I've been here consistently for 3 years (& counting) & it took me this long to write a review?!? So my review is based on my many years of experience shopping at Circle Thrift (CT). Get ready as this will be the most comprehensive review ever on my favorite store in Philly (& maybe all of America? maybe the entire world?).
Times I've spent here
At most: 2x / week
Usually: weekly
At least: biweekly
CT standard not-on-sale $ (pricing system):
Prices here are undefeatable! The cheapest you'll find anywhere! Frugal people gather around!
Orange tags: $15
Any colored tags depend on the week: for the colors not on sale, unless otherwise specially marked:
Men's Shirts: Short-sleeves: $3; Long-sleeves: $4
Tanks: $3
Bras: @@@@@
Underwear: (don't remember seeing boxers)
Swimwear: 1-piece set: $4; 2-piece set: $2/ per piece
T-shirt Top (Female): $3
Long-sleeve blouses/shirts: $4
Pants, Shorts: $4
Pants, Long: $5
Leggings: $4
Athletic Tops: $3
Athletic Pants: $4
Dresses: $7
Skirts: $4
Suits: $10
Blazers: $6
Trousers (Men): $10
Sweaters: $5
Ties: $1
Lounge/Sleepwear: $4
Sweatshirts: $5
Sweatpants: $4
Outerwear: $10
Kids clothing: $1
Shoes: as marked price
Books in CT2: hardcovers: $2, softcovers: $1
Items in CT2: (ie furniture, large items, knickknacks) as marked price
Items I've seen here:
A whole range for different genders and age groups including newborns & children.
Since CT is located in Fishtown, a hip neighborhood, the items that are donated here are usually purchased by people with modern/ good taste. I've also heard wealthy people donate newly bought items here for tax benefit/write-off purposes.
I've seen anywhere from fast fashion items (H&M, SHEIN, Forever21, Walmart, etc.) to quality (anthropology, everlane, Banana Republic, J. Crew) to high-end (Brooks Brothers, Stuart Weissman) to luxury brands (though I don't think they authenticate items nor am I able to distinguish so buy at your own caution. But I saw brands like Fenty, LV, Gucci, Valentino, etc.)
Any items you'd think they'd have, they'll have albeit not in store all the time but if the timing and coincidence are right, it'll be there. & any item you don't think you'll need, but you buy to need, you'll find here.
From lingerie to undergarments, to cookware & dish-ware & utensils & appliances, to electronics, to footwear of all kinds including ice skating boots, to clothing of all kinds including coats and scrubs, even wedding dresses, to socks and hats, to newborn & baby onesies/ footsies, baby accessories like hats & shoes & bibs & toys, to seasonal decors & gift bags/ cards, to the arts & crafts corner with yarn, to linens, bedding & cushions, to suitcases & personal bags of all kinds (book bags, duffles, female bags), to garden pots, to PJs,
Pros about this store:
Discount/ sale system: & explanation of their turnover rates:
Weekly items discount for 50¢ for that week's color (of items less/ = $10) or 1/2 off (no limit) for that week's second color. Weekly discounts begin on Wednesdays.
Items have fast turnover rates in the store (unlike Goodwill which is why Goodwill seems like digging through trash) + affordable pricing system + discount system = there's always treasures to be found.
If an item is without its color price tag, it will automatically be CT's regular price.
To describe it;
Small selection but fast turnovers, so it's best to go often as there are new items every day.
Staffing:
The people here are so friendly! I've always seen Ivan here & he brightens our day! Scotty is a ray of sunshine in CT2.
The only cons/downsides:
No bathroom for public use... due to privilege being abused by druggies... *sigh*, but they're not unreasonable about it if you're pregnant. I'd go to Riverwards Produce Market grocery store or Cake And Joe bakery for a close bathroom (see Google map picture).
No haggling. Strict about this one even if the condition of the item is not as good.
Sometimes during holidays (ie this year, during Thanksgiving week, they were open for 2 days), their colored discount rotation is unchanged (ie instead of a weekly rotation, it's extended by another week, totaling 2 weeks).
The physical store itself is a lil' rundown (ceiling not completely intact) but that doesn't stop CT from being loved by regulars! I believe it's because they focus on donating their earnings to charity. Talk about a humble hero!
They also love bag donations in addition to regular donations.
Store gets slightly hot at times.
To remove the crayoned-colored prices after your purchase, just simply use alcohol-based hand sanitizer/ wipes. It'll remove from most surfaces except wood with a certain finish, but CT is mindful of not using crayons but a sticker take instead... so not a prob!
Edit 2024: They are in the process of new store ownership, which got rid of student and elderly discounts. I truly hope they keep their 50¢ weekly deals and current color discount system. read more