Cancel

Open app

Search

Cristal Sarah Cakes

4.4 (17 reviews)
Closed • 9:00 am - 8:00 pm
Updated over 3 months ago

Cristal Sarah Cakes Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Cristal Sarah Cakes

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Thomas W.

We totally had a lovely time with this cake. On a pretty short notice I went on a search for who could handle my requests for my partner's birthday and surely Cristal came through with the clutch. I saw some amazing pictures here on Yelp so I went to find the social media page as well and saw even more amazing artwork thst she calls cakes. I always have to say this, I cook and bake as well. I could be a baaaaad somebody if I had good decoration skills. So my critiques come from a place of "I know how to do that".... First of all from the moment she answered the phone her warm customer service aura radiated. I was hooked. Instead of her telling me it's short notice and what she can't do she LISTENED to what I wanted so that we can figure out what she CAN do. I saw something on her page that represented the birthday boy, a little bit of royalty, and pride and she said was feasible given the time. So we pressed go. The communication of her process was way above expectations and we together set a standard of what was acceptable. Take a look at my attached pics for a glimpse. It was tasty, spiked, and on time. I can't wait to work on another project and include one of her cakes. Also let's mention I live in Atlanta and was treating my boo to a surprise birthday. Please check out all of her work and indulge.

The cake I wanted
Amanda M.

If I could give a lower rating I most definitely would. I was broken hearted to say the least when I finally received my cake. To start, I contacted Cristal back in September inquiring if she could prepare a specialty red velvet cake because I was allergic to red dye. Fairly enough she asked for me to give her a couple weeks to test the recipe. She contacted me back saying she could do so. Excellent! Or so I thought. A few weeks prior to my arrival in Miami, Cristal requested that I pay for the cake in full. I openly expressed that I was not comfortable doing so, without physically seeing the cake. She went on to tell me that it had to be paid in full in order to guarantee the cake. At 5:30 in the morning the day of delivery, she messages me saying she cannot fulfill my original request. Which tells me she waited until the last minute. She went on to tel me how she hasn't slept, Not my problem, you're running a business. She never gave me a concrete time of when she was going to deliver the cake so of course she was late and I had to move my dinner reservation to a later time for my birthday dinner on NYE. When she arrived with the cake, she didn't want to get out the car and bring the cake into the hotel. When she did bring it in, the cake was open and exposed and before I could get a good look at the cake she handed me money and said here's half and walked off. And that's where she messed up. The lack of professionalism I couldn't fathom. You can have an attitude all you want to but when you deal with me your business and professionalism needs to be on point especially when you're charging almost $300 for a trashy cake. So as promised CRISTAL I will be reporting you to yelp and the Better Business Bureau, since you have yet to respond about the rest of my money. ***Text messages and photos to follow***

Cheny Fiona M.

I had a wonderful experience with Cristal. It was so easy to order over the phone and I felt immediately comfortable, she knew exactly what I wanted! I appreciate that she stayed in touch with me up until the moment she delivered them. As we know, cupcakes can bit a hit or miss and it is always risky trying a new cake artist but I'm happy I did! I ordered two dozen Strawberry shortcake cupcakes for a baby shower celebration and they were so beautiful and a hit! You can see and taste the freshness and all the heart that she puts into her baking. I brought a couple of them home with me and put them in the fridge...I actually just had another one and omg, they also taste scrumptiously chilled! Beautiful fresh cupcakes for springtime! Thank you, Cristal! I'll be ordering again for another special occasion or I might just need a dozen for myself, just because!

Aeb B.

I want to thank cristal Sarah cakes for the great job on my brothers bday cake. Highly recommend her!! Thank you

Simply beautiful and tastes great!!!
Beauty I.

Where do I begin ? First of all I waited to the last minute a week before to order cake I don't live In Miami so I was looking for place to take my vision I had and bring it to life which that's exactly what CRISTAL SARAH CAKES DID!!! Not only did she deliver the cake to the restaurant the cake was beautiful and delicious I would recommend anyone who is traveling and want to make a birthday special for someone please order she was so humble and telling from her passion and voice I already know she is beautiful!!! I can't wait to order again cake I ordered was red velvet with the cream cheese filling the cake was beautiful and delicious s just so beautiful the pictures don't do justice

Custom beats headphones & doggie on camouflage chocolate cake w/ vanilla cream cheese frosting
Candace S.

