The ice cream was as I expected it to be, cold and delicious. What I didn't expect was the service to be so amazing. Evie was so patient and kind while I was trying to select a flavor that my 4 year old autistic son might approve of. Later in our visit I was a little embarrassed in asking her to take our picture but she did so without judgement and without hesitation. For some it's just ice cream, but to me it was so much more. Evie, thank you for being such an awesome person and helping to make our day out perfect! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Sweet Cream Ice Cream Kid's Scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

See all

The ice cream itself meets expectations--rich, creamy, and flavorful. However, the pre-set combinations tend to be overloaded with mix-ins, which can overwhelm the base flavors. I'd recommend creating your own custom blend for a more balanced experience. The location could use some attention. Tables were wobbly, and while the space appeared basically clean, it lacked a sense of tidiness and upkeep that would make the visit more comfortable. What really left a sour taste was the refusal to provide a cup of water after spending nearly $50. Being told to purchase bottled water instead felt unnecessarily stingy. Offering a simple cup of water is a small gesture that goes a long way in customer service--and it's disappointing when that's overlooked. read more

UPDATE: Spencer M. told me to email them the review to continue the conversation which I assume would mean a coupon or other action but sadly they never answered the email so this message below my review is a lie to make Spencer look like a responsible business owner. ORIGINAL REVIEW: I was there 12/26/23 around closing since we were the last customers before locking up. The line was long but we thought, it's ice cream it can't take that long. It took a longggg time to get to the counter. Not a big deal, but why did it take so long? The two employees were taking scoops of ice cream and trying to put on a show by throwing customers ice cream across the room into the cups. It created many unsanitary situations where they dropped the scoops or touched dirty surfaces like the ceiling with scoops while doing a trick and only dipped them in the water to "sanitize" them. They also wasted roughly $40 worth of ice cream from missing the throws across the entire lobby with every customers order. I haven't been to cold stone for years but I always thought of cold stone as a fancy ice cream place since you're paying $6+ for a scoop, but this place was ratchet. Jefferson point has gone down hill and that's very unfortunate. read more

Ordered a Strawberry Milkshake. It was put in a very small cup for the price and without any whipped cream. It was very runny consistency so was basically just strawberry milk. Would maybe pay $2 for it not close to $7. Also got vanilla with Oreos and the ice cream was not even to the top of the bowl. The ice cream also had 1 Oreo chopped in it. Very poor portion for the price I paid. Overall, just a bad experience there at the Cold Stone at Jefferson Pointe. Also, I think it depended on the server you got for how much of a portion you got. Very overpriced for below average ice cream shop experience. read more

Evie was only worker and she was as pleasant as she was speedy in fulfilling a constant line. Great service in a tough situation.

I went in for ice cream but left with a cake! I've always liked ColdStone's ice cream. So, on Thursday I was just going to pick some up and bring it home for my girlfriend and I. Cold Stone is just as good at selling as they are at making ice cream. The girls were super friendly and let me know about their Valentine's Cakes, which I just HAD to jump on. What a great way to ask her to be my Valentine! Was so good that me and my girlfriend finished it last night! read more

Great service and really friendly employees. Salem is so sweet. & she makes the best ice creams that they make in store. They have a wonderful winter selection check it out! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

Went here during a shopping trip to Jefferson pointe. It's located by the amc theatre. There was a short line but it takes awhile to get to the front to place your order giving you plenty of time to scan the menu and ice cream selections to make your creation. The prices went up so it's anywhere from $5-$9 for ice cream with 1 mix in for free and $1.29 for each additional topping that comes in a cup. Add a cone for $1.79 more. So it could be very pricey. The actual cold stone where they mix in the toppings was a huge mess. Old ice cream in the stone, toppings and ice cream in the cracks between the stone and the toppings area, toppings scattered all over the counter and lids off the containers. Syrup bottles were caked I. Old dried liquid and needed cleaned or thrown out. They do add plenty of topping but if you get something g that needs to be chopped up they don't do a good job at it. The check out area was dirty. Needed wiped off and sanitized.the employees are your typical teenager kids who do. It know the first thing about customer service. The girl I had was extremely rude not friendly and never smiled. She barely said two words to me. I was left on my own to pay and when it didn't work for my payment type I had to wait on her while she was making a Grubhub order. She wasn't available to ask for lids or a bag because I was taking it to go. This place has def gone downhill since my last visit while increasing their prices significantly. I def won't be going back esp when there are local places that are much better. read more

See all

Arrived at 8:15 and was told they wouldn't serve anyone else. Hours say 9pm close online and on the doors. No other signs anywhere just rude management and employees ignoring customers literally already in line and waiting. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

