Cancel

Open app

Search

Cosa Nostra

4.7 (7 reviews)

Cosa Nostra Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Cosa Nostra

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Alexis O.
609
96
143

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 3
Photo of Josh D.
4
149
36

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 1

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

La comida se demora un poco pero definitivamente vale la pena. El risotto de champiñones es una experiencia religiosa.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 2,036 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Anita La Mamma del Gelato - One Scoop @ A Time

Anita La Mamma del Gelato

4.7(320 reviews)
0.5 km
$$

It's hard to say anything bad about this place!…read more The line is long, but it's full of excitement and gawking at everyone's gelato and seeing their faces when they take their first taste. Also, the line moves pretty quickly. At $7.19 for the regular (two flavors), it's not cheap (PR McDonald's vanilla ice cream cone is $0.99 for comparison!), but it's definitely worth doing (at least) once. The flavors are all extremely unique and it's a mystery what may be in a specific flavor (e.g. Pavlova and mixed berries), but you can try to your heart's content for free. In the end, I doubt there is a "bad" flavor. My favorites were cookieman (like Oreo cookies in a vanilla base) and chocolate cookie. Pistachio was good, but a taster would have sufficed. Sadly, they did not have a mint and chip!

Very cute gelato shop in old San Juan! We drove by one day and saw a line around the store, so we…read morehad to stop today when we were walking in the area! Very cute interior, clearly well thought out and designed to be a photo/insta location. The colors and decor all flowed well. But beyond that, they have wonderful flavors! We tried about 7 in our group and they were all good. Tasted high quality and you could distinguish what the flavor was supposed to be. Fresh made on site I would guess. The order process is a little difficult w use they have so many flavors spread out over about 15 feet of displays. Hard to pick what you want without running back and forth to see if you would miss anything! The seating areas were nice and had lots of seating. Disappointed to see that the bathroom was out of order and just had an envelope with a handwritten message on it. Really took away from the experience. But would enjoy again!

Photos
Anita La Mamma del Gelato - Strawberry

Strawberry

Anita La Mamma del Gelato - Chocolate Overload: (Salted Chocolate)

Chocolate Overload: (Salted Chocolate)

Anita La Mamma del Gelato - Last Call: (@ Some Point, These Folks Start Wrapping Things Up In The Sit-Down Area But Ordering Up Front Is Still Happening)

See all

Last Call: (@ Some Point, These Folks Start Wrapping Things Up In The Sit-Down Area But Ordering Up Front Is Still Happening)

Café Cuatro Sombras - 8oz Latte

Café Cuatro Sombras

4.4(611 reviews)
0.2 km
$$

Looked into the top coffee spots of Puerto Rico, this stood out. It doesn't get better than…read morefarm-to-cup type of coffee. AMBIANCE Parking: Old San Juan rules--come early or be ready to walk. Seating: Multiple seating areas for individuals and small groups but it's also a cafe too so there is seating in the back too. Vibes: Clean, modern café with a mix of locals and tourists. You can tell people come here for the coffee, not just to pass through. It leans more intentional and coffee-focused rather than just aesthetic--which I appreciated. FOOD / DRINKS Coquito Frap (Recommend) When in Puerto Rico, Coquito. Creamy, coconut-forward, and lightly spiced--like a frozen coquito with a coffee twist. Sweet, smooth, and definitely more of a dessert drink than a regular latte. CUSTOMER SERVICE Friendly and efficient. Even with a crowd, things moved quickly. TL;DR OVERALL 4.5 Stars. Solid spot. Great drink options at a reasonable price. They know what they're doing. Whether you're a coffee person or just need a reset, this place delivers. Salute to the Munoz family for sharing their coffee to the world! TIPS * Try their house coffee if you want the full experience--that's what they're known for.