Best custom cake in the world!! And certainly in Miami! Professional, timely fashion, will make whatever you want and works with you, your ideas and budget. I had a custom cake for my bday and it was so great I'm getting one for my father, and any other events I have coming up. My friend's were obsessed with her work. I tried her cupcakes which were fabulous but the cake really blew me away! My forever flavor is chocolate cake with vanilla cream cheese frosting. My friend will be using her for her daughter's bday so I can't wait to see what they come up with. I will update pics after each time I use her.. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! I just had my second cake and it was another party pleaser! Can't wait to do my parents anniversary cake! If you have an event, these cakes will not disappoint! Only when there is none left :)

Custom Cupcakes!
Cherie T.

Cristal Sarah made great custom cupcake for my boyfriend's 29th birthday. She was very sweet and asked a lot of questions about what I wanted to make sure that she got it exactly right. She did an excellent job and he loved the cupcakes I would recommend that everyone get their sweets from Cristal Sarah.

I couldn't have asked for a more perfect cake ! Everything i wanted and more !!!!!!!!!! Thank you cristal for going above and beyond making it happen so last min ! THE BEST!!!

I rarely leave yelp reviews but even more rarely do I find a company in Miami that is worth using more than once. I've ordered many times for different events and birthday parties. Cristal never disappoints with her creativity and immaculate designs. She is super sweet and very helpful. Many times I just tell her the theme of the party and she comes up with the ideas of what to put on the cakes and it's one less thing I have to think about when putting together a party. I can honestly say she nails it every. single. time. I've also told her exactly what I want a cake to look like and again PERFECTION. The very best part is the cakes are to die for. I cannot stand fancy cakes that no one wants to eat bc they taste like fondant hell.

See all

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Nicole H.
33
479
59

1 year ago

Wanted to charge me $350 for a small basic cake. All other bakeries quoted me around $150. Absolutely absurd pricing!

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 4
Thanks 1
Love this 4
Oh no 1

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 1

8 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 4
Thanks 1
Love this 3
Oh no 0
Photo of Aeb B.
65
72
25

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Candace S.
83
114
195

8 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 5
Thanks 0
Love this 4
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 3
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Ashley M.
125
4
17

7 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Thank You Madina...you are the sweetest!

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Cristal S.

Cristal S.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Cristal Sarah Cakes

Tonight, for 10 people. I'd like a Sephora cake. Is this something you can do for today at 7:30 PM?

Good morning, Thank You for contacting us. We don’t have enough time to create a custom designed cake for tonight.… 

Hello, what is cost for 40 people cake, Pirate Theme, 4 year old , boy birthday cake?

6th Bday boy. 30 servings?

Good evening. When is your event and how many servings?

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Frudeco - Heart & Round Cake

Frudeco

4.8(174 reviews)
31.0 km•Little River
7 years in business
Family-owned & operated

What a beautiful cake! They made it exactly how I requested. From the look of the cake to the…read moreflavoring. I ordered a vanilla cake with passionfruit filling. It was a hit at my birthday party. Everyone absolutely loved it. You can order on the phone or online. They never disappoint. I'm happy with the final product. If you ever need a delicious cake, Frudeco is the place to order from for all your special occasions.

Frudeco feels like a luxury dessert boutique that happens to be in Miami, not just a neighborhood…read morebakery. Everything about it gives "special occasion" energy, from the presentation of cakes to the way the shop feels curated and elevated. This is not a bakery but more of a pickup your order place. Food (5/5) This is where Frudeco really leans into the luxury Miami cake aesthetic. The cakes and cupcakes are beautifully designed, highly detailed, and made to look like they belong at a celebration where presentation matters just as much as flavor. The pricing reflects that premium feel too -- cupcakes start around $22 for a 3-pack and go up to about $98 for a dozen, so this is definitely a splurge, but one that feels consistent with the quality and styling. It's the kind of dessert that feels more like edible decor than an afterthought. Their site shows elaborate vintage, wedding, anniversary, and themed cakes, with prices that reflect that premium presentation. I've ordered cupcakes for my daughter's birthdays. Vibe The vibe is chic, celebratory, and very Miami in the best way. Frudeco has that polished, high-end feel that makes it perfect for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, and any event where the cake needs to make a statement. It feels less like stopping by for dessert and more like picking up a centerpiece.

