Great food! Great service. Super fun cute place. A must see while visiting or a quick stop for lunch for locals.

I wasn't happy with the coney. I didn't enjoy my dog and it tasted bland. They say it's not like it used to be. I didn't like the fact they were working with no gloves and touching everything. Nah, I don't think I'm returning. read more

Small town charm, small burgers and BIG taste. Thin patty on a bun steamed over onions with a special chili sauce. Can't go wrong. read more

See all

Someone who gives Coney Island a bad review is either shilling for another restaurant in town or out of their d*** mind. I'm not saying everyone has to love it. But I certainly do. It may not be the absolute best burger in the world, (and they don't claim to be) but it happens to be delicious, crave-inducing, undeniably unique for 50+years, and absolutely irreplaceable. If Coney Island closed its doors, I would weep. And there is no other restaurant that I could say that about. It is consistent and no, it has not changed. Even when the ownership changed hands, the consistency remained. You could cook anything on that flat top grill and it's gonna taste like Coney Island. I understand the younger generation that grew up eating box mac & cheese every day of their life (and still does) may not understand why it's good. But I just don't care. It is good. And it is great. I'll take 2 double cheese all the way and one cheese dog all the way and you're missing out if you don't. read more

Food was not good. Bad quality ingredients and bland. Had burger and dog. I finished, but my wife threw hers out. Will not return. This is more akin to a little league concession stand than a restaurant. read more

Our pet sitter lives in Crestview and we had heard about this joint from a few folks who grew up there. Decided one day when we dropped our dog off we had to stop and see! So glad we did! It's nothing more than a tiny little shack that serves very inexpensive food and they make no bones about what they are. I had the Wednesday lunch special of a double cheeseburger, chips and a drink. I asked for no sauce on the burger and they had no issue with my request. The burger was delicious but next time I'll ask for an additional slice of cheese as it just needs another slice. Quality beef and great flavor! No brioche bun or pickles, not even lettuce. I took off a star as no fries and no inside seating. You order your food from a side window, which is fine except I was hoping to sit inside and it wasn't open. Had to eat in the car. read more

See all

Super nostalgic coney-island style burgers and dogs meaning topped with the most delicious Coney Island sauce and mustard onions. The bread just melts away read more

I do not understand the 5 Star reviews. Definitely priced to be considered affordable, but the food is not good. The staff were really friendly, but that is not enough for me to ever want to return. read more

This is one of those spots that make you glad you turned off the main road. The dogs and the burgers took you back to a simpler time. Sloppy and delicious topped a chili sauce which recipes dates back to 1947 when the restaurant opened. Will definitely be back the next time through Crestview. read more

See all

Both of our families have been coming to the Coney Island restaurant since we were lil kids! Raymond Fountain & 4'sons and My late father, Sheriff of Okaloosa Co. "Ray Wilson" and his 4'kids would buy a couple dozen Hamburgers & hotdogs to take with us kids on Sunday, after church ,to swim at Munson pond,mmm read more

The worst hotdog and hamburger I have ever had. Not real beef. I read a review that said the meat tasted like dog food smelled and they hit the nail on the head. Will never be back here again. Waste of money. read more

An institution in Crestview. We dream about these burgers in our sleep! They are greasy, they are unhealthy and they will stay with you for days, but ...all worth it. The sauce is an important component for these delicious burgers, but the method of cooking is just as important. The seasoned grill, the flat patties, the steamed onions and buns. Don't miss this. Grab a sackful and head to the beach. Amazing. read more

Coney Island - Cheese Coneys! - Fast Food Near Me - Crestview, Florida

So this place looks a little strange, it's on a corner by the rail road tracks and you order from the window. But it's cheap and the burgers and dogs are a tasty treat. I think if you're in the area stop by but don't make an extra effort. read more

Lifelong fan of this establishment--both the hot dogs and hamburgers. Has lost a lot of the ambience since Covid (presumably) closed the seating area, but I still visit multiple times per year. Glad they moved to plastic bags--that was my only complaint from years past because the paper sacks would leak onto floor mats. I appreciate restaurants who do one thing and do it well. Oh, and you better love onions. read more

One of the best sloppy burgers around, unique in its own way. Don't forget to grab a chili dog or two as well. I've been eating here for over 30 years. read more

Coney Island is a historic staple in Crestview its been here since long before I was born! (I'm 40) If you're new to the area you MUST give it a try! Best burgers and dogs EVER!! But don't even try to ask what the "secret sauce" is lol, just know it's amazing!!! read more

Coney Island - Fast Food Near Me - Crestview, Florida

I tried eating here only once. It tasted like dog food smells to me. Whatever they put all over the dog's and burgers is nasty and you don't get a choice if you want it on or not. They just put it on my dog and my husband's hamburger. We haven't went back read more

You can't be in the Crestview area without a stop at Coney Island. I've been here many times over the last 10-12 years and always leave a happy customer. Coney Island burgers also have a rare quality in that if you get them to go and eat them about 10-15 minutes later they actually taste totally different (in a good way). The secret is in the sauce for sure. If you're anywhere near Crestview, Coney Island is a must. The staff is always friendly and make you feel welcome each and every time! As a previous reviewer posted, this isn't a sit down to order kind of place. Just like burger joints of olden days, you order at the counter. There are no "servers". Don't let a negative review keep you from visiting. This really is a staple in the area. Yes, it's an older building but it's historic. Don't be afraid to give Coney Island a try! read more

