This is your butchers butcher! Great and consistent quality - yes you can taste it! Strong variety and the sandwiches are great.

The steaks from here are superior to anywhere else in the area. Catering is awesome as well, above average chicken and everything handled with care. read more

Best steak sandwhich on earth, use to drive past coming home from airport dozens of times. Now I don't pass it without stopping! You will not regret. read more

Cogman's Creek - Butcher Near Me - Butler, New Jersey

Order the Ultimate Roast Beef sandwich. Portion was outstanding, taste was excellent, and price was very reasonable, but the wait time was way too long considering the number of staff in the place and the fact that there was only one other customer in front of me. read more

Deceptive Business! They claim (or imply) that their meat is from their small farm in Vermont. It's not. It's no different than any other prime meat you can get almost anywhere, but they charge way more money. I was going here for years to purchase my meat, thinking it was from their "small farm, nestled in 300 acres in Vermont" ( from their website). Lies. The meat is from industrial feedlots. I will never go here again, and I am writing this review so, hopefully, no one else will get duped by these scoundrels. There are plenty of farms out in Sussex County to support. Sorry Cogmans, but you do suck. read more

You really cant go wrong with Cogmans. I have had the steaks, hamburgers, empanadas, cheesesteaks, sides, salads and a number of the sandwiches. Have never been disappointed. They are all very nice there too. read more

What is there not to like. A simple butcher shop with a solid meat selection and incredible salads and sandwiches. This is a must stop for me when I am in the area. read more

Stopped in otw to a cabin in Warwick for the wkend and my wife and I were both blown away by how delicious the food was and great the meat looked! The Preakness is out of this world, can't wait to stop in Sunday to pu some dry aged steaks!! read more

I'm sorry. . . How have we lived nearby for the past 2.5 years and not one single person told us about this place????? We were craving steak last week, and somehow I finally remembered seeing this place on Route 23 so I decided to head over. I was a little sticker shocked at first at $39.99/lb for filet, considering I usually pay around $30/lb at my usual grocery store. I don't have one regret! This was the most flavorful and tender filet any of us have ever had. This will definitely be our new steak butcher for sure. We've also been lacking for a decent takeout spot since we've moved here. Another night we ordered the Black & Blues sandwich (flank steak, caramelized onions and bleu cheese) and The 1-2 sandwich (chicken cutlets, mozz, roasted red peppers and balsamic) and fries. The sandwiches were out of this world. Great quality ingredients and everything tasted so fresh and was cooked perfectly. Don't sleep on Cogman's!! read more

How have I never reviewed this place before! I stop here at least once a week if not more. They have quality meats and the staff is SUPER nice! They are all so helpful and great. They have daily specials that they post on Facebook and we usually order off of that menu so we get to try all different things. They also have a case of prepared foods if you just want to pick up some chicken or veggies or something like that. They also have a freezer with different types of ravioli and pastas which I have yet to try but looks really good. Definitely come in here to pick up a great lunch or dinner read more

Great deli that that we stop at frequently. High quality food (not just average deli food). Great portions and prices.

Great quality meats! Super friendly staff! Highly recommend. I'll be back on a regular basis

This place took me by surprise. I was expecting a smaller store but inside has a lot of great options with friendly staff. The load the sandwiches up well and cold cuts are fresh. Perhaps the only critique would be softer bread. This store also carries Nasto's ice cream which is made in Newark, NJ. I don't see it for sale often and it is pretty good. read more

See all

There isn't a butcher shop for miles so I was pretty excited to see this store open in Butler. Of course then I drove past it every day for the past month saying "I have to remember to stop in". Finally dropped in yesterday to pick up some steaks for dinner and glad I did. Small place that does sandwiches as well but had a really nice selection of items. I was getting Filet Mignon for 3. Gentleman behind the counter was nice and very helpful. Got me my steaks, cut them and wrapped to go. These might have been the best steaks I have ever cooked at home. Meat was tender as can be. Quite a bit better then the ones I normally get at the grocery store - and to be honest not that much more expensive. Highly recommend you stop by and give them a try. You won't pay a lot more but man the beef was fantastic. I will be back for sure. read more

See all

From their farm to my belly! Thank you Cogman's for choosing our area to settle down in. Visited today and really dig the setup. Tons of unique prepared food (salads, etc), awesome sandwich menu, and a great butcher/meat selection. Perfect spot for me to pick up something fresh to throw on the grill on the way home from work (briskets, porterhouse, whole chickens, tenderloins, Ribeyes, NY Strip, T-Bone, Skirt, lamb, veal, and more). I saw some pictures from the owner of his family farm in VT where the meat comes from.....300 PLUS acres with 80 happy cattle, 100 healthy hogs and free to run chickens breathing the fresh Vermont clean air. I asked for 4 center cut pork chops, I couldn't believe my eyes when he want back in the fridge and came out with a WHOLE PIG and cut the chops fresh off the hog. HOW COOL IS THAT! Instead of those cuts being exposed to the air for days or weeks as in the stop and shop they were cut fresh as fresh can be. It is so hard to find meat that is not from an antibiotic/hormone driven factory farm so it is so nice that these guys drive 6 hours each way to bring us some wholesome nutrition. I'll pay a few extra bucks for that..... Very warm atmosphere, nice people, and a great product. NOICE!!!!! Update: When ever I don't feel Ike cooking I look at the cogman Facebook page for the days specials. Very creative inventive menu each day. I asked for some healthy options and now there is a salad everyday. Sure beats cooking and most things are under 8 bucks. Very cool read more