Photos
Frudeco - Medium Letter

Medium Letter

Frudeco - Pink Coquette Heart Cake

Pink Coquette Heart Cake

Frudeco

See all

The Cake Lovers - Gender reveal cake

The Cake Lovers

4.8(201 reviews)
58.9 km
•$$

I've been searching for a go-to cake place, and after ordering a cake from The Cake Lovers for my…read morebridal shower, I can confidently say I'll never order a cake anywhere else! The cake was absolutely incredible. It was so delicious that people were literally picking at it until there wasn't a single crumb left. Seriously, we had zero leftovers, which says everything! It was the most delicious and prettiest cake I've ever had, and I'm already looking forward to the next event I get to host so I have an excuse to order another one. On top of the amazing cake, the service was wonderful, and the owner was so kind and lovely to work with. I can't recommend The Cake Lovers enough!

I just wanted to take a moment to thank you from the bottom of my heart for creating the most…read moreincredible cake for my mother-in-law's 90th birthday. I honestly cannot put into words just how amazing it was. The cake was absolutely breathtaking, and it was even more beautiful than I could have imagined. Every little detail was so perfect, and I could truly tell how much thought, care, and love you put into creating something so special for her. You didn't just make a cake--you created a beautiful centerpiece and a memory that will be a part of such an important milestone in her life. It was clear that you understood how meaningful her 90th birthday was, and you put so much heart into making the cake worthy of such a special occasion. Everyone was absolutely amazed by it! It was not only beautiful, but it was delicious, too. You truly exceeded my expectations in every possible way. Thank you for taking my vision and turning it into something even more beautiful than I could have dreamed. I am so grateful for the time, creativity, and love you put into making my mother-in-law's 90th birthday so unforgettable. I will never forget how beautiful that cake was, and neither will our family. Thank you for being such an important part of making her special day absolutely perfect. Gina

Photos
The Cake Lovers - My granddaughter naming. Chocolate..

My granddaughter naming. Chocolate..

The Cake Lovers - Pete the cat birthday cake

Pete the cat birthday cake

The Cake Lovers - Cowgirl theme cake. The front black spot is a reflection not smeared.

See all

Cowgirl theme cake. The front black spot is a reflection not smeared.

OH MY GOSH! Brigadeiros - Coral Gables

OH MY GOSH! Brigadeiros - Coral Gables

4.6(345 reviews)
19.5 km•Silver Bluff, Shenandoah
•$$

I had a last minute celebration and called to see if they had cakes because I've always wanted to…read moretry this place, and they are very flexible and take same day orders! Luckily I didn't need to place an order because they already had some cakes in the store. This cake was $30 and heart shape was available for Mother's Day weekend. We took one bite into the cake and it was not what I expected, it was so much better!! The cake itself was barely sweet. Brigadeiros were incredibly flavorful and crunchy-- there's really no words to describe it, you just have to try it for yourself! I'm really looking forward to going back and getting a box of all the flavors brigadeiros.

I will start by saying that I'm Brazilian and I grew up eating brigadeiros. So, on Sunday I went to…read moreget a box to bring to a friend's lunch, and I was shocked with the price of the boxes/the sweets/the cakes. They are, oh, my gosh, so expensive!!!! But ok, whatever I was there and I needed to bring something to my friend's lunch. They did not have the options for smaller boxes, only with 6 brigadeiros. Which, if you know, these are tiny little truffle balls, and I wouldn't be able to bring 6 brigadeiros to my friend's house just randomly in a tiny box the size of the palm of my hand. The other options were the much bigger flimsy boxes. The girl working there suggested I took 2 boxes with 6 brigadero's each, which was also weird, still saying that there were no other boxes, only a super fancy one (fancy as in sturdy) with 16 brigadero's, I guess, or the bigger flimsy ones. So I asked if she could give me the empty outer box so that I could put the 2 smaller boxes inside the paper canister, and I don't think she could, and of course it's not the girl's fault, but if you're charging $4 per brigadero, and you have an empty store year round, maybe an idea is to try to keep the clients coming back. Then I thought, ok I'll get a cake. The tiny cake costs $60!!!! Oh my gosh, what?? I left.

Photos
OH MY GOSH! Brigadeiros - Coral Gables
OH MY GOSH! Brigadeiros - Coral Gables - Small Cake. Brigadeiros.

Small Cake. Brigadeiros.

OH MY GOSH! Brigadeiros - Coral Gables - Brigadeiro Milkshake

See all

Brigadeiro Milkshake

Cristal Sarah Cakes - desserts - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...