Great service at the bar Good sides Steaks were a little tough Grilled shrimp was excellent as was the blt wedge salad read more

The service was great. Enjoyed the Caesar salad. The loaded baked potato was light on the "load", especially the sour cream, surprisingly. The thing that ruined the experience was the toughest 16-ounce ribeye I've ever tried to eat. It was a slightly overcooked medium-rare, and I couldn't quite finish half of it. Very disappointing, overall. read more

Love the food, service is always great, always have fun with the Texas style decor. My favorite server is Allysa, hadn't seen her in a couple months though, maybe next time. read more

Very bad business food was bad was double charged tried paying with Apple cash with my phone. It went through on the Apple Cash on my phone manager said that it would not process ended up paying with another card so I end up paying double rip off establishment. read more

large crowd we were seated quickly service was great and food came out hot and extremely good very quick service considering place was very busy read more

I was ready to give up on Colton's, here in Searcy. The last half dozen or so times that we've been there last, there was always something. Tremendously bad service, overcooked food, waiting for food forever, just always something. I am glad that we did give it one more shot. We had an amazing server, Free, and he catered to our every need and request. Drinks stayed full, not a severely long wait on the food (especially considering how busy they were), and the food all came out perfect and correct, which blew me away because he didn't write anything down and there was six of us. We will be sure to ask for him for now on. read more

sirloin was so tough it was not edible- 7/8th of it was left on plate. called this to attention of waitress and the reply was that it depends on who is cooking. no offer for discount if any kind. waitress was otherwise good checking on us often. read more

Great location near stockyards. The ribs portion was so large that we still had half a rack after my wife and daughter finished. Waiting staff was attentive to needs. read more

I don't like to give negative reviews on restaurants because it's such a hard business to thrive in but sometimes glaring mistakes are too hard to gloss over. In general, since covid has increased the curbside pickup scene, I have steadily noticed that the portion sizes and quality of the pickup orders are less than what you get if you actually ate in the restaurant. Mexican restaurants are the worse offenders of this, in my opinion. The Searcy Colton's is usually a pretty good choice for dine in or take out, but this time, they fell flat. I ordered the 6 ounce sirloin, medium rare, steamed broccoli and baked potato. The broccoli and potato were fine. Hard to mess those up. The steak, though, while cooked properly, was tough and stringy. But what really chapped my hide was the flat, hard roll that was put in the to-go box. I know if you dine in the rolls will keep being served if you want. When ordering for pickup, though, you get all your going to get. I feel those should be the best quality rolls. Three of the rolls were fine but fourth was pathetic! See the picture for comparison. The pathetic roll was hard, undercooked and flat. The most aggravating thing is that someone actually handled that roll, knew what they had and purposely put it in the box. Once again, I don't like to give negative reviews, but, Colton's, you need to step up your game if you want my business in the future. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Normal roll on left, pathetic roll on the right. - Seafood Near Me - Searcy, Arkansas

Best filet in Searcy! We order and pick up. Convince and great service all in one. Our go to on Saturday nights,! Lana. Duncan read more

It's been a while since I have been to Colton's in Searcy. But this new building (new to me) and bar looked great. I ordered the a side salad with spicy ranch and the ribeye del rio. The side salad with spicy ranch made my night! It's the fist time i have had spicy ranch that was actually spicy! I took my first bite and i was like bam there is a little heat there! The ribeye was slightly over cooked but not by much. The spicy butter they put on the steak after it came of the grill was really good. I even enjoyed my green beans! Mom would be so happy! Overall we had great service also. read more

We were just there a couple hours ago. I ordered the grilled shrimp and replaced my rice with Sautéed Mushrooms. The shrimp was to salty and had way too much lemon juice on it. I couldn't eat it. The sautéed mushrooms were spicy and I could only taste the onion they cooked with, there was no mushroom flavor at all. Also the menu never stated it was spicy. Wasted my my money on food that couldn't be eaten. We won't be back. The waitress was great. read more