See all

Staff is very friendly, great sandwiches and a large variety of fresh meat and prepared foods. read more

See all

Got 3 Porterhouse steaks here for Father's Day. Didn't see the guy grab them but when I got home and looked I was surprised to find basically no filet on the steak. Why should I be paying $25 a pound for a PorterHouse when it is really just a T-Bone ? read more

Cogman's Creek has quickly become a local favorite of mine. This place does it all with fresh ingredients, daily specials and a friendly attitude. I have tried a number of their sandwiches off the main menu in addition to their daily specials. I have yet to try anything that I did not like. I would recommend the Black and Blu, Classic Panini, Reuben, Stogie, and the Beef Melt sandwiches. Their steaks are cut fresh to order and melt in your mouth. I'm a sucker for a thick and juicy rib eye! If you're looking to pick up a few things to make for dinner, or grab a quick bite to eat- Cogman's Creek Butcher Shop is a solid choice. read more

Cogman's Creek - Butcher Near Me - Butler, New Jersey

The food here was originally awesome. But today I got raw chicken and rotten avocado. First, How could you serve rotten food? They were almost black. Second, why would you put undercooked poultry in a salad. You can clearly see and feel that it is not fully cooked as you cut it up. Shame on them. read more

See all

The cheesesteak meat was great, but unfortunately they chose to use some sort of cheap liquid cheese whiz for the cheese, very strange. Also, the chicken soup tasted like plastic because they chose to microwave it in a cheap plastic container which created cancer-causing chemicals in the soup. read more

Farm to table type food. Fresh, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. I've never been disappointed with any of my meals. The Waldorf Salad, the paninis, the empanadas, and the wraps are all SO tasty. Cogmans employee's are always very respectful and welcoming. Everything they make is made with pure love. HIGHLY recommend for a quick bite or caterings! read more

Cogman's Creek - Butcher Near Me - Butler, New Jersey

I've used this place since they opened and often enjoyed their meat and sandwiches. But this year we picked up two very expensive briskets of beef and were horribly disappointed in how awful they were....two huge chunks of untrimmed fat and in one of them we could barely find the beef after we trimmed it ourselves. Wow- we'll never buy that particular cut there again. And make sure, if you do, that you see if before they wrap it to avoid an unpleasant surprise when you get home. A wasted $120. Next year we'll go back to Market Basket, which has always been excellent. read more

Great prepared food and delicious meats. So glad we found this place! Moved to the area 4 months ago and Cogman's quickly became our go-to lunch spot. The cheesesteaks are really good, the burger is awesome and the assortment of daily specials always sound great (and the ones I've tried have not disappointed). We order from here whenever we have company (and a lot of times when we don't!). Over the holidays we decided to give their meats a try and we were not disappointed. Twice we've ordered filets and both times they were exactly what we were looking for. The guys that work there are all super helpful and friendly. Lucky to have a place like this so close to us. Prices are definitely not cheap but you get what you pay for and what we've gotten has always been worth it. My only complaint would be that there aren't usually specials posted online for the weekend! read more

Delicious steaks! Friendly service and good selection. Looking forward to coming in more frequently now that I've found the place. read more

Cogman's Creek - NY strip steaks - Butcher Near Me - Butler, New Jersey

Love this place, it's worth the extra coin to get quality. The staff is always helpful and gets me exactly what I want. This is the place to stop in when you get that call from your significant other on the way home and they say 'Babe, can you pickup dinner... no I don't know what I want'... the guys at Cogman's always let me know what's good that day and it takes the guesswork out of it! OH... one more thing... they have Nasto's ice cream in the freezer.... try it, it's pretty good. read more

I've been passing this place for a while and figured we'd try it today. They sell all natural raised meats and have a good selection of other fine foods. I bought two rib eye steaks, about 2 pounds total. They were probably the best beef I've ever eaten. Even my wife loved her steak, and she's not a steak lover. Highly recommended. Not being much of a shopper, I thought they were a bit pricey, but my wife said that was the normal price for good meat. I will send me family and friends there for great meats. It's at the top of my list. read more