Café Cuatro Sombras in Old San Juan is a lovely café with wonderful staff and a really welcoming…read moreatmosphere. We loved it so much we actually went twice during our trip - and even made a final stop before heading to the airport to go home. On our first visit, Hector (the roaster) happened to be there, which made the experience feel even more special. The staff overall were all so kind and attentive. The coffee is absolutely excellent - velvety smooth, rich, and delicious. I could easily drink more than one cup. I had a latte, and my husband had a macchiato, and both were great. They have a cute little outdoor atrium seating area, but we preferred indoors where all the comfy pillow seating was. Just a note - they don't offer decaf - but for regular coffee drinkers, it's a must-visit. Such a gem in Old San Juan!

Photos
Café Cuatro Sombras - Caramel latte

Caramel latte

Café Cuatro Sombras - Croissant sandwich and hazelnut latte

Croissant sandwich and hazelnut latte

Café Cuatro Sombras - Cuatro Sombras Panini

See all

Cuatro Sombras Panini

Himalaya Ice

Himalaya Ice

4.3(75 reviews)
0.5 km
$

If you're wandering around Old San Juan sweating through your 10,000th step of the day, do yourself…read morea favor and stop into Himalayan Ice Company. First--rolled ice cream is basically edible entertainment. I stood there way longer than necessary watching them flatten, scrape, and roll it like I had nowhere else to be. It's giving Food Network... but you get to eat the finale. The flavors? BANGING. Super creamy, fresh, and not overly sweet--which means you can actually finish it without feeling like you need to lie down immediately after. Big win. The vibe is adorable--very vintage, colorful, and just a fun little spot to duck into and cool off. Definitely one of those places you end up taking pictures in without planning to. Service was adequate--nothing over-the-top, but they kept things moving and got us through the line without any issues, even when it was busy. Place looked clean, which matters when people are basically performing dairy gymnastics in front of you. Overall: great treat, fun experience, and absolutely worth the stop. Would I go back? Yes--for the ice cream... and to watch the rolling again like it's my new personality.

Anita Gelato had a ridiculous line out the door, so we found this as an alternative to try to cool…read moreoff from the heat. The wait wasn't too long, but the process of making one of these ice sheets takes a good 5 minutes, so there's some patience involved as they only took one order at a time. We did a custom roll ($10) with Oreo, coconut, and pineapple. It somehow ended up tasting like red bean, which I'm not complaining! Very refreshing and enjoyed every bite of it.

Photos
Himalaya Ice - Tesla Rolls

Tesla Rolls

Himalaya Ice - Pick your own: Nutella, coconut and mint cookie

Pick your own: Nutella, coconut and mint cookie

Himalaya Ice

See all

La Taberna Lúpulo

La Taberna Lúpulo

4.4(419 reviews)
0.5 km
$$

I'm not a big beer guy. But, a few years ago at número uno they had this beer con parcha (passion…read morefruit) that I really enjoyed. So, we are walking around old San Juan and I'm like homie I need the first drink we can find! Enter La taberna lúpulo. First, dude servicing the bar was extra cool. Just friendly and engaged and didn't act like we just business, but friendly. I wasn't even planning on drinking beer. But my homie was like what do you recommend and he poured a sample of some blonde ale and... wheat ale con parcha!! I was like o snap let me have a glass of that. Fire!! I wouldn't call it sweet, but it has that hint. More importantly it was fresh and not funky. I personally find tap beer is usually not fresh tasting and tend to prefer bottles or cans when I drink beer. But that was not a problem here. Tasted brand new and delicious. The location is unbeatable, in the heart of old San Juan. The decor was fun and eclectic. I'm a fan of the elephant personally due to my old school ties with elephant size productions. Oh and it was super inexpensive. It was like $4-$5 a beer iirc. Which is crazy for a trendy neighborhood like this (La factoría around the corner). Great job to the staff at Lúpulo. Highly recommended.

A fine place to stop for lunch. The food wasn't bad, but wasn't anything special. We tried a beer…read morethat I'd rate pretty highly, but it was just something shipped in from the states. The staff was nice enough but far from attentive.

Photos
La Taberna Lúpulo - Paola was friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful.

Paola was friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful.

La Taberna Lúpulo
La Taberna Lúpulo - This is their version of a piña colada

See all

This is their version of a piña colada

Cosa Nostra - pizza - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...