Seems like they could care less if your there or not my kids like their food so I've been many times the waitresses look miserable to be there although friendly it's poorly managed so save yourself the headache trust me...I'm addinto this review because I just tried to go back after 7 months to give it another try it honestly seems worse smh read more

I don't normally post a review but tonight I was upset I called in a order around 3 and they said - pick up in 25/30 mins It was over 30 mins that my husband was outside the door waiting At 4:29 they charged our card - I don't understand what happened but I wish my husband would have just left after the long wait The server listed on my card was Halle J They could have at least offered a discount Someone screwed up read more

We'll I guess I'll use what's left of our gift cards at another location..... Or just toss them.... Great place if you like 1 steak that's gristle and another that's over cooked.... Oh and don't forget the queso dip appetizer that came out seconds before the meal.... With a nice film over the top from sitting forever... And the margarita I ordered that took 15 minutes + to receive..... and was not what I ordered..... but other than that enjoy Won't be back.... read more

worst Mac and cheese I've ever tasted. ordered catfish platter ... tasteless. was supposed to come with slaw ... no slaw.... guess chef doesn't know the menu very well. this chain is for customers who are satisfied with run of the mill food... so many others to choose from ... read more

Colton's steakhouse is to basic steak lovers as chipotle is to basic burrito lovers. As you can tell from the photos, presentation is not a priority for those at Colton's. The salmon cream cheese dip we ordered as an appetizer was frozen solid and thrown alongside some pita chips from the supermarket. The steak (ordered med. rare) was cooked medium well and lacked any kind of flavor. The one thing they did right at Colton's was the warm, buttery rolls that came with the food. Those were worth 5 stars. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Seafood Near Me - Searcy, Arkansas

See all

The cook definitely needs some training. The ribeye was way over cooked instead of medium rare. The pork chop was pink. Pretty sure the cook confused the ribeye for the pork chop. Not impressed at all. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Way undercooked pork chop - Seafood Near Me - Searcy, Arkansas

Bad service and mediocre food makes for a bad combo. Waited 15 minutes at our table and no one had waited on us. So I get up and ask for our waitress she finally showed up to take our order. I got the fresh out of the freezer chicken fried steak and it was trash. read more

I love their steaks, specialty salads, and chicken-fried chicken! Truth be told, I could make a meal out of a basket of rolls. Colton's is where I always go to celebrate. Never been disappointed. read more

I went here my first night in town, got the bacon filet topped with feta, it was ok, I'm pretty sure it came out of a prepack. I went again tonight, the corn on the cob was really good, the smoked sirloin was difficult to cut and tasted like liquid smoke. The "horseradish" sauce is mostly mayonnaise. I didn't finish the sirloin I ordered a cheesecake to go. My second bite I could feel a long coarse hair, I spit the food out of my mouth and separated it from the hair. The attached pic shows the hair sitting on the mostly uneaten cheesecake. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Cheesecake with a side of hair. - Seafood Near Me - Searcy, Arkansas

Service was very good here but not sure if I would come back. Buckets of peanuts like Texas Roadhouse would have at each table. The side salad was crisp cold and fresh with a good assortment of toppings. The house spicy ranch-ish dressing was good with just a touch of a spice noted kick. The dinner rolls were very good and was pleasantly surprised that they served honey for a roll topping. Love honey so was a nice treat. The fried okra is fried okra but was very good and my favorite next to the honey and rolls. As for the 12 oz sirloin, Texas Roadhouse has a far superior steak that's this was. About half was not eaten due to course gristle embedded in this cut. Not much flavor in the cut either added my own salt and pepper to bring the meat to life. The steak sauce had to try. Odd combination of A1 and Worcestershire sauce blend. Odd finish on the tongue and the ketchup was French's. Frenchs never a fan to sweet All in all an average meal. Would have been great if the steak would have been a notch better read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Inside view - Seafood Near Me - Searcy, Arkansas

See all

food was awesome! the service was perfect! we were a party of seven and had a great experience! Thanks Searcy Colton's!