Amazing butcher shop! Everything we've ever gotten here has been consistently fresh and delicious. The meats are high quality so yes it is a little more expensive than your average supermarket or grocery store. Totally worth the price though!! My favorite thing here is the skirt steak. We've gotten there burgers stuffed with bacon and cheese that we're also amazing, the hotdogs, chicken, steaks and sandwiches are all great. We got a big tomahawk steak for Father's Day that came out great on the grill. The pre made salads are always fresh and tasty. I love the broccoli and potato salads. They have different types of potato salad such as bacon cheddar which has a nice taste, none of them are overly mayonnaise-y which I like. They make a great sandwich, wrap and panini as well and have daily specials. The staff is always very helpful and pleasant. Definitely worth a trip for some nice quality meats! read more

See all

I can't say enough good things about Cogman's Creek. We have catered from them = Fabulous!! Dinner on a whime = always something fresh to throw on the grill! Sandwiches = Delicious - always fresh and daily specials! Chili is very good! Try their Farmhouse sandwich - one of my favorites! read more

I've been looking for a great Butcher and I came across Cogmans Creek!! The service you get is outstanding. Chris, and the other guys there are so tentative and soo helpful!! I've been there numerous times and time after time the service is superb!!! Oh, and their speciality selections and meats are plentiful and of good quality!! I couldn't be happier! Keep It Up Guys! read more

This place is right down the street from my work but I only recently decided to give them a try. I feel sorry for myself for missing out for so long! Reasonably priced as far as sandwiches and salads go. You can fully customize your own salad, with way bigger than average portions of protein if you add them on. The meat was perfectly cooked and did not disappoint. This instantly became my go to lunch spot, and I can't wait to stop in to see the meat selection. read more

So happy this place is local for us. Incredible food, service, and people. Great pre-made deli items. Their sandwiches are awesome. And obviously the meats are top notch. The rancher is my favorite sandwich. Skirt steak salad is great And fried zucchini and cauliflower are a must. read more

I was very excited for this place to open. It's an excellent concept in an area that is under-served by places like this. My first time stopping in was OK. They cut a porterhouse to order, but honestly the quality and taste of the meat was not as good as some other local places. My second time stopping in (yesterday) was a total waste of time, so I'm glad it's on my way home from work and I didn't go out of my way. The case was virtually empty. The porterhouses available were all less than 1inch thick, and the gentleman behind the counter indicated that was all they had - either true or he just didn't feel like taking the effort to cut one for me. So while the concept is good, the execution leaves a lot to be desired. Also, I'd like to mention, that it's not "FARM TO TABLE MEAT" if you buy it from a store. There are actual farms in Sussex County that sell meat direct to consumers. I would absolutely love for this place to improve and succeed, as I love supporting local businesses and it's right on my way home; so I will keep checking in to see if things have changed. Until then, I will buy my weekly steak at Market Basket or Sussex Meat Packing, both out of the way but both totally worth it. Especially the latter. read more

I decided to stop in after hearing from a coworker that they have an excellent selection of farm fresh ingredients and I forgot my lunch at home. I was in the mood for a steak salad with caramelized onions and bleu cheese. It was the perfect size and absolutely delicious! The steak was cooked perfectly and just melted like butter. I was so impressed and it was reasonably priced. I look forward to ordering lunch from here again and even picking up steaks to bring home :) read more

If you haven't gotten food from Cogman's you are missing out! Their farmhouse sandwich is the stuff dreams are made of! Turkey, carmalized onions, Gouda & sliced apples! Amazing Big selection of meats as well-really great cuts if beef and pork. Staff is super knowledgeable and very friendly. Always happy to give advice on how to prepare meats and answer any questions you have read more

I won Christmas this year and I owe it all to Cogman's. We ordered Prime Rib roast and, 15lbs of beautifully marbled beef later, we all couldn't move more than an eyelid from the happiness in our stomachs. Just a reminder that quality beef comes at a quality price. That is true for most things, though, and it was worth every cent. If you are looking for a butcher who goes above and beyond, Cogman's is your place. #christmaswin read more

Burger is out of this world. You can taste the beef as no other place. I bought meat from them. It is expensive but you get what you pay. You will not be disappointed read more

I had ordered a few sandwiches for a group of workers. They said the meat/steak was the best especially Mr. Strip Panini. The Zegas was a favorite as well. The breaded chicken cutlets were perfectly cooked. Not too thin and not too thick, just right! They raved about it! Made me happy to have treated them to a great lunch from a great place. read more

So i recently stopped going here for sanitary reasons. My first experience was a guy cutting the meat with Bandaids all over him, second it seems every time I went in the windows were never washed and last they don't use gloves when packaging the meat. The meat was good but I cant eat somewhere where I feel they don't keep a clean environment. May try again, but the Denville butcher looked so much nicer and they used Gloves to handle the meat. read more

I have been passing this place everyday on my ride back home and kept thinking that I should stop and check them out. I love the concept of knowing where your food comes from. A small place but with a lot of selection. The man behind the counter was very helpful at recommending how to prepare the meat. I bought pork chops and chicken breast for the week. The price was more than conventional meat at a super market but you get what you pay for, and I will definitely be back for more! read more

Great sandwiches and selections! The owner and the staff were friendly and offered suggestions. Will definitely be going back.