My absolute go to for pizza in the Augusta area for 30+ years. They also have sandwiches, meatball subs, calzones all delicious with quality ingredients. Their Pepperoni pizza is just the right amount of cheese and the crust isn't too thick. They offer coupons for each pizza purchase for a free small pizza. They offer delivery for a fee and sometimes you may need to wait an hour but it always arrives hot. Tips are encouraged for the drivers. They also give quietly to the community and the schools. Located in the heart of town if you are in the mood for pizza, this is the place. read more

Tried this place for the first time, and it will definitely be my last as well. I ordered a sandwich on a hoagie roll and it was all vegetables. Very disappointed for 13 dollars. Barely any meat at all. Oh well will not be going back. read more

Staff is nice. Pizza is decent. Pass on the $9 Mozz sticks. The fact they actually served these is crazy to me. read more

College Carry Out - "Mozzarella Sticks" - Pizza Near Me - Augusta, Maine

So let's begin and say this is the best pizza in the Augusta area.. everything about the pizza is fantastic, crust is tasty, sauce is very good and there is definitely no shortage of toppings. So why the 4*, I hate to admit it, the lobster roll brought them down. The lobster filling was actually very much on par, it was the roll. It just overpowers the lobster as there's just too much roll for the lobster roll. Added points, they are handling the covid issue like champs and was real pleasure to do business with. read more

College Carry Out - A 12" pizza and a lobster roll - Pizza Near Me - Augusta, Maine

Seems wildly overpriced, 22$ for a 1 topping pizza? These aren't some fancy pies. 30$ for a loaded. Probably the priciest pizza I've actually seen in Maine read more

Decided to try their 1/2 lb lobster rolls today for Mother's Day. They were pretty busy but the service was fast enough. I got my lobster roll with lettuce and tomato. Delicious! I was slightly nervous about the size of it at first, I mean twelve inches of lobster roll is no laughing matter, this is serious business here! However, I managed to eat the whole thing. It's a tough job, but somebody's got to do it. We enjoyed sitting out at the picnic table, shaded by the trees, listening to the birds... it was so peaceful. A nice treat. Also, their other sandwiches are delicious and reasonably priced. I've never had a bad experience with College Carry Out! read more

College Carry Out - Mother's Day Lobster rolls, YUM! - Pizza Near Me - Augusta, Maine

I ordered take away and was not disappointed! Since it was a pick up, I got the buy 1, get 1 at 1/2 price. One pie was pepperoni and green pepper, the other was meatball and onion. Both were very tasty, plenty of toppings, crust was chewy in a yummy way and flavorful. The staff were very friendly and looked like they actually enjoyed working there. It is now my only pizza place! read more

For a basic pizza without the bells and whistles this will do the trick. Plus they deliver. Perfect for kids dinner.

We ordered pizza here a couple times on our vacation (one can only eat lobster so many days in a row!) and it was pretty good both times. The crust was nice, the toppings were good, sauce was fine. All in all, they make a solid pizza. Much better than chain restaurants, but not quite as good as some of the New York -style places (of which, I'm not aware of any in this area anyway). We picked up our pizzas, which were hot and fresh right when they said they would be, so it seems like they have the timing worked out pretty well. I'll definitely be back next time we're in the area. read more

Ordered 3 rollup sandwiches while dad was having some tests done at a nearby hospital. Service was fast, and all sandwiches were excellent, while a little pricey. Would recommend splurging here to get some quality food. Everyone raved about how good the food tasted. I would go back if I were a local. Just an average deli shop, don't remember if there was a dining area there. read more

Okay food. Prices are great for what you get. Great foul of people working there. They do have great customer service and they are pretty good about the timing with the food too read more

Used to be a "go to". Will not order from them any more. Ordered the "Sampler", was not informed of one item being unavailable, the one thing we really wanted, and unilaterally replaced with a corn dog, which would not have been my choice. Having my phone number, they could have called. Rest of the items under cooked. When called, was informed "I can give you half off the next sampler". The sandwich ordered also came incomplete. Was told 30 minutes for delivery, started being concerned after an hour. I'd have given them the benefit of doubt as it is a Friday night, but considering I ordered at 5pm, I doubt they were overwhelmed with orders. VERY unsatisfied, will look for alternatives. read more

Craving a lobster roll, I called College Carry Out and ordered their small. Y'all... a small is still about 8 inches and loaded with meat. I can't imagine the size of a large! I also found the price fair for what I got. The only thing I wasn't a fan of was the roll, it was a bit dry and toasting it made it drier, so next time I may not get it toasted. Ordering over the phone was easy and when I got there, they brought my order right to my car with as little contact as possible. read more

In my opinion this is the best pizza place in the Augusta area. The pizza is consistently cooked the same. They have a different pizza special everyday. read more

The food was overpriced for what we got. It was bland and small for what we payed. Our delivery driver came 15 minutes later than when we were told he would. This joint is overrated and ridiculously overpriced. read more

I've been meaning to come here for years I drive-by over and over again and I see the sign that says lobster roll. Best around or Best in town. So today on my long 2 1/2 hour Monday commute--I decided today was the day. I walked through the front door and it was set up very well for ordering food. I was asked immediately if I was ready to order. Now if I were a regular and was ready to order I would have really appreciated the question. Being that it was my first visit I was slightly put off by the immediate request. I took a little bit of time to review the menu which is on the wall while the gentleman who asked if I was ready to order stared at me the entire time. They were all very fast-paced in the store. Everyone was working and moving around. So I understand his anticipation of my order. But dude! I want to read the menu. So I order a tuna club. And I ask if it is white tuna or light tuna. I am told it is the lightest tuna you can get without spending an arm and a leg, but it's not white. He offers chicken salad, "it's white" he says. OK smart ass; I'll have the chicken salad. Since I don't have time to read the whole menu because you laser beams are blinding me! Mr. Alert says it comes on a club roll or you can have it in a wrap. I opt for the roll thinking, "don't call it a club". As i'm waiting for the sandwich I get a chance to read more of the menu-I could have had it on bread toasted-[insert curse of choice here] "I'm too busy looking busy to understand the menu" guy is a bit checked out and not lovin' his job right now. The next time I'm just gonna look at the paper menu and avoid his gaze, gaze, gazing. The sandwich was very good. Plenty of chicken salad and diced onions. The pizza looked good as well - and they were REALLY fast. My advise: don't let the "eyeballs on you" man throw you off your ordering game and you'll find your way there more often. read more

I was looking forward to a good lobster roll while I was visiting in Maine and was told to try College Carry Out. After paying $20 for a small, I was disappointed to find the lobster meat was tasteless and I'm thinking it was previously frozen. I definitely Do Not recommend the lobster roll here! read more

What can I say? The pizza was pretty good but it had peppers on it when I didn't order peppers. Then they said delivery was going to be 30 minutes and it took more than an hour. When I called I asked them why they didn't call me to inform me they were going to be over an hour and the girl lied to me and said they didn't take my phone number. That's not true that's one of the first things they did was take my phone number. I don't see myself ever ordering from them again read more

Spend some weekends up in this area at a family members camp. First time trying this place and was happy we did. Their pizza was good and I def recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza. Service was on point as well as they brought our food out to the car right when we called upon arrival. Friendly staff. Will be ordering again next time we're back in the area. read more

Since moving to Augusta over the summer/fall, we sought a good pizza delivery outfit. We swung and missed a couple of times (mediocre pizza and no delivery) before coming across College Carry Out. Their name suggests you have to go pick up your order, but wrong--they deliver within the city, and guess what: The pizza is excellent, the price reasonable, and you don't have to wait too long for it to arrive. Until I read some of the other reviews, I did not realize you apparently can dine in as well, so we'll have to try that sometime, and sample some of their other menu items. They have calzones but I haven't found strombolis yet (here's hoping). read more

When I visit Augusta this is the pizza place we hit. Solid pie an establishment that has served the community for many years. Owner is always is the store which leads to consistency in the product. My favorite is the bacon pizza. They usually have deals online. Not the best pizza I've had but solid. read more

Their chicken salad Dagwood would literally be my last meal if I was on death row. This is why i give them give 5 stars. I have ordered this same item from other stores and never gotten one as amazing as theirs. Their pizza is also an 8/10. VERY good, thick home made crust, maine style pizza and all the veggies seem pretty stinkin fresh. (I would also like to add that the two star review may have been because there was a new person training on making pizza, it DID go down in quality and was fairly floppy and gross for a little while, and I stopped ordering it. But it has since come right back up to par. It sucked, then it got better) read more

This place is absolutely wonderful nice location nice parking lot nice outside seating with a picnic table conveniently-located friendly staff good menu you can call ahead and have your food ready when you arrive nice little convenience store part as well got an assortment of beverages and an area for adult beverages very good. read more

I went to College up at UMA, & this place was great to hit for beer after class. Employees are friendly and have decent selection of munchies and BEER. Don't let the surrounding area scare you off, it's worth checking out. read more

I used to love College Carryout, but they have changed their pizza. It is now mediocre, which is very disappointing. . .

Best pizza in the greater Augusta area. Def worth trying out!

Always amazing pizza. This is the best around no matter what toppings you choose you won't be disappointed. I love that they deliver for those days I am feeling lazy. The Dagwoods are delicious and who doesn't love a sandwhich with bacon. Service is quick and friendly. Stop by and pick up a bite to eat on a day you are feeling too lazy to cook. read more

i just had a company sponsored event for over 200 people. The pizza was fantastic. it was served hot and on time. The perfect amount of toppings and it was cooked great. would strongly recommend for any size group. read more

We placed an order for our office at 10:15 am. The girl answering the phone had the personality of a wet mop. They told me it would be delivered in 40 minutes. An hour and 20 minutes we had nothing. I called and was told that they messed up the credit card #. Girl claims she tried twice to call.. My phone never rang. I confirmed that they had the right number and they did. They never called me. So we had to wait 40 more minutes... Lunch is over by now. Should have gone some place else read more

Awesome little sandwich shop. Take out only. If you want a good pizza or an Italian that won't disappoint this is the spot to hit. Very busy every day but the wait is never too long. Their signature "gobbler" sandwich is simple but delicious. read more

Chicken salad dagwoods are homemade! They give huge portions and it's Delicious. Their platter sandwiches are great too.

The food was not bad. I got the Lobster roll and there was a good amount of Lobster. My daughter loved the chicken nuggets. The serving sizes were good for the price. The service was the best part!! read more

I eat here often. Whether it's a pizza or a wrap I am never disappointed and the food is delicious. The staff are very friendly and accommodating. One of my favorite places to eat. read more

Employee was rude to me when I was ordering, honestly did not care for that. For much less money you can get a better pizza. One this is less greasy, taste better and where the employees have a better attitude. Go to dominoes instead. read more

If I could give this dump less than a full star I would. Greasy, low quality ingredients, wet crust, etc. We keep giving them the op to redeem themselves but they don't even try. read more

if you have a hp plate beware, went to the Maine credit union , their driver took the only hp spot and forced me me to park at the end of the lot I had a person in a wheelchair who had to wait till he left. when I called the shop they could care less .I guess they rules are only for a few read more

Their pizza is so good I buy a second just to cuddle with afterwards and ask it if it was as good for it as it was for me.

This is the worst place to get delivery ever. Ordered recieved food over 45 minutes late. Sandwiches were so soggy they could not be eaten. Frye were cold but overcooked and to hard to eat. Mozzerealla sticks were frozen in the middle. When contacted for a refund and to return the uneaten food the "manager" first told us they do not deliver to our area haha ok. So then we told them we wanted to return the food and were told we can't do that but could receive 50 percent off our next order. Hum no we will not be ordering again. She then proceeded to hang up on us twice the first time claiming she didn't hang up on us and the second time when I asked her to cancel the transaction she hung up again. I guess we will be going in tomorrow to speak to the actual business owner since we were not allowed to ask for the contact info. Seriously do not order here my husband took two bites of his sandwich and is now puking. Shitty undercooked food apparently causes poisoning. I wonder where to send the hospital bill if he has to go to the e.r. read more