This place is cute. Very New York, everyone was very friendly, had a local vibe. The cashier was…read morevery nice. I like the decor and the way they write everything on the blackboards. It's very colorful. It's also very clean and tidy. My order didn't take long. And my cashier was the one handing out the orders and he had a smile on his face. I got us whole wheat everything bagel with a fried egg, chipotle Gouda, and turkey sausage with chipotle mayo with a hash brown on the side. And when I opened the bagel open I could see the cheese from both ends of the bagel melting apart, I was in heaven. It tasted so good. And the best part was that my bagel didn't fall apart (like some places). Everything was so delicious. I was left very happy and very pleased with this place. I will be back.

Not too far from Penn Station. A great meal to start the day in NYC if you're arriving in the…read moremorning. I had a plain bagel with lox, onions, scallions, and tofu spread, which seems to be a cream cheese alternative. The bagel was perfectly toasted. I didn't even know a bagel could be perfectly toasted. There was a generous serving of lox, and the tofu spread was a bit runny. Overall, an excellent bagel and a great experience.

The food is terrific. Staff is too. Ambiance is very much…read moreNYC. Seating outside is a plus.

We stopped in on a whim after seeing their sign, and I'm so glad we did! We were hungry and ordered…read moreright away. I don't remember the exact name of my dish, but it was avocado toast--and let me tell you, it was delicious! It had a light lemon flavor and a perfectly cooked sunny-side-up egg. My husband ordered the pastrami sandwich, and it was stacked high, juicy, and full of flavor! I enjoyed a hot herbal tea, and he had orange juice. Such a delicious find! We'll definitely be back next time we're in New York. Don't skip this place!

Simply fab & yummmmmm!! I am in love with this place…read more... Can't wait for this place to come to our own Colorado , Boulder! The bagels are superrr here...fresh & super soft! & the cinnamon butter here is delicious! Service is pretty quick....inspite of being a super crazy line.... So explore the streets of New York & keep enjoying these best bagels in town! Highly recommended guys... If you in the area...

They are delicious iF you eat them right away but a day…read morelater... rock solid! So the biggest mistake these guys make is selling them by minimum of three Cuz two of them are gonna go bad... Then they give you so much Schmear that you cannot eat and then you end up having too much of everything. That makes the one good bagel and two the trash for 15 bucks

It's all in the name: bagels bagels bagels. I had a classic: nova with the works on near perfect…read moreeverything bagel. It's a tiny place below street level so it's not perhaps a place to linger. Service was a tad slow, but you have to make an allowance for morning rush.

"Low gluten" bagels are available here. I ate one & didn't die. Field research…read more It wasn't the best bagel I've ever had, but it was far from the worst. The extensive cream cheese options were so fun! It looked like a gelato counter at first glance, with how many choices there were. I went with the cinnamon walnut situation on a sesame "low gluten" bagel & it hit the spot. My French vanilla iced coffee was decent as well. All in all, it was the fuel I needed for my long day in Manhattan. I'd probably return if I was craving a bagel. Thanks for considering us gluten-free folks!

We found this place next to our hotel in Times Square and we ended up eating breakfast here almost…read moreevery morning! Great bagel sandwiches (sausage egg & cheese was my favorite!) and their iced coffees were amazing! They serve them in plastic/metal sealed containers so they tend to stay cold longer. I tried 3 different coffees in 3 days and they were all great! Service can be a little slow at times because it gets CROWDED in the mornings, but I won't knock them for that. Also there is only a tiny area to sit but it's NYC so that is typical.

The ambience was really inviting as the decor was whimsical and colorful. For a rainy Sunday the…read moreplace was packed, but my husband & I were able to secure a table to dine in. For it being our first time, we were a little confused with the ordering process, and they were so busy that it took a while to be acknowledged. There were kiosks to place the order, but we couldn't find a place to request special requirements, so we had to figure out how we could order at the register amongst the slew of other customers. Our order for 2 bacon egg and cheeses were called with a biscoff iced latte and we were excited at first. But when we opened the sandwiches our bacon was just 3, maybe 4 fatty pieces when we specifically asked for crispy bacon. My husband settled for his, but I requested a reorder where they corrected the bacon issue, and even put more slices. Besides that snafu, I was excited for my latte, but was also underwhelmed by the taste. I assumed since it was a biscoff cookie latte (which I love) that it would be sweeter... The establishment was nice, and there were so many selections, so we would give it another try before writing it off completely.

