This place is just what New Bern needed! When we moved up last year from Florida I really missed places such as Crumbl Cookie and Insomnia cookie. Now that we have Cookie Plug, my sweet tooth is satisfied and all is right with the world again. Let's start with the ambiance. I love how unique this place is. The walls are decked in beautifully colored graffiti, a boom box is mounted near the door blasting jams, and there's a variety of awesome urban stickers for purchase. The gentleman behind the counter was super personable and fun. He had a line practically out the door even after 9pm, but still let each customer take pictures and ask questions. He also took the time to explain the directions to reheat and enjoy these scrumptious gooey delights once we got home. Now onto the most important part - The Cookies themselves. Lets talk size. These bad boys are huge and thick. I'm talking crispy edges with warm soft centers. They also had a great variety of flavors to include the traditional chocolate chip, or "The OG" if you will, as well as a walnut version of the OG, a sprinkled sugar cookie, cookies and cream, strawberry cheesecake, Smores, chocolate peanut butter, the "Bam Bam" inspired by Fruity Pebbles, a Purple velvet with white chocolate chips, a snickerdoodle, a red velvet with Oreos, as well as "the Secret Stash", which is currently a limited edition "flava" that is made with chocolate chips & Caramel. They also had bite sized Keto cookies, if that's your thing.
What's not to love here? read more