Very good steak! Their Mac and cheese was the real deal. The waitress was super nice and helpful. Their curbside take out was fast and easy. The food was hot. To the point and just good. read more

Hard ass chips chipped my tooth. I tend to be a silver lining kind of guy. Here's the pro I found from this experience. Great news.... I can't get food stick in my teeth due to mine being involved in a single chip accident. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Seafood Near Me - Searcy, Arkansas

Colton's has improved since they moved to their new place. Food WAS GOOD and serve ok. Big improvement.

I have eaten here before and did okay. But, this time it was unsafe. I asked for and received the GF menu. I requested the Caesar salad as a side without croutons, which is on their GF menu. It came to the table and after two bites I found a soggy crouton in the salad. I think they premix the salad with croutons and pick them out. I told the waitress and she apologized and offered to make another salad for me, which I refused. Now I'm already sick and regretting eating here. read more

Stopped in around 6:00. Biggest mistake I made this year. Steak part raw the other part over cooked. My worst meal at McD's was better than this meal at Colton's. Someone needs to instruct the manager on how to run a restaurant. read more

Sunday - Mother's Day - we knew it would be packed - it was and you cannot make reservations! We were the group of 27 who patiently waited along with many others for an hour and a half! Just a heads up to the wait staff - at the end of the meal when you are retrieving the plates IF there are five or six plates on the table that have only one bite out of the steak there is a problem!!!! Ignoring it is not the way to go! An inquiry would go a long way !!!! read more

Wow what a surprise. We were just in town for a day and decided to give Colton's a shot. We had the New York Steak and the Bourbon glazed salmon. Not only was the food amazing but our server was an absolute joy. She was attentive and had a contagious smile. When we return we will definitely be back. Truly a place worth checking out!!! read more

Just came in town and found this great gem. Great food at a good price and the service was second to none. Thanks for a great dinner.

Really had a nice dinner here. Facility looks new, or remodeled recently. I was seated right away. The bucket of peanuts were tasty. I had the 9 oz Sirloin, loaded baked potato, and salad. The steak was a nice size, properly cooked, and was flavorful. For an additional $1 I got the loaded baked potato It was good, not outstanding, but good. The salad was fresh, the Ranch dressing was pretty thin. Fresh hot rolls with honey were outstanding. My server was Nikki, she was prompt, friendly, and helpful. Overall I was pleased. It was a nice "middle of the road Steakhouse. By that, it wasn't a high priced five star steakhouse, but it was a lot better than Western Sizzlon or Golden Corral. read more

Waitress was very disrespectful to us and rolled her eyes when they got our food incorrect. Whole party felt sick after eating your food. Also chicken taste like fish. Terrible service. Fix it read more

The waitress was a train wreck. The bartender was busy flirting with the busboy sitting at the bar. It took four groups to straggle in before someone showed up to seat us. read more

The servers were all very friendly and the atmosphere was pretty swanky. I liked the peanuts on the table, it was a nice little touch. But, the best thing was the Applewood smoked bacon on my chicken sandwich. Usually when you order bacon you get like 1-2 scrawny, overcooked little pieces but this bacon was thick and had a great smoked flavor. The only thing I wish I could have changed was to just ditch the sandwich and I would have ordered a plate of their bacon! read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - The chicken sandwich with Applewood Smoked bacon. - Seafood Near Me - Searcy, Arkansas

picked up a to go order. The salad lettuce was dripping wet so no dressing could stick to it. I asked for no butter on steamed veggies - guess what... a stick of butter. Thank God I didn't have to listen to the cow bell they ring for birthdays. The only reason I go there is there is no where else to go for a baked sweet potato! read more

The servers are the gem of this place. The food is acceptable and portions are generous. It is one of the only places that serve consistent food in Searcy. read more

Good food and service. Try the chicken or steak salad. The Texas salad is great too, if you want a big salad with no meat. Tea is good.

We was seated at the table and pass by and no one ask what we wanted drink or eat for 13 minutes. It was not busy. We left.

Peanuts on the floor. Doesn't that really say it all? Please. The culinary designs are weak, and the food isn't much better. Edible? Well, yes. But, if you want a good steak, burger, or sandwich, find someplace else. It really is more of a grill than a steakhouse. read more