I only had one day in NYC, and this spot was HIGHLY recommended! The line was out the door, but…read moregiven how many people were there it went super fast! They obviously got the crowd work down! This was possibly the absolute BEST bagel I've had in my life! I got the BEC with a hashbrown and garlic bagel, and man let me tell you... The ambiance of the place was pretty cool too! We went when they were decorated for Halloween so it was aesthetically pleasing. Can't wait to come back and try more!!

2nd bagel of the trip, and we made our way to Liberty Bagels to give it a try…read more We went with an Asiago bagel with jalapeno cream cheese. It came out to around $7 bucks and it's a good-size bagel. A little light on the cream cheese though. Coming from the Bay Area, pretty much any nyc bagel is going to be better than what we typically get but I found this one to be ok. Of the New York bagels I've eaten over the years, I felt like it was just ok. It wasn't super busy, so if you need a quick bite and craving a bagel, it'll do what it needs to do.

Great breakfast spot in the city! Bagels and coffee are top notch! They have a big selection of…read morecream cheese for everyone, and their sandwiches are amazing! Service here is 10/10; friendly, welcoming, and helpful! The pub itself is warm and comfortable feeling, and great music playing throughout the place. If you're wanting an authentic New York bagel, and want to enjoy it in a chill atmosphere, this is the spot!

I love this place! I discovered it on a bagel tour and their coffee is excellent and their bagels…read moreare delicious! You have the try the pumpernickel everything bagel with za'atar and olive cream cheese. Something I never would've thought I'd like but the ultimate savory slam to your tastebuds! The lemon poppyseed is also very good! PS- try the black & white cookies! I don't have anything to compare them to but it were fresh and so so good for my husband and I's first black & white!

we stopped here for lunch on a thursday around 12 pm. there was a short line, but it moved quickly…read more it's decently sized in there, with a few tables to sit and eat on. we ordered the atlantic salmon bagel sandwich and the ham/egg breakfast sandwich. the salmon sandwich was LOADED. they slathered on a thick layer of cream cheese and SLABS of smoked salmon were placed on top of that. this was the first time i couldn't finish a smoked salmon bagel. it was freaking delicious. the ham/egg breakfast sandwich was alright. it wasn't outstanding, but also not bad. will be returning for more salmon sandwiches!!! :p

We wanted the authentic NYC lox sandwich experience, so naturally we had to stop by this seemingly…read moremost- visited bagel shop. After seeing how insane the breakfast line was, we decided to come back in the afternoon instead. For $16, we got a lox sandwich with everything bagel, regular cream cheese, salmon, tomato, and onion. Capers cost an extra $1, apparently they are not included by default at this location. The bagel was well baked, with the perfect chewy texture without being dry, and they were pretty generous with the smoked salmon. Overall it was a very solid lox sandwich. Would I wait in an insane morning line for it, though? Probably not.

We just had the best experience dining and enjoying drinks at this place! Huge thanks to Jorge and…read moreOmar for taking such amazing care of us behind the bar. Their recommendations were spot-on, the drinks were incredible, and they made our night even more special. Such great hospitality and a wonderful atmosphere. We'll definitely be back!

It was beautiful and the escargots were marvelous. I went there for a date and it was perfect…read more Great service too!

Review Pio Bagel was…read moresuch a great New York experience! We had the rainbow bagel with strawberry cream cheese and the plain bagel with lox and cream cheese, along with a small cappuccino. Everything was so fresh.The bagels were made right there and you could really taste the difference. The lox bagel was excellent, and the rainbow bagel was just plain fun. Great food, fresh bagels, and that classic NYC feel. Definitely a place we'll remember from our trip!

I really like the options Pio bagel has and their juices are always a hit. I got my usual toasted…read morebagel with egg salad. We also got pancakes. Of course I had to get my green juice. The juice, and pancakes were great. However my bagel was a disappointment---the egg salad was so chunky it looked the eggs had just been cut in quarters, and the mayo was not mixed well into the rest of the ingredients. There are a few tables to sit inside. Service was very good.