New in Town. I came across some great reviews and decided to check this place out--and I'm so glad…read moreI did! The food was really good, and the service was excellent. Our waitress was super friendly and welcoming. We ordered a 10" pepperoni pizza, and it did not disappoint--the crust was perfectly crisp, and the sauce was full of flavor. I also tried a Ski soda for the first time, and it was a fun, refreshing treat. The sweet tea was great, too. The restaurant was very clean and had a pleasant vibe, with lots of interesting pictures on the walls. Even the bathroom was spotless, which is always a good sign. I can't wait to go back and try some desserts and more items from the menu!

Great Little locally owned Italian restaurant in the heart of downtown. Their pizzas looked…read moreamazing. Being a one person diner for the night. I try their pasta which was good as well. Their signature ranch dressing is very unique. If you haven't tried it I recommend it. It's almost like a ranch with Italian seasoning. Weight staff were very friendly and accommodating with my to go drink and to go container for my leftover pasta.

Very clean The staff is very friendly I've never seen such clean showers staff is very…read moreinformational and helpful The place has showers laundry excellent food Oh and by the way very fresh Tea That's important

Best Pizza in town. Get a side of cheddar cheea3 and one marinara. You'll thank me later.read more

Pan pizza is similar to what you'd get at Pizza Hut. Not bad. Kind of oily dough…read more Interestingly the 8" pan pizza is $8, but the 10" pan pizza is $16 Bread sticks are soft. Step up from grocery store bread sticks

Everything about Jerry's is a 10! Great food!…read more Great people! Would highly recommend to anyone

Great family oriented restaurant! Reasonably priced, extensive menu and good sized portion,with…read morefriendly , prompt service! You won't be disappointed

I am conflicted about this review. The service was excellent and the restaurant was clean and…read morepeaceful. The waitress was super nice and super honest. She let me know that the cook was new and she's already had two customers send back their steaks for not being done as requested. She told me to let her know if mine was not done as I requested, which it was not. She took it back and brought me a new one, which was done as I asked for and I ended up having an excellent meal. What really won me over was the fact that the waitress comped my entire meal as well as my appetizer. So, while the cook messed up, the kindness and honesty of the waitress made up for it. If you visit this location, make sure you get Courtney C as a waitress.

2 hour wait for food that was room temperature…read more Completely unacceptable as a dinning experience and not worth the time or money to go there.

I just had another wonderful trip up to Joe's Pizza in Centralia Illinois. This time I had the meat…read morelovers pizza. Very nice and the ambience is very comforting. I shall return.

Always a great experience at Joes. Their pizza is delicious and their salads are even better.read more

We are lucky in Salem to have 3 pretty good Italian/Pizza places. I'd say Joe's has the nicest and…read morelargest dining room of the three. Today instead of ordering the daily lunch special like we normally do my wife got the soup and salad (I think soups are a new item here) and I ordered chicken Parmesan. The side salads you get are pretty large. We don't like tomatoes peppers and olives so ours are pretty plain. She had Caesar and I had regular. Both came with lots of cheese and mine had bacon. They do give you a pretty small container of dressing, but I guess that is kind of a good thing. Soup choices were tomato or potato and she chose potato. She thought it was a bit underdone. My chicken parm came with a half sized serving of pasta, which was pretty large. I was so full from just eating the salad and chicken parm I took the pasta home. I've had the baked meatballs too and both dishes are pretty similar. Lots of cheese. The meatballs could use more sauce, but are limited by the baking dish. I like them both well enough to have had them multiple times.

Food is mostly microwaved, soggy, and not at a proper portion ratio…read more Servers and staff are very polite though. 10/10 If I go again, it's because I know I won't be waiting for service.

I have been coming here since I was a little kid, and that my folks, has been a few years. *wink*…read more We arrived promptly at 11 which is when they start their buffet. We didn't time it that way, it's just the way it worked out. We got our drinks, and when we went up to order, they asked each of us what we liked on our pizzas. That was really cool. After a short wait, the pizzas were ready. They accommodated each of us (as well as others in the restaurant). For those who know me, check out those shrooms on my slice of pizza in my photo. Heaven! Was it the best pizza in the world? No. But their willingness to accommodate was amazing! Also, it is the best pizza that I've ever had on a buffet. The ones in our area just plain suck.

Best pizza you will ever have in your life.. pizza dough is made fresh every day... also the…read moreingredients are all fresh!!

By far THE best pizza in town! They always have fresh ingredients and the pizzas are always hot and…read moreready when you tell them what time you want to pick it up. I have never had a bad pizza from this Casey's and I order A LOT of pizza! Staff is always very friendly too.

The cleanest nicest Casey's I have ever been to! Pizza was amazing. Workers were pleasant and…read morehelpful. We were there Friday night