free in order to not be held accountable for their actions. I used to shop at this place a lot as they have a great selection of games but I will never ever be giving this place my money again. Keep in mind that supporting this business while you are aware of the shady things they have done is inadvertently supporting said shady things. After seeing how this establishment treats a long time customer like me so poorly shows me that they care very little about customer satisfaction, and my only hope is that this business either changes around their smug, uncaring attitude, or dies like the many other game stores that have tried to open there.

This is my most favorite shops in Geneva!! The they have great deals and the consoles we have…read morepurchased have worked for years now and just got a great deal on the most recent console I purchased! Josh and Justin are great guys and are extremely informative and helpful. I will continue to shop there as long a they stick around.. Thumbs up Guys!!

Great store, friendly environment, and I never feel screwed when I leave there (that's high praise…read morefor a game store). Josh, Justine and aj are the best!!!!!

Why isn't there any reviews for this gem of a retro game store. They sell mostly everything of…read morewhat's new and almost everything of what's old. The manager (a.k.a Radman) or Tim is the best game store clerk known to man

Legacy is so much more than a game store - while they do fulfill that role beautifully!…read more Legacy Games in Webster is a home. It is a safe haven for creativity, imagination, and open discussion through the common enjoyed experiences of trading card games, board games, video games, and more. Awesome community, awesome ownership, great location.

Have been going here since November. Keep coming back. Night and day with their friendly and…read morewelcoming atmosphere compared to other local game stores. Very knowledgeable and don't try to push products on you. Played with my son there during events and very much a community that teaches those who are new and not experienced as others. Absolutely love it here and keep coming back supporting them with my time and purchases!

Amazing little store thats packed wall to wall up to the ceiling with everything. And theyre…read morebuilding a second store!! Its like what oogie used to be but even better.

These guys have everything that GameStop or any other game store doesn't even have! They have a…read morehuge collection of Nintendo, Xbox, PlayStation, SEGA games for every console and a huge variety of systems (all models).

While walking the Canandaigua Arts & Music Festival we stumbled on this cool retro video game shop…read more It's apparently been around a while but doesn't show up in searches when we've tried to find similar places. The store has a good selection, though organization of the titles was a little haphazard. Still, this is a solid store that we will be sure to add to our regular rotation of retro game stores we frequent. You should this place out for hidden gems!

Awesome store with a great selection and great prices. Some insanely cool older rare games and…read moreaccessories too. A great place to checkout if you're a retro gaming fan!! They have a huge selection of new and used games. This place is so fun.

This store is out of the way, but worth your time. They have some of the more hard to find items…read moreand lots of retro hardware. The store is very well organized and the staff is knowledgeable. We try to stop here weekly.

The place has a good vibe and I like seeing places that have space for gathering and gaming events…read more However, I wandered around for quite a while looking at stuff, and not a single person greeted me or asked whether I needed help finding things, whether I had any questions - nothing. Am I a ghost? Unclear. They had some fun geeky Funko pops and Critical Role figurines.

This shop is off the beaten path. Initially it looked promising. Video games aren't the primary…read morefocus, but the shop looked cool. Selection was decent, though we were saddened to see huge stickers on all the cases/boxes -- including some that were cardboard. If you're a retro game collector, you likely care about case/box condition. Ultimately, we decided not to purchase games here because of this.