We wanted to try Coney Island Hot Dogs in Crestview because of the reviews. What is going on? ABSOLUTELY the worst hot dogs we have ever had BAR NONE, almost inedible, PLUS neither hot dog was as we ordered. We both took one bite and then threw them out. On a later date we tried the Hot Dog Shoppe in North Crestview at the Winn Dixie Plaza. DO YOURSELF A FAVOR if you want a MUCH better hot dog with home made fries head a little north. NO COMPARISON! read more

Best burgers and hot dogs on the east coast! I come to the panhandle at least once per year and make it a priority to drop in and buy a sack of their delicious burgers and dogs. A must try for all! read more

It was mediocre compared to what is was like growing up. The comstumer service was great and fast. I should have added mustard to my hot dog and hamburger to add a little bit of more flavor. read more

Love these burgers. When we go visit family in Crestview we stop at CI first. I dream of these.

Its just not the same about 14 years ago to much money 21.00 $$ for 6 hotdogs got there at 1:40pm they said they where out of burges

Coney Island is still in the same place it was the first time I ate there 50 years ago. It was love at first bite! We have made it one of the "must stop" places on our trips home. Naturally the prices have changed over the years, but the service and quality haven't....both are excellent! If you live in Crestview and haven't tried their burgers and dogs, what are you waiting for? The dogs (and buns) are steamed to perfection. The burgers are cooked on a flat grill and topped with their trademark Coney sauce while still on the grill so that the flavor cooks in. The recipe for the Coney sauce has to be one of the most closely guarded secrets on Okaloosa County! I've tried, but I cannot duplicate it. I'll just have to settle for getting my fix on our visits home! read more

Coney Island - Fast Food Near Me - Crestview, Florida

See all

This place is a Historical landmark in my opinion I can remember eating Coney Island dogs and burgers since I was a kid. And still continue to enjoy the awesome little spot on Main Street. read more

Coney Island has been around for over 60 years, and I can't believe that I'm the first to give it a review. It's not often to find freshly ground beef burgers cooked on a flat-top on the Gulf Coast, but that's what you get here. They steam onions and mustard on the meat, and top with chili. The buns are steamed, so the whole burger is soft and the flavor is better than anything I can think of. The burgers are thin, which is great for more griddled surface area. Next time, I might get a double. Finding Coney Island was like discovering a burger lovers treasure! read more

Always amazing!! I stop in every time I'm in town!!! Best hotdogs and hamburgers ever... and I always get them with a grape soda!! One of the few favorites that hasn't changed throughout the years!! read more

I have eaten here for the 60 years they have been in business. So long I remember them being 8 for a $1.00 mix and match hotdogs and hamburgers. When I moved from the area after college my wife and I had to stop, eat, then grab a bag for my freezer. Greasy, unhealthy but flavor over Kobe beef burger! This place was fast food for rail passengers at the old train station... Take out only They were fast food before McDonalds was a twinkle in Ray Crocks eyes. It's a must try cult following read more

Simple, awesome retro style hot dog and burger joint. Food was super fresh and quick and tasted awesome. Make sure to get your burger or hot dog done all the way with mustard, chili and onions! read more

Simple food served by regular folks at a decent price. What's not to love? Wish they'd open one in Fort Walton. But when I'm in Crestview I stop here. Every time. read more

I've been coming here since 1992. It's tiny and an old restaurant. They've been making their burgers and hot dogs the same way since then...and probably before that. They put mustard and onions and chili on everything unless you specify otherwise. They got Yoohoo, Grapico, Mountain Dew, and 3-4 other drinks. My regular is a hot dog and burger all the way, and a drink. I've never been disappointed. They probably aren't the healthiest food items on the planet, but they are tasty. Like the sign says "You get it our way or You don't get a damn thing." Check out the map of the USA and the world, and see where all the customers came from-every continent except Antarctica. read more

I would give this place no stars if possible. I felt like the food they served were leftovers. They do not have coney dogs. They have regular hotdogs that were probably on sale at Wal-Mart. I wish I hadn't wasted my money. The cleanliness was below average. Also I never saw the "cooks" wash their hands or wear gloves during the food preparation. Hole in the wall places are supposed to have excellent food, idk wtf happened here?!? read more

Nasty. The chili they used on the chili dogs was just red water. I never had a nasty hotdog until today. Never again. Oh and the cooks don't wear gloves. I don't recommend this place to anyone but I do discourage all from going! read more

I would also give this place no stars. First of all, my family and I arrived and sat in a booth. No-one approached us. The cooks definitely made eye contact with us. Then after 5-10 minutes, no one still came by to take an order. Then, a couple arrived and went to the counter and sat down.....the cooks immediately asked, "what can I get for you?" Yes, coney dogs.......from where? The hotdogs tasted like they were freezer burned and boiled. The burgers were so small and thin, that it took me several bites before I bit into the burger itself. There was water dripping from the ceiling. This place was advertised as having been open since 1971. It appears it hasn't been cleaned since either. Will NEVER put my family through this again. read more