Coldstone right after lunch! You never could go wrong with ice cream. We ordered "Founders favorite " and "Birthday Cake Batter". Quick service, not too many people. Offered sanitizer and staff were wearing masks. Not too many guests at the time we visited, 3 to be precise. Our server was friendly and warm, made sure we didn't feel uncomfortable cause of COVID and showed us where the sanitizer is. All wrapped up in less than 6 minutes. The only reason I gave 4* is the bowl waffle seemed to be a day old but I didn't taste that for the cone waffle. So all in all something to note specifically for the waffle bowl. Street parking available easily. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

The employees who were working at 9pm on Friday were very friendly and helpful! They seemed to really enjoy their jobs and they were very attentive to the customers. The icecream was great! Will definetely come back! read more

How can you expect to sell ice cream if you don't have most of the flavors that people want? Nobody around on a Monday at 6 and they said they have no chocolate no dark chocolate and no Snickers this would be a great place to put a Cold Stone Creamery. Been a few years since I've been here I can understand why they have such low ratings. The windows to the front looking out we're so dirty you could barely see out them if you have employees standing around all the time somebody should learn how to wash windows. Because obviously they don't know how to make ice cream so at least they could be productive doing something else. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Its Monday and they are out of chocolate and deep chocolate and snicker bar.. And its only MONDAY! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

Today we're celebrating a birthday and I choose Coldstone to provide the cake and ice cream. My thought being, why not knock out to steps in one. I'm ever so glad I did. Service: while I was not greeted at the door, the employees were nice none the less. I chalked up the lack of greeting to working on a holiday. Product: I choose the cookies and cream ice cream cake. The cake was "iced" with whip cream and consisted of 2 layers of chocolate cake sandwiched together by a layer of cookies and cream ice cream. They cake was excellent. It was cold and dreamy at the same time. We also opted to get ice cream cupcakes. They too, were "iced" with whip cream, but the cake layer was yellow. They were just enough for teenagers who no longer want to sing the dreaded "Happy Birthday" song. I think I've found my new favorite. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

See all

Very awesome cookies we love going ever chance we can fast service ............. Staff is friendly helpful kind

It is a decent place. Cold Stone Creamery has a large selection of flavors. However, if you want to add "Mixers" ie. toppings, you pay an additional dollar for anything above one, so the price can really add up. I would say that their ice cream is good, and they have a decent seating area. However, the prices are high. So for me, this would be a place I would go only once in a while. The service that evening was good, and the line was short. Of course I can understand what over reviewers were saying because as movies were letting out, the place got much busier. read more

Me and the wife stopped in last night after a pretty atrocious dinner elsewhere. The line was wrapped around the inside and was busy. The crew here worked diligently and through a few snags with credit card receipt tape and after about a 15-20 minute wait we were served. Despite the ever growing line, we were served with a smile. My wife got her usual birthday cake shake and I ordered a mud pie mojo waffle cone. It was heaven! Coffee ice cream, fudge, peanut butter, and roasted almonds in a wonderfully cinnamon flavored waffle cone. It was magic! The manager should be proud of their team for handling a constant rush the way they did. Excellent service and excellent product. I would rate this experience a 4.5 because Of the long wait time but other than that, it was a wonderful experience read more

10 pm close time and locked the doors at 9:30 with people inside and out enjoying their ice cream and refuse to serve us no happy when we had two kids expecting this. So went to Portillos and was very satisfied and spent out money their. read more

Horrible service!! Second time we've gone there and there are 5-6 employees and only 1 helping customers. We waited a half hour with 2 sets of people in front of us & still didn't get our ice cream. We will not go back!!!!!! They need to learn what customer service is!! read more

I left a review two months ago and never received a called or contact from the local store. I message the email given and never received any contact from anyone besides the reply to the review telling me to send an email and promising store manager would call me about it. Obviously the local store doesn't value non dairy customers. read more

Cold Stone Creamery works their softish ice cream with mix ins of your choosing. You can also select from more than a dozen signature creations and specialty items. I tend to go for Cake Batter or Sweet Cream based items though the chocolate based ones look delish but rich! The family group I was with go out rarely and only do chains. With dread I logged my every few years trip to a Cold Stone this evening. My group's selects were All Lovin' No Oven, Founder's Favorite, a chocolate with chocolate chips custom bowl, and a bowl of raspberry plain. + Enough staff that we didn't have to wait to be served on a Friday night + 15 varieties of ice cream bases available including a seasonal offer, and all 4 of ours were fresh - Staff gave me a sample on my request of the seasonal Dark Chocolate Peppermint, but had no suggestions for mix ins. There was a slight peppermint flavor that came through after the chocolate. To my surprise there was no peppermint candy in the base (think Edy's) AND no crushed candy canes or anything minty for a mix in! - Dirty tables and floor was so dirty with actual melted ice cream one in our group didn't want to watch someone step in it and told the staff it was there. - My Founder's Favorite was mixed beyond recognition. No swirls of caramel or fudge, it was a hodge podge and looked a mess. There are other options in the area and I suggest trying one of them before this location of Cold Stone. read more

I'm giving this three stars for taste. Definitely not the best ice cream I have had, but also not the worst. The facility was very clean, the employees were super friendly and very nice... The product itself left something to be desired. I guess cold stone just isn't my favorite ice cream. read more

Service was not great. Very unorganized. Seemingly no one was in charge. Could write a lot but I don't want to berate with negativity. Ice cream was average. read more

I ordered a pint of ice cream $13 it was cookie dough Carmel fudge cake batter ice cream and of course cookie dough and a mint chocolate chip shake previously the last month service was great and the employee was very nice this time I can't say the same me and my husband were in line and a couple behind us they ordered 2 cups of ice cream they were served and checked out before she even started our ice cream when it was finally our turn the lady was rude and didn't really know what she was doing and didn't really mix my ice cream up all the way then she only put 2 cookie dough circles in a big tub of ice cream!!! Outrageous when I usually go I get at least that much cookie dough circles in my normal bowl but seriously 2 that's it for a whole tub of specialized ice cream that I am paying $13 for! The employee that we went to before last month was amazing and the ice cream was phenomenal and she put more cookie dough than that in there and actually mixed up my ice cream all the way and filled my tub full! This employee literally scooped up some normal ice cream and added it to the top of my tub to finish filling it! Oh I am pissed off the only reason I was civil is because this is the only cold stone in town and I enjoy there ice cream despite this horrific encounter today. read more

See all

Stopped in for desert. This place was packed tonight but the line moved pretty fast. Great service!

I love it when they sing to me! I have never had a bad experience here. In fact I think the young ice cream makers go out of their way to interact and some times entertain their customers. It's pricy but it's really really delicious so I don't seem to mind. So far I've had the Birthday Batter and the Mint Mint Chocolate Chip. Both are great. Well I've had the Mint Mint Chocolate Chip a lot so I guess that' my favorite, bownies and mint ice cream.... YES PLEASE! read more

Always pretty disappointed in the service I get here, due to the amount of time it takes to wait in line; however, Mother's Day was on a new level. Waited in line for at least 20 minutes only to find out that almost every flavor (specifically chocolate & vanilla) they ran out of. They only had 6 flavors total remaining at 7:00 (on the first warm Sunday night of the year), and offered no recommendations of things they may be able to do to substitute the flavors for their signature dishes. Also, never once did they make any announcements, post any signs, etc. to let customers know. Many customers expressed how displeased they were, but the staff didn't care - probably because it was a bunch of high school/college kids just there to do a simple, minimum wage summer job. #2Stars read more

The Ice cream here is amazing. They have so many different options to choose from. I ordered a no oven all lovin and it was great. The only problem was the line was very long, and they were out of whipped cream! Almost perfect. read more

My favorite ice cream place ever! Their signature creations are so good i cant even look at anything else on the menu! The portions are huge and the prices are decent for what you get! read more

Prices are too expensive for what you get, there are a lot of flavors and combinations but prices definitely add up quick and the quality is just average. I tried their new special that "looks and tastes so good" it wasn't all like advertised, it was below average, not very flavorful and the employee I dealt with was annoyed by me and a little rude. So many other places I will choose from now on. read more

I love Coldstone! Props to Brandon who was apparently working by himself on a very busy Sunday afternoon. He still managed to provide friendly service and make my favorite flavor combo perfectly, which is the Mud Pie Mojo. Coffee ice cream with peanut butter, oreos, and almonds. It is oh so yummy. read more

It's 1 in the afternoon and they have run out of half their ice cream flavors. It's been open for an hour.

How in the world can an ice cream place not have ANY cones?! Seriously disappointed!!! Saturday of spring break, took the kids there-no cones, no M&Ms ?! Seriously we drove all the way to Jefferson Point for this just to be disappointed read more

came in on the hottest day of the year so far ready for some nice cold ice cream with a group of 6.. absolutely hotter than hell waiting in a 25 min line got served melty ice cream... which we were prewarned about....turns out the A/C is out and hasnt worked for quit some time. management needs to take care of this. absolutely ridiculous!! read more

The ice cream is okay. We came here because Menchies had closed :(. I was so disappointed after I got the bill that it ruined the whole experience. I was shocked that 4 small ice cream cups and one extra topping each ended up being over $20. The ice cream wasn't THAT good. You can go to TCBY and spend $6 for 4 or even Minchies and spend $10. We won't be going back to Cold Stone. read more

They seemed energetic and really did a lot with the ice cream. Unfortunately my cotton candy tasted like sweet milk and my wife's specialty ice cream tasted about the same albeit with more chocolate. $11 spent and we ended up tossing them both and having some ice cream at home instead. read more

Great ice cream and fantastic energy. Could use more seating but overall a cozy place. A great place for a sweet tooth.