Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Commack United Methodist Thrft Shop

    4.5 (2 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Commack United Methodist Thrft Shop Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Commack United Methodist Thrft Shop

    Recommended Reviews - Commack United Methodist Thrft Shop

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Kona K.
    17
    456
    11

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Thrift Stores 6,348 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Antiques at Northport

    Antiques at Northport

    (2 reviews)

    This place makes me so happy! I came there this past week to try and find some plates. They have…read moreeverything you could possibly need. I can't believe how organized everyone's section is. The staff is very friendly and helpful. It put me in the best mood once I left. Will return!

    This place has a lot of great antiques (usually too pricey, but sometimes can find a deal on…read moresomething). However, I went in the other day and found a lampshade on a shelf that I liked that happened to not be priced. As a person that regularly frequents thrift and antique stores, I understand that if it's not priced then it's either not for sale or someone ripped the price tag off and thus, it's not for sale at this time. I went up to the counter where THE OWNER was sitting and I basically said "I understand if you can't sell this to me since it's not priced but I am interested!" The owner responded rudely and said that the reason it's not priced is because I took it off the base of the lamp where the price is. I said "Oh, I didn't take it off the lamp, it was by itself on the shelf." She huffed and rudely said, "Yes you did... I should know, it's my store!!!!" At that point, it wasn't worth fighting for so I turned around and put it back where I found it (on a shelf with 5+ other solo lampshades). On my way out, she tried to THEN haggle me and offered me $10 for the lampshade and then offered unsolicited advice that I should really bring in the lamp if I'm looking for a lampshade. I said no thank you and left. I don't need to be lectured and accused of something at an antique store filled to the BRIM with items. Antiquing is supposed to be a fun way to find old treasures and functional items for your home.

    Act II Consignment Boutique

    Act II Consignment Boutique

    (19 reviews)

    $$

    Whom I would assume was the owner of this store was so awful and dismissive…read more For reference I am a young lady and showed up in workout clothes (I had just came from a class). I operate an online vintage designer boutique and had some inventory I didn't turn over that I originally brought to Plato's Closet. l I realized that they are not like the shops in the city and mostly take fast fashion so I was so excited to see Act II only a few miles away. I walked in with my bag of clothes and the owner informed me that she was by appointment only which is fine, I asked to make an appointment. She said she would take a look since I was there. I let her know that not all of the clothes in the bag would be for her but she should take a look as I had some great stuff. She proceeded to pull 2 things out of my bag like they had cooties and exclaimed I DONT TAKE STUFF LIKE THIS I CANT LOOK AT THIS IF THEY WERE FOLDED OR ON HANGERS. I explained to her like I said I was at Plato's so that is how they were put back in the bag. I want to add here the entire corner of her store by the window was full of clothes in bags on the floor. She proceeded to refuse to look through the rest of my items after I told her I had a bunch of Theory, Tanya Taylor, and Frame Jeans. So she wouldn't give me an appointment but wouldn't look at my things as is? I believe she had an idea about me the second I walked into the store based on my appearance. I wasn't aware I would be meeting the queen. I have been working in luxury fashion for the past 6 years and am a collector of vintage designer items and would have been happy to be a customer and possibly a frequent consigner to this store if the owner did not develop such a rude preconceived notion. Although I did not feel inclined to look around judging by the yelp photos of the inside it looks to be a lot of Michael Kors outlet and shoes I can get a better price on at Marshall's so she may have not known Max Mara or Alberta Ferretti of it hit her in the face anyway!

    Long Island does not have enough consignment shops. But I am SO GLAD for Act II!!! Patrice, the…read moreowner, is one of my favorite people. I had gone in on a whim after driving past and having been someone who had worked in consignment boutiques in Los Angeles her shop does not disappoint. I have found the most beautiful pieces in there. Don't get it twisted it is NOT a thrift store. There is a huge difference. Thrift stores are fun for trash picking, consignment boutiques like Patrice's place are fabulous, chic, and full of beautiful pieces at a fraction of the price for some of the biggest names in designers in excellent condition and also having the ready-to-wear looks for everyday fashion. I am totally obsessed and I go in every week now sometimes twice a week because you can literally always find something new and you also could miss something that's how fast of a turn around her pieces have. I hate giving up "my spot" but I would be doing a disservice to the community by not sharing this gem. Handbags, sunglasses, jewelry (both high end costume and fine jewelry), shoes, clothing...she's literally got it all. Plus you can also consign your goodies there too if you have some great clothes in need of a freshing up in your wardrobe. XO, Your favorite customer Michelle

    Commack United Methodist Thrft Shop - thrift_stores - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...