It's the best pizza around. Really. They also have amazing subs and salads. Would pick Oldtown over…read more4 star or Domino's any day. Oh but like most places in this town they don't take a credit card so make sure to have cash on hand!

We were visiting the area and were looking for a local place to grab a bite and this worked…read moresplendidly. The pizza was good and the wings were great. The pizza was perhaps the cheesiest I've ever had. That's a plus for us but maybe not for everyone. The service was timely, friendly and accommodating. The seating was outside via covered picnic tables which worked great since the weather was nice. The take out business was brisk while we were there during a work day evening which we took as a good sign. We wouldn't hesitate to go back if we were in the area again!!

Pizza was yummy!! Service was excellent! No indoor seating, but weather was perfect for the outdoor…read moreseating area!

Had the calzone, very good and reasonably priced. Service very good . Would recommendread more

Apparently this place has been here for about 12 years. However I have always just passed by this…read moreplace dozens of times because my favorite dive is down the road, but a cousin suggested that I should stop. So glad we did. Love the ambiance with the quilts and the river view. The food is wings, salads, pizza, subs, and Stromboli. Hand dipped ice cream. The pies looked good, too. I really liked the Italian sub and my partner had the pulled pork sandwich. Friendly service, too. Definitely want to come back!

Best pizza in Crooksville, hands down! Reasonable prices and friendly service. One tip is to bring…read morecash as they do not take bank/credit cards.

Home made food made fresh. Everything on the menu is amazing, the breakfast is also great. Italian,…read moreseafood, and steak nights every weekend. Only problem I had is they only accept cash. If it wasn't for that it would've been 5 stars.

Capt's Pepperoni Pizza is the best. Pizza is cheesy and delicious! Pepperonis are crispy and…read morecupped. The crust is just right

I think pirates pizza is delicious. I order a large size just to warm it up the next day.read more

Out of towner looking for a sit down pizza restaurant and we found good one…read more We ordered a medium pepperoni, a mini BBQ chicken, side of ranch and two drinks. Both pizza's were cooked well with some crisp on the edges which is heavenly. I was surprised on how big the restaurant was and the service was really good. Everyone had a responsibility and seemed to work flawlessly. Go Blue!

We ordered a couple of pizzas for carry out while camping nearby…read more The pizzas were hot and fresh. Just out of the oven when we came to pick them up. We ordered a veggie pizza and a supreme meat pizza. Toppings were extremely generous on both pizzas. Garlic bread with cheese was delicious. A great place for lunch or dinner when visiting Hocking Hills.

Crossroads Cafe is a nice clean place, it's adjacent to the Sunoco gas station. All the food is…read morehome cooked, an is served by friendly servers. The Cafe has its own stand alone dining area, its modern and very clean with lots of natural light. I was out motorcycle riding, on the beautiful area roads, when I happened across this nice place. They have daily specials, and great daily menu, for breakfast and lunch, to include pizzas. They are child friendly with kid menu items. Plenty of convenient parking for all types of vehicles. I had a hot dog here, an the sauce was probably a Greek based tomato sauce. Truly exceptional.

An experience of the past with the taste of the past present and future. An absolute local…read morefavorite. The service is above average, the food is excellent.

Good restaurant that has been a staple in New Lex for years. Their food is consistently tasty and…read morethey keep the prices as low as they can. One of the best spots in town.

Super nice patio and food. I can imagine this would be amazing on cool summer nights to hang out as…read morewe were here in November. Good drink selections as well. The margarita pizza was tasty well cooked. Will be back next time we are camping for sure!!

We had the pizza & it was amazing! My boyfriend has not…read morestopped talking about it. I must also rave about the french fries that were incredible!! We ate most of them without realizing we didn't even have ketchup. That's how good they were! I also love the fact that banana peppers are an ingredient on the Italian hoagie. Superb!!! We are definitely going to visit again whenever we're back in the area!!! Thank you to Papa Dino's for a great first visit!!!

You're in for a treat if Evan happens to be working the bar. Try one of his specials or let him…read moresurprise you. As far as food, the grilled cheese is my go to. It's not only comforting but absolutely delicious.

Trying to order online. (1) On a laptop they ask for verification you're not a bot. After you click…read moretwice to verify you're human, the website has a blank page which also says "cannot post". Dead end. (2) via cell, when you try to add toppings to a pizza, the app won't go to toppings. Sorry, but if your webmaster is stuck in 1996 website mode, you're going to lose customers fast. It's the 2020's, and your site via both laptop & cell phone is unreachable and un-orderable? Good luck...................