Whether you are a collector of sports cards/memorabilia; someone shopping for a sports fan in the…read morefamily; or simply searching for something unique for yourself that you can't seem to find anywhere else, this is where you should go! I enjoy looking at cards/memorabilia the old fashion way where I can hold and view the actual item I'm purchasing rather then going online and hoping for the best. That is one of the many reasons I am a frequent visitor here. It has a vast variety of unique sports cards/memorabilia no matter what sport, team, or player you are a fan of. Even more outstanding then the selection to choose from is the friendly service you will receive from the owner. John has gone out of his way numerous times for me in helping me find what I was looking for, or answering questions I had. He is more then fair on his prices and very trust worthy, so you never have to second guess whether you are getting a fair deal on what you are buying or selling. With the strong online presence of sports memorabilia, there are not many places like this that exist anymore. This only demonstrates what a outstanding job he does running a very successful and fun establishment.

From the owner: We carry a wide range of video games, systems, and accessories along with sport and non-sport…read morecards, collecting supplies, autographs, and sports memorabilia from your favorite teams. We are western New York's only authorized Beckett Grading Submission center and JSA authorized dealer. We offer appraisals on one item or whole collections. We buy, sell, and trade so bring in your old unwanted items.

This store is out of the way, but worth your time. They have some of the more hard to find items…read moreand lots of retro hardware. The store is very well organized and the staff is knowledgeable. We try to stop here weekly.

Great services, top quality games. Good trade in credit. Every system you can think of.read more

A huge selection of items, but definitely at a treasure hunt kind of vibe as it is a bit of a junk…read morestore. Super friendly dogs greet you, and the staff are nice as well. This has a vendor style set up, and seems to change around. It is winter, and I will say the place is freezing, but it gave home to a little room up and to the side that had a friendly man who really turned his space into a little oasis. It was shut off from the rest, had space heaters and was well curated with items. It was a really fun place to find. Recently they seemed to have turned the front into a redemption center for recycling. I am all about recycling but it did smell really terrible. It was also cold enough we didn't get to explore all of the floors. In the waaaaay back there is a door labeled with a sign that says "unheated! Close door behind you!" This vendor space had some really gorgeous antiques in it, with a few lights I am still thinking about. My advice is to go, dress warm if its cold outside, and prepare for a little adventure as there are twists and turns and places to find everywhere. Not all the stairs are connected too, so if you find a place with stairs, go up them!

Huge hodgepodge of unrelated antiques. The best ones are…read moreupstairs in the front We found two things we can't leave behind. Gottem!! At a discount 1/2 off from one dealer on site, upstairs. Thank you Big Teddy Bear Collector.

While walking the Canandaigua Arts & Music Festival we stumbled on this cool retro video game shop…read more It's apparently been around a while but doesn't show up in searches when we've tried to find similar places. The store has a good selection, though organization of the titles was a little haphazard. Still, this is a solid store that we will be sure to add to our regular rotation of retro game stores we frequent. You should this place out for hidden gems!

I stopped by Sound Go Round today (May 27) with a bunch of Pokémon plush toys, some action figures,…read moreand a few DVD movies. My brother-in-law and nephew came along, but this was strictly my deal -- they were just along for the ride. I was really happy with how smoothly everything went. The staff treated me well, and I walked out with a nice mix of store credit and cash in my pocket. I didn't make a big fuss or smile too much because I didn't want my family thinking I was getting any kind of special treatment. They actually thought I was crazy for making the trade at all, but that's okay -- it was my stuff, and I'm the one who decides. I wasn't trying to get rich or score a huge payday; I'd just gotten bored with it all and wanted it gone. Sound Go Round handled everything fairly and professionally. Thanks for making the process easy!

This place is absolutely amazing, regardless of your era. They have a vintage collection from just…read moreabout every gaming and toy era you can imagine, and the place is HUGE. Whatever your nerd heart desires, whether it is comic books, movies, cds, game consoles, action figures, clothing, plush toys, etc etc. This place will scratch your itch. Can't recommend enough.

This is the best game / nerd shop ever. The service is amazing and the owners are super friendly…read moreand make you feel welcome! The selection and prices are amazing. There is so much variety !! Everything is perfect and everyone should support this company over corporate!! I'd highly recommend for anyone interested in going, you will not be disappointed

This is our favorite retro gaming shop anywhere we've traveled. The staff is super helpful,…read moreknowledgeable, fun, and friendly. They have a wide selection and they update their social media frequently with new items. If they don't have something, they can either get it or tell you where you can find it. The one time we had a problem with an item, they immediately made it right with a smile and without any hesitation. We try to visit at least twice a month. It's about a 30 minute ride each way for us, but absolutely worth the trip. On the rare trip that we don't buy anything, we still have a fun time. If you're a retro gamer, this will become quickly one of your favorite stores.

The store was nice and organized and the people that work there are really nice and helpful. I…read morebought two systems, one was a PS3 the other an original Xbox. I don't live in Upstate NY anymore and wanted to bring the PS3 down to Florida with me. Unfortunately two buttons on the ps3 controller didn't work at all when I went to set up the system. Because I live far I couldn't swap it out for one that works. Downside to used systems and games. Other than the controller not working, the system works and was for a good price.

This place is a true local gem! If you're looking for vintage games this will be ur new BFF!! When…read morewe moved to the area, a few months ago, we found this place rather by chance along our walk route. We have enjoyed the massive selections of vintage games more than any other shop in Manlius! Also, the staff is beyond helpful. Being able to browse, getting questions answered and receiving fantastic recommendations is why we go here over eBay as we once did.

I am writing to echo the sentiment of several reviewers here as I too experienced an uncomfortable…read moreinteraction with who I believe is the owner. My wife and I were checking out the Ithaca Commons and leisurely walked into this comic shop. As soon as we walked in, the owner asked if we needed help. I said I was just browsing. He then asked if I collected comics. I said I used to up until 2005 but then sorta lost interest due to the over-saturation of the semi-annual crossover events, but I still have a rough knowledge of the happenings in the current Marvel Universe. The guy then started getting really pushy by suggesting that I get back into comic collecting by picking up a trade paperback. I felt pretty uncomfortable so I just kept browsing around the store. My wife tried making small talks asking if he had any nearby restaurant suggestions. He gave an awkward answer (I'm paraphrasing here), "not really, food is food." And then resumed pestering me to buy a book. If I haven't bought a comic in the last 20 years, what makes him think that I was gonna start in his shop during a trip 3000 miles away from home? I was getting really uncomfortable at this point with the awkward silence so I picked up an issue that I had mild interest in. I imagine if we walked out empty handed he would have scolded us like he did to many other people here. 2 stars instead of 1 because he wasn't awfully rude I guess. ‍

Best place in Ithaca to buy comics they have a good selection of old and new comics and if you…read moredon't want to miss an issue of one you can get a subscription.