I catered my wedding with Jims Jumbo burgers and they were excellent. So good, I was inspired to…read morewrite a song: I wanna make a burger for youuu... not just ordinary burger... but an angel made my patty, its true... Burger song...burgerr song....burgerr song. to you. I proclaim from now....and the rest of my life. I loved that burger so much. Wish I could make it my wife... I cook youuuuu... A burger song. Cook youu.... a burger song. For youu.

I was in Ponca City, Oklahoma on a film project and I stumbled on this burger joint and I had to…read morecheck it out. Jim's Jumbo Burger is this tiny spot on the corner and is take out only from a single window. It's only open a few hours a day and looks like it's been there, in the same exact spot since before Teddy Ruxpins existed. Exactly my kind of burger joint for lunch when on the road!!!! I grabbed a double cheese burger with bacon and jalapeños and a side of onion rings. I am team mustard so I got yellow bliss added to my buns and I asked for the lettuce, onion, tomatoes and pickle be spared as I had to eat on the fly. I really wish I'd have got it tho!!! The burger didn't need it, but I would have preferred it. So this burger was so freaking good!! Patties had this beef flavor that just kicked my taste buds with a tire iron in the best way possible. Then I had bacon stop by and say hi while slapping me a jalapeño kiss . It was hard to keep my truck between the mustard and mayonnaise stripes!! This was an emotional cheeseburger experience!! My onion rings were solid and delicious but for my preference a little too greasy. I'd eat them again but would opt to try the fries if I make it back up that way again!!! Im so glad I stopped in!!! Service was great and the two folks inside were so friendly!!! They showed me what Oklahoma is all about with their kindness in taking my order and getting it out quickly!!!! Cheers y'all!!!!

I'm not sure what I was expecting by going to a hot dog place, but since Coney Island is supposedly…read morea staple on the strip I figured maybe I'd be pleasantly surprised. Big mistake. The hot dogs came out barely warm and embarrassingly small. The chili was thin and watery, like it had been strained through a mop bucket, and the cheese tasted like it should have been thrown out days ago. For over ten bucks, I got two sad little hot dogs and a pile of mystery meat slop. You'd honestly get a better, more filling meal for a fraction of the price by grabbing whatever's been sitting on the rollers at a gas station. At least those have some substance. Service wasn't any better, just one guy watching videos on his phone until someone walked in, then tossing the order on the counter like he was doing me a favor. No effort, no care, no reason to ever come back. The only way Coney Island is worth it is if you're so drunk you can't taste a thing and your vision and judgment are so blurred you don't realize what you're spending. Ohhhh... now it makes sense why it's on the strip.

Bring back the hot dogs, buns & cheese that made this business famous. The stuff you use now is…read morehorrible. Back in the 70s to 90's it was awesome & was a mandatory stop every we came to Stillwater.

Great coneys!! Had a nice slight Smokey flavor, I don't know if it was the dog or chili but it was…read moregreat!! Fast, friendly service!! Two thumbs up!!

I love Coney's. Disappointed. Smallest hot dog I have ever seen. Slightly bigger than your average…read morehreakfast sausage link. Tasted like canned chili was on it.

Always a for-sure stop when I'm in town. Great food and chill vibe. Service is always good when I'm…read morethere. Top notch dogs - two thumbs up!

Mercury Dog and the Spicy Tulsan were just as good as ever. (The truck was at an event in Owasso…read moreat Three Dogs Bakery this weekend). It had seriously been years since I'd had a Mercury Dog. My favorite with cream cheese, raspberry jam and jalapeno relish. Weird but GREAT!

Very friendly service and convenient location. Grew up in Tulsa eating at coney island and this…read moreis close , but not quite as good. Also on Facebook page or website pricing is listed incorrectly Pricing has gone up , not unreasonable, but they need to update social media

Not a fan. Wieners taste like they are the cheapest you can buy at the supermarket. Think bar S…read more level... If you can get downtown, the Coney Island down there which is not affiliated with this outfit is much better. Local products full of flavor etc. Wanted to love this place, but it is more expensive and lower quality than what you can find downtown . The chili is OK. Basic but not gross. I didn't taste anything that was disgusting, but nothing worth returning for. And I'm very sad to say that.

My goodness this place is Oklahoma's best kept secret. The taste of the food was sooo fresh and…read moredelicious. The food is prepared fresh so you have to be patient but it is so worth the wait, trust me. The staff definitely makes you feel at home, they were all so sweet and genuine! 10/10 food 10/10 service 10/10 would recommend!

This was the worst burger I have had in years. I'll explain…read more. it was $14 for what was quite obviously a frozen patty burger on a plain, store bought bun. It was so bad and so overpriced that I thought about contacting the authorities. Seriously, if my experience was indicative of what is normal, don't ever go here. If, by some odd chance, this was an anomaly, I am willing to be corrected. I will not be coming back.

Food fabulous and fresh!! The ambience of a coney stand on or by the beach in California. Beach…read moreBoys playing in the background. It's our family's favorite coney spot!!!! The owners are such a sweet older couple with grandchildren who helped naming this unique hidden gem. Oh the root beer is just crisp with a perfect foam and flavor.

Delicious hotdogs. They have different types of sausages and different items to put on the hotdogs…read more I added jalapeños to mine. The people that work there are super nice.

Rowdy is awesome! We've been eating here ever since Gus owned it. This is hands down the best coney…read moreplace in Oklahoma!!

I read many reviews that said to try out the hotdgos from Coney Island, so I gave it a try. Got…read moretheir cheese special, a hot chili bowl, and a baked potato. The cheese special wasn't the best, but wasn't the worst. It tasted kind of old and I was hoping the cheese was gonna be a bit more melted rather than just sprinkled on. The chili bowl tasted just like a regular chili bowl, so nothing special, but probably the only thing I liked. They forgot my baked potato so I can't rate that, which is sad. Not sure if it was just an off day, but I wish I had a better experience. I picked up my order for take-out, so I can't rate much on the inside dining experience ambiance of the space, nir much on the staff.

The portions are on the smaller side, tho the flavor is good. Service was quick and personable…read more Restaurant is clean and quiet with background music.