I follow a couple on IG they went to eat the famous lobster roll at Clam Castle and that was our…read moreplan. We arrived at Clam Castle and as I was about to get out of the truck my cousin text me the viral lobster roll at Supreme Seafood. I told my fiancé I want to go to Supreme Seafood. He said it's only down the street. We arrived and I was very excited. As we walked in we were greeted by the owner and the two young ladies at the counter they were very welcoming and iit was very clean inside. It's a very small establishment with a eclectic vibe and it was quite cozy. Our starters were clam chowder and I had the shrimp corn chowder. It was very flavorful and they didn't skimp on the shrimp. My fiancé ordered a full order of the clam strips with coleslaw and I ordered the $55.00 lobster roll with steak fries and coleslaw. They do have a $40.00 lobster roll which 4 Oz and $80.00 which is 16 Oz of lobster meat. The clam strips were fried perfectly and there is nothing better then tasting that fresh clam they were perfect. My lobster roll had 8 oz of sweet, succulent meaty lobster over flowing in perfectly toasted buttery roll. I had very huge pieces and there were some trying to escape the roll but I won that fight that lobster roll was banging. The new owner informed me that the original owners were there for 35 years. The new owner had been there for 4 years. I told him where I was initially going and he said they had a family that ordered their 2 foot lobster roll that cost a working $230.00. He showed us the lobster roll he prepared and what was left after the family of three which included two adults and a newborn baby. I will definitely return to try the 2 foot lobster roll. If your in North Branford, CT please stop and enjoy all the delicious seafood at Supreme Seafood. To all my Yelper let's continue to eat our way through the world.#Foodie4life.

My first time with the new owners and everything went well…read more I like whole belly clams and finding them can be difficult and they are pricey. This is one place that has them, fried to perfection and offers them in their Combination for a small upcharge. I got an order, which was a generous pile of scallops, shrimp, belly clams and filet. I got a separate order of fried calamari with cocktail sauce; another fave. The eat in area is cute and comfortable and the two men, owners, I believe were friendly. I ate about half of my order and took the rest home. Yum!

The Best Seafood!! Fried, Baked, Broiled whatever is your flavor. I always get the Whole Belly…read moreClaims the Best Around. My wife always gets the Honey Salmon over a Rice Pilaf. They have a Fried Seafood Platter that is Plentiful and fried to perfection. They also have a good Steak. The atmosphere with outside seating overlooking a Boat yard is very pleasing to the eyes too. We enjoy sitting on a hightop in the Bar area which you can also see the Boat yard. The service is always good and the Two Sisters that are the owners are very friendly and will come over to visit while you are there. An all around good Restaurant. You will not go wrong or be disappointed.

We're visiting Branford with old college friends, already a plus. If you like beer and fried…read moreseafood, second plus We stopped here after a short hike and a beer really hit the spot. For food we had the New England Clam chowder, one of my favorites and this was really good. Then we shared the steamers fried captains platter, and an extra order of fried clams. We had both the strips and belly clam. I preferred the belly clam. The Cole slaw was really good too For six of us , just 2 beers 140 plus tip

Great lobster rolls! Right on the water. Service was excellent! BYOB Homemade salads are also very…read moregood.

We went on a warm day in mid May. We were hosting guests who recently moved from out of state to…read moreget a good lobster roll. We were pretty disappointed. There were small biting flies swarming the area, making it terribly uncomfortable. They were getting in our food and biting us all over, the food was good but it made it very hard to enjoy. Additionally, the waitress failed to bring out two of our meals, when we asked about it she brought out the ticket saying the meals weren't listed... but she said she recalled taking the order when we reminded her. So part of our party ate after everyone else while we all were getting bitten up. I understand they don't control the flies, but I think it's important to know if you plan on visiting this time of year. Not sure if this problem exists other times of the year as well.

Nice place, good food, good service…read more Forgot to take photos and don't remember what we had but would go back again.

We stopped for an early dinner this afternoon on our way home. This seaside restaurant has been…read morearound since 1968, and the interior feels warm and inviting. The bathroom was also very clean, which is always a good sign. Our waitress, Erica N., provided five-star service--warm, friendly, and professional throughout, always with a smile on her face. We each started with a New England clam chowder, which was quite tasty. For our entrées, my husband ordered the broiled seafood combination, while I chose the 1.75 lb baked stuffed lobster. Both dishes came with two sides - broccoli and baked potatoes. As for my stuffed lobster, the presentation was appealing, but the stuffing lacked the seafood I was hoping for. I'm used to seeing stuffing filled with shrimp, scallops, and sometimes lobster meat, but this one seemed to be mostly breadcrumbs. My husband felt similarly about his entrée--he found it just okay. Overall, while the food didn't fully meet our expectations, the restaurant's long-standing history, inviting atmosphere, and especially the excellent service made for a pleasant experience. It's a nice stop for a casual New England seafood meal, and we would be open to returning to try other dishes.

We stopped in for lunch on a weekend and enjoyed some lobster rolls and lobster Mac and cheese!…read more The rolls were nicely warm and buttery with fresh lobster. Served with fries, which you can substitute for other sides. We devoured it all while enjoying the beautiful view of the beach from the upper level. There is also a nice balcony patio with outdoor seating. The servers were very friendly.

Left the beach in New Haven and decided to look for a place close by to have an early dinner. We…read morefound The Lobster Shack--Nestled in a quaint neighborhood. We were seated immediately as the patrons started coming in. It was a great place filled with windows all around. We ordered beverages and food. The lobster roll, mussels and for our carnivore, the prime rib special. Being from the southwest, fresh seafood is a luxury. After some brief conversation, food came out. The lobster roll and fries did not disappoint. Made perfectly. Mussels were oozing in butter and garlic with a few pieces of toast to soak up the juices. Delicious. The prime rib, filled the plate. We left nothing. A great place to sit and dine.

Dinner was excellent! We tried the meatballs eggplant rollatini and calamari and were pleased with…read moreall of them! Angel was pleasantly attentive as our server. Don't let the modest outside fool you. The ambiance inside was relaxing and elegant. Great date night for us. We will be back again

Service was friendly and selection was unique. They have a lot of activities on different nights…read morethat seem fun.

I'm so happy we found this restaurant. It's located within a boat storage etc. idk but we were…read morehappy we found it. The restaurant is on the small side. But they have outdoor tables which would be awesome on a good day. We arrived at 3:30 so we had a little bit of a long wait since there was only one waiter. The food was good. We will be returning again.

Nellie's Waterfront Bar & Grill is the kind of place people go for the location and atmosphere as…read moremuch as the food. Sitting by the water gives the restaurant a laid back, summer seafood spot feel that makes it easy to enjoy your time there. That said, if you're looking for a restaurant with a wide variety of seafood options or more creative seafood preparations, this probably isn't the place to go. We started with the chips and guacamole appetizer, which tasted good, but the portion size was pretty small for the price. The raw little neck clams were one of the highlights of the meal, very fresh, clean tasting, and exactly what you'd want from a seafood spot. For entrées, the cod sandwich was surprisingly solid. It was a nice size, fairly priced, and felt like one of the better values on the menu. The ahi tuna wrap was also good overall, but it felt like it was missing a stronger or more flavorful dressing to really bring everything together. The lobster roll was decent, but for the price, there simply wasn't enough lobster in it to justify the cost. Overall, there were definitely some enjoyable parts of the meal, especially the fresh shellfish and the waterfront atmosphere. The biggest downside was the pacing of service, as there were long waits between dishes throughout the meal. Still, for a casual waterfront stop with straightforward seafood options, Nellie's delivers a decent experience.

As always, food was amazing in every way. I had the stuffy skins for the first time, one of the…read moremost unique and delicious combinations I've eaten. The service is friendly and accurate. And the corn chowder, beyond words.

The lobster bisque is outrageously delicious! The corn chowder is also awesome. We complemented the…read morechef. Very limited seating in side(3 sm tables), but picnic tables outside. The service was very customer centered .

I've been to Cafe Fiore a few times over the years, and it's left a good impression. O usually go…read moreat lunch to meet a relative or friend. I've had the Chicken Marsala from their lunch menu, which was flavorful, well balanced, and generously portioned. The atmosphere is warm and inviting. It is usually quiet during lunch so it's a good place to catch and have a good conversation. They also offer some specials according to their website including Ladies' Night on Tuesdays from 3:00 pm to closing, and Happy Hour Monday through Thursday from 3:00-6:00 pm. Even though it's been a little while since my last visit, Cafe Fiore is a place I remember positively and would return to.

I was here once before with a friend and had the salmon dinner. This time I got grilled salmon. I…read morelike the entree better because it had garlic, capers in white wine sauce and the grilled was bland. It was a good piece of salmon and I did like how it was cooked so that helped. The bartender is busy making drinks for all the tables so you can wait awhile to order. But everybody is friendly so I relaxed, sipped my wine, ate my homemade garlic knots & salad and was happy. Nice place, good food.

Such a unique restaurant that's worth a stop! The Place is a great lunch stop along 95. It's cash…read moreonly and BYOB. All of the seating is outside, but some areas have a cover for shade. The menu is on a sign and it was hard to decide what to order. We chose the grilled shrimp, clam special, grilled corn on the cob, grilled whole lobster and a veggie kebab. Everything was cooked perfectly and it was fun to watch the employees work the huge grills. The clam special was topped with a sauce and I've never had anything like it before. The shrimp were juicy as well. The veggies had a great charred flavor and didn't need any seasoning. Anytime I pass Guilford on 95, I'll be sure to stop at The Place!

Interesting place. All outdoors even the cooking over a huge open fire. Tables, some chairs some…read morelogs. I got the catfish and vegbob (veggie kabob). Both kinda plain. I left hungry not full. Super noisy under the tent. My wife got shrimp. Not shelled. Not deveined. No utensil to devein. They invite you to BYOB, side dishes, dessert and even table cloths. They're cash or check only. I know it's popular kinda like camping but I prefer camping. We likely won't be back. Servers